Players Marks: Nottingham Forest v Charlton

@lancashire_lad I watched the whole stream so feel free not to include these marks into your final total.

Hamer - 5 - Big blunder with the 1st goal and looked a bit dodgy all match which is unusual for him
Solly - 6 - Average not quality
Morrison - 6 - Some good tackles but like the rest of the defense he was torn to pieces by Forest's passing game
Cort - 5.5 - There was no ariel battle for him to dominate and he lacked agility at times
Wiggins - 6 - Nothing going forward and he was average defensively
Cook - 4.5 - Not in the game at all
Hollands - 5.5 - was chasing shadows so he couldn't offer anything going forward
Pritchard - 5.5 - Got overpowered in midfield
Jackson - 5 - Not in the game on the wing but when moved to centre mid he did well and spread the ball about nicely, shame he was only there for about 5-10 mins.
Kermorgant - 6 - Lacked service so wasn't in the game much
Wright Phillips - 6 - Ditto Kermorgant
Haynes - 4.5 - Did nothing at all

Fuller and Kerkar both made an impact when they came on and probably ended up being our 2 best players even though they only played for 5 mins.

Hamer 5
Solly 7
Morrison 6
Cort 6.5
Wiggins 6
Cook 5
Hollands 4
Pritchard 4
Jackson 4
Kermorgant 6
Wright Phillips 3
Haynes 4

Fuller 6
Kerkar 6

Hamer 5. At fault for the first goal
Solly 7. Wasn't able to get forward much. One excellent late surge.
Morrison 6. Hard afternoon's work
Cort 6.5 won a lot of high balls one superb tackle may have saved a goal
Wiggins 6. As Solly minus the surge.
Cook 4. Why was he given that role? Needs to think faster
Hollands 5. I hope this was just an off day
Pritchard 5. I thought he did ok fighting the tide.
Jackson 4. As Hollands but insert "really really"
Kermorgant 5. Not his best. But there are better defenders around this season.
Wright Phillips 5. With hindsight should have been sacrificed for a 4-5-1
Haynes 5. Didn't make an impact

Fuller n/a
Kerkar n/a

Hamer - 5
Solly - 6
Morrison - 6
Cort - 6
Wiggins - 6
Cook - 4
Hollands - 5
Pritchard - 5
Jackson - 5
Kermorgant - 6
Wright Phillips - 6
Haynes - 5

Fuller n/a
Kerkar n/a

Hamer 4 At fault for the first goal, looked shakey all game
Solly 7 solid
Morrison 5 struggled with Forest movement
Cort 5 same as above
Wiggins 5 never got forward at all. gave the ball away a lot in the first half
Cook 3 never settled, not sure how much was his fault as he was moved from the right to the middle to the left to up front
Hollands 6 Got overrun as he had no help from the other midfielders
Pritchard 5 struggled throughout
Jackson 4 Struggled on the wing yet again, looked better in the middle but still doesn't look good enough.
Kermorgant 5 struggled to win as many headers, but probably down to the lack of service
Wright Phillips 5 struggled no service
Haynes 3 Didn't look interested

Powell 2 messed around with the formation too much.

Only plus point was Fuller looked a threat as soon as he came in strong and good with the ball at his feet. Kerkar looked half decent aswell.

Hamer 5
Solly 5
Morrison 7
Cort 5
Wiggins 6
Cook 1
Hollands 5
Pritchard 4.5
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 6.5
Wright Phillips 5
Haynes 6

Fuller n/a - you might say n/a but we were a different team when he came on

Kerkar n/a

That's shocking marking, se9. Makes a mockery of the system.

lancashire lad said:

For those of you at the City Ground today your marks please, just copy and paste the list. The thread will remain open for marks until Tuesday lunchtime and Stats will be out by the evening:

Hamer - 5
Solly - 7
Morrison - 6
Cort - 6
Wiggins - 5
Cook - 5
Hollands -5
Pritchard -5
Jackson - 5
Kermorgant - 5
Wright Phillips - 5
Haynes - 5

Fuller n/a
Kerkar n/a

Thought Fuller showed more in his short cameo than the rest put together, sorely lacking any craft or creativity throughout.

Hamer - 6
Solly - 7
Morrison - 5
Cort - 5
Wiggins - 6
Cook - 4
Hollands - 5
Pritchard - 6
Jackson - 5.5
Kermorgant - 5
Wright Phillips - 6
Haynes - 4.5

Fuller n/a
Kerkar n/a

Hamer - 6 at fault for the first goal, no way he should be beaten from that angle.
Solly - 7 Solid, even though he was left seriously exposed.
Morrison - 7 Don't think he did much wrong, couple of good tackles.
Cort - 6 Some decent headers away, when we were being bombarded.
Wiggins - 6 Couldn't do anythng but hoof it into the box and hope.
Cook - 4 Looked like a boy up against men.
Hollands - 6 Let down by his fellow midfielders.
Pritchard - 4 Chasing shadows , no real position.
Jackson - 5.5 Looked more comfortable in the middle.
Kermorgant - 5 Did the best with what he had
Wright Phillips - 6 Didn't get much service but took up a position on the right to cover for Cook/Pritchard
Haynes - 5 Not sure if 100% fit or just a bit lazy.

Fuller n/a
Kerkar n/a These two looked very good when they came on , completely changed the game momentum. Look forward to seeing more of Fuller.

Hamer 6
Solly 7
Morrison 6
Cort 6
Wiggins 6
Cook 4
Hollands 6
Pritchard 4
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 6.5
Wright Phillips 5.5
Haynes 6

Fuller 8 on the time he played, looked very strong on the ball, can't wait to see more of him.

Not really mate, if 50 people give a mark then mines will only have a 2% influence on the result. That's how averages work.

Dont feel disheartened from having your say simply because I have.

Garrymanilow said:

To balance what you've done out I'd have to give Cook a 10. Which he doesn't deserve. Rating Cook at a 1 obviously doesn't make sense but if you're determined to stick with it then I'm not going to waste my time doing a load of ratings when it is now pointless. Been an embarrassing day for this board

Bazza, take you and your long nose onto other thread. cheers