Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks: Charlton 3-1 Chesterfield

lancashire lad
lancashire lad Posts: 15,644
edited September 2011 in General Charlton
For those Lifers at the Valley today your marks please, upto 10 halves allowed. Just copy and paste the list.
The STATBANK and PROMO-METER will be published on Tuesday.

Hamer
Solly
Morrison
Taylor
Wiggins
Wagstaff
Stephens
Hollands
Jackson
Hayes
Wright Phillips

Kermorgant n/a
Hughes n/a
«134

Comments

  • cockneyCAFC
    cockneyCAFC Posts: 558
    Hamer 7
    Solly 7
    Morrison 6.5
    Taylor 7
    Wiggins 7
    Waggy 6.5
    Hollands 7
    Stephens 7
    Jackson 8
    Hayes 6.5
    Bwp 6.5
  • JaShea99
    JaShea99 Posts: 5,468
    Hamer 8 - solid and can consider this an unofficial clean sheet because no way should that goal have stood
    Solly 7 - quiet at times but linked up well with Waggy as always
    Morrison 7.5 - haven't had so much confidence in a centre back pairing in a long while. Solid
    Taylor 7.5 - unlucky not to score and see above
    Wiggins 7 - decent going forward as well as at the back
    Wagstaff 7 - wish he'd take players on more as we know he can do, but lino clearly had a grudge and he suffered as a result
    Hollands 8 - doesn't put a foot wrong
    Stephens 7.5 - solid but still looks a bit lightweight at times
    Jackson 7.5 - well taken goal
    Hayes 6.5 - so frustrating to watch. You can't argue with his goals but could be such a better player if he had a decent first touch.
    Wright-Philips 7.5 - looks so much more accomplished then when he first came in that he does more than just score

    Kerm deserves a mention for his quick thinking for the final goal and just his being a complete contrast to Hayes in terms of first touch, even though he only had a few moments on the ball.
  • Holdkneebomb
    Holdkneebomb Posts: 1,266

    Hamer 7
    Solly 7
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Wiggins 8 MOM - reminded me of luke young at his best today
    Waggy 6
    Hollands 7
    Stephens 7
    Jackson 7
    Hayes 6
    BWP 7

    Kermit 7 v promising  debut

     

  • Clem_Snide
    Clem_Snide Posts: 11,747
    Hamer - 6.5
    Solly - 7
    Morrison - 6.5
    Taylor - 7
    Wiggins - 7
    Wagstaff - 6
    Stephens - 6
    Hollands - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Hayes - 6
    Wright Phillips - 6.5

    Kermorgant n/a
    Hughes n/a
  • masicat
    masicat Posts: 5,012
    Hamer 7Solly 7Morrison 7Taylor 7Wiggins 8Wagstaff 6 my opinion will never change.Stephens 6Hollands7Jackson 8 Hayes6Wright Phillips 7
  • Nozza2310
    Nozza2310 Posts: 210
    Hamer - 7Solly - 8 MOMMorrison - 7Taylor - 7Wiggins - 7.5Wagstaff - 6.5Stephens - 7Hollands - 7.5Jackson - 7Hayes - 6.5Wright Phillips - 7.5
    Kermorgant n/a - 7.5
  • Will
    Will Posts: 36
    edited September 2011
    Hamer  7 Solly 8 Great againMorrison 7.5 SolidTaylor 7.5 Fouled for a blatant penWiggins - 8.5 Fantastic, constant threatWagstaff - 7 Quiet but good cross for BWPStephens - 8 Controlled the game, drifted in and out a bit too muchHollands - 8 DecentJackson - 8 Constantly involved, good crossingHayes - 6.5 Poor, messed up a bit but was unlucky not to score at the endWright Phillips - 7 Fairly quiet in 2nd half, always thought he'd score
    Kermorgant - Looked very good
  • stackitsteve
    stackitsteve Posts: 12,109
    Hamer - 7.5 deserved a clean sheet
    Solly - 8.5 quality....as is usual this season
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Wiggins - 8
    Wagstaff - 7
    Stephens - 7
    Hollands - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 6.5
    Wright Phillips - 7
  • AFKABartram
    AFKABartram Posts: 57,889
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Wiggins 7.5
    Wagstaff - 7
    Stephens - 7
    Hollands - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 7
    Wright Phillips - 7.5

  • Addickted4life
    Addickted4life Posts: 7,467
    edited September 2011
    Hamer 7.5 best I've seen him play. Deserved a clean sheet 

    Solly 8 His usual best 

    Morrison 7 him a Taylor look good together

    Taylor 7 same

    Wiggins 7.5 like him the look of him alot more as he's settled in

    Waggy 7 needs to practice his diving as the one before the pen was a bit over dramatic. He actually did a good cross to BWP : 0  

