Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: JPT: Charlton 0-3 Brentford

lancashire lad
lancashire lad Posts: 15,736
edited October 2011 in General Charlton
Marks please for those at the Valley and those who watched the "live" broadcast:

Sullivan
Hughes
Taylor
Doherty
Evina
Green
Mikel (Alonso)
Stephens
Jackson
Hayes
Wagstaff

Morrison
Euell
Kermorgant

I shall close this thread at 4pm tomorrow and have the STATBANK up tomorrow evening.
«13

Comments

  • Miserableoldgit
    Miserableoldgit Posts: 21,469
    Could be "Interesting...."
    ;-)
  • Cafctekkers
    Cafctekkers Posts: 1,267
    Sullivan -6Hughes-5.5Taylor-6Doherty-4.5Evina-6Green-7Mikel (Alonso)-6 needs time thoughStephens-7Jackson-6.5Hayes-6Wagstaff-6
    Morrison-6Euell-6Kermorgant-6.5
  • JT
    JT Posts: 12,348
    Sullivan - 6Hughes - 2Taylor - 5Doherty - 2Evina - 6.5Green -6.5Mikel (Alonso) - 4Stephens - 5Jackson - 5.5Hayes - 6Wagstaff - 4.5
    Morrison - 6Euell - 6Kermorgant - 6.5
  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 25,056
    edited October 2011

    Sullivan - 6
    Hughes - 4
    Taylor - 6
    Doherty - 3.5
    Evina -7 MOM
    Green - 6
    Mikel (Alonso)- 5.5
    Stephens - 5.5
    Jackson -5
    Hayes - 6
    Wagstaff - 5

    Morrison - 6
    Euell - 5
    Kermorgant - 6
  • C_A_F_C
    C_A_F_C Posts: 3,879
    Sullivan - 6.0
    Hughes - 4.5
    Taylor - 4.5
    Doherty - 4.0
    Evina - 6.0
    Green - 5.0
    Mikel (Alonso) - 4.0
    Stephens - 5.0
    Jackson - 5.0
    Hayes - 5.0
    Wagstaff - 5.0

    Morrison - 6.0
    Euell - 5.5
    Kermorgant - 6.0
  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 13,514
    Sullivan - 6.5
    Hughes - 5
    Taylor - 6
    Doherty - 4
    Evina - 6.5
    Green - 6.5
    Mikel (Alonso) - 5.5
    Stephens - 4
    Jackson - 5
    Hayes - 5
    Wagstaff - 4.5

    Morrison - 6
    Euell - 5
    Kermorgant - 6
  • Numbers
    Numbers Posts: 835
    Sullivan 6
    Hughes 5
    Taylor 6
    Doherty 5
    Evina 6
    Green 6.5
    Mikel (Alonso) 5
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 6
    Hayes 6
    Wagstaff 6

    Morrison 6
    Euell 6
    Kermorgant 6
  • Holdkneebomb
    Holdkneebomb Posts: 1,274
    Sullivan 6 momHughes 4Taylor 5Doherty 4Evina 6Green 5Mikel (Alonso) 4Stephens 5Jackson 6Hayes 5Wagstaff 5
    Morrison 6 Euell 5
  • Will
    Will Posts: 36
    Sullivan - 6.5Hughes - 4Taylor - 5Doherty - 4Evina - 6Green - 6Mikel (Alonso) - 5Stephens - 5.5Jackson - 6Hayes - 5Wagstaff - 5.5
    Morrison - 6Euell - 5Kermorgant - 6
  • AFKABartram
    AFKABartram Posts: 58,285
    Sullivan - 6
    Hughes - 4.5
    Taylor - 5.5
    Doherty - 4
    Evina - 6.5
    Green - 6
    Mikel (Alonso) - 3
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson - 5.5
    Hayes - 5.5
    Wagstaff - 5.5

    Morrison - 6
    Euell - 4.5
    Kermorgant - 5.5

  • Sponsored links:



  • Oriental_Addick
    Oriental_Addick Posts: 1,003
    edited October 2011
    Sullivan: 5/10 - Actually made a pretty good save in the build-up to their first goal, didn't do a whole lot wrong. Decent cover for Hamer IMO.
    Hughes: 2/10 - What can you say, didn't put a foot right all game, the fact that he has over 600 professional appearances makes it even worse.
    Taylor:   5/10 - Not his greatest game but with the shambles going on around him you can't really blame him.
    Doherty: 3/10 - Marginally better than Hughes, but then again maybe not.  Looking forward to seeing the back of him ('cause the front is enough to make you want to vomit).
    Evina:   6/10 - MotM - Pacey, made some intelligent runs, and linked up play particularly well with Jackson.  Kept a cool head among the rabble surrounding him.  Exciting prospect.
    Green:  5.5/10 - Some decent dribbles down the right, showed glimpses of his shooting and crossing ability as well as his knack for making space for himself on the pitch.
    Mikel:    4/10 - Gave away the pen and had a shocker of a first half.  However he does have a nice passing range and an eye for the game.  Should come good.
    Stephens: 5/10 - Off the pace, works better with someone confident and industrious alongside him.
    JJ:       4.5/10 - Very quiet game by his high standards and clearly not up for a sustained run in the JPT.  Roll on Saturday.
    Hayes:  5/10 - Several neat flicks and touches but cut an isolated figure up front.
    Waggy:  4/10 - Spent most of the match moaning and should definitely now make way for Green.

    Morrison: 5.5/10 - The best defender we have at the club, shored up the defense when he came on.
    Euell:      4.5/10 - Not much he could do to turn around the result, however he provides inadequate cover for any position he is selected for.
    Kermit:    5.5/10 - Something about this lad excites you every time he gets on the ball.  Pushing Hayes very hard for a first team spot.

    On the whole, we should take a deep breath and remember that in the long-term this result is probably for the best in terms of our pursuit of the league.  In the short-term it gives us a reality check and reminds us not to take our foot off the gas or take any team lightly.

    Although this team did not perform on the night we actually do have some decent cover for positions including Waggy, Cort, Evina, Alonso and Kermit/Hayes. 

    Looking forward to this Saturday.

    COYR!

  • Madz
    Madz Posts: 1,004
    Sullivan - 6 - Couldn't really blame him for any of the goals
    Hughes - 5 - Think Solly's place is safe.  Works hard though
    Taylor - 5.5 - Looked out of sorts alongside Doherty. 
    Doherty - 5 - Guy just doesn't give me confidence.
    Evina - 7 - Best player for us today. Caught for pace a couple of times but intercepted a few good balls and looked comfortable going forward. MOM
    Green - 6 - I like his turn of pace, but didn't use the ball enough to great affect. Although noone to aim for when he did get the ball.
    Mikel (Alonso) - 5/6 - First half 5 second half 6 as i think he started to settle in the second half. Still off pace. Needs more game time or at least a couple as sub.
    Stephens - 6.5 - He looks a lot better alongside Hollands
    Jackson - 6 - Very quiet game.
    Hayes - 6 - Just didn't get the ball. Pointless playing up front with someone who is not a natural striker.
    Wagstaff - 5.5 - Not a striker. Although his strike in the second half was cracking.
     
    Morrison - 6 - Better of the 3 centre backs.
    Euell - 6 - Not the player he was. Couple of good passes, but no pace.
    Kermorgant - 6 - Could have been good with lob and won a few headers. Shocking free kick though :-)
     
    Overall, disappointed with performance, but not overly bothered.
  • tangoflash
    tangoflash Posts: 10,804
    Sullivan - 6
    Hughes - 4.5
    Taylor - 6
    Doherty - 3.5 (OMG)
    Evina -7 (MOM)
    Green - 6
    Mikel (Alonso)- 5.5
    Stephens - 6
    Jackson -5.5
    Hayes - 6
    Wagstaff - 5

    Morrison - 6
    Euell - 5
    Kermorgant - 6.5
  • stop_shouting
    stop_shouting Posts: 3,703

    Sullivan - 6
    Hughes - 4
    Taylor - 6
    Doherty - 3
    Evina -7
    Green - 5
    Mikel (Alonso)- 4
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson -4
    Hayes - 6
    Wagstaff - 4

    Morrison - 6
    Euell - 4
    Kermorgant - 6
  • addick16
    addick16 Posts: 1,019
    edited October 2011
    Sullivan - 6

    Hughes - 4.5 (really poor first half and gave the ball away A LOT!)

