Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Naby Sarr

Fumbluff
Fumbluff Posts: 10,128
in General Charlton
Oh dear (x3)
«13

Comments

  • NomadicAddick
    NomadicAddick Posts: 2,114
    Thought he was very solid first half, only a young lad and lost a bit of confidence when he made his first slip. Then went down hill although he did make a good tackle at the death when they were appealing for a penalty. Be nice for him to get a good run and build his confidence so diarra can stay in midfield.
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,437
    What..?

    Made the one small mistake for the goal today but otherwise immense, completely different player from when he first played... Was really calm and composed when on the ball and got rid of it sensibly

    I just hope his Hamstrings are okay after a brilliant hooked clearance early in the second half, the Wednesday player was in had he messed that up or had he tried anything else
  • Valley11
    Valley11 Posts: 12,001
    Christ let's have a night off eh? There's so much negativity at the moment, quite rightly. But after a 3-1 win perhaps just let it be....for 24 hours at least eh ?
  • Unknown
    Unknown
    This content has been removed.
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,437
    NomadicAddick said:

    Thought he was very solid first half, only a young lad and lost a bit of confidence when he made his first slip. Then went down hill although he did make a good tackle at the death when they were appealing for a penalty. Be nice for him to get a good run and build his confidence so diarra can stay in midfield.

    Leave Diarra in the middle until Kashi is fully fit, keep Lennon on loan @ Gillingham where there must be a recall clause hence why he wasnt allowed to play today
  • se9addick
    se9addick Posts: 32,047
    One of his best games for us, made a mistake for their goal but overall looked much better.
  • 1StevieG
    1StevieG Posts: 10,964
    Surely a wind up?
  • J BLOCK
    J BLOCK Posts: 8,315
    Thought he was solid today, very impressed
  • Tayls
    Tayls Posts: 58
    I thought he was really good today. Was called on a number of times to cut out the final ball a number of times and did it really well. Diarra, Gudmundsson and him were stand out players today.
  • Fumbluff
    Fumbluff Posts: 10,128
    edited November 2015
    For me he had an okay first half, then fell on his arse in front of me, airshotted in front of me that lead to the goal, then got properly mugged in front of me.
    I thought I was maybe being a tadge harsh after the okay first half but the fact Colin disagrees can only prove I'm correct. Phew
  • Sponsored links:



  • Fumbluff
    Fumbluff Posts: 10,128
    Agree moving Diarra to his preferred position makes a world of difference just think there will be an increase in squeaky bum times
  • DamoNorthStand
    DamoNorthStand Posts: 10,940
    Thought he was quality today. The slip for the goal was very unlucky. I mentioned in the post match thread that the Wendy player miscontrolled and took a flukey double touch which caused Naby to slip.

    Along with Ba, a different player to last week.
  • 1StevieG
    1StevieG Posts: 10,964
    edited November 2015
    nah mate, I think you'll find you are wrong.
  • Huskaris
    Huskaris Posts: 9,853
    I don't get overly dramatic when we lose and I don't get overly dramatic when we win so I don't see why I shouldn't say this just because we won, he is shite. He hasn't had a single good game for us, and he just seems like a complete bufoon. Having said all this, why the hell did we get rid of Morisson on a free... Diarra is brilliant in midfield and shouldn't have to play in defence, but I would rather him play there than risk Sarr there. Think if it was 0-0 when he was swinging at air...

    Having said that, thank God, had £2 at 60/1 on 3-1...
  • Taxi_Lad
    Taxi_Lad Posts: 3,772
    Very accomplished first half. Positionally very good and made numerous interceptions. Shame that slip led to a dip in confidence. Noticed Bauer was first to pick him up
  • ross1
    ross1 Posts: 51,003
    Must not forget how old he is and the amount of English football experience he has had
  • ShootersHillGuru
    ShootersHillGuru Posts: 50,627
    ross1 said:

    Must not forget how old he is and the amount of English football experience he has had

    100% this.

  • iamdan
    iamdan Posts: 2,421
    Huskaris said:

    I don't get overly dramatic when we lose and I don't get overly dramatic when we win so I don't see why I shouldn't say this just because we won, he is shite. He hasn't had a single good game for us, and he just seems like a complete bufoon. Having said all this, why the hell did we get rid of Morisson on a free... Diarra is brilliant in midfield and shouldn't have to play in defence, but I would rather him play there than risk Sarr there. Think if it was 0-0 when he was swinging at air...

    Having said that, thank God, had £2 at 60/1 on 3-1...


    Can't see how you think he is 'shite?'
    Youngster in his (guessing) 10th English appearance and you've written him off already?
    Personally thought he played pretty well, few interceptions, block and calm on the ball. The slip was costly yes.
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 85,234
    He didn't slip for the goal.

    He slipped before and they got passed him but didn't score.

    He then had an air shot from which they scored.

