Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Players Marks: Charlton v WBA (closes Monday lunchtime )
lancashire lad
Posts: 15,632
At the Valley or from a live stream, your marks please
Phillips:
Lockyer:
Oshilaja:
Sarr:
Matthews:
Pratley;
Gallagher:
Dempsey:
Doughty:
Davison;
Green:
Forster-Caskey:
Williams:
Referee:
Hemed: n/a
Phillips:
Lockyer:
Oshilaja:
Sarr:
Matthews:
Pratley;
Gallagher:
Dempsey:
Doughty:
Davison;
Green:
Forster-Caskey:
Williams:
Referee:
Hemed: n/a
0
Comments
-
Live stream.Phillips: 9
Lockyer: 8 solid.
Oshilaja: 9.5 solid. we need him centre back
Sarr: 9 solid. Assured. Still a danger up top.
Matthews: 8 lots of effort.
Pratley; 9.5 MOM MVP left it all on the line
Gallagher: 9 class as always
Dempsey: 6 maybe a bit too early
Doughty: 8.5 solid
Davison; 9 bossed their defence
Green: 8.5 looked dangerous and assured
Referee: 0 wtf?
Forster-Caskey: 6 not sure
Williams: 8 always classy
Hemed: n/a
0 -
Live Stream
Phillips: 6.5
Lockyer: 7.5
Oshilaja: 8
Sarr: 7.5
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 8.5
Gallagher: 7.5
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7.5
Davison; 8.5
Green: 7.5
Referee: 3
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 7
0 -
Phillips: 9
Lockyer: 6 cost us the first.
Oshilaja: 7 solid at blocking tackling and clearing but needs to do the Semedo work, stay late and practice his passing.
Sarr: 7 solid. Really unfortunate own goal.
Matthews: 7 good defensively.
Pratley; 7.5 struggled last 15. But good game until then
Gallagher: 7.5 grew into the game and equaled their best players.
Dempsey: 6.5 tired early
Doughty: 6.5 some of his crossing tonight was sketchy
Davison; 7.5 bossed their defence until a stray elbow caught him on the jaw.
Green: 7.5 dangerous player. Like him a lot.
Referee: 4 Those cards ref, use them for the filthy challenges...
Forster-Caskey 6 looks rusty, but not unexpected.
Williams: 7 tricky player scares the shit out of me with his play acting.
Hemed 6.5 worked hard, almost a perfect ball to Green, still think there's a decent player in there.0 -
from Stream
Phillips 8
Lockyer 7
Oshilaja 7.5
Sarr 7
Matthews 7
Pratley 8
Gallagher 7
Dempsey 6.5
Doughty 6.5
Davidson 7.5
Green 7.5
Forster-Caskey 6.5
Williams 70 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7.5
Sarr: 7
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 8
Gallagher: 7
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7
Davison; 7.5
Green: 7.5
Referee: 3
Forster-Caskey: 5
Williams: 6
Hemed: n/a
0 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6 minus one for the goal
Oshilaja: 6 minus one for the goal
Sarr: 7 plus one for the tackle
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 7.5 warrior
Gallagher: 7.5
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 8 1st choice anywhere on the left
Davison; 8 great shift
Green: 7.5 excellent first half ; faded
Referee: 1 I never rank them- see it as pointless but he was shocking
Forster-Caskey: 6 off the pace but got better
Williams: 6.5
3 -
Phillips: 7.5 some decent saves. Kicking not great. Not at fault for either goal
Lockyer: 7 lost a point for the huge error. Gained one for the equaliser. Battled hard and love the aggression
Oshilaja: 7 needs to learn how to pass. Battled and blocked well
Sarr: 8 unfortunate own goal. Extra point for that tackle!!!
Matthews: 7.5 thought he done well down the wing.
Pratley; 9 such a wind up. Battled well and his experience got us over the line.
Gallagher: 8 done very well.
Dempsey: 6 not his fault - he just faded away
Doughty: 7 looked tired but great ball in for Lockyer
Davison; 9 great to see him score. Caused their defence problems all game.
