Players Marks: Charlton v Oldham
Comments
-
Amos: some great saves 8
Konsa: didn't get forward much (acting on orders?) and tended to misplace his passes when he did 6
Bauer: solid and unspectacular which is what you want in a defender 7
Lennon: a constant source of worry which isn't what you want in a defender 4
DaSilva: some good runs but he'll never make it at Chelsea without a serious improvement 6
Kashi: he has a job to do and does it consistently 7.5
Marshall: mostly useless 4
Aribo: not up to the standard of last Monday but one great pass to set up KAG 6.5
Holmes: he's not the player who earned the new contracted 6.5
Mavididi: spectacular goal apart, what have the Romans ever done for us?not a lot worked for him but he was always involved 7
Magennis: better than last week but then hard not to be 6
Ahearne-Grant so not a finisher which is so annoying as he gets in to such good positions
1 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Lennon: 6
DaSilva: 6
Kashi: 5.5
Marshall: 6
Aribo: 6
Holmes: 6
Mavididi: 6.5
Magennis: 5.5
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a0 -
I've got no problem with your scores but 'giraffe'? Puh-lease! Bubble, possibly bird, but not giraffe.Sillybilly said:
...
Konsa: 4 - some scary stuff mixed with some good. Makes you appreciate Solly. £7mill? You’re having a giraffe.
...0 -
Amos: 7.5
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Lennon: 4
DaSilva: 6
Kashi: 5.5
Marshall: 6
Aribo: 7
Holmes: 5
Mavididi: 7.5
Magennis: 5.
Ahearne-Grant n/a 1st rule of a good striker is to get there. Both shots on target. Great cross straight onto JJ's head. Really improving with every game.
Jackson n/a
1 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6.5
Bauer: 6.5
Lennon: 6
DaSilva: 6.5
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 5
Aribo: 6.5
Holmes: 6.5
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 5.5
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a0 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6.5
Lennon: 5
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 5
Aribo: 7.5
Holmes: 6.5
Mavididi: 6.5
Magennis: 50 -
Amos: 7.5
Konsa: 5.5
Bauer: 6.5
Lennon: 5.5
DaSilva: 6
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 5
Aribo: 6.5
Holmes: 6
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 5.50 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 5
Lennon: 4
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 3
Aribo: 7
Holmes: 7.5
Mavididi: 7
Magennis 40 -
Brought an old friend I'd not seen in 9 years to this and we were pleasantly nattering away the whole time. These marks are therefore a bit more vague than usual
Amos 8
Konsa 7
Bauer 7.5
Lennon 6
JDS 7
Kashi 6.5
Marshall 6
Aribo 7
Holmes 6.5
Marvadidi 8 MOM what a goddamned goal
Magennis 6
Wasn't as bad a performance as many are making out but we sure invited pressure in the second half, and played loads of aimless forward passes1 -
Will these ratings be discounted as the masicat didn’t see the game out?masicat said:Amos: 7 good
Konsa: 6 ok
Bauer: 6.5 good
Lennon: 4 can he see a player we cant see? Who does he keep passing to?
DaSilva: 6.5 works his socks off
Kashi: 5 meh
Marshall: 3 meh meh
Aribo: 5 jury is out for me
Holmes: 7 A footballer who needs better around him
Mavididi: 6 minus 1 for the dive
Magennis: 5 just isn’t good enough
Ahearne-Grant I didn’t see him, left on 75
1 -
Sponsored links:
-
Amos 7
Konsa 6
Bauer 7
Lennon 4 Terrible passing and hardly any tackles - what does Robinson see in him!
JDS 7
Kashi 5 - Everything goes backwards or sideways - what does he add ?
Marshall 6
Aribo 8 Started to look class MOM
Holmes 7
Marvadidi 7
Magennis 7 We still need to play 2 up front - Marvadidi was too far wide under Robinsons instructions.0 -
Someone at the same game as me. Some of the marks on here are so generous, thought I'd dreamt yesterday.Sillybilly said:Clearly at a different game from everyone else. Lamentable performance and my marks reflect that. Lol away, but this is the game I watched.
Amos: 7 - saved us in second half.
Konsa: 4 - some scary stuff mixed with some good. Makes you appreciate Solly. £7mill? You’re having a giraffe.