    Stephens 7.5 spread the ball about beautifully

    Hollands 7.5 complements Stephens really well. does the dirty work in midfield

    Jackson 8.5 best he's played all season. used his space really well. MOTM  

    Hayes 7.5 seems to be an on off player. extra 0.5 for his goal

    BWP 8 worked his socks off for the team and got his goal


  • Sponsored links:



  • charlton_hero
    charlton_hero Posts: 4,671
    Hamer-7Solly- 7.5Morrison -7Taylor-7Wiggins-6.5Wagstaff-7Stephens-6.5Hollands-7.5Jackson-7Hayes-7Wright Phillips-7
  • Kap10
    Kap10 Posts: 15,592
    edited September 2011
    Hamer 7
    Solly 8
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7Wiggins 7
    Wagstaff 6.5 
    Stephens 6.5
    Hollands 7
    Jackson 7.5
    Hayes 6.5

    Wright Phillips 6.5

    Sodding formatting I give up
  • rikofold
    rikofold Posts: 4,051
    Hamer 6.5 - would have got a 7 but he needs to rein in his kicking a little
    Solly 8 - proper full back
    Morrison 6.5 - both centre halves were solid but looked terribly vulnerable when they were run at
    Taylor 6.5 - how on earth did the ref think that was simulation?
    Wiggins 8.5 - just edges Jackson for MOM for me, best I've seen of him
    Waggy 8 - always involved, great touch, and a great cross for the third
    Hollands 7.5 - first half 9, ran the game, but faded in the second
    Stephens 7 - really dropped out of the game second half, needs to find a little more consistency because he's a fabulous player when on his game
    Jackson 8 - best game of the season for him by some distance
    Hayes 6.5 - first half decent, second half woeful
    BWP 8 - what happened to the lazy looking greed merchant of last year?  Passed when he could have shot, patient for his chance and took it well.

    Special mention to Kermi (and Powell for introducing him), because his touch changed our game.  Fabulous pass to Waggy to cross for the third. 
  • DartfordAddick
    DartfordAddick Posts: 1,085
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Wiggins- 8
    Wagstaff - 7
    Stephens - 7.5
    Hollands - 8
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 6.5
    Wright Phillips - 7
  • Marriott110
    Marriott110 Posts: 1,528
    Hamer 8Solly 8Morrison 7Taylor 7Wiggins 7.5Wagstaff 7Stephens 6.5Hollands 7Jackson 7.5Hayes 7Wright Phillips 7.5
  • Salad
    Salad Posts: 10,189
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 7
    Morrison - 6.5
    Taylor - 6.5
    Wiggins 8
    Wagstaff - 6.5
    Stephens - 7
    Hollands - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 6.5
    Wright Phillips - 7
  • feesh_cafc
    feesh_cafc Posts: 135
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 6.5
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins - 8
    Wagstaff - 6.5
    Stephens - 6.5
    Hollands - 8(MOM)
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 7
    BWP - 7
  • seth plum
    seth plum Posts: 53,448

    Hamer 7 Chose the wrong way with the pen, but all round good game.

    Solly 8 MOM just. He is so consistently very good it is getting boring.

    Morrison 7 Took responsibility.

    Taylor 7 Took responsibility.

    Wiggins 7.5 Some lovely supportive runs on the flanks, one great bit of skill.

    Wagstaff 7.5 Cross for the goal when he had already run himself into the ground. Great player for us.

    Stephens 7 Good as always, first half better than the second.

    Hollands 7.5 really good game, especiall as he hasn't slept since Monday ;-)

    Jackson 7.5 Great first half topped off with an authoritative finish.

    Hayes 7.5 yeah a bit inconsistent, but had to deal with opponants in close contention, but he scored.

    Wright Phillips 8 How come he is suddenly winning headers? Really excellent finish.




    Kermorgant 7 good vignette.

    Hughes 7 For gawd sake let him 'warm up' for the entire match, he so much wants to.

    Chesterfield 6

    Our fans 7

    Their fans 6.5

    Our management 8.5

    Their management 6.5

    officials 7 glaring error notwithstanding.

  • mid_life_crisis
    mid_life_crisis Posts: 3,267
    Hamer - 7Solly - 7Morrison - 6.5Taylor - 6.5Wiggins - 7.5Wagstaff - 6.5Stephens - 7Hollands - 7.5Jackson - 8Hayes - 6.5Wright Phillips - 7
  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,083
    edited September 2011
    Hamer 7 deserved a clean sheet.
    Solly 7 not at his best but he was good enough!!    Morrison 7.5 loving this partnership with Taylor .Taylor 7.5 ditto but was wrong side for penalty. His one and only mistake. How he got booked for simulation I will never know.Wiggins 8 his best game for us. Bournemouth reject? I will have him any day.
    Wagstaff 7.5 another great game... he's keeping Green out of the team. Nice assist.    Stephens 7.5 I like him a lot.
    Hollands 7 he did look tired but it is understandable. He was still impressive. One lovely tackle.Jackson 7 usual Jacko... nice goal... was lucky with the pen that wasn't. It was a pen to me.
    Hayes 7.5 The better striker today. Worked hard.
    Wright Phillips 6.5 Off the pace but he was winning headers but he would've got a lot of criticism had he not scored. Took goal well.

