For those still banging on about Kermorgant
Comments
-
Oh yeah. Cause it's been such a shining example of how to run a football club for the last 7 or 8 YEARS.Greenie said:
Good luck I hope you head don't get stuck in the sand.PragueAddick said:
The point is that we don't believe it. We think it's an urban myth. A lot of people say a lot of things when it comes to money and work, and most of it is hot air. Good management is all about working out the real threat from within all the hot air.Greenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
No one is bigger than the club and having read all guff on this thread about him again thankfully none if you will ever run our club.
I reckon some on here would make a decent fist of it to be honest.
1 -
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!2 -
Greenie even if it is true, it's not as simple as saying "screw that greedy bastard we can do without him". You ask any businessmen or even football men. If the person doing that is marginal to your squad then fair enough you tell them to piss off. But if they are absolutely vital to you making profit (or winning football matches), then as bitter as you might feel about it, sometimes you do have to cave in.oohaahmortimer said:
He didn't want to trigger the extension when he was looking to secure a better dealGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
He was in a place to negotiate a better deal due to the interest from Bournemouth and any player in their right mind would do that
Negotiation is where they were at , decent players can do that , he was in a position to do that
How true that he'd have not played for the rest of the season if we'd said you've got run your contract down is I doubt very much but then it wouldn't make sense for any of the parties involved to do that
I've heard countless stories of people having deliberately open conversations with recruiters, or giving their employers ultimatums and getting extra cash cos they're worth it. My company had some graduate kid fresh out of uni come into his first 6 month appraisal and ask for an extra grand salary cos he knew his mate was on that at another company. They thought he was a bit cocky but they gave it to him cos he's half decent and some of the previous youngsters we've had just weren't. Look at Rooney. Man U caved in and paid him a fortune despite the fact he was ready to jump ship to their local rivals and neighbours.
Kermogant was our best player and was worth what he was asking for as he's proved at Bournemouth.12 -
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
0 -
I think you'll find , well from me at least , that whoever RD is taking his footballing advice from and getting him to spend his money on the likes of polish Pete rather than Yann is where everyone is finding it difficult to accept the expenditureNWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
If there was no dough being spent/offered for players then I think we'd all accept that fair enough RD isn't gonna be spunking so we 're running a tight ship and Yann was out of our price range5 -
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!1 -
Do you not think that they've been looking elsewhere with their agents at securing deals come the end of the season,NWCorner said:
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
do you not think that if the teams they'd made contact with had wanted them as much as Bournemouth wanted Yann that they'd have kept Schtum and not looked to increase their contracts ????
Come on perleeeeease
It's dog eat dog out there , every man for themselves
Those players aren't as good as Yann
1 -
Ultimately we did not have to give Yann anything extra at all.
We could and should - in the absence of a replacement - have said, "Fine, don't re-sign for us, no problem. But we are not selling you and you will be staying here until the end of the season, you can then take your pick of clubs to sign for."
Even two or three goals from Yann plus a couple of assists and we might already be safe.4 -
Yes. As they have been all season. I seem to remember Wiggins getting a massive 5 year deal but not a sniff for anyone else ,so Roland was already in the business of unbalancing the squad.NWCorner said:
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
There will be plenty of time for Roland to sort out wage structures and squad policies in the summer but this was a 'needs must' situation and in my opinion he let us down.
3 -
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.NWCorner said:
Yes. I absolutely docarly burn said:. Blockquote class="Quote" rel="Greenie">So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
Well unfortunately running a football club is a gamble. So not giving yann the sort of money he wants/deserves and spending it on pete, reza, obika who are scoring for fun at the minute weren't the best move imo.
