Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Wigan (closes Monday evening)

13

Comments

  • Chunes
    Chunes Posts: 17,422
    edited August 2021
    MacG: 7
    Matthews: 5 
    Inniss: 5 He's still very unfit. 
    Famewo: 6 
    Gunter: 5 Has he ever had a good game?
    Dobson: 5 
    Watson: 7 
    Morgan: 4 
    DJ: 5 
    Stockley: 6
    Kirk: 6.5 
    Referee: 5.5
  • clive
    clive Posts: 19,579
    MacG: 8
    Matthews: 6
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 6
    Gunter: 6
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 5
    Morgan: 4
    DJ: 5
    Stockley: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 6
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,782
    carly burn said:
    The pigeon was the standout for me.
    Made a nuisance of himself in the box and nearly got on the end of Kirks fluffed shot
    It is a concern when a pigeon decides the safest place to be is the box we are attacking at home! Maybe we underestimate the football knowledge of pigeons. I think research is required as when you see how they target their shits, there has to be some intelligence there. Maybe even a case for reincarnation! 
  • jamescafc
    jamescafc Posts: 1,832
    MacG: 8
    Matthews: 6
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 6.5
    Gunter: 5
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 5
    Morgan: 6
    DJ: 5
    Stockley: 5.5
    Kirk: 6.5
    Referee: 6
  • bristoladdick
    bristoladdick Posts: 1,152
    MacG: 8
    Matthews: 6
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 5.5
    Gunter: 5.5
    Dobson: 6
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 6
    DJ: 6.5
    Stockley: 7
    Kirk: 6.5
    Referee: 6
  • Redmidland
    Redmidland Posts: 44,700
    MacG: 8.5 (MoM)
    Matthews: 5
    Inniss: 5.5
    Famewo: 5.5
    Gunter: 5
    Dobson: 4.5
    Watson: 4.5
    Morgan: 3.5
    DJ: 6
    Stockley: 7.5
    Kirk: 7
  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,240
    MacG: 8 kept the score down MOM.
    Matthews: 5.5 got over loaded.
    Inniss: 6 strong but looking really leggy.
    Famewo: 6 kept trying.
    Gunter: 4.5 out of position and looking older than 32.
    Dobson: 6.5 had decent game.
    Watson:6 did ok but his slowness affects Cafc in transition. 
    Morgan: 5.5 good, bad and ugly.
    DJ: 6.5 shame he can't hit the target.
    Stockley: 6.5 was getting upset when looking behind and no support for most of the match. 
    Kirk: 5.5 has ability but does look lightweight and must do better with the chance from 3 yards. Will improve.
    Referee: 6 
  • bromleyjohn
    bromleyjohn Posts: 5,988
    MacG: 8
    Matthews: 7
    Inniss: 6.5
    Famewo: 6.5
    Gunter: 5
    Dobson: 6
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 3
    DJ: 5
    Stockley: 7
    Kirk: 7
  • sinceiwasyoung
    sinceiwasyoung Posts: 1,040
    lancashire lad said:
    your marks please:

    MacG: 9 at least 3 top saves 
    Matthews: 5.5 not sure why he didn't try getting forward more
    Inniss: 5 not sure why he didn't cut out more crosses
    Famewo: 6 getting back to his best
    Gunter: 4.5 didn't look happy on the left
    Dobson: 4.5 his distribution is wank
    Watson: 5 tried hard , but is painfully slow
    Morgan: 4 lucky not to be subbed 
    DJ: 5 end product/shooting is woeful
    Stockley: 6 tried hard and created our best chance for Kirk
    Kirk: 5.5 should have scored 
    Referee: 5 did ok

    Blackett-Taylor: 2 non league at best
    Washington: 4 a real off day
    Davison: 3 didn't notice him


  • RichyB2
    RichyB2 Posts: 15
    edited August 2021
    MacG: 7
    Matthews: 4
    Inniss: 5
    Famewo: 5
    Gunter: 3
    Dobson: 4
    Watson: 4
    Morgan: 4
    DJ: 5
    Stockley: 5
    Kirk: 5
    Ref : 6

  • Sponsored links:



