Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Derby v Charlton

lancashire lad
lancashire lad Posts: 15,702
edited September 2012 in General Charlton
For those at Pride Park tonight your marks please, just copy and paste the list:

Hamer
Wilson
Morrison
Cort
Solly
Green
Hollands
Stephens
Jackson
Kermorgant
Wright Phillips

Kerkar
Fuller

This thread will stay open until Thursday lunchtime.

Comments

  • se9addick
    se9addick Posts: 32,195
    Now THIS is the sort of game where giving someone an extreme mark could skew the results !

    Fair play to those that went.
  • JuniorRed80
    JuniorRed80 Posts: 36

    Hamer - 6 no saves to make
    Wilson - 5
    Morrison - 5
    Cort - 6
    Solly - 6
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 5
    Stephens - 4
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant - 6
    Wright Phillips - 5

    Kerkar - 6
    Fuller - 6
  • Deadred
    Deadred Posts: 1,514

    Hamer 6
    Wilson 5
    Morrison 6
    Cort 6
    Solly 6.5
    Green 7.5
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 5
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 6
    Wright Phillips 5.5

    Kerkar 6
    Fuller 6.5
  • boggzy
    boggzy Posts: 3,631
    edited September 2012
    Hamer 6
    Wilson 5
    Morrison 5
    Cort 5.5
    Solly 6
    Green 7.5
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 7
    Wright-Philips 5.5

    Kerkar 7
    Fuller 8




  • SaySomething
    SaySomething Posts: 2,558
    edited September 2012
    Hamer 6
    Wilson 4
    Morrison 5
    Cort 6
    Solly 6
    Green 7.5
    Hollands 4
    Stephens 6
    Jackson 5.5
    Kermorgant 6
    Wright Phillips 6.5

    Kerkar 6
    Fuller 7
  • Shrew
    Shrew Posts: 5,758
    edited September 2012
    Hamer 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 5
    Cort 5.5
    Solly 6
    Green 7.5
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 5.5
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 6.5
    Wright-Philips 6

    Kerkar 6.5
    Fuller 7
  • oohaahmortimer
    oohaahmortimer Posts: 34,373
    Hamer 6
    Wilson 4
    Morrison 5
    Cort 6
    Solly 6
    Green 8
    Hollands 4.5
    Stephens 4.5
    Jackson 4.5
    Kermorgant 6
    Wright Phillips 6

    Kerkar 6
    Fuller 7

  • LonelyNorthernAddick
    LonelyNorthernAddick Posts: 2,424
    edited September 2012
    Edit after discovering who had made the mistakes.

    Hamer - 6
    Wilson - 5 - Was average overall, worse in the second half though.
    Morrison - 5.5 - Average in general.
    Cort - 6- Slightly better i guess
    Solly - 5 - Wrong position, could tell he was unsuited to where he was supposed to be.
    Green - 7.5 - Re-vitalised the game for us, scored and set-up the second very well, a point off for giving away that penalty though
    Hollands - 5
    Stephens - 4.5 You can't give goals away like that, unacceptable really.
    Jackson - 5.5 Needs to be in the centre I think.
    Kermy - 6.5 Did alright
    BWP - 5 Frankly don't think he's good enough for the championship. Doesn't do enough damage.

    Kerkar - 6.5
    Fuller - 7.5
  • No.1 in South London
    No.1 in South London Posts: 3,978
    Hamer 6
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 6.5
    Cort 6
    Solly 6
    Green 7.5
    Hollands 4
    Stephens 5
    Jackson 5
    Kermorgant 5,5
    Wright Phillips 5

    Kerkar 6
    Fuller 7
  • No.1 in South London
    No.1 in South London Posts: 3,978
    LonelyNorthernAddick said:

    Wilson - 4 - Gave away a penalty foolishly and was a bit useless in general.

    Think you'll find that was Green for the Pen. Wilson did ok tonight. He's prone to an odd lapse in concentration (one short back pass which Hamer dealt with), but he covered well got forward and can delier a decent ball in which helps.