We've given jacko a new 2 year deal and he must be our top earner. One minute people on here are saying his legs are gone. The next minute he is captain marval. So surely we could have pushed the boat out a little bit on yann.3 -
Sponsored links:
-
Absolutely, players will always look after number one that's why Yann took the money, left and good luck to him.oohaahmortimer said:
Do you not think that they've been looking elsewhere with their agents at securing deals come the end of the season,NWCorner said:
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
do you not think that if the teams they'd made contact with had wanted them as much as Bournemouth wanted Yann that they'd have kept Schtum and not looked to increase their contracts ????
Come on perleeeeease
It's dog eat dog out there , every man for themselves
Those players aren't as good as Yann
0 -
There isn't exactly a long list, though, and what exactly would the objection have been to signing them? Possibly that they are going to be released this summer regardless of whether we stay up in order that the squad can be stuffed with more of RD's nonsense signings.NWCorner said:
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
What sits underneath all this is that the mismanagement of the previous pair had put certain players - and Kermorgant in particular - in a powerful bargaining position. Doubtless Yann's agent encouraged him to exploit that, but his position was a strong one regardless as events have demonstrated. RD's response was to pretend that it wasn't - and to believe instead that the ragbag of rubbish he sent over was capable of meeting the challenge instead.
We are now reaping the consequences of the fact he either didn't understand what he was doing or he didn't care.4 -
Perhaps Yann could still remember the promises made to Haynes and Fuller about new contracts at the end of last season. Talk is cheap.NWCorner said:
But they did get him in on the Thursday, after he had spoke to AFCB, after the twitter storm and it wasn't KM doin the dealing it was Martinoohaahmortimer said:Not forgetting the presence of Kermo defensively who for us made so many defensive clearances aerially and would drop in to midfield to help hem out in battles
Answering NWCorners question I'd have pulled him in with my footballing advisers and manager and sorted things out , rather than asking my gopher to be the inbetween of it all
Protheroe. Yann was asked what he wanted, more money ? Player/Manager assurances ? Security for your family ?
Yanns answer was security. MP offered him a 2yr deal from this Summer on decent money, not Bournemouth money. Yann threw his arms in the air and walked out. The rest is history.
I thought he was a great player !
Rightly or wrongly he has gone !
Have we replaced him ? No
Were we pulling up trees with him in the side ? Not really
Would he of kept us up ? Who knows. He might of got injured next game !
Mistakes have been made but hopefully the club/owners will learn from it, learn how tough our leagues are, we can stay up and then build from there.
Don't sell him, let him play to the end of the season and walk for free.
If a contract extension is triggered - both sides can mutually cancel it should they wish to.
Overall, let's keep in mind that YK has given any number of interviews about his departure, while our Board still refuse to even tell us how much we got for him - maybe they are ashamed of this huge mistake.
Bottom line is: We are in crisis and would be better with YK in the squad, our Board are throwing us false season ticket deadlines, Polish players that can't even make the reserves, goalkeepers that refuse to get on the bus but are still in the squad, free wifi and match programmes, compulsory seat moving - or maybe not, loads of players expected to get us out of the mess this season without any guarantee of their own future, a change of manager for a bloke we have never heard of, and his assistant likewise, along with a World Cup star who couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo, and a bloke who can only play for an hour tops. You can't tell if it's voucher Z or bring your own lawn.
Amateurs.
10 -
Where does everybody get the figure of £700000 for Polish Pete from? As far as I know it has never been disclosed. I think we would be a better team with Kermy. But he was given a better offer at Bournemouth so he took it. It is not ideal but it happens. We have sold our best players before in all my Fifty three years of supporting the Club. I am sure we will carry on doing it. I don't like it but it is Roland's money and he can do what he likes with it.2
-
Airman, I totally agree that Yann hasn't been replaced, RD has totally underestimated our league and his replacements aren't great. I don't for one minute believe that RD doesn't care. I think he is having to clean up a big mess on and off the field left by the previous lot.Airman Brown said:
There isn't exactly a long list, though, and what exactly would the objection have been to signing them? Possibly that they are going to be released this summer regardless of whether we stay up in order that the squad can be stuffed with more on RD's nonsense signings.NWCorner said:
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
What sits underneath all this is that the mismanagement of the previous pair had put certain players - and Kermorgant in particular - in a powerful bargaining position. Doubtless Yann's agent encouraged him to exploit that, but his position was a strong one regardless as events have demonstrated. RD's response was to pretend that it wasn't - and to believe instead that the ragbag of rubbish he sent over was capable of meeting the challenge instead.