    Taylor - 6

    Doherty 4.5 -(soooo slow, poor clearance for 1st/early goal)

    Evina 6.5 (cafc motm. he looked composed on ball and offered real pace down the left side)

    Green 6 (beat his man a few times, overall ok performance)

    Mikel (Alonso) 5- gave up pen after turnover inside own18, decent passing range

    Stephens 6-

    Jackson 6

    Hayes - 5 - (grew tired of his multiple failed fancy flicks, when we really needed to settle the ball)

    Wagstaff - 5.5 



    Morrison 5.5

    Euell 5 (powell cant fit him in anywhere)

    Kermorgant 6


  • EastTerrace
    EastTerrace Posts: 3,977
    Sullivan 5
    Hughes 4
    Taylor 5
    Doherty 4
    Evina 6
    Green 5
    Mikel (Alonso) 4
    Stephens 5
    Jackson 5
    Hayes 6
    Wagstaff 5

    Morrison 5
    Euell 6
    Kermorgant 5
  • Clem_Snide
    Clem_Snide Posts: 11,842
    Sullivan - 5.5
    Hughes - 3.5
    Taylor - 5
    Doherty - 2
    Evina - 6.5
    Green - 6
    Mikel (Alonso) - 3
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson - 4.5
    Hayes - 5
    Wagstaff - 4.5

    Morrison - 6
    Euell - 4
    Kermorgant - 5.5
  • falconwood_1
    falconwood_1 Posts: 7,369
    Sullivan 6
    Hughes 3 -did himself no favours
    Taylor 5
    Doherty 3 -hope he didn't Sky+ it
    Evina 7 -looks half sensible
    Green 6
    Mikel (Alonso) 2 -although not match fit that was a 'special' performance.
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 5
    Hayes 5
    Wagstaff 6

    Morrison 6
    Euell 5
    Kermorgant 5

    Can see Euell & Doherty gone in January.
  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,099
    edited October 2011
    Sullivan 5 nothing special
    Hughes 4 Disappointing is the only word I can use for him.
    Taylor 5 Doc not a good partner for him
    Doherty 4.5 past it I reckon... I like him but I can't stick up for him on this occasion.
    Evina 6.5 MOM not at Wiggin's standards yet but he'll get there.
    Green 5 One good free kick... not a lot right, not a lot wrong. Silly booking as well.
    Mikel (Alonso) 6 the abuse he received makes me dislike cafc fans. Wasn't great first half but you have to give credit were it's due. Passing was quality 70% of the time. The bloke next to me was having a go at him as he walked out the tunnel in the first half!!!!!
    Stephens 5 Non existant really.Jackson5 same as Stephens. 
    Hayes 6.5 couldn't do a lot but he tried.
    Wagstaff 6 Victim of poor reffing decisions most of the time. Dealt with it well.... he tried. Best shot of the game.
    Morrison 6 Best CB on the night.
    Euell 4.5 He was a ghost in the centre
    Kermorgant 5.5 couldn't really do a lot to be fair
  • 1StevieG
    1StevieG Posts: 10,972
    3 players that should never be allowed near a football pitch again.
     
    Sullivan - 5
    Hughes - 2 Lazy immitation of a professional football player.
    Taylor - 6
    Doherty - 1 For someone with so much experience why didn't he head the ball to the keper in the 1st minute? Poor.
    Evina - 6
    Green - 6
    Mikel (Alonso) - 0 Gave away a stupid penalty and gave Brent.ford the ball whenever he had it. Embarrasing.
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson - 5
    Hayes - 5
    Wagstaff - 5

  • Sponsored links:



  • Kap10
    Kap10 Posts: 15,656
    edited October 2011
    Sullivan 6
    Hughes 5
    Taylor 6
    Doherty 4
    Evina 7
    Green 6
    Mikel (Alonso) 5
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 6.5
    Hayes 6.5
    Wagstaff 6

    Morrison 6
    Euell 5
    Kermorgant 6

    Doherty was awful, earlier today someone texted me that Luton were in for him and i said he was too good for that level, he's not good enough on this performance.

    Hughes, well we were told he was all heart no skill and they were right, although not sure about the heart.

    Alonso poor, but he is not match fit - Powell error in selection, should have been on the bench and get 30 minutes at the end.  Some signs that if he gets fit could be good.  A zero mark is daft,he was better than Doherty and at least as good as Hughes, but that is not saying much.

    Powell selection and set up poor, oh wellconcentrate on the league and FA Cup - someone has to win it, why not us!!

  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,099
    3 players that should never be allowed near a football pitch again.
     

    Mikel (Alonso) - 0 Gave away a stupid penalty and gave Brent.ford the ball whenever he had it. Embarrasing.
    Ridiculous.
  • Addickted4life
    Addickted4life Posts: 7,479
    Sullivan 6 nothing he could do about any of the goals and was unlucky with the 1st goal

    Hughes 4 looks well past it and doesn't offer anything at all to the team 

    Doherty 3 The worst player so far in any league this season. Should be released and retire before it gets any worse for him

    Taylor 5.5 not his usual best but was playing with Doherty

    Evina 6 Looked O.k but struggled to deal with Weston

    Green 6.5 (MOTM) only player that looked good going forward all game and was unlucky with his free kick

    Alonso 5.5 saw flashes of potential but overall of the boil

    Stephens 6 had nothing to work with but did a decent job

    Jackson 5.5 nothing special and the game sort of past him by

    Hayes 5 I think he'll loose his spot to Kermit. To be fair to him he lacked service but why did he volley that chance rather than be composed?