Bauer: 5. Generally solid but a few bizarre moments.
Lennon: 4. Passing was hilarious.
DaSilva: 6 - didn’t come off for him as it usually does but a class above.
Kashi: 3 - complete liability and I just don’t get the hero worship. Always backwards and at least three suicidal passes.
Marshall: 3. Contributed sod all.
Aribo: 5. Not as good as last week KAG taking the flack for missing a chance when Joe should have shot himself.
Holmes: 4. Never gave up but thought he was rubbish.
Mavididi: 6 a good job he was playing or I’d have been slitting my wrists. A bit hamstrung by the booking but a great goal.
Magennis: 4 - system hangs him out to dry but just not good enough and badly needs a rest.
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a
Robinson - 1. FFS man, Oldham were utter cack and we spent 45 minutes sitting back and defending. Your nose is out of joint at the moment. Fair enough. But catch a f*****g grip!!!!
Amos - 7
Konsa - 5
Bauer - 5
Lennon - 4
DaSilva - 5.5
Kashi - 2
Marshall - 3
Aribo - 5
Holmes - 4
Mavididi - 7 MOM for his goal.
Magennis -3
Why did we sit back in second half rather than go for a second to kill game off? Defending suicidal at times! sooner KR goes the better!1 -
Amos: 7 Did well when called on
Konsa: 6 Didn't get over the half way line as much as JDS, not a bad thing with KR "wierd" tic tacks, would be better in midfield imo
Bauer: 7 Solid first game back, good to see him
Lennon: 5 Cant pass but don't lack effort
DaSilva: 7.5 A tiny piece of quality, Oldham like others this season tried to expose his hieght and failed
Kashi: 2 Released to ball side ways whenever a player got within 3 yards of him, looked like a bloke trying not to get involved, offered so little in midfield, not the player that started the season, scared to get hurt? or playing for the end of his contract? desperately disappointing! Great passing stats though!
Marshall: 4 Needs to play in a 442, lacks confidence knows he's playing badly, a better player with Solley behind him?
Aribo: 8.5 MoM, Best midfield player at the club, ignored by Kashi all game (he kept hanging around the centre area), our one man midfield presence, the lads got talent, like to see Konsa along side him.
Holmes: 6 Can never fault effort and he always gives that, please pass the football more!
Mavididi: 7 The worse dive in years deserved booking, then done well, perhaps we have someone who can exploit the space that Holmes makes by being double/trebled marked, it's not happened since Foshu Henry got injured.
Magennis: 4 needs a rest badly, a victim of KR single system, he must be pissed off with being marked out of every match by two div 3 CB's
Ahearne-Grant 6 Lisbie clone, but keeps trying, give him more starts he needs confidence it just might happen!
Jackson n/a so unlucky not to score
Karl Robinson 1 What did he say at half time, "lads new formation 1 9 1" at times we didn't even have the 1 up top, did we really try to sit on a 1/0 for half the match? Oldham not scoring astonished me, the Blackpool match came to mind and imo Oldham are worse than Blackpool, sad display, poor management.1 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Lennon: 6
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 6.5
Marshall: 5.5
Aribo: 6.5
Holmes: 6.5
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 6
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a0 -
yes they will be discounted but he gets a like for honestyDazzler21 said:
Will these ratings be discounted as the masicat didn’t see the game out?masicat said:Amos: 7 good
Konsa: 6 ok
Bauer: 6.5 good
Lennon: 4 can he see a player we cant see? Who does he keep passing to?
DaSilva: 6.5 works his socks off
Kashi: 5 meh
Marshall: 3 meh meh
Aribo: 5 jury is out for me
Holmes: 7 A footballer who needs better around him
Mavididi: 6 minus 1 for the dive
Magennis: 5 just isn’t good enough
Ahearne-Grant I didn’t see him, left on 752 -
Amos - 6
Konsa - 5
Bauer - 5
Lennon - 4
DaSilva - 5.5
Kashi - 2
Marshall - 3
Aribo - 5
Holmes - 4
Mavididi - 6 MOM for his goal.