We are now reaping the consequences of the fact he either didn't understand what he was doing or he didn't care.
0 -
dickplumb said:
Where does everybody get the figure of £700000 for Polish Pete from? As far as I know it has never been disclosed.
I've heard it from a good source
0 -
Agreed, but that was what he bought. Caveat emptor and all that. They say that someone who represents themselves in court has a fool for client - I suspect something similar applies to someone who does their own due diligence when buying a football club.NWCorner said:
Airman, I totally agree that Yann hasn't been replaced, RD has totally underestimated our league and his replacements aren't great. I don't for one minute believe that RD doesn't care. I think he is having to clean up a big mess on and off the field left by the previous lot.Airman Brown said:
There isn't exactly a long list, though, and what exactly would the objection have been to signing them? Possibly that they are going to be released this summer regardless of whether we stay up in order that the squad can be stuffed with more on RD's nonsense signings.NWCorner said:
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
What sits underneath all this is that the mismanagement of the previous pair had put certain players - and Kermorgant in particular - in a powerful bargaining position. Doubtless Yann's agent encouraged him to exploit that, but his position was a strong one regardless as events have demonstrated. RD's response was to pretend that it wasn't - and to believe instead that the ragbag of rubbish he sent over was capable of meeting the challenge instead.
We are now reaping the consequences of the fact he either didn't understand what he was doing or he didn't care.3 -
Could maybe have tried something like this: Yann, we're offering X and you want Y. As you think you're worth Y then this is what we'll do, you keep us up this year and you can have Y which will kick in from the summer. We go down and you stay on X.
Or just offered him Y in the first place and sold him off a bit later if it was proving expensive.
1 -
If you want to start cleaning up a mess you don't start by kicking out the key asset to keeping your club secure at Championship level, you start with non-entitys like Evina and you kick out these stupid loans you are paying wages week in week out and aren't even playing them far near enough.NWCorner said:
Airman, I totally agree that Yann hasn't been replaced, RD has totally underestimated our league and his replacements aren't great. I don't for one minute believe that RD doesn't care. I think he is having to clean up a big mess on and off the field left by the previous lot.Airman Brown said:
There isn't exactly a long list, though, and what exactly would the objection have been to signing them? Possibly that they are going to be released this summer regardless of whether we stay up in order that the squad can be stuffed with more on RD's nonsense signings.NWCorner said:
Do you not think that if the club gave Yann what he wanted, all the other better players wouldn't of been knocking in Roland's door ?carly burn said:
Why throw in better deals for anyone else?NWCorner said:
Ok, you give Yann £15,000 a week, throw in some better deals for Morrow, Ben etc and we still go down. You have a lot of big earners in League One, but that's ok cos Roland is loaded.carly burn said:
Yes. I absolutely doGreenie said:So if a player tries to hold the club to ransom and says I will be injured if my contract extension is triggered you think it would be ok to cave in and give him what he wants?
Thankfully none if you run our football club!
What sits underneath all this is that the mismanagement of the previous pair had put certain players - and Kermorgant in particular - in a powerful bargaining position. Doubtless Yann's agent encouraged him to exploit that, but his position was a strong one regardless as events have demonstrated. RD's response was to pretend that it wasn't - and to believe instead that the ragbag of rubbish he sent over was capable of meeting the challenge instead.
We are now reaping the consequences of the fact he either didn't understand what he was doing or he didn't care.
It's like starting a car boot sale by selling your car, after that you're always going to struggle to keep it together. YK is an unreal footballer, imagine being told to mark him for 90 minutes and imagine being told to mark spongefoot for 90.....