  • Sponsored links:



  • LonelyNorthernAddick
    LonelyNorthernAddick Posts: 2,424
    No.1 in South London said:

    LonelyNorthernAddick said:

    Wilson - 4 - Gave away a penalty foolishly and was a bit useless in general.

    Think you'll find that was Green for the Pen. Wilson did ok tonight. He's prone to an odd lapse in concentration (one short back pass which Hamer dealt with), but he covered well got forward and can delier a decent ball in which helps.
    Was it!? Oh sorry, thought it was Wilson. But i think we'd do better with Solly on the right and Evina left.
  • C_A_F_C
    C_A_F_C Posts: 3,878

    Hamer - 6
    Wilson - 4
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 5
    Solly - 6
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 5
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson - 6
    Kermorgant - 7
    Wright Phillips - 6

    Kerkar - 7
    Fuller - 7
  • Bryan_Kynsie
    Bryan_Kynsie Posts: 2,179


    Hamer 7 made several decent saves
    Wilson 6 nowhere near as bad as some have said
    Morrison 5 we were vulnerable on the deck through the middle
    Cort 5 not as dominant as he has been
    Solly 6 does the basics well but clearly out of position
    Green 7 MOTM but daft penalty detracted from overall performance
    Hollands 4 worryingly ponderous. Hopefully just an off day
    Stephens 4 needs to make much more impact and not cost us a goal
    Jackson 4 much as I love the guy he is really struggling
    Kermorgant 6 needs better service
    Wright Phillips 6 played ok with no real help from midfield

    Kerkar 6 surely must start on the left at Ipswich
    Fuller 7 always looks dangerous and should be on sooner

    This thread will stay open until Thursday lunchtime.

  • Simonsen
    Simonsen Posts: 5,556
    Hamer 6 - iffy kicking but ok generally.
    Wilson 6 - tried hard and defended ok.
    Morrison 6 - ok
    Cort - 7 Defended manfully.
    Solly - 6 Defended ok but lack of left foot put us in bother.
    Green - 8.5 2nd half was the best wing display I can remember from a Charlton winger....great skill. Brilliant goal, great run and cut back for 2nd goal, run and cross for Kermo header, magic run and cut back for near post chance, some good tackles but gave away a pen! The high mark is for entertainment value.
    Hollands - 5 Not really in it.
    Stephens - 6 Some good but an awful error for 2nd goal. Never gave up though.
    Jackson - 5.5 Was better in the centre and had a header cleared off line. Struggled with Derby's wing-play.
    Kermorgant - 7.5 Won lots of headers and was a handful.
    Wright Phillips - 6 Tried his best but we did look better when Fuller replaced him.

    Kerkar - 7 So skillfull and unlucky with last min header.
    Fuller - 7.5 Pace, movement and strength. Looked good.
  • Floyd_Road
    Floyd_Road Posts: 15
    Hamer - 6
    Wilson - 5
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 6
    Solly - 6
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 5
    Stephens - 5
    Jackson - 6
    Kermorgant - 7
    Wright Phillips -6

    Kerkar - 7
    Fuller - 7
  • cypriot_addick
    cypriot_addick Posts: 381
    Hamer - 6
    Wilson - 3 was so bad, kept hoofing it and some dodgy passes back to hamer and just was basically awful.
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 6
    Solly -7 playing out of position and did well considering.
    Green MOM - 9 wonder goal and set up the 2nd plus creating several chances, yes gave away pen but was covering wilson who was no where to be seen.
    Hollands - 4
    Stephans - 4 him and hollands did nothing in the centre.
    Jackson - 4 at times didn't even realise he was playing.
    Kermo - 7 scored a goal and won alot of headers 2nd half.
    BWP 6 - no service and only played 60 min.

    Kerkar and fuller both 7.5 both were excellent.
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,040
    First away game of the season .

