Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players marks Charlton 5-2 Preston North End

lancashire lad
lancashire lad Posts: 15,709
edited November 2011 in General Charlton
For those at the Valley today your marks out of 10 please, just copy and paste the list:

Hamer
Solly
Morrison
Taylor
Wiggins
Green
Hollands
Hughes
Jackson
Kermorgant
Wright Phillips

Hayes n/a
Wagstaff n/a
Euell n/a
«13

Comments

  • cockneyCAFC
    cockneyCAFC Posts: 558
    Hamer 7.5
    Solly 7.5
    Taylor 8
    Morrison 8
    Wiggins 8
    Green 7.5
    Hollands 7.5
    Hughes 7.5
    Jackson 8
    Kermorgant 7.5
    Bwp 8
  • Stone
    Stone Posts: 3,026
    Hamer 7
    Solly 8
    Taylor 8
    Morrison 8
    Wiggins 8.5
    Green 8
    Hollands 8
    Hughes 7.5
    Jackson 7.5
    Kermorgant 7.5
    Bwp 8
  • Nozza2310
    Nozza2310 Posts: 210
    Hamer - 6.5
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins 8.5
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 9
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson - 7.5
    Kermorgant - 9 MOM
    Wright Phillips - 7.5
  • rikofold
    rikofold Posts: 4,051
    Hamer - 6.5 - not always convincing
    Solly - 7.5 - f'ing quality
    Morrison - 9 - gets my MOM vote, sneaking ahead of JJ and Wiggins. Was just brilliant today
    Taylor - 8 - Solid as
    Wiggins - 9 - gets better and better each game
    Green - 8 - great crossing
    Hollands - 7.5 - brilliant headed goal
    Hughes - 7.5 - quietly effective
    Jackson - 8.5 - great game, corners in particular were almost undefendable
    Kermorgant - 8.5 - Involved throughout. 
    Wright Phillips - 8 - More intelligent running, left in acres of space for his goal but was always going to score it.
  • Clem_Snide
    Clem_Snide Posts: 11,810
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 8
    Taylor 7
    Wiggins - 8.5 - this bloke is absolute quality. You don't need an out an out winger with him in the team
    Green - 8 - best game so far
    Hollands - 8.5
    Hughes - 7
    Jackson - 8
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 7.5
  • WSS
    WSS Posts: 25,120
    Hamer - 7
    Solly -7
    Morrison - 8
    Taylor - 7
    Wiggins - 8.5
    Green - 7.5
    Hollands - 8 
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Kermorgant - 7
    Wright Phillips - 8
  • stackitsteve
    stackitsteve Posts: 12,133
    Hamer - 7.5
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 8.5
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 8
    Hughes - 8
    Jackson - 8.5
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 8
  • Addickted4life
    Addickted4life Posts: 7,479
    edited November 2011
    Hamer - 7 - Still not convinced by him but he did the job
    Solly - 8 - Mr Constancy, does everything
    Morrison - 9 - Defended magnificently. Him and Taylor were made for each other.
    Taylor - 8.5 - ditto
    Wiggins - 9 - Up and down the left for the whole 90 mins, tearing PNE to pieces
    Green - 8.5 - His best performance by a mile. 
    Hollands - 9 - Deserved his brilliant goal and was pure class
    Hughes - 7.5 - Needs to header forward not back but defended the back four really well
    Jackson - 9 - him and Wiggins linked up superbly and his 2 goals were well taken. A skippers job. MOTM
    Kermorgant - 8.5 - Flick on's were top notch and his work ethic was great
    Wright-Phillips - 8 - Took his goal well and again kept the PNE defenders on their toe's. 
     