Magennis -33 -
Amos 7 Important saves kept the win intact
Konsa 6.5 Thought he did OK
Bauer 7 Welcome back
Lennon 5 Unconvincing
DaSilva 7.5 MOM Always looks good
Kashi 5 No real impact
Marshall 4 Continues to disappoint
Aribo 6.5 Always involved
Holmes 6 Not his best game
Mavididi 7 Extra point for Quality goal
Magennis 6.5 No support up front.0 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Lennon: 5
DaSilva: 6.5
Kashi: 5.5
Marshall: 6
Aribo: 6.5
Holmes: 6
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 5.50 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Lennon: 6
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 4
Aribo: 6
Holmes: 6
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 60 -
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Lennon: 6
Da Silva: 7
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 5
Aribo: 6
Holmes: 6
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 50 -
Sponsored links:
-
Rare trip to Valley. Saw little to have me rushing back.
Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6.5
Lennon: 5
DaSilva: 6.5
Kashi: 6.5
Marshall: 6
Aribo: 7
Holmes: 6
Mavididi: 7 motm
Magennis: 6
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a0 -
Amos - 7.5 MOM
Konsa - 5.5
Bauer - 5.5
Lennon - 5
DaSilva - 6
Kashi - 4
Marshall - 4
Aribo - 5.5
Holmes - 4.5
Mavididi - 6
Magennis - 41 -
Amos: 6
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 7.5
Lennon: 6.5
DaSilva: 6.5
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 5
Aribo: 7
Holmes: 6.5
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 6.50 -
Amos: 8
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 7
Lennon: 5
DaSilva: 6.
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 5
Aribo: 6
Holmes: 6
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 60 -
Amos: 7.5
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Lennon: 6
DaSilva: 6
Kashi: 5.5
Marshall: 5
Aribo: 5.5
Holmes: 5
Mavididi: 7
Magennis: 5.5
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a0 -
Amos - 7.5 MOM
Konsa - 5
Bauer - 5
Lennon - 4
DaSilva - 6
Kashi - 5
Marshall - 4
Aribo - 6
Holmes - 5
Mavididi - 7
Magennis - 5
These marks given on the basis of an unconvincing 1-0 win over a poor team.0 -
Amos: 6.5 - Did OK and not unduly troubled
Konsa: 4 - Soooo negative and offered nothing down the right, bar the last 15 minutes
Bauer: 7 (MoM) - Quite solid
Lennon: 4 - Awful game; off the pace, poor distribution. Sarr is better!
DaSilva: 6.5 - Got forward well, but no end product much of the time
Kashi: 4.5 - Lots of short passes, but not a play maker
Marshall: 5 - Made ground but often hussled out of it
Aribo: 5 - Didn't get out of second gear until last fifteen minutes. Should realise he is not going to dribble though the oppo defence every week!
Holmes: 6 - Hit the bar after 70 seconds when earlier in season it would have flown in. Not a happy bunny.
Mavididi: 6.5 - Some good runs and a fine goal but often surrounded later in game and could have passed better
Magennis: 4 - No service, no smiles, no fun
The team was crying out for a sub after an hour but Robbo left it way too late and left the pressure on far too long.0 -
Amos: 6.5 Nothing much to do until we decided to camp in our own box second half
Konsa: 5 average
Bauer: 4 played poorly at times against piss poor opposition.
Lennon: 3 as above but slightly worse
DaSilva: 5 average
Kashi: 3 did nothing of note and was easily bypassed second half
Marshall: 3 i am sure there is a player in there somewhere just has not shown it
Aribo: 6 up and down well and covered a lot of ground
Holmes: 5 average
Mavididi: 6 great goal but poor booking. Needs time
Magennis: 4 below average
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Jackson n/a1 -
I'm really, really restraining myself, but even though we went a bit cowardly in the second half, they only really had 2 chances in the game, and we had 5 or 6, which is usually how the balance of power is judged - we did enough to win, and consequently some of these marks, for all that it was a poor second-half show, are frankly ludicrous. Like, these are the marks for a shambolic 3-0 defeat.2
-
You’re really, really not.Leuth said:I'm really, really restraining myself, but even though we went a bit cowardly in the second half, they only really had 2 chances in the game, and we had 5 or 6, which is usually how the balance of power is judged - we did enough to win, and consequently some of these marks, for all that it was a poor second-half show, are frankly ludicrous. Like, these are the marks for a shambolic 3-0 defeat.
2