    Hamer 6 Not at fault for any of the goals
    Wilson 6 Steady game ,would have preferred the natural balance Evina would have given us
    Morrison 6 Defended well
    Cort 7 Has been our best player so far in the games I've seen
    Solly 6 Needs to be back at RB ,offered little going forward due to lack of left foot
    Green 8 MOTM Would have been a 9 ,point deducted for conceeding a stupid penalty
    Hollands 5 Concerned he is not adapting to the Championship
    Stephens 5 Lost a mark for the error which led to the 2nd goal
    Jackson 6.5 Looked a lot better when moved to cm ,think he can't be played wide at this level.CM is his natural position
    Kermorgant 7 Took his goal well
    Wright Phillips 6 Tried hard

    Kerkar 7 Made an impact gave the team good balance with Green
    Fuller 7 We need him to start soon ,we look a different proposition when he comes on

  • feesh_cafc
    feesh_cafc Posts: 135
    Hamer - 6
    Wilson - 6
    Cort - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Wilson - 6
    Green - 8
    Stephens - 5
    Hollands - 5
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant - 6
    Wright-Phillips - 5.5

    Fuller - 7
    Kerkar - 7.5
  • CharltonKerry
    CharltonKerry Posts: 2,991
    Hamer 6
    Wilson 5
    Cort 6
    Morrison 6
    Solly 6
    Green 8 mom
    Stephens 5
    Hollands 5
    Jackson 4.5
    Kermorgant 7
    BWP 5

    Kerkar 7
    Fuller 7.5
  • ThreadKiller
    ThreadKiller Posts: 8,638
    Hamer - 6
    Wilson - 4.5
    Morrison - 5
    Cort -5.5
    Solly - 5.5
    Green - 8
    Hollands - 4
    Stephens - 4.5
    Jackson - 5
    Kermorgant -6
    Wright Phillips -5.5

  • Sponsored links:



  • Redrobo
    Redrobo Posts: 11,340
    Wow, all make Green MOM. A first surely.
  • TelMc32
    TelMc32 Posts: 9,162
    Hamer - 5 unusually some poor pieces of distribution, putting himself under pressure
    Wilson - 5 a good few lapses, with sloppy passes. Needs to find some composure
    Morrison - 5 tried hard, looked a little overrun at times
    Cort - 6.5 won everything in the air, immense. Not so assured on the floor.
    Solly - 6 switched back to the right in 2nd half. Usual effort from him
    Green - 8 unlucky for the penalty, very soft. Brilliant goal & set up for Yann
    Hollands - 5 bypassed a fair amount as Derby passed round us
    Stephens - 6 bad mistake for their 2nd, but put in a very good shift in midfield & battled hard
    Jackson - 5 no lacking effort, but made to look pedestrian at times by Derby's passing
    Kermorgant - 6 took goal well, took a few knocks but not as dominant in the air as we had come to expect. Won more as the game went on
    Wright Phillips - 6 worked very hard & chased every ball. One very poor shot dragged wide, but not much else.

    Kerkar & Fuller - both 7 - gave us a lot more impetus going forward. Might knock 1/2 off Fuller for taking the ball off Kerkar for the offside goal. Kerkar would have been on!!

    Very difficult for us for long periods. Derby had some great passing & movement for a large part of the game and Coutts showed us what we missed out on & young kid Will Hughes, just 17, was superb. Nothing of him, but outplayed our midfield.
  • harveys_gardener
    harveys_gardener Posts: 7,038
    Was it Stevens poor back pass, radio said MM?
  • TelMc32
    TelMc32 Posts: 9,162
    harveys gardener said:

    Was it Stevens poor back pass, radio said MM?

    The lead up to the goal began with a pass back from Dale which was a bit wayward and put unnecessary pressure on the defence. That said, I thought he had a very good game and pressed and chased well, as well as trying to get his usual passing game going. Some strange markings for him above, but he got some very complimentary comments from people I was with at the game.

Categories

“Marketplace”