Green: 7.5 tricky player. Played well
Referee: 2 bottled the big decisions
Forster-Caskey: 6 rusty but glad he’s back
Williams: 7 tricky player. Scared the shut out of them.
Hemed: n/a Done well
0 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6.5
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 7
Matthews: 6.5
Pratley; 8.5
Gallagher: 7.5
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7
Davison; 7.5
Green: 7
Referee: 1
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Williams: 7
Hemed: n/a
0 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7.5
Sarr: 8 - I’m normally quick to criticise Sarr but he made an absolutely incredible sliding tackle in the box second half to avert a certain goal
Matthews: 6
Pratley; 7
Gallagher: 7.5
Dempsey: 7.5
Doughty: 7
Davison; 8.5
Green: 8
Referee: 2
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Williams: 7.5
1 -
Phillips: 7 dunno if he could have saved the first? Did pretty well
Lockyer: 7 atrocious for their first goal but made up for it
Oshilaja: 6.5 some good tackling and such but his passing was errant and he completely messed up before their 2nd goal
Sarr: 8 if he's auditioning for a contract, he couldn't have done much better. headers, blocks, tackle of the season contender, an assist and his passing was excellent
Matthews: 7 decent, got a bit brushed aside now and then but largely solid
Pratley: 7.5 some really good work - intimidated their midfield a bit at times
Gallagher: 7 good delivery when he decided to take the set-pieces properly, decent hassle, not quite his usual self on the ball
Dempsey: 5.5 not quite ready yet, but we had nobody else
Doughty: 7.5 how is he so good already?
Davison: 8 gave them so much hard work and is starting to look like a mini-Yann in some ways
Green: 7.5 really exciting first appearance, brain as well as speed
Referee: 7 thought he handled an explosive-tempered game sensibly
Forster-Caskey: 6 he'll be back properly soon, we hope
Williams: 7.5 gives us so much
Hemed: n/a looked up for it, keep it going now!
4 -
Sponsored links:
-
Phillips 8
Lockyer 7
Oshilaja 8
Sarr 7
Matthews 7
Pratley 8
Gallagher 7
Dempsey 5
Doughty 6.5
Davidson 7.5
Green 7.5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 7
0 -
At the valley
Phillips: 7 couple of good saves poor kicking as per
Lockyer: 6.5 minus one for the goal but good header though sure be a OG
Oshilaja: 7 like him at the back
Sarr: 7.5 plus one for the huge tackle
Matthews: 7 solid
Pratley; 7.5 never stopped running, leader
Gallagher: 7.5 tireless
Dempsey: 5.5 not ready would prefer Morgan
Doughty: 7.5 all day long over Purrington now
Davison; 8 great shift
Green: 7.5 excellent first half ; faded
Referee: 4 Poor
Forster-Caskey: 6 off the pace but got better
Williams: 6.5 Skilful1 -
Phillips: 7 - Fine
Lockyer: 8 - Great goal, always looks confident
Oshilaja: 5 - Spray and pray with most of his balls
Sarr: 6 - Sarr, 10% brilliance (the tackle), 90% below average. Desperate to be a ball playing defender, he is not.
Matthews: 6 - Fine
Pratley; 9 - Does he ever stop? Great workrate
Gallagher: 7 - Sometimes too casual, had the teenage girl sitting next to me going mad
Dempsey: 6 - Fine
Doughty: 7 - Getting there
Davison; 8.5 - For someone that size, he is incredibly strong.
Green: 7 - more to come from him.
Referee: 2 - Absolutely lost control.
Forster-Caskey: 6 - can't say I noticed him
Williams: 6.5 - will get better with fitness, love the guy.
