Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

The 2017 Summer Transfer Rumours Thread (Deadline Day from page 264)

1226227229231232296

Comments

  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 85,215
    cafc4life said:

    Mikhail Kennedy out for the season. Ruptured ACL

    terrible news
  • Rickie Lambert unattached. Worth a punt on a one year deal or is he past it at 35?

    Knows league one inside out and no doubt would understand very well how to play at the top of a 4-2-3-1.

    I noticed recently that he was still without a club. Even at 35 I think he would be decent at this level.
  • Swisdom
    Swisdom Posts: 14,976

    Can we please stop going after Mk rejects. If Karl likes them that much he should have bloody stayed there. If they did not get Mk franchise up with Karl what makes him think they are going to do it with us.

    What can we expect when we do not have a scouting network? Driesen aside.
    I'm pretty sure we do. Dresden didn't scout Mavididi, Fosu or Dasilva

    The whole Tarpey thing has benn dreamed up on twitter based on a comment on here.

    Lambert is a good shout as someone who knows the system we play and his scouseness might work for Robbo too.
    We are far too light up top though - at least 1 body is needed immediately - Grigg will do for me

  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,374
    edited August 2017
    Are Wigan not playing Grigg?

    Either way there's no chance RD will pay the sort of fee they'd want for him.
  • Weegie Addick
    Weegie Addick Posts: 16,520

    If we are actually going in for the lad from Maidenhead as a key signing then something's wrong.

    Nah, nothing wrong at all at Charlton these last three and a half years!
  • JamesSeed
    JamesSeed Posts: 17,380

    If we are actually going in for the lad from Maidenhead as a key signing then something's wrong. But I don't think we are

    But football has a history of successful 'unlikely' signings. JS made quite a few, and players like Ian Wright, Charlie Austin and Vardy would be other good examples. I wouldn't rule someone out because they play for a lower division club.

    Having said that, I haven't seen the lad play...
  • cafc4life
    cafc4life Posts: 4,632
    Can't wait for Robinson to say we were in for Tarpey but unfortunately got beaten to the deal by Morecambe who offered him an extra £7 a week
  • wmcf123
    wmcf123 Posts: 5,824

    I know there has been criticism of the owners for a long time now and, probably, rightly so but with every change in manager there is a kind of 'start again' in each window.

    In January Robinson said that we just missed out at the end of the window and that he was going to start on the summer signings straight away. What that does mean is that there is no justification for us not having what those making the decisions want on 1st September. So I think we have to assume that the squad will be, exactly, what RD and/or KM want it to be in a fortnight.

    Ignoring injuries and suspensions (and I might have a small amount of sympathy with Marshall) there will be no hiding place if this season doesn't bring promotion - or, at least, get very close.

    They have had six months to build this squad and with no change of manager and a fixed style of playing (4-2-3-1) if we fall short it will be because that is what they want to have happened. It won't be a mistake that they can learn from it will be an indication of what they want for our club and there can be no 'second chances' for them.

    I know people have been saying this for months and months but there is, literally, nothing they can hide behind this time.

    4231 is a hideously rigid w

    Rickie Lambert unattached. Worth a punt on a one year deal or is he past it at 35?

    Knows league one inside out and no doubt would understand very well how to play at the top of a 4-2-3-1.

    I noticed recently that he was still without a club. Even at 35 I think he would be decent at this level.
    I think this system needs mobility. If we signed somebody like him, I'd advocate a switch to 442 ( I'd actually support this anyway). I know it's not going to happen as it would render Reeves redundant but a goal scorer alongside magennis in a 442 with a midfield of Fosu/Marshall/Clarke, Caskey, Kashi and Holmes could be very lively
  • Goonerhater
    Goonerhater Posts: 12,677
    edited August 2017
    if and thats IF its true we only have 300k in the kitty the manager knows nearly every player in the leagues and conferance that can do a job for us is out of our price range,that includes loan signings from Prem clubs which also demand a fee.
    Sad thing is even 10% of the Lookman money could have really done damage.

    Just a thought ,why not get rid of the PR machine and give the money allocated to the manager.
  • Gravesend_Addick
    Gravesend_Addick Posts: 7,299
    edited August 2017

    Valley11 said:

    The new Steve Portway?

    Certainly one to keep an eye on.

    Being from Gravesend, Steve Portway is still the best non league striker I've ever seen. Shame his big move never materialised. Even after his injury, he was better with 1 eye than any other striker I've seen at that level with 2
  • Sponsored links:



  • Essex_Al
    Essex_Al Posts: 3,582

    Can we please stop going after Mk rejects. If Karl likes them that much he should have bloody stayed there. If they did not get Mk franchise up with Karl what makes him think they are going to do it with us.