8 -
He was offered a contract and turned it down having previously refused to play to avoid a contract extension. Charlton to the core.1
-
Sponsored links:
-
The devil is in the detail my friend, do you know specifically what the contract was, how long, how much? The shorter and less money the less fair on him - he has a family and a life to sustain in England.PL54 said:He was offered a contract and turned it down having previously refused to play to avoid a contract extension. Charlton to the core.
0 -
Or did he... ?PL54 said:He was offered a contract and turned it down having previously refused to play to avoid a contract extension. Charlton to the core.
1 -
And we are left with Sordell.PL54 said:He was offered a contract and turned it down having previously refused to play to avoid a contract extension. Charlton to the core.
A man who gives it all for the cause
People need to realise that the football world spins differently to the one most of us operate in.
3 -
I have no idea what happened behind the scenes, but ultimately, judgement of those decisions at the time can probably best be made by asking are we now a stronger football team? I think the answer is unfortunately no we are not. It seemed a bizarre decision then, and nothing since has made it look any better. Hindsight is a wonderful thing and all that, but it seemed the wrong decision on footballing grounds at the time, and it seems ludicrous now.
But, of course, if we stay up, and I think we will by the skin of our teeth, it maybe will not matter in the long term.
If, on the other hand, we mess up the last few games, and get relegated then quite a few decisions in the last few months will look misguided at best.
I cannot see how relegation could be viewed as anything but disaster for this club and the new management and ownership.
Let's just hope we pull out enough points in the coming few weeks....
7 -
As one not in the know, do we know this for a fact? What was in YK's contract after the next game? Was it an auto renewal or trigger an option for the club or player? If it was the player's option, why shouldn't he negotiate? If it was the club's, they clearly didn't take it up.SELR_addicks said:Wonder if any other teams eulogise a player that refuses to play for the club and then holds the chairman hostage for more money at 32 years old?
Be annoyed at the lack of adequate replacement, but Yann is no legend.0 -
All been explained in NLA posts, I happen to believe him.rikofold said:
As one not in the know, do we know this for a fact? What was in YK's contract after the next game? Was it an auto renewal or trigger an option for the club or player? If it was the player's option, why shouldn't he negotiate? If it was the club's, they clearly didn't take it up.SELR_addicks said:Wonder if any other teams eulogise a player that refuses to play for the club and then holds the chairman hostage for more money at 32 years old?
Be annoyed at the lack of adequate replacement, but Yann is no legend.
1 -
So have I, and furthermore that there are future add-ons. however the figure may be in euros.oohaahmortimer said:dickplumb said:Where does everybody get the figure of £700000 for Polish Pete from? As far as I know it has never been disclosed.
I've heard it from a good source
It was confirmed for me last week. I joined the de Graafschap fans forum, and there exactly this figure is widely discussed as a fact.0 -
Imagine being stuck with Kermo next season when we could have had Church.........oh wait a minute !1
-
There is another urban legend going around, which I give no more or less creedence to than NLA's version of events.
It is that Katrien was so taken aback by the firestorm from the fans when it became clear he was off, that she phoned RD to ask if he might not want to reconsider.
Now, if he had been sold because he had been "holding RD to ransom", "tried to play hardball and lost", and all the other romantic macho urban legend fantasy, do you really think Katrien would even bother to make such a call?7 -
PragueAddick said:
There is another urban legend going around, which I give no more or less creedence to than NLA's version of events.
It is that Katrien was so taken aback by the firestorm from the fans when it became clear he was off, that she phoned RD to ask if he might not want to reconsider.
Now, if he had been sold because he had been "holding RD to ransom", "tried to play hardball and lost", and all the other romantic macho urban legend fantasy, do you really think Katrien would even bother to make such a call?
There are obviously two sides to this story and both camps (Yann's and the club), I suggest, are being selective with the facts they choose to acknowledge.2











