Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Scathing commentary on RD and Lerner

Good stuff from Barney Ronay. Has the bit about customers wrongly attributed but the rest is scarily accurate.

http://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2016/apr/22/aston-villa-charlton-athletic-owners-relegated

Comments

  • SDAddick
    SDAddick Posts: 14,492
    He's a fantastic writer. Will not mention the club he supports.
  • SDAddick said:

    He's a fantastic writer. Will not mention the club he supports.

    For some reason I always thought he was 'Boro.
  • Very well written and sad reading.
  • SDAddick
    SDAddick Posts: 14,492

    SDAddick said:

    He's a fantastic writer. Will not mention the club he supports.

    For some reason I always thought he was 'Boro.
    The poshest Millwall supporter you'll ever hear. He acknowledged it on Football Weekly some years back.
  • timken
    timken Posts: 1,006
    Not sure he is right when he says near the end "you get the owners you deserve" what have we done to deserve out useless twat of an owner?
  • Anna_Kissed
    Anna_Kissed Posts: 3,302
    "...dangerous entrepreneurial uber-capitalist with some funny ideas".
    Quite. And it's not us who are laughing.
    As I wrote on another thread on Tuesday night: Money-man brings misery to thousands.
  • SDAddick
    SDAddick Posts: 14,492
    edited April 2016
    timken said:

    Not sure he is right when he says near the end "you get the owners you deserve" what have we done to deserve out useless twat of an owner?

    He wasn't talking about us, he was talking about the game as a whole, and I think his point is a brilliant one and one I bang on about a lot:

    "This is the real nub. You get the owners you deserve, As a society we have made the decision to submit to the market, to say pretty much anyone can own pretty much anything, the only regulating forces demand, supply and finance. This argument says football clubs are not in any real sense community assets (communities themselves are old hat) but commodities like anything else. To complain that we’re not happy unregulated markets attract both desirable investors and incompetent chancers is a bit like leaving the doors and windows open and then bursting into tears when someone walks off wth your television. This is the problem with neo-liberal economics."

    "But there is nothing in English law or in football regulation to stop any of these people buying up that embedded infrastructure of clubs and grounds and generational ties and acting as they will. To offer protection, in the style of the German league, would be to perform some unacceptable act, the ultimate crime of corrupting or perverting the market. And so here we are, two grand old clubs thrashing about hoping for the right kind of buyout next time, the right kind of gambler, the right kind of monied weirdo."


  • TelMc32
    TelMc32 Posts: 9,088
    edited April 2016
    Read this earlier and picked up on the couple of inaccurate attributions, but otherwise an excellent and sad piece.

    Can't believe he's a spanner though!! The Guardian and writing big words!!! :wink:
  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 26,182
    Great read
  • Rob
    Rob Posts: 11,927
    I like this piece...

    'the wretched Roland Duchâtelet'

  • Sponsored links:



  • Addick Addict
    Addick Addict Posts: 40,013

    SDAddick said:

    He's a fantastic writer. Will not mention the club he supports.

    For some reason I always thought he was 'Boro.
    TelMc32 said:

    Read this earlier and picked up on the couple of inaccurate attributions, but otherwise and excellent and sad piece.

    Can't believe he's a spanner though!! The Guardian and writing big words!!! :wink:

    His son used to play cricket for Lewisham District and trialed for Kent U11s last year. He wrote a passionate article about the demise of Lewisham as a centre for cricket but, again, he allowed his beliefs to get a little in the way of the facts.
  • Chizz
    Chizz Posts: 28,397

    SDAddick said:

    He's a fantastic writer. Will not mention the club he supports.

    For some reason I always thought he was 'Boro.
    TelMc32 said:

    Read this earlier and picked up on the couple of inaccurate attributions, but otherwise and excellent and sad piece.

    Can't believe he's a spanner though!! The Guardian and writing big words!!! :wink:

    His son used to play cricket for Lewisham District and trialed for Kent U11s last year. He wrote a passionate article about the demise of Lewisham as a centre for cricket but, again, he allowed his beliefs to get a little in the way of the facts.
    That never happens here though.
  • Draizetrain
    Draizetrain Posts: 801
    Rob said:

    I like this piece...

    'the wretched Roland Duchâtelet'

    Its fantastic isn't it. We can all say it on here until we're blue in the face but to see it `in print' by a serious Journo in a serious broadsheet is manna from heaven....and hes absolutely right. Roland is wretched. `Wretched Roland'....kinda catchy eh.
  • Off_it
    Off_it Posts: 28,961
    Rob said:

    I like this piece...

    'the wretched Roland Duchâtelet'

    Wretched (meaning brilliant)
  • timken said:

    Not sure he is right when he says near the end "you get the owners you deserve" what have we done to deserve out useless twat of an owner?

    I think he meant in football generally rather than us.
  • Chippycafc
    Chippycafc Posts: 14,190
    Superb article