    My mate Adam went his first Charlton match today after supporting them for years and he give's Jackson MOTM.   
  • Bagpuss
    Bagpuss Posts: 334
    Hamer - 6.5
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 9
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 9
    Green - 7.5
    Hollands - 8.5
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 8
  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,318
    Hamer - 6
    Solly - 7.5
     
    Morrison - 8
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins - 7.5
    Green - 7.5
    Hollands - 7.5
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Kermorgant - 7.5
    Wright Phillips - 7

  • Sponsored links:



  • GreenWithEnvy
    GreenWithEnvy Posts: 1,857
    edited November 2011
    Hamer - 6.5 - not much to do but early confusion with Taylor and a dodgy kick for a clearance makes me wonder about him at timesSolly - 8 - usual solid gameMorrison - 8.5 - showed some great moments to take the ball out of defence calmly and a goal at last!Taylor - 8 - so glad he and Morrison are the concrete of our defenceWiggins - 9 - simply stunning! The assist for the 5th will live long in my memory MOMGreen - 8.5 - unlucky not to score today and an excellent performance.Hollands - 8 - good goal, and he's in a purple patch right now. Hughes - 8 - quietly effective, breaking up the PNE attacks. Jackson - 8.5 - a true skipper's performance today Kermorgant - 8 - the guy is so skilful and aware but looks so nasty to play against. Shame he didn't get a goal today.Wright Phillips - 8 - so much more of a team player these days and in the right place at the right time for his goal. So important to us.
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,823
    edited November 2011
    Hamer - 6.5 - did OK
    Solly - 7.5 Dependable as ever
    Morrison - 9 - 0.5 for the goal and grea partnership with Taylor
    Taylor - 8.5 - ditto without the goal
    Wiggins - 9 - What a signing
    Green - 8.5 - Excellent
    Hollands - 9 - Thanks Bournemouth - 2 great players
    Hughes - 8.5 Thought he was quietly efective - very good
    Jackson - 9- 2 Goals - great performance MOTM
    Kermorgant - 8.5 - Very effective
    Wright-Phillips - 8.5 - Class player -best striker in the Division -end off as far as I am concerned.
  • Holdkneebomb
    Holdkneebomb Posts: 1,271
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 7
    Morrison - 8
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 8 mom
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 8
    Hughes - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 7
  • Athletico Charlton
    Athletico Charlton Posts: 14,427
    Hamer    6.5 - Just not convinced by him at all

    Solly   7 - solid.

    Morrison 9 - great game and some skills

    Taylor 7 - solid

    Wiggins 8 - absolute bargain, Prem player in future

    Green 7.5 - best game for us today

    Hollands 8 - great goal

    Hughes 7 - solid and his ability to cover means Wiggins can bomb on further

    Jackson 9 - two good goals, and played well all the way through MOTM

    Kermorgant 8 - good flicks and distribution

    Wright Phillips 7 - got his goal although not his best game today



    Hayes n/a - some good touches

    Wagstaff n/a - tried but didn't get into the game

    Euell n/a - only a short period but don't see why he is on the bench ahead of others

     

    The one dissapointment was the ref who was abysmal today.  Tends to go unnoticed when we won so comfortably but they should have been down to 9 players and he didn't even book their keeper!  Loads of very poor decision making throughout the game.
  • Kap10
    Kap10 Posts: 15,641
    Hamer - 6
    Solly - 7
    Morrison - 7.5
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins - 8
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 8
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Kermorgant 7
    Wright Phillips 6.5

    Hayes n/a
    Wagstaff n/a
    Euell n/a

  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,823
    Thought Kermit deserved a booking too - was one of those lenient ones!
  • Mendonca In Asdas
    Mendonca In Asdas Posts: 22,716
    edited November 2011
    Hamer - 7 
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 9.5
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 9.5
    Green - 9
    Hollands - 9 
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson - 9
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Philips - 8.5

  • philipoters
    philipoters Posts: 44

    HAMER : 5  Lucky not to cocede a couple of goals tends to push the ball away instead of holding it very dodgy

    SOLLY : 7 Good solid display

    TAYLOR & MORRISON  9 Two great defenders with a fantastic understanding

    WIGGINS : 9  Becoming our best left back since CP

    GREEN : 7  A display more of what we expected I still want more from him hid on occasions

