Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Cover to Cover: Little Sister - Elvis Presley v Ry Cooder

Henry IrvingHenry Irving
in Rumours
Two versions of the same song by different artists. Listen without prejudice and say which you prefer and why.

No other versions and no Cannon St drunken rants for so called responsible adults

So which to do you prefer? The 1961 Elvis rockabilly original or the 1979 Ry Cooder R & B cover


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSGGmOf_zdU


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jlvia6f8VOs
«1

Comments

  • Options
    GreenieGreenie
    Ry Cooder all day long, the harmonies and groove are excellent. Presley's is just awful.
    IMO the King of Rock N Roll was Little Richard, Presley was just a 1950's Rick Astley.
  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    Greenie said:

    Ry Cooder all day long, the harmonies and groove are excellent. Presley's is just awful.
    IMO the King of Rock N Roll was Little Richard, Presley was just a 1950's Rick Astley.

    A view I'm sure will be eagerly discussed on here very soon.
  • Options
    GreenieGreenie
    Henry Irving said:

    Greenie said:

    Ry Cooder all day long, the harmonies and groove are excellent. Presley's is just awful.
    IMO the King of Rock N Roll was Little Richard, Presley was just a 1950's Rick Astley.

    A view I'm sure will be eagerly discussed on here very soon.
    Yes no doubt H.
  • Options
    masicatmasicat
    Greenie said:

    Ry Cooder all day long, the harmonies and groove are excellent. Presley's is just awful.
    IMO the King of Rock N Roll was Little Richard, Presley was just a 1950's Rick Astley.

    Ha Ha.
  • Options
    SolidgoneSolidgone
    edited May 2017
    I agree with Greenie with my vote landing on Ry Cooder.
  • Options
    iainmentiainment
    Ry Cooder for me.
  • Options
    DA9DA9
    Not getting involved.....
  • Options
    Henry IrvingHenry Irving
    DA9 said:

    Not getting involved.....

    boo
  • Options
    DA9DA9
    Henry Irving said:

    Two versions of the same song by different artists. Listen without prejudice and say which you prefer and why.

    No other versions and no Cannon St drunken rants for so called responsible adults

    So which to do you prefer? The 1961 Elvis rockabilly original or the 1979 Ry Cooder R & B cover


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSGGmOf_zdU


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jlvia6f8VOs

    Stretching it to call it rockabilly, great stroller for the ladies though.
  • Options
    stonemusestonemuse
    Not a song I like that much, but Presley is the better version, prefer his vocals.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Its_Hamer_TimeIts_Hamer_Time
    I prefer Elvis' vocals, but I like the harmonies on the Ry Cooder version.
  • Options
    bobmunrobobmunro
    Ry Cooder by a country mile.
  • Options
    BangkokaddickBangkokaddick
    Oddly enough I was discussing this song just today with a couple of my guests who turned up at breakfast with two Thai sisters, one much younger than the other and was following in her big sister's footsteps!

    Anyway, both versions have their merits but in this case it's really an issue of what style of music you prefer and Ry Cooder wins for me, with a slight reggae beat and excellent harmonies, whereas the other version is really just another typical Elvis song from that particular era.
  • Options
    sillav nitramsillav nitram
    Ry Coooooooooooooooooooder for me, I like a drop of Ry.
  • Options
    BedsaddickBedsaddick
    edited May 2017
    I do like Elvis but this is not one of his best - Ry Cooder wins this one,
  • Options
    addixaddix
    Hadn't heard of either versions before. I own one Elvis 'best of' type album and can see why this song doesn't feature on it. Both versions easily forgettable, but Elvis just edges it for me.
  • Options
    Wheresmeticket?Wheresmeticket?
    Bangkokaddick said:

    Oddly enough I was discussing this song just today with a couple of my guests who turned up at breakfast with two Thai sisters, one much younger than the other and was following in her big sister's footsteps!

    Anyway, both versions have their merits but in this case it's really an issue of what style of music you prefer and Ry Cooder wins for me, with a slight reggae beat and excellent harmonies, whereas the other version is really just another typical Elvis song from that particular era.

    How old were the guests?
  • Options
    seth plumseth plum
    Not a fan of the actual song.
    Not one of the best Elvis vocals, and despite a great effort by Scotty Moore, the vocals are what Elvis is all about.
    marginally Ry Cooder I suppose.
  • Options
    McBobbinMcBobbin
    Nice bit of guitar on the Elvis one, I'll go for that. Ray cooder one sounds like live music played in a bar in the costa del sol ca. 1992
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Johnnysummers5Johnnysummers5
    I prefer The Ry Cooder version, but am a big Elvis fan
  • Options
    DA9DA9
    The Elvis version is typical of the material he was recording at the time, a lot of movie (although this wasn't in a movie) type lightweight songs, and he never really recorded probably again until 68/69 in a studio, the rest being movie soundtracks albums, formulaic and money spinners, but critically slammed.
    One of the better ones from the era.

    FYI, he only ever won one Grammy in his lifetime, for a gospel album.
  • Options
    LawrieAbrahamsLawrieAbrahams
    Ry Cooder for me.
  • Options
    stonemusestonemuse
    DA9 said:

    The Elvis version is typical of the material he was recording at the time, a lot of movie (although this wasn't in a movie) type lightweight songs, and he never really recorded probably again until 68/69 in a studio, the rest being movie soundtracks albums, formulaic and money spinners, but critically slammed.
    One of the better ones from the era.

    FYI, he only ever won one Grammy in his lifetime, for a gospel album.

    Interesting, didn't know that, quite surprising.
  • Options
    bristoladdickbristoladdick
    Ry Cooder for me as well.
  • Options
    KillarahalesKillarahales
    Ry Cooder (on the album Bop Till You Drop which is excellent)
  • Options
    sillav nitramsillav nitram
    Killarahales said:

    Ry Cooder (on the album Bop Till You Drop which is excellent)

    Very good album.
  • Options
    BangkokaddickBangkokaddick
    Curb_It said:

    Bangkokaddick said:

    Oddly enough I was discussing this song just today with a couple of my guests who turned up at breakfast with two Thai sisters, one much younger than the other and was following in her big sister's footsteps!

    Anyway, both versions have their merits but in this case it's really an issue of what style of music you prefer and Ry Cooder wins for me, with a slight reggae beat and excellent harmonies, whereas the other version is really just another typical Elvis song from that particular era.

    Your first sentence needs further clarification.
    Just use your imagination!
  • Options
    Chef_addickChef_addick
    Hadn't heard the song before, and to be honest didn't really like either, but of the two I preferred the Elvis version.
  • Options
    3blokes3blokes
    Ry Cooder from here.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!