Charlton 1-1 Leyton Orient aet, 3-4 on penalties - Player Marks

Hamer 6.5
Evina 6
Taylor 5
Cort 5.5
Green 6
Wagstaff 6.5
Cook 6
Hollands 6
Wilson 5.5
Kerkar 6
Smith 6.5

All much of a muchness to be honest

Hamer - 6
Evina -7
Taylor -6
Cort - 7
Green - 7
Wagstaff - 7.5
Cook - 7.5
Hollands - 7
Wilson - 4
Kerkar - 7
Smith - 7

Hamer 7
Evina 6
Taylor 6
Cort 6
Green 6
Wagstaff 6
Cook 7
Hollands 6
Wilson 5
Kerkar 6
Smith 5

Some people marking Evina 7 and some marking him 3.

Puzzled.

i dont think green was worth a 6 or 7, he was poor imo and would probably get at most 5

Hamer 6.5
Evina 6
Taylor 7
Cort 6.5
Green 5
Wagstaff 6
Cook 7.5
Hollands 6.5
Wilson 5
Kerkar 6.5
Smith 5.5

Hamer - 7
Evina - 6
Taylor - 6
Cort - 6
Green - 5
Wagstaff - 5
Cook - 6
Hollands - 7.5 mom
Wilson - 6
Kerkar - 6
Smith - 6

Hamer - 6
Evina - 4
Taylor - 6
Cort - 6.5
Green - 4
Wagstaff - 6.5
Cook - 4.5
Hollands - 5
Wilson - 5
Kerkar - 6.5
Smith 4.5

Oggy Red said:

Some people marking Evina 7 and some marking him 3.

Puzzled.

I just think he is chuff. Very quick but can't cross a road and is defensively naive. He needs to improve considerably to be anywhere near good enough for the Championship.

Hamer - 7 Kept us in it with point blank save in 2nd half
Wilson - 4 Least impressive of the newbies and worryingly the one we paid money for! Poor in the air (never attacks the ball but looks at the player he is marking instead), seemed to get the blame for the corner they scored from, gave away the penalty in the 2nd half and missed a penalty in the knockout stage. A debut to forget!
Evina - 6 Made some good runs 2nd half but I never feel too comfortable with him defensively
Taylor - 6 Solid back up player
Cort - 6 Good in the air
Green - 5 I keep hoping he'll come good and earn a place in the 1st eleven but was off target with every shot when in great positions and still gives the ball away too easily
Hollands - 7 Didn't look fit but his quality shone
Kerkar - 7 A little lightweight but v.gd distribution. Good acquisition
Cook - 8 MoM. Looked the most likely to make something happen. Great freebie.
Smith - 7 V promising. Worked his nuts off and good on the floor for a big man. I don't think he'd score many goals if he does play in Championship league games but arguably already as good as Hayes as a backup for Yann
Waggy - 6 Scored a flukey goal but went missing for most of the rest of the game after that

lancashire lad said:

For those lucky Lifers at the Valley tonight please give your marks, between 0-10 halves allowed, for each player who played at least 30 minutes. Just copy and paste the list and give your marks.
This thread will be closed on Thursday afternoon and the Statbank will appear on Friday.

Cup stats will be kept seperate from the Championship:

Hamer 7
Evina 7
Taylor 6
Cort 7
Green 3.5
Wagstaff 7.5 mom
Cook 7
Hollands 6.5
Wilson 6
Kerkar 7.5
Smith 7

Pritchard n/a (on for less than 30 minutes)
Jackson n/a
Wright Phillips n/a

Hamer 7
Evina 5
Taylor 6
Cort 6
Green 5
Wagstaff 6
Cook 7.5
Hollands 7
Wilson 5
Kerkar 6
Smith 6

Saw a Green 3.5 too! Just don't get it!!

Haha Diawara the original 50 pence head, and then went onto play countless champions league games??? Go figure! Why are some players so poor for us?