Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Next manager - Ben Garner confirmed (p256)

18889919394285

Comments

  • I’m not sure who the people “who have an agenda” against TS are or what their “agenda” is, But I do recognise this as the way any criticism of the spivs, Duchatelet and ESI was dismissed. Until it wasn’t. 
    So based upon the one part you’ve chosen to address, as I’ve said before a lot of what you say is listened to being that you do the Charlton fanzine and seem to be a bit more Itk, are you suggesting now that we should be comparing Thomas to the shitbags previously, as me being someone not itk would like to know. As for the agendas , It’s pretty