    HUGHES : 7  Proved his worth again today solid display

    KERMORGANT :8  Does this lad ever get beaten in the air fantastic find CP

    WRIGHT PHILLIPS 8 : Does what he does best scores goals enough said

    HOLLANDS : 8.5  Probably our best buy works his socks off

    JACKSON : 8  Another captains performance a good partnership with Wiggins

    Hayes  6

    Wagstaff  6

    Euell     6

  • McBobbin
    McBobbin Posts: 12,090
    Hamer - 7 shouts at the defence a lot. Few dodgy kicks, but not really at fault for the goals
    Solly - 8 fine
    Morrison - 8.5 great goal, solid
    Taylor - 8.5 thought he had the edge over Morrison defensively, some good tackles. Proper defensive partnership.
    Wiggins - 9 his cross for the fifth was like something out of a football computer game. Class.
    Green - 8 good game, set up the first with a great run and some dangerous balls
    Hollands - 8.5 good game and a goal
    Hughes - 8 kept running
    Jackson - 8.5 tired by end but a captains performance
    Kermorgant - 8 causes problems. Must be horrible to play against
    Wright Phillips - 8 does what he keeps on doing
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,040

     

    Hamer 6 Sometimes I feel he is not commanding enough

    Solly 7 - Effective

    Morrison 8 Good goal which gets him an extra mark

    Taylor 7 - solid

    Wiggins8.5- Another superb display

    Green 7 -Getting better , looking dangerous

    Hollands 8.5- I really like his determination well taken goal

    Hughes 7 Has made us look  more solid a very astute signing at this level proving his doubters wrong

    Jackson 9 -MOTM not just for the goals but the excellant dead ball scenarios , we missed him when he was subbed

    Kermorgant 7 - Kept going

    Wright Phillips 7 - Scored , I suspect SCP is trying to use him sparingly . We would all complain if he got injured late on .

    Hayes Looked as though he had a point to prove

    Wagstaff Using him late on seems to be working well

    Euell Good to see him back , but he is not a left midfielder Evina should be on the bench to cover the left footers.


     


  • Sponsored links:



  • Buglehorn
    Buglehorn Posts: 1,020
    Hamer  6.5

    Solly 7

    Morrison 8

    Taylor 7.5

    Wiggins 8.5

    Green 7

    Hollands 8

    Hughes 7

    Jackson 8

    Kermorgant 8.5 mom

    Wright Phillips 8



    Hayes 6

    Wagstaff 6

    Euell 6
  • 1StevieG
    1StevieG Posts: 10,972
    Hamer - 7 Not much to do apart from pick the ball out of the net twice. Distribution getting better and commanding his area.
    Solly - 8 another strong solid performance but lost the ball a couple of times towards the end.
    Morrison - 9 Another superb performance and took his goal well. A superb partnership with Taylor.
    Taylor - 9 Loved the rollocking he gave to the midfield in the first half for letting a cross come in. Great partnership with Morrison
    Wiggins - 10 Just for the cross alone for the 5th goal. Lots of pace, control, superb defending and briliant going forward.
    Green - 9 Starting to come up with the goods and set up 2 of the goals, the cross for BWP's and the Peakyesque rocket for JJ's first.
    Hollands - 9 Superb in midfield and working well with Hughes. Stunning header for the 5th.
    Hughes - 8 Composed on the ball and got stuck in.
    Jackson - 9 A strikers finish for the first and another well taken penalty again. Worked his nuts off.
    Kermorgant - 9 Gave their defenders an absolute nightmare winning headers and not giving up. Great work for the penalty.
    Wright Phillips - 8 even when not involved he still manages to snag a goal. Some neat passing and unlucky not to score a second after some clever footwork.
  • seth plum
    seth plum Posts: 53,448
    Hamer - 6 He has had better games, quite pleased he took a few catches.
    Solly - 6 Did that nasty early challenge subdue him?
    Morrison - 7.5 Pretty decent, credit for the goal. 
    Taylor - 7 Dealt with their main man very well.
    Wiggins - 8 Really good yet again, great ball for the fifth goal.
    Green - 7 Uneven, but played a part in the first crucial goal.
    Hollands - 7.5 Great header, improving.
    Hughes - 6.5 Unspectacular, but did a job as they say, fitness fanatic I heard today.
    Jackson - 8.5 MoM Telling how we dipped after he went off, the penalty in it's context was as good as his first.
    Kermorgant - 8 Unrewarded excellent performance, took a lot of flack for the team, always competitive and assertive.
     
