Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Statbank: Nottingham Forest 0-1 Charlton Athletic
lancashire lad
Posts: 15,635
many thanks to the 79 Lifers who gave marks, a couple of points:
I have increased the shots in target by 1 as the Press Association make no mention of Alfies shot early in the game that lead to a corner.
Very unusual that our 3 central defenders did not commit a single foul in the game - perhaps they left it to Davis
I have increased the shots in target by 1 as the Press Association make no mention of Alfies shot early in the game that lead to a corner.
Very unusual that our 3 central defenders did not commit a single foul in the game - perhaps they left it to Davis
11
Comments
-
thanks to Danny for spotting my error in the goal scorer table, now corected0
-
He’s nabbed another MOM gong.0
-
The form table for our upcoming fixtures looks a lot more comforting now!1
-
Was the only contact Smith made with anything one of their players so he got booked? The match thread made it sound like he got nowhere near the ball.0
-
So both both Pratley and Lockyer are one away from ten bookings and a suspension?0
-
I guess that is tongue in cheek but I thought at the time it was for kicking the ball into the crowd during injury time to waste a bit more of it 😉AddicksAddict said:Was the only contact Smith made with anything one of their players so he got booked? The match thread made it sound like he got nowhere near the ball.0 -
I think it was. A harsh bookingRedChaser said:
I guess that is tongue in cheek but I thought at the time it was for kicking the ball into the crowd during injury time to waste a bit more of it 😉AddicksAddict said:Was the only contact Smith made with anything one of their players so he got booked? The match thread made it sound like he got nowhere near the ball.0 -
Yes, 37 games is the cutoff so both have to survive a further 5 matchesrobinofottershaw said:So both both Pratley and Lockyer are one away from ten bookings and a suspension?
What we could do without is both being out at the same time, as Pratley can also cover in defence, especially if we play a back 30 -
Is it a 1 or 3 game suspension?0
-
2 i think.lancashire lad said:Is it a 1 or 3 game suspension?2 -
Sponsored links:
-
Correct 2 match ban for 10 yellows, 3 match ban for 15 yellowsCharlton_Stu said:
2 i think.lancashire lad said:Is it a 1 or 3 game suspension?
1 -
Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season1
-
Is that the highest mark for a center half ever? I remember Wiggins getting higher (I think).
Not a criticism of anyone's marks but I wonder how much unconscious bias plays apart in the marking. I think I marked Taylor 1 higher than Hamed and most people I noticed was either 1 or 1.5 difference yet Taylor was over 1.5 better in the end result.
Just thinking out loud but I wonder what thier scores would be if the performances were swapped round?1 -
Davis, if he plays many games over the next 10 weeks.Leuth said:Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season4 -
Who's Davies ? Is he related to Davidson 😉soapboxsam said:
Davies will if he plays many games over the next 10 weeks.Leuth said:Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season3 -
If it's Lord Naby I'll attend the next game in a hairshirt1
-
My mistake.RedChaser said:
Who's Davies ? Is he related to Davidson 😉soapboxsam said:
Davies will if he plays many games over the next 10 weeks.Leuth said:Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season
David yellow card Davis, the Brummie enforcer was the man.2 -
Sorry for being a bit anal Sam but if we don't nip these things in the bud we'll have another Ventokele or Otzumer on our hands 😉.soapboxsam said:
My mistake.RedChaser said:
Who's Davies ? Is he related to Davidson 😉soapboxsam said:
Davies will if he plays many games over the next 10 weeks.Leuth said:Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season
David yellow card Davis, the Brummie enforcer was the man.1 -
Sarr ranges from 3.94 to 8.92 with plenty of random scores in between. As an ST holder, I get the lack of confidence but not to that extent.1
-
Sponsored links:
-
I get it - there are always Marmite players. I remember Leaburn. I appreciated his weaknesses but we were always a better team with him in it, but I recall fans sprouting vitriol about his uselessness. There was a clear split amongst fans. It happens at all levels, I had players that I managed that I used to get parents in my ear telling me not to start them whereas they were the first players on my team sheet.
It is all about opinions I suppose. In terms of my players, I actually found it incredible others couldn't see what I could see. But they couldn't. Just a quick glance at the stats tells you that Sarr is 5th in our scoring charts and joint top in terms of assists. Incredibly you will have detractors saying, but he is there to defend! No he is there to contribute to the overall maximum effectiveness of the team!5 -
MuttleyCAFC said:I get it - there are always Marmite players. I remember Leaburn. I appreciated his weaknesses but we were always a better team with him in it, but I recall fans sprouting vitriol about his uselessness. There was a clear split amongst fans. It happens at all levels, I had players that I managed that I used to get parents in my ear telling me not to start them whereas they were the first players on my team sheet.
It is all about opinions I suppose. In terms of my players, I actually found it incredible others couldn't see what I could see. But they couldn't. Just a quick glance at the stats tells you that Sarr is 5th in our scoring charts and joint top in terms of assists. Incredibly you will have detractors saying, but he is there to defend! No he is there to contribute to the overall maximum effectiveness of the team!Kishishev was another great example. Incredibly hard worker who broke up play and must have been horrible to play against, yet many only saw the mistakes (he made a couple of high profile ones that led to goals). qFor some the first name on the team sheet every week, for others a liability.I wonder whether the Sarr-bashers are the same people, generations notwithstanding, that used to dislike Kish and Carlo?
1 -
That's mean.Charlton_Stu said:
2 i think.lancashire lad said:Is it a 1 or 3 game suspension?2 -
But now we've got Davis.Leuth said:Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season0 -
Not forgetting the Belgiums who used to run us.RedChaser said:
Sorry for being a bit anal Sam but if we don't nip these things in the bud we'll have another Ventokele or Otzumer on our hands 😉.soapboxsam said:
My mistake.RedChaser said:
Who's Davies ? Is he related to Davidson 😉soapboxsam said:
Davies will if he plays many games over the next 10 weeks.Leuth said:Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season
David yellow card Davis, the Brummie enforcer was the man.4 -
Only ever been sent off twice in his careerAddicksAddict said:
But now we've got Davis.Leuth said:Find it incredible that we've not had a player sent off this season
Once for Birmingham and once for Inverness0 -
With these three Marmite players, Kish, Carlo and Naby, I have always really rated their importance to the team.1
-
Kish never broke up play. He just covered ground and closed spaces. He was a runner. And that's why I never got why he was so highly rated. It's almost one of those 'Oh I see things you don't, so I rate him' players but in reality he did very little other than run.
According to the PL site, in 175 PL appearances he made 25 tackles. Yep.
1 -
Never really got Kishishev, Carlo was an asset and I know for a fact that Colin Walsh thought he was superb to have as a target man. Naby, on balance, gets my vote as well so that blows the theory that if you didn't rate Kish you don't rate Carlo and or the Nabster as far as I'm concerned 😉.1
-
There is nothing to say you will rate all three as they are different players with different strengths and weaknesses but there may be individual aspects of their play that people identify as being important to the team and others may not see them.0
