Andy Murray

To be fair Murray has been misrepresented.

What he actually said was that the negativity of the 'NO' campaign made him reconsider his original position. As a Scot, even a non-voting one, he is entitled to an opinion regardless of whether I or anybody else agree with it.

I am a strong advocate of free speech in most circumstances but the scumbag who tweeted about Dunblane needs to take a serious look at him or her self.

Fiiiiiish said:

Such a strange over reaction to voting yes.

Why does it even matter? God forbid someone be proud and love their country.

I think the ones proud of their country are the ones that voted no. A breakaway Scotland would've been a disaster for the nation, not that I'd give a shit......................

Liam Gallagher is an absolute cory.

Would love to slap that silly haired manc c**t

He may be a gobby manc knob but he has a match point in this case...

An expat Scot listens to the debate and decides he supports the Yes campaign - that's it!

Does that make him anti English/British (his girlfriend is English)?

Does voting Yes make the 1.6 million anti English/British?

Does Rory McIlroy's decision to represent the Republic Of Ireland make him anti British?

Murray can be pro Britain and pro Scotland and vote for its independance. Nobody died.

Get over it.

PL54 said:

He's a twat

That's disappointing.He really rates you.

Andy Murray's opinions on this, that, or anything else are completely irrelevant to me. Until someone posts about it on Charlton Life and then I feel compelled to comment.

Redskin said:

DRAddick said:

Redskin said:

bingaddick said:

Does voting Yes make the 1.6 million anti English/British?

Some of them, yes.

So that makes the true answer no then.

No, it doesn't.

Well yes it does because you stated that it's only some of them so for the majority they're voting for other reasons other than anti English/British. So the answer to the question is no. And if you think a significant amount voted Yes based on their dislike of us then your mistaken.

Murray's entitled to his opinions, it would be strange if he said nothing about such an important topic. His brother is much more passionately a Yes voter.

And Murray, by living in England at least pays some taxes here, unlike many of his rivals (and most racing drivers) who live in Monaco

Redskin said:

DRAddick said:

Redskin said:

DRAddick said:

Redskin said:

bingaddick said:

Does voting Yes make the 1.6 million anti English/British?

Some of them, yes.

So that makes the true answer no then.

No, it doesn't.

Well yes it does because you stated that it's only some of them so for the majority they're voting for other reasons other than anti English/British. So the answer to the question is no. And if you think a significant amount voted Yes based on their dislike of us then your mistaken.

I don't see what you fail to grasp about my post.
The motivation of some people's decision to vote 'yes' was borne out of anti-English/British
sentiment.
The fact that they may be in a minority is immaterial and precludes the true answer, whatever that means, being no.

As for thinking 'a significant amount voted Yes based on their dislike of us', I didn't say that.I don't know how many did: neither do you.

So after they voted, they sent you a text explaining their decision?

You are assuming that it's anti English/British.

Redskin said:

cafcdave123 said:

Redskin said:

DRAddick said:

Redskin said:

DRAddick said:

Redskin said:

bingaddick said:

Does voting Yes make the 1.6 million anti English/British?

Some of them, yes.

So that makes the true answer no then.

No, it doesn't.

Well yes it does because you stated that it's only some of them so for the majority they're voting for other reasons other than anti English/British. So the answer to the question is no. And if you think a significant amount voted Yes based on their dislike of us then your mistaken.

I don't see what you fail to grasp about my post.
The motivation of some people's decision to vote 'yes' was borne out of anti-English/British
sentiment.
The fact that they may be in a minority is immaterial and precludes the true answer, whatever that means, being no.

As for thinking 'a significant amount voted Yes based on their dislike of us', I didn't say that.I don't know how many did: neither do you.

So after they voted, they sent you a text explaining their decision?

You are assuming that it's anti English/British.

Jesus, do you people actually read the post.

I said the motivation of some people's
decision to vote 'Yes' was borne out of an anti-English/British sentiment.

If you can't grasp that simplicity of that, you must be a bit dim, which I don't imagine you are.

But the question was "Does voting Yes make the 1.6 million anti English/British?". If the answer is "yes some of them" then the overall (true) answer to that question must be "No", because by saying "some" you're also stating that voting Yes doesn't make all the 1.6 million anti English/British. If you'd dropped the word "yes" and just said "Some of them" then that would have been an acceptable response to the question.
If the question was "Did some people vote yes because of Anti English/British" then your answer would have indeed been correct.

Any confusion towards your post is because your answer is for a question that wasn't asked. I can't grasp how you can't see the simplicity of that ;-)

Redskin said:

cafcdave123 said:

Redskin said:

DRAddick said:

Redskin said:

DRAddick said:

Redskin said:

bingaddick said:

Does voting Yes make the 1.6 million anti English/British?

Some of them, yes.

So that makes the true answer no then.

No, it doesn't.

Well yes it does because you stated that it's only some of them so for the majority they're voting for other reasons other than anti English/British. So the answer to the question is no. And if you think a significant amount voted Yes based on their dislike of us then your mistaken.

I don't see what you fail to grasp about my post.
The motivation of some people's decision to vote 'yes' was borne out of anti-English/British
sentiment.
The fact that they may be in a minority is immaterial and precludes the true answer, whatever that means, being no.

As for thinking 'a significant amount voted Yes based on their dislike of us', I didn't say that.I don't know how many did: neither do you.

So after they voted, they sent you a text explaining their decision?

You are assuming that it's anti English/British.

Jesus, do you people actually read the post.

I said the motivation of some people's
decision to vote 'Yes' was borne out of an anti-English/British sentiment.

If you can't grasp that simplicity of that, you must be a bit dim, which I don't imagine you are.

So SOME of the voters text you what their vote was based on?