7 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7.5
Sarr: 7.5
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 8
Gallagher: 7
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7.5
Davison; 7
Green: 7.5
Referee: 3
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 7
0 -
Sarr and his huge tackle!!FULLERpromise said:At the valley
Phillips: 7 couple of good saves poor kicking as per
Lockyer: 6.5 minus one for the goal but good header though sure be a OG
Oshilaja: 7 like him at the back
Sarr: 7.5 plus one for the huge tackle
Matthews: 7 solid
Pratley; 7.5 never stopped running, leader
Gallagher: 7.5 tireless
Dempsey: 5.5 not ready would prefer Morgan
Doughty: 7.5 all day long over Purrington now
Davison; 8 great shift
Green: 7.5 excellent first half ; faded
Referee: 4 Poor
Forster-Caskey: 6 off the pace but got better
Williams: 6.5 Skilful6 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 8 -
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 9 MOM
Gallagher: 7 One of his quieter games
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7
Davison; 8 Worked hard, nice goal
Green: 6
Referee: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 7
2 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6.5
Oshilaja: 7.5
Sarr: 8
Matthews: 6.5
Pratley; 8
Gallagher: 7.5
Dempsey: 5
Doughty: 7.5
Davison; 8.5
Green: 7.5
Referee: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 6.5
0 -
Phillips: 6.5
Lockyer: 6.5
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 6.5
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 7
Gallagher: 6.5
Dempsey: 6.5
Doughty: 6.5
Davison; 7
Green: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Williams: 6.5
Referee:5
0 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 7
Matthews: 6
Pratley; 8.5
Gallagher: 6
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7
Davison; 8.5
Green: 7.5
Referee: 3
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 7.5
0 -
Phillips: 7 didn't have many saves to make in the end
Lockyer: 6.5 yes I know he scored but he also gave the ball away for the first so he gets an extra point for the goal which shouldn't gloss over his relatively poor showing defensively
Oshilaja: 6.5 looked strong and composed first half
Sarr: 8 what a tackle that was, and an assist for the first
Matthews: 7 better than Solly in every aspect now IMO.
Pratley; 8 wind up merchant and warrior
Gallagher: 7 drifts in and out of games a lot now
Dempsey: 6 anonymous
Doughty: 8 great little player
Davison; 8.5 took his goal really well and battled hard, proper nuisance
Green: 7 didn't really threaten with his running but made a few runs that pulled players about
Referee: 4 bottled a couple of red card decisions but didn't give too many niggly fouls
Forster-Caskey: 7 did well after first 5 mins
Williams: 7.5 wins so many fouls.
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 8
Matthews: 8
Pratley; 8.5
Gallagher: 7.5
Dempsey: 7
Doughty: 8
Davison; 9
Green: 8
Forster-Caskey: 7
Williams: 7
Referee: 3
0 -
Phillips: 8
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 8
Matthews: 8
Pratley; 8.5
Gallagher: 8
Dempsey: 7
Doughty: 8
Davison; 8
Green: 8
Forster-Caskey: 7
Williams: 7
Referee: 3
Cracking game and atmosphere
0 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7 (would have been 6 but for goal)
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 9 (extra 2 for THAT tackle)
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 8
Gallagher: 7
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7
Davison; 8
Green: 7
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 6 (not up to speed yet)
Referee: 6
1 -
Phillips: 7 poor pass backs doesn't help his kicking.
Lockyer: 7 minus 1 for mistake + 1 for goal.
Oshilaja:7 shocking pass, did fine.
Sarr: 8, I know he makes mistakes but his goals, assists and the occasional last ditch Big tackle ! means he plays unless ESI buy back Joe Gomez.
Matthews: 7.5 good solid performance
Pratley; 7.5 he shouldn't be playing 90 but fantastic pro..
Gallagher: 6.5 not at best buy hopefully here to end of season.
Dempsey: 6 tried hard but above his pay grade
Doughty: 7.5 give this kid an adults wage.
Davison; 8.5 showed so much nous. Should've gone off 10 minutes earlier because he was limping.
Green: 7.5 impressed, look forward seeing him play with. Taylor and Bonne.
Referee:7 agree with Louth ! Most of the yellows were correct. Even if Kettle would have shown 3 reds: 2 for Albion and Lockyer for not walking away once he was free from R-K. They were discussing a Welsh trip.