    What can we expect when we do not have a scouting network? Driesen aside.
    You do talk some shit at times! (actually, most of the time!)

    Steve Gallen is Head of Recruitment, with loads of experience and well respected within the game!
  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 19,218

    The game was at Fylde. A long way for KR to go, so if he was there he must be serious.

    If he was at that game (Which I have serious doubts about) why would it be Tarpey he was looking at. It might have been Danny Rowe of Fylde who scored 50 plus goals for them last season.

    I will give it an hour ;-)
  • iaitch
    iaitch Posts: 10,221
    shirty5 said:

    The game was at Fylde. A long way for KR to go, so if he was there he must be serious.

    If he was at that game (Which I have serious doubts about) why would it be Tarpey he was looking at. It might have been Danny Rowe of Fylde who scored 50 plus goals for them last season.

    I will give it an hour ;-)
    Which goals are better? National League South or NAtional League North?
  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,079
    I heard we were in for Danny Rowe of Fylde..................





    ;-)
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 51,989

    The game was at Fylde. A long way for KR to go, so if he was there he must be serious.


    Of course he wasn't there.
    I doubt he was there for one second, but didn't want to get grief from anyone saying how did I know for sure.
  • palarsehater
    palarsehater Posts: 12,296
    so weve gone from will grigg to dave tarpey.
  • Fans are so fickle, we'll put 4 past Northampton at the weekend and then we'll be praising the the flexibility of the 4-2-3-1 formation and the goal scoring talents of Holmes, Reeves and Fosu!

    We've lost Ajose, Watt and Igor, none of them were up for it for different reasons. We have Novak and Mag fighting for one spot, unfortunately one isn't fully fit and one stupidly got himself a 3 match ban. We still have a couple of weeks to get another body in to provide further options which I'm sure we will, in the mean time just relax and enjoy the ride!
  • My best mate has a season ticket for maidenhead and said tubby is worth a punt. Having seen colin attached to the rumour it's definitely fake news.
  • Sponsored links:



  • DamoNorthStand
    DamoNorthStand Posts: 10,934

    My best mate has a season ticket for maidenhead and said tubby is worth a punt. Having seen colin attached to the rumour it's definitely fake news.

    Big Fat, Big Fat Dave
    Big Fat, Big Fat Dave
    Big Fat, Big Fat Dave

    Big Fat Davey Tarpey.
  • ross1
    ross1 Posts: 50,974
    edited August 2017
    Charlton will not sign free agent Cameron Stewart, News Shopper understands.

    Stewart, 26, was on trial with the Addicks earlier this summer, and impressed in most of his games.

    The winger left the club before the start of the season, with Charlton boss Karl Robinson refusing to rule out a future deal.

    But News Shopper has been told that Stewart was an alternative to Ben Reeves if the MK Dons playmaker did not join the club.
  • RaplhMilne
    RaplhMilne Posts: 4,601

    If we are actually going in for the lad from Maidenhead as a key signing then something's wrong. But I don't think we are

    Wouldn't be a key signing but would be one I'd like to see us make. More than worth a punt.
    If we've got money to risk, no problem, but this can't be our plan. Anyone here remember John Bartley. More goals than games played in his career, but only 8 in 40 for Millwall over two seasons. Went back to non-league, and back to almost a goal a game pace until he retired.
    Remember him well. Played central striker for Welling and Millwall played him wide. I believe that didn't suit him an the goals dried up. Why buy a plumber and ask him to lay bricks.
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,291
    edited August 2017

    If we are actually going in for the lad from Maidenhead as a key signing then something's wrong. But I don't think we are

    Wouldn't be a key signing but would be one I'd like to see us make. More than worth a punt.
    If we've got money to risk, no problem, but this can't be our plan. Anyone here remember John Bartley. More goals than games played in his career, but only 8 in 40 for Millwall over two seasons. Went back to non-league, and back to almost a goal a game pace until he retired.
    Remember him well. Played central striker for Welling and Millwall played him wide. I believe that didn't suit him an the goals dried up. Why buy a plumber and ask him to lay bricks.
    Jesus these stats can't be real can they? - They look mental!! i.e. 70-goals over two seasons for Maidstone and Welling at one stage!!

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Bartley_(footballer)
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 16,907
    ross1 said:

    Charlton will not sign free agent Cameron Stewart, News Shopper understands.

    Stewart, 26, was on trial with the Addicks earlier this summer, and impressed in most of his games.