    Much better today, in part because Diarra was always there as almost a third CH to cover him and Bauer.

    Yes, he's young, inexperienced and new to the country so it will take time which is all why you make sure you have experienced cover.

    We have no CHs as cover/subs if we play Diarra in midfield.
  • CyrilDavies
    CyrilDavies Posts: 855
    For what is worth I thought he played very well. Had he been one of our own and 22yrs old, people would be raving over him.
  • Sponsored links:



  • East Kent Addick
    East Kent Addick Posts: 1,350
    Henry Irving said:

    He didn't slip for the goal.

    He slipped before and they got passed him but didn't score.

    He then had an air shot from which they scored.

    Much better today, in part because Diarra was always there as almost a third CH to cover him and Bauer.

    Yes, he's young, inexperienced and new to the country so it will take time which is all why you make sure you have experienced cover.

    We have no CHs as cover/subs if we play Diarra in midfield.

    This - he is certainly improving and shouldn't be written off - I thought he had a decent game against Brentford as well despite the 3-0 defeat - remember Sweaty Balmer's own goals in his first games for Charlton and he didn't turn out too shabby.

    The real shock is that we went into this season with 2 young CBs who'd never played in England (plus a converted midfielder) and its's been one of our strongest areas in the team so far!
  • LargeAddick
    LargeAddick Posts: 32,587
    Another WUM. Saar was excellent yesterday except for an unfortunate slip. I said the other week we have a decent player on our hands with Naby and yesterday showed that. Still young, going to make mistakes, but has all the attributes and will go far.
  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,231
    It was a shame about the slip and the Air shot because Sarr has had 2 good games at home. I wanted him to play along side Bauer with Diarra giving protection in midfield for some time, Sarr is raw but i can see him making real improvement if the whole team can show the same energy as yesterday, plus we had a better shape when Sheff Wed had the ball.
  • MartinCAFC
    MartinCAFC Posts: 3,223
    CyrilDavies said:

    For what is worth I thought he played very well. Had he been one of our own and 22yrs old, people would be raving over him.

    This. Imagine if Harry Lennon had mirrored Sarr's season so far, everyone would be calling him the new Rufus.

    I thought Sarr was very good yesterday and will no doubt improve with more experience.
  • ShootersHillGuru
    ShootersHillGuru Posts: 50,627
    Let's be honest the last couple of months have been a disaster and must have been difficult for all the senior pro's never mind those coming into British football for the first time and in Sarr's case being very young as well. Add to that the baptism's of fire for the home grown youngsters and it's a right dogs dinner.

    The fault lays fairly and squarely at the door of Roland. As Henry points out inadequate cover at CB, inadequate strike force and lack of creativity in central midfield with no natural width in the team to boot. Hugely unbalanced squad relying on those youngsters to step up.

    IMHO. All the youngsters have stepped up including Sarr but that doesn't hide the fact the squad is way too thin. Guy Luzon the fall guy for Roland's lack of football nous.

    The ball is now in your court Roland.
  • Gumbo
    Gumbo Posts: 957
    I'd say 1 good game from the 4/5 I've seen he's nowhere near as good a Harry Lennon
  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 13,175
    CyrilDavies said:

    For what is worth I thought he played very well. Had he been one of our own and 22yrs old, people would be raving over him.

    Not knocking Sarr as I think he's got potential, but we apparently spent about £2m on him so it's very different to having an academy product playing at that level. Sarr necessarily has higher expectations based on his price tag and his pedigree
  • iaitch
    iaitch Posts: 10,230
    Gumbo said:

    I'd say 1 good game from the 4/5 I've seen he's nowhere near as good a Harry Lennon

    Remind me how many games Lennon has played in the Championship?
  • To_Be_Franck
    To_Be_Franck Posts: 1,095
    Garrymanilow said:

    CyrilDavies said:

    For what is worth I thought he played very well. Had he been one of our own and 22yrs old, people would be raving over him.

    Not knocking Sarr as I think he's got potential, but we apparently spent about £2m on him so it's very different to having an academy product playing at that level. Sarr necessarily has higher expectations based on his price tag and his pedigree
    But if we sold one of our own for (just) £2m, there would be uproar for letting him go on the cheap
  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,231
    Gumbo said:

    I'd say 1 good game from the 4/5 I've seen he's nowhere near as good a Harry Lennon

    Until Harry Lennon is given games at Centre half in CAFC 1st team
    You can't be sure ?
    Harry Lennon only start in the League for at Left back, which is not his position.
    Harry is 21 next month so is getting game time at Gillingham
    Nabby Sarr is now 22 so the time is now for him to show.
    Patrick Bauer is just 23 and is a more solid type.

    To let Morrison go on a free at 26 when TBH was always only going to stay for 1 season and Bikey always seem to lose form at every club he's ever been at was yet another bizarre action by CAFC in the last 2 years.

Categories

“Marketplace”