  • TelMc32
    TelMc32 Posts: 9,068

    MacG:  8 four or five excellent saves kept us in the game for so long.
    Matthews:  5 offers very little pushing forward in support.
    Inniss: 5 struggling badly and quite obviously not fit.
    Famewo: 5 gave it away too many times. 
    Gunter: 4 very poor. Appreciate its not his preferred side, but he’s an experienced pro & an international. 
    Dobson: 5 nothing out of the ordinary, but shouldn’t have been the one to be hooked.
    Watson: 6.5 best of our midfield. Shouldn’t be able to say that.
    Morgan: 3 woeful. Shouldn’t be in the first team & we certainly shouldn’t be building a team/midfield around him. Set pieces are dreadful.
    DJ: 5.5 some good touches, but nothing produced of any note.
    Stockley: 5 ran around a lot and got angry with the poor service. Nothing else really.
    Kirk: 6 showed signs of a decent player. 
    Referee: 5
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 70,030
    MacG: 7.5 the only positive today
    Matthews: 5.5
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 6
    Gunter: 5.5
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 5
    DJ: 5.5
    Stockley: 5.5 
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 5
  • rananegra
    rananegra Posts: 3,698
    MacG: 7.5 kept us in it
    Matthews: 6
    Inniss: 5.5
    Famewo: 5.5
    Gunter: 5.5
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 5
    DJ: 5.5
    Stockley: 6.5 not his fault he gets no service 
    Kirk: 5.5
    Referee:  5 some strange decisions but he didn't cost us the game

    Blackett-Taylor: n/a just as well no marks for him, no impact
    Washington: n/a 
    Davison: n/a
  • CatAddick
    CatAddick Posts: 2,391
    MacG: 8
    Matthews: 5
    Inniss: 5
    Famewo: 5
    Gunter: 4.5
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 5.5
    Morgan: 3.5
    DJ: 5.5
    Stockley: 6.5
    Kirk: 7
    Referee: 6.5
  • Cloudworm
    Cloudworm Posts: 977
    MacG: 8
    Matthews: 4 
    Inniss: 4
    Famewo: 6 
    Gunter: 4
    Dobson: 6
    Watson: 7
    Morgan: 5
    DJ: 6
    Stockley: 6 
    Kirk: 7
    Referee: 7 
  • msomerton
    msomerton Posts: 3,003
    MacG: 7
    Matthews: 5
    Inniss: 5
    Famewo: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 5
    Morgan: 5
    DJ: 6
    Stockley: 5 
    Kirk: 5
    I am being generous and saying that the outfield players bang average as we played a team likely to be going for promotion.
    Were as we are going for a relegation battle at this rate.
  • YTS1978
    YTS1978 Posts: 1,720
    MacG: MOTM 8 made some cracking saves to keep us in it. Wish he come out a catch a few crosses though!
    Matthews: 5 not up to his usual high standard
    Inniss: 4 looked shaky and on edge all game
    Famewo: 4 mystified by some of the high marks here, for such a big bloke he is constantly outmuscled. Had a really poor game.
    Gunter: 4 Square peg in a round hole. Looked uncomfortable
    Dobson: 5 tried hard, but at the moment it's not going for him. Never hid though and no lack of effort
    Watson: 6 does what says on the tin
    Morgan: 4 I'm a big Albie fan, but he seems to be crumbling under the pressure of being asked to be the main man at the moment 
    DJ: 4 flatters to deceive. Gets the fans on their feet when he gets the ball, but they all sit back down ver quickly when he either falls over or blazes the ball into row z!
    Stockley: 7 our best centre half today. Battled hard up front but had no real service. Could really do with a strike partner as this 433 aint working. Am starting to get a bit pissed off with us constantly lumping the ball in his general direction and hoping for the best
    Kirk: 6 a promising debut. Should have shot in the 2nd half rather than laying to ball off to Blackett-Taylor who was in a tight spot himself
    Referee: 6 about standard for this division

    Blackett-Taylor: tried hard, but looked knackered after 10mins. Maybe not surprising 
    Washington: work his nuts off as usual
    Davison: no time to make an impression, the game was already lost
  • Paddy7
    Paddy7 Posts: 1,663
    MacG: 7 Kept us in it.
    Matthews: 6 Progressed slightly further forward but not enough to hurt them. 
    Inniss: 7.5 Barely gave Wyke a sniff.
    Famewo: 8 Thought he was our best again. 
    Gunter: 5.5 Get a bloody LEFT back. 
    Dobson: 6.5 Some of the criticism is harsh.
    Watson: 6.5 One of his better games for us. 
    Morgan: 5.5 Tried hard again but with little to show for it.
    DJ: 6 Soon petered out.
    Stockley: 5.5 Made little impression with so little service. 
    Kirk: 6 We need to get players closer to him to benefit from his ability. 
    Referee: 6.5 Not too fussy. 