    Powell and the management team 9 easily.
     
    Preston were a 4.5 but they had half their team out injured.
     
    Officials 7.5.
     
    Preston fans 7 much better than their team.
     
    Our fans 7.5 loud at times but some cricket like moments, maybe it was an 'absorbing' game.
    Wright Phillips
  • C_A_F_C
    C_A_F_C Posts: 3,878
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 7
    Morrison - 8
    Taylor - 7
    Wiggins - 9
    Green - 9
    Hollands - 8
    Hughes - 8
    Jackson - 9
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 8
  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,980
    Hamer - 7.5
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 9 MOM
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 8.5
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 8
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson - 8.5
    Kermorgant - 7.5
    Wright Phillips - 7.5
  • peteshep1905
    peteshep1905 Posts: 491
    Hamer - 7
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 9
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 8.5
    Hughes - 8.5
    Jackson - 8
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 8
  • Mckforester
    Mckforester Posts: 854
    Hamer - 7Solly - 8Morrison - 9Taylor - 8Wiggins - 8.5Green - 8Hollands - 8Hughes - 8Jackson - 8.5Kermorgant - 8Wright Phillips - 8.5
  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,776
    Hamer 7
    Solly 7 solid
    Morrison 8 defends well and comfortable on the ball, good to see a centre back score
    Taylor 7.5 solid as usual. Has shown the difference between him and Doherty, pace isn't a problem when players read the game well and make the right decisions
    Wiggins 8.5 such a threat going forward, pace, ability on the ball and most important and impressive an end product, another assist for him today. Did well enough in his first few games recently has really shown what he's capable of.
    Green 7.5 good game but still more to come from him in both goals and asssits
    Hollands 8 like Wiggins has recently shown, proper box to box midfielder
    Hughes 7 solid
    Jackson 8 good game, links up with Wiggins well when going forward
    Kermorgant 7.5
    Wright Phillips 7 not his best game but scored. Had the right idea a few times but didn't quite pull it off

    Hayes n/a 
    Wagstaff n/a
    Euell n/a - have to agree with others that would prefer Evina or Stephens on the bench
  • mid_life_crisis
    mid_life_crisis Posts: 3,277
    Hamer - 7Solly - 7.5Morrison - 8Taylor - 7.5Wiggins - 9 will play premier league football (hopefully for us)Green - 8Hollands - 8.5Hughes - 8Jackson - 8.5Kermorgant - 8.5Wright Phillips - 8
  • Jints
    Jints Posts: 3,526
    Hamer 7 - distribution is good but worries me sometimes
    Solly 7 - solid but didn't stand out in attacking
    Morrison - 8 really good partnership with Taylor
    Taylor - 7.5 another solid performance
    Wiggins - 8 great cross for the final goal, oozes quality
    Green - 8 very good performance, his corners put them under all sorts of pressure
    Hollands 8 - another consistent display. 
    Hughes 7.5 covers well
    Jackson - 8 good goals, bit slow sometimes. Links well with Wiggy
    Kerm - 8.5 MOTM, how the hell does he win every single header? What a find, brilliant awareness and foresight for the pen
    W-P - 7.5 constant threat but strange as it sounds in a five goal match didn't really get great service today
This discussion has been closed.

Categories

“Marketplace”