    Wagstaff 5.5 ran around with out great effect until his shot at the end. Him and Hayes don't go together


    Morrison 5.5 

    Euell 4.5 never noticed him and I think it was a wrong choice to bring him back

    Kermit 5.5 thinks he's Cantona but does look good and did more than Hayes     
  • Nozza2310
    Nozza2310 Posts: 210

    Sullivan - 6.5
    Hughes - 3
    Taylor - 6
    Doherty - 3
    Evina - 6.5 MOM
    Green- 6
    Mikel (Alonso) - 6
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson - 5
    Hayes - 5.5
    Wagstaff - 5

    Morrison - 6.5
    Euell - 5.5
    Kermorgant - 6
  • paulsturgess
    paulsturgess Posts: 4,059
    Sullivan 6
    Hughes 4 - deary me pony for the opener and some terrible passing
    Evina 6.5 - looked okay in a dismal team performance
    Doherty 4 - take him luton
    Taylor/morrison 5 each - get them back together so they can play like they did at sheff
    Green 6 - looked dangerous in spells
    Stephens 5 didnt get into it
    Alonso 2 - absolutely dreadful. abysmal passing looked so clueless and lacking sharpness, and that pen - pitiful touch, pathetic strength, awful challenge. Please d and d stay fit
    Jacko 5
    Hayes 5
    wagstaff 4.5 good shot but poor
    Euell 4.5 i love him but we d be better with anyinsah this yr
    Kerm 5
  • Athletico Charlton
    Athletico Charlton Posts: 14,484
    Sullivan               5

    Hughes               4

    Taylor                  5

    Doherty               3

    Evina                   7 (MOM)

    Green                  6

    Mikel (Alonso)      3

    Stephens             5

    Jackson              4.5

    Hayes                  6.5

    Wagstaff               4.5



    Morrison                5

    Euell                     4

    Kermorgant           N/A (I left a bit early so didnt see enough)
  • Mortimerician
    Mortimerician Posts: 5,222
    Sullivan 5 Didn't cover himself in glory, but had no cover
    Hughes 1 Shit in every aspect of the game.  Defending, distribution, positioning was dismal.  Come back Franny, all is forgiven
    Evina 6.5 Great driving runs forward, but a bit suspect defensively. 
    Doherty 4 - Tried hard, but the comedy centre of most of our woes
    Taylor 5 - Started the horror off with a weak defensive header and didn't get much better
    Green 4 Good free kick, but otherwise no threat, petulant and generally shite.
    Stephens 5 actually forgot he was playing
    Alonso
    3 None of the fraternal magic has rubbed off.  Pathetic challenge for the pen and offered little to nothing else
    Jacko 4 No idea where he was supposed to be  playing, but ineffective wherever it was.
    Hayes 4 Tried hard, but shite.  Kermy will have the start on Saturday, no doubt.
    wagstaff 5.5 Some awful passing, but worked hard and was one of our few threats.  Dr Evil the lino did him few favours. 
    Euell 5 odd good position, but offered little
    Kerm 5.5 Added a bit of strength, but didn't get into it.
  • Oggy Red
    Oggy Red Posts: 45,001
    Sullivan - 6
    Hughes -5
    Taylor - 6
    Doherty - 4
    Evina - 8 MOM
    Green - 7
    Mikel (Alonso) - 5
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson - 6
    Hayes - 7
    Wagstaff - 6

    Morrison - 6
    Euell - 6
    Kermorgant  - 6

    The key players who only played because of the "6 first team" ruling, gave the impression of being involved as minimally as they could get away with. Alternatively, the manager's instructions may have been something like, for example - don't do anything rash, don't pick up a card, don't get injured.

    The clown who gave Alonso a 0 marking makes a mockery of this thread.
  • Buglehorn
    Buglehorn Posts: 1,025

    Sullivan 5

    Hughes 5

    Evina 7

    Doherty 5

    Taylor 6

    Green 6

    Stephens 5.5

    Mikel 5

    Jackson 6

    Hayes 5.5

    Wagstaff 5.5

    Euell 5

    Morrison 6

    Kerm 5

     

  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 25,056
    .

    The clown who gave Alonso a 0 marking makes a mockery of this thread.


    This

Categories

“Marketplace”