  • Sponsored links:



  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,083
    Don't know why it does that 
  • thewolfboy
    thewolfboy Posts: 2,931

    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Wiggins 7.5 Best yet. 
    Wagstaff - 7
    Stephens - 7.5 Reminds me of Hoddle but can he tackle?
    Hollands - 7.5
    Jackson - 7.5
    Hayes - 7
    Wright Phillips - 7.5
  • Stig
    Stig Posts: 29,092
    edited September 2011
    Hamer 7 Solly 8 Morrison 7 Taylor 7 Wiggins 7.5 Wagstaff 7 Stephens 8 Hollands 8 Jackson 8 Hayes 7 Wright Phillips 8
  • grumpyaddick
    grumpyaddick Posts: 6,597
    Hamer 7Solly 8:  not bad for a short assMorrison 7Taylor 7Wiggins 7.5Wagstaff 6: so much energy going nowhereStephens 6.5 Hollands 6.5 breast is best.Jackson 7.5Hayes 7: would be lethal if he could run too.Wright Phillips 7: even scores while sulking
    Kermorgant 6 : a bit laboured i thoughtHughes 6 : definitely dyes his hair.
  • cafcsinger
    cafcsinger Posts: 5,558
    Hamer - 7.5
    Solly - 7
    Morrison - 7.
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins- 8
    Wagstaff - 7
    Stephens - 7.5
    Hollands - 7
    Jackson - 8.5
    Hayes - 7
    Wright Phillips - 7 .5
  • Deadred
    Deadred Posts: 1,514
    edited September 2011
    Hamer - 7 Did everything he had to, great 'teckers' killing a high lob with his feet - this boy can play never mind keep goal
    Solly - 7 Another assured performance
    Morrison - 7 Solid never troubled until the penalty when he got wrong footed and had no other option
    Taylor - 7 Quietly goes about his business should've had a penalty outrageous booking for diving
    Wiggins - 7 Best game at home so far, more of the same please
    Wagstaff - 6.5 Worked hard, one of his quieter games but a great cross for BWP to score
    Stephens - 7 Kept probing as always, unlucky with some rasping efforts on goal, quick thinking with free kick for assist with 2nd
    Hollands - 7 Another workmanlike performance tidy and efficient always prepared to stick a foot or head in re 2nd goal
    Jackson - 8 Was up for it today a Captain's performance involved in build up for 1st goal and scored a good 2nd MOTM
    Hayes - 7 Another mixed bag of link up play pleased he scored though.Missed a sitter taking a touch instead of blasting BWP's on a plate pass
    Wright Phillips 7.5 Wasn't quite happening 1st half apart from his shot touched in by Hayes & unselfish pass to him. Kept going and worthy of his injury time goal
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,034

     

    Hamer 7 Didn't do anything wrong

    Solly 7 Competent performance

    Morrison 7 Looked sound

    Taylor 7.5 Shows leadership at the back

    Wiggins 8.5 Looking good both defensively and going forward . Very impressive

    Wagstaff 7 Good performance

    Stephens 8 Back on top form

    Hollands 8 Made some crucial interceptions

    Jackson 9 Excellant performance capped by well taken goal

    Hayes 7 Wasn't as good second half

    Wright Phillips 8.5 Not just a goal scorer his build up play was very impressive today



    Kermorgant n/a Good cameo , liked what I saw

    Hughes n/a Helped keep us solid in injury time
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,836
    edited September 2011
    Hamer 7 // Solly 8.5 //Morrison 7.5 // Taylor 8 // Wiggins 8.5 //Wagstaff 7.5 // Stephens 8 // Hollands 8 // Jackson 8 // Hayes 7 // Wright Phillips 7.5

    Never given ratings that high. Wow.
  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,083
    Hayes - 7 Another mixed bag of link up play pleased he scored though.Missed a sitter taking a touch instead of blasting BWP's on a plate pass

    I thought BWP passed it a tad too early and Hayes couldn't adjust quickly enough... however, we won =] not being picky or anything.. just that was my view
  • Deadred
    Deadred Posts: 1,514
    edited September 2011
    Don't think it was BWP's fault RugbyAddick from my view in the North West all he needed to do was put his foot through it. Killer Hales, Super Clive Mendonca would have and so would BWP had he been on the receiving end of the pass, which is the difference between a natural striker and a hold up play man who likes to take a touch. Hey who cares I quite like Hayes he can be as frustating as hell at times but his contribution far outweighs his sloppy moments. Bring on the MK Dons COYR
This discussion has been closed.

Categories

“Marketplace”