Forster-Caskey: 6. Not up to speed yet but good to see him.
Williams: 6.5 great to see him get on pitch and walk off pitch. The X factor player that we need to get 10 games out of. 45 minutes a game will be magic.
Hemed: n/a looked slimmer and quicker.
The jury will be out until he plays longer.2 -
Phillips: 6
Lockyer: 7.5
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 7.5
Matthews: 7
Pratley; 8.5
Gallagher: 7
Dempsey: 5.5
Doughty: 7.5
Davison; 7.5
Green: 8
Forster-Caskey: 7
Williams: 7
Referee: 5
0 -
Phillips: 8 - Great save when 0-0 (when he looked as though he slipped), didnt have much to do today
Lockyer: 7 - Was ready to give him a "5" until his equaliser, by far his worst game for us
Oshilaja: 7 - Played well, only subbed so we could have a balanced back four
Sarr: 8 - Struggled in the first half, grew into the game but THAT sliding challenge, just WOW!!
Matthews: 7 - Had a good solid game, didnt really put a foot wrong
Pratley: 8 - His experienced once again showed today, needs a rest
Gallagher: 6 - Not at his best today, West Brom did well to contain him
Dempsey: 6 - Did nothing special, didnt need to, was the right time to take him off
Doughty: 7.5 - Great assist for the second goal, doing a great job out of position effectively
Davison: 9 (MOTM) - Bullied two of the best Centre-Backs in the League!!
Green: 7 - Nothing quite came off for him today yet showed a good Football brain
Referee: 5 - Bookings were correct yet too eager to blow for a foul for the slightest contact
Forster-Caskey: 6 - Didnt really notice him to be honest
Williams: 7 - Won endless set pieces, something we've not had for a while
Hemed: N/A - Put in a shift, hopefully a sign that his fitness is returning and we'll benefit from it3 -
Phillips: 8 solid performance
Lockyer: 7 poor judgement for first goal but redeemed with equaliser
Oshilaja: 7 Played great first 60 min then tired??? Mistakes for baggie 2nd goal
Sarr: 7 sound
Matthews: 8 Great performance
Pratley; 7 seemed out of energy
Gallagher: 7 battling as usual but we'll contained
Dempsey: 6 made mistakes not needed but good account
Doughty: 7 good continues to improve
Davison; 7 wish he could win though hwaaders but good first goal
Green: 7 looked useful and wants them to play wuicker
Forster-Caskey: 7 gave us stability we needed in middle
Williams: 7 dangerous - more games would be great
Referee: 5 fair to start with then ignored Lockyer wrestling and should have done something about baggie fans keeping the ball.
0 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 7
Sarr: 7
Matthews: 7.5
Pratley; 8
Gallagher: 7
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7
Davison; 8
Green: 7
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 7
Referee: 5
0 -
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Oshilaja: 5
Sarr: 7
Matthews: 7.5
Pratley: 8
Gallagher: 7
Dempsey: 6
Doughty: 7
Davison; 7
Green: 7
Forster-Caskey: 6
Williams: 7
0 -
Phillips: 8 steady goal keeper we got
Lockyer: 8 may have cost us a goal but what a reaction from himOshilaja: 8 played well, heavy touch when passing, but bring steel to MF, surprised he went off but good call from Bow
Sarr: 9 Awesome Nabster! great tackle in the box, can’t blame him for anything today
Matthews: 8 great Find thus dude
Pratley; 9.5 MoM another great 90 mins, getting younger every match!
Gallagher: 7 looked a lot better when JW and JFC made an appearance
Dempsey: 6.5 ran out of puff But tired hard
Doughty: 8 makings of a very good wing back
Davison; 9 soooooo impressive today
Green: 6 yet to show what he’s worth
Forster-Caskey: 7 very encouraging
Williams: 7 as above
Referee: 2 he’s that Aussie Twat isn’t he!
Hemed: n/a He don’t look to good to me0