    Blackett-Taylor: n/a Made little impression.
    Washington: n/a As above.
    Davison: n/a As above - therein lies the problem.
  • Killarahales
    Killarahales Posts: 1,066
    MacG: 7.5
    Matthews: 6
    Inniss: 6.5
    Famewo: 6
    Gunter: 6
    Dobson: 6.5
    Watson: 6.5 
    Morgan: 5
    DJ: 6
    Stockley: 7
    Kirk: 7
    Referee: 5
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,034
    MacG: 8 Kept us in it 
    Matthews: 6 Average . Felt DJ and CBT left him exposed 
    Inniss: 5 Doesn't look as sound as last year . Is he match fit ?
    Famewo: 5 Similar to Inniss he doesn't look as good as last year
    Gunter: 6 He is not a natural left back but he is sound defensively 
    Dobson: 5 I am a fan since he was at Walsall .  He wasn't good yesterday but shouldn't have been subbed
    Watson: 6 He played well in my view . Some of the views are harsh .
    Morgan: 5 Not the answer as a CAM 
    DJ: 5 Disappointing 
    Stockley: 6 Kept going . Another game when his defensive duties were superb defending corners 
    Kirk: 7 Showed promise.

  • Sponsored links:



  • roseandcrown
    roseandcrown Posts: 7,590
    edited August 2021
    MacG:  7.5
    Matthews: 5.5
    Inniss: 5.5
    Famewo: 6.5
    Gunter: 5
    Dobson: 6.5
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 6
    DJ: 6
    Stockley: 6
    Kirk: 6.5
    Referee: 7

    Blackett-Taylor: n/a
    Washington: n/a
    Davison: n/a
  • ParkinsonOut
    ParkinsonOut Posts: 1,473
    MacG: 7
    Matthews: 5
    Inniss: 5
    Famewo: 5.5
    Gunter: 4
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 4
    DJ: 4
    Stockley: 6
    Kirk: 5
    The Pigeon: 8 a constant threat in front of goal, sign him up 🐦

    Referee: 4
  • follett
    follett Posts: 1,057
    MacG: 8 some fantastic saves which kept us in it
    Matthews: 5 capable of much better
    Inniss: 3.5 very poor and looked very laboured
    Famewo: 5.5 Won his aerial duels but wasn't great with his feet
    Gunter: 5 will cut him some slack as being played out of position but desperate for a LB
    Dobson: 6 was ok and created a decent chance with a good turn ofpace
    Watson: 7 our best outfield player on the day
    Morgan: 3 sadly out of his depth was very poor
    DJ: 5.5 some good movement and runs but lacks help down the wing from an overlapping LB
    Stockley: 5 was uncharacteristically poor in the air and looked isolated at times
    Kirk: 5.5 should have scored. Some promising signs 
    Referee: 5 not great but far from the reason we lost
  • Big_Bob
    Big_Bob Posts: 1,542
    MacG: 8 MOTM
    Matthews: 6
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 6
    Gunter: 5
    Dobson: 5
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 5- worked hard with no quality. Better as an 8 than 10
    DJ: 5
    Stockley: 3- dreadful. Gave fouls away and moaned at our players all game.
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 
  • Charlton_Road_James
    Charlton_Road_James Posts: 335
    MacG: 7 MOM
    Matthews: 5
    Inniss: 5
    Famewo: 6
    Gunter: 5
    Dobson: 5.5
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 4
    DJ: 6
    Stockley: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 6
  • RedArmySE7
    RedArmySE7 Posts: 5,407
    MacG: 7.5
    Matthews: 5
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 6.5
    Gunter: 4
    Dobson: 6
    Watson: 6
    Morgan: 4
    DJ: 5
    Stockley: 6
    Kirk: 6.5
    Referee: 5
  • RaplhMilne
    RaplhMilne Posts: 4,610
    MacG:             8
    Matthews:       5
    Inniss:             5
    Famewo:         5
    Gunter:           4
    Dobson:          6
    Watson:          5
    Morgan:         4
    DJ:                 6
    Stockley:       6.5
    Kirk:              6
    Referee:       5
  • Billy_Mix
    Billy_Mix Posts: 2,722
    MacG: 9
    Matthews: 7 
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 6 
    Gunter: 7
    Dobson: 3
    Watson: 7
    Morgan: 6
    DJ: 4
    Stockley: 8
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 4 
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 33,812
    lancashire lad said:
    your marks please:

    MacG:   9
    Matthews:   6
    Inniss:    6.5
    Famewo:   6
    Gunter:    5
    Dobson:    6
    Watson:    6
    Morgan:    5.5
    DJ:       7
    Stockley:  7
    Kirk:   7
    Referee: 

    Blackett-Taylor: n/a
    Washington: n/a
    Davison: n/a


  • seth plum
    seth plum Posts: 53,448
    MacG: 7.5
    Matthews: 5
    Inniss: 6
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 5
    Dobson: 6
    Watson: 5
    Morgan: 5
    DJ: 4
    Stockley: 6
    Kirk: 7

    Referee: 6

Categories

“Marketplace”