Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Liam Gallagher on Charlton
Comments
-
Don't 100% agree with that - I'm from the 60s generation and Oasis still spoke to me.RodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.5 -
Did they say ‘Hey, Bob, jack in what you’re doing and head out and get totally like wasted man.’?bobmunro said:
Don't 100% agree with that - I'm from the 60s generation and Oasis still spoke to me.RodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.0 -
Something similar, yes!Alwaysneil said:
Did they say ‘Hey, Bob, jack in what you’re doing and head out and get totally like wasted man.’?bobmunro said:
Don't 100% agree with that - I'm from the 60s generation and Oasis still spoke to me.RodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.0 -
I shuddered when i heard about this year's Knebworth gig.
I went to the one in 96. That three hour queue for a beer put me off big concerts for life. I was sober, it was shit!
4 -
Curb_It said:I shuddered when i heard about this year's Knebworth gig.
I went to the one in 96. That three hour queue for a beer put me off big concerts for life. I was sober, it was shit!
I saw oasis at the new wembley in 2009.
I didn't have to que up for a beer as some angry nutter decided to chuck his £8 pint in my face0 -
wow, thats cheap!Dave2l said:Curb_It said:I shuddered when i heard about this year's Knebworth gig.
I went to the one in 96. That three hour queue for a beer put me off big concerts for life. I was sober, it was shit!
I saw oasis at the new wembley in 2009.
I didn't have to que up for a beer as some angry nutter decided to chuck his £8 pint in my face0 -
Not just your age group … I was born in the 50’s and love OasisRodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.5 -
People born in the 50's have more musical taste and general better knowledge than people born in any other decadestonemuse said:
Not just your age group … I was born in the 50’s and love OasisRodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.
Fact.3 -
Don't agree that no band since has spoken to a generation, the Arctic Monkeys did when they broke.
Fair play to Liam for still making music, doesn't appeal to me in anyway, but good luck to him3 - Sponsored links:
-
I can't disagree with that!blackpool72 said:
People born in the 50's have more musical taste and general better knowledge than people born in any other decadestonemuse said:
Not just your age group … I was born in the 50’s and love OasisRodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.
Fact.0 -
Can't accept this.blackpool72 said:
People born in the 50's have more musical taste and general better knowledge than people born in any other decadestonemuse said:
Not just your age group … I was born in the 50’s and love OasisRodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.
Fact.
You didn't write FACT.5 -
Surprised it managed to hit you from the stage.Dave2l said:Curb_It said:I shuddered when i heard about this year's Knebworth gig.
I went to the one in 96. That three hour queue for a beer put me off big concerts for life. I was sober, it was shit!
I saw oasis at the new wembley in 2009.
I didn't have to que up for a beer as some angry nutter decided to chuck his £8 pint in my face5 -
I was at the Sunday gig in 09 and from the sheer volume of piss being thrown you should count yourself lucky it was overpriced beer you took a face of!Dave2l said:Curb_It said:I shuddered when i heard about this year's Knebworth gig.
I went to the one in 96. That three hour queue for a beer put me off big concerts for life. I was sober, it was shit!
I saw oasis at the new wembley in 2009.
I didn't have to que up for a beer as some angry nutter decided to chuck his £8 pint in my face2 -
agreed, arctic monkeys also have far larger musical diversity in their back catalogue than oasis. I think i remember reading that they actively dislike their old songs, whilst noel could still go on for hours on how much of a masterpiece live forever is.Rothko said:Don't agree that no band since has spoken to a generation, the Arctic Monkeys did when they broke.
Fair play to Liam for still making music, doesn't appeal to me in anyway, but good luck to him0 -
I actually thought The Streets were quite close to that whole speak for a generation thing with their debut.5
-
If I’d written something half as good as Live Forever then I’d be exactly the same.kentaddick said:
agreed, arctic monkeys also have far larger musical diversity in their back catalogue than oasis. I think i remember reading that they actively dislike their old songs, whilst noel could still go on for hours on how much of a masterpiece live forever is.Rothko said:Don't agree that no band since has spoken to a generation, the Arctic Monkeys did when they broke.
Fair play to Liam for still making music, doesn't appeal to me in anyway, but good luck to him3 -
completely agree. I love the streets, but mike is very much marmite - especially to those that don't want to sit down and listen to his music properly. He definitely changed the game in a big way.Karim_myBagheri said:I actually thought The Streets were quite close to that whole speak for a generation thing with their debut.2 -
I'm talking about my specific generation regarding oasis. I was older when the Streets and Arctic Monkeys came about and they would have perhaps had a similar influence on younger generations in the way oasis did for those aged 14- 17 in mid 90s.