    The winger left the club before the start of the season, with Charlton boss Karl Robinson refusing to rule out a future deal.

    But News Shopper has been told that Stewart was an alternative to Ben Reeves if the MK Dons playmaker did not join the club.

    Probably the right call and you got that impression at the time. But with Marshall out for a while I would be tempted to give him a deal until Jan to give us cover.

    We have bigger priorities though
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,031

    ross1 said:

    Charlton will not sign free agent Cameron Stewart, News Shopper understands.

    Stewart, 26, was on trial with the Addicks earlier this summer, and impressed in most of his games.

    The winger left the club before the start of the season, with Charlton boss Karl Robinson refusing to rule out a future deal.

    But News Shopper has been told that Stewart was an alternative to Ben Reeves if the MK Dons playmaker did not join the club.

    Probably the right call and you got that impression at the time. But with Marshall out for a while I would be tempted to give him a deal until Jan to give us cover.

    We have bigger priorities though
    He was on trial at Oldham afterwards. I understand they turned him down as well.
  • grumpyaddick
    grumpyaddick Posts: 6,596

    Fans are so fickle, we'll put 4 past Northampton at the weekend and then we'll be praising the the flexibility of the 4-2-3-1 formation and the goal scoring talents of Holmes, Reeves and Fosu!

    We've lost Ajose, Watt and Igor, none of them were up for it for different reasons. We have Novak and Mag fighting for one spot, unfortunately one isn't fully fit and one stupidly got himself a 3 match ban. We still have a couple of weeks to get another body in to provide further options which I'm sure we will, in the mean time just relax and enjoy the ride!

    I don't object to Tom posting on his way to work but "relax enjoy the ride" ? Really?

    This three year death ride into the abyss has been so traumatic and bumpy my arse hurts.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 16,907
    Richard J said:

    ross1 said:

    Charlton will not sign free agent Cameron Stewart, News Shopper understands.

    Stewart, 26, was on trial with the Addicks earlier this summer, and impressed in most of his games.

    The winger left the club before the start of the season, with Charlton boss Karl Robinson refusing to rule out a future deal.

    But News Shopper has been told that Stewart was an alternative to Ben Reeves if the MK Dons playmaker did not join the club.

    Probably the right call and you got that impression at the time. But with Marshall out for a while I would be tempted to give him a deal until Jan to give us cover.

    We have bigger priorities though
    He was on trial at Oldham afterwards. I understand they turned him down as well.
    Surely that has little to no bearing on us though. I don't know the strengths of their squad but wingers may not be an area the are short in.

    Karl implied he certainly considered him an option even if it was only if Reeves (+1/2 others) didn't work out. As 4th choice cover until Jan he would be ideal.
  • Fans are so fickle, we'll put 4 past Northampton at the weekend and then we'll be praising the the flexibility of the 4-2-3-1 formation and the goal scoring talents of Holmes, Reeves and Fosu!

    We've lost Ajose, Watt and Igor, none of them were up for it for different reasons. We have Novak and Mag fighting for one spot, unfortunately one isn't fully fit and one stupidly got himself a 3 match ban. We still have a couple of weeks to get another body in to provide further options which I'm sure we will, in the mean time just relax and enjoy the ride!

    I don't object to Tom posting on his way to work but "relax enjoy the ride" ? Really?

    This three year death ride into the abyss has been so traumatic and bumpy my arse hurts.
    https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjHtb-e8NvVAhUDPVAKHcRlA3gQtwIIKzAB&url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HqA9wLa4OZw&usg=AFQjCNG_fIPaeZLBL2KqdwM8QHIG3MjfkA
  • Airman Brown
    Airman Brown Posts: 15,734

    Richard J said:

    ross1 said:

    Charlton will not sign free agent Cameron Stewart, News Shopper understands.

    Stewart, 26, was on trial with the Addicks earlier this summer, and impressed in most of his games.

    The winger left the club before the start of the season, with Charlton boss Karl Robinson refusing to rule out a future deal.

    But News Shopper has been told that Stewart was an alternative to Ben Reeves if the MK Dons playmaker did not join the club.

    Probably the right call and you got that impression at the time. But with Marshall out for a while I would be tempted to give him a deal until Jan to give us cover.

    We have bigger priorities though
    He was on trial at Oldham afterwards. I understand they turned him down as well.
    Surely that has little to no bearing on us though. I don't know the strengths of their squad but wingers may not be an area the are short in.

    Karl implied he certainly considered him an option even if it was only if Reeves (+1/2 others) didn't work out. As 4th choice cover until Jan he would be ideal.
    Except that Oldham would know that before they took him on trial, presumably?