FA Cup semi - it's been 60 odd years! How many promotion/relegation we hadbin that time? What would you remember more x years down the line?
Christ we could get hull/Sunderland and suddenly you're 90mins from a potential final and therefore europe, as anything could happen in 90mins in a semi.
As previously discussed, we would be ineligible for Europe if Standard Liege qualify (which they will).
We qualify for Europe, RD sells us for one euro to his girlfriend, all sorted, simples! :0)
We wont get this chance again. I want to remember something special. Staying in the championship /league 1 vying for promotion is what Charlton have done for decades and sadly it wont change in a hurry.
Survival , but if I had option of winning it then that all day long , final maybe because that would mean winning in semis at wembley and like others have said us going wembley doesn't happen to often .
Wembley. It might never happen again for another 16 years.. We could survive in the Championship this year and go down the following season. Wembley stays with you forever.
If you'd said championship survival and the cup final then that'd be a tough one. As it stands, the semi final is nowhere really and we'd quite likely lose it so i'd have to take survival.
Yes Wembley is a rarity but how many people will look back fondly and tell their kids about the 6-0 defeat to Man City?
Maybe it would be a good idea to revive this thread IF we get to the semis and get knocked out and see if any opinions change. A final would be a different question and a tough one.
A cup final win, then yea id take that over survival all day.
The semi final would probably be against a team that would comfortably beat us. Has to be survival. Far better than seeing Chelsea stick four past us at Wembley.
Wembley. It might never happen again for another 16 years.. We could survive in the Championship this year and go down the following season. Wembley stays with you forever.
Wembley. It might never happen again for another 16 years.. We could survive in the Championship this year and go down the following season. Wembley stays with you forever.
Tut Tut 😉
Can we please not mention the "R" word before even a ball has been kicked...
Always league over cups unless you win the thing (and we have no chance!). A semi final would be a fun day out but not at the expense of being back to L1 week in week out.
Comments
I have seen Charlton at Wembley, twice.
FA Cup win is a once in a lifetime for us, I'd happily not get another point this season to see that
Wembley is permanent, relegation is temporary.
Yes Wembley is a rarity but how many people will look back fondly and tell their kids about the 6-0 defeat to Man City?
Head has to rule the heart on this one.
A cup final win, then yea id take that over survival all day.
Semi final? No.
Final? Probably.
Winners? Definitely. Relegate us now if you want.
Cushty...🙄
And how many do we have in total ?
It's the off field problems that always start the procedure of relegating us in the 1st place. It's happend 3 times.
An FA cup run is not infront of the que before survival.
Can we please not mention the "R" word before even a ball has been kicked...
I was convinced we'd win the 1/4 final, I have never forgiven Harriot for that shocking miss at 0-0.