I do also appreciate that the oaps on here like @bobmunro and @stonemuse do also dig them :-)
3 -
I'm surprised about the Streets, you're about the same age as me, and the Streets felt like something which talked directly to me.RodneyCharltonTrotta said:I'm talking about my specific generation regarding oasis. I was older when the Streets and Arctic Monkeys came about and they would have perhaps had a similar influence on younger generations in the way oasis did for those aged 14- 17 in mid 90s.
I do also appreciate that the oaps on here like @bobmunro and @stonemuse do also dig them :-)1 - Sponsored links:
-
Likewise for something like Fake Tales of San Francisco, but Alex Turner is constantly looking to reinvent himselfcafctom said:
If I’d written something half as good as Live Forever then I’d be exactly the same.kentaddick said:
agreed, arctic monkeys also have far larger musical diversity in their back catalogue than oasis. I think i remember reading that they actively dislike their old songs, whilst noel could still go on for hours on how much of a masterpiece live forever is.Rothko said:Don't agree that no band since has spoken to a generation, the Arctic Monkeys did when they broke.
Fair play to Liam for still making music, doesn't appeal to me in anyway, but good luck to him0 -
As a middle class Essex boy, it was always Blur that spoke more to me! (Not that I'd admit it) My chavvier, druggier mates mates were all about the Prodigy. Mind you I rocked a Spliffy top back in the day so was definitely part of the scene youknowhatimean. V97 Chelmsford with prodigy and blur was Essex woodstock (yes I binned off prodigy after Breathe to watch the Bluetones...)2
-
Try and find a bloke that can't relate to this song.Rothko said:
I'm surprised about the Streets, you're about the same age as me, and the Streets felt like something which talked directly to me.RodneyCharltonTrotta said:I'm talking about my specific generation regarding oasis. I was older when the Streets and Arctic Monkeys came about and they would have perhaps had a similar influence on younger generations in the way oasis did for those aged 14- 17 in mid 90s.
I do also appreciate that the oaps on here like @bobmunro and @stonemuse do also dig them :-)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MpiyqpAu-Q
4 -
Liked the Streets a lot but nowhere near the same impact or "sit up and take notice" effect that oasis had on me in 94/5/6Rothko said:I'm surprised about the Streets, you're about the same age as me, and the Streets felt like something which talked directly to me.
I was in early 20s when the Streets surfaced so well beyond that key formative age when a band really grabs hold of you as a wide eyed youngster.4 -
same, although we do now go to things like the hop farm and other low key events - it may not be cool but the main thing is you can take a deck chair in and get served easyCurb_It said:I shuddered when i heard about this year's Knebworth gig.
I went to the one in 96. That three hour queue for a beer put me off big concerts for life. I was sober, it was shit!2 -
The Prodigy outshone Oasis at Knebwoth in 96McBobbin said:As a middle class Essex boy, it was always Blur that spoke more to me! (Not that I'd admit it) My chavvier, druggier mates mates were all about the Prodigy. Mind you I rocked a Spliffy top back in the day so was definitely part of the scene youknowhatimean. V97 Chelmsford with prodigy and blur was Essex woodstock (yes I binned off prodigy after Breathe to watch the Bluetones...)2 -
The documentary film about the Knebworth gig is absolutely superb.0
-
Artic Monkeys may have spoke to a generation to a degree but nowhere near on the scale Oasis did, not even a quarter as much as Oasis.Rothko said:Don't agree that no band since has spoken to a generation, the Arctic Monkeys did when they broke.
Fair play to Liam for still making music, doesn't appeal to me in anyway, but good luck to him4 -
I look at my sisters generation and the effects the AM had on them was massive, also a band that generation found online so the growth was different, compared to Oasis who had one national radio station to dominate.buckshee said:
Artic Monkeys may have spoke to a generation to a degree but nowhere near on the scale Oasis did, not even a quarter as much as Oasis.Rothko said:Don't agree that no band since has spoken to a generation, the Arctic Monkeys did when they broke.
Fair play to Liam for still making music, doesn't appeal to me in anyway, but good luck to him0 -
You mean like Limahl???blackpool72 said:
People born in the 50's have more musical taste and general better knowledge than people born in any other decadestonemuse said:
Not just your age group … I was born in the 50’s and love OasisRodneyCharltonTrotta said:seth plum said:It always surprises me that people find his voice attractive in any way.
To me it sounds like a musical whine, and unlike other questionable voices like Jagger or Dylan he never sounds to me like he means what he sings.
You're not his target audience Seth. Oasis spoke to a generation of us in a way no band did before or has since if you were of a certain age and type in the mid 90s.
Fact.
And I suppose that, in fairness, Kajagoogoo also spoke to a generation, but that that generation's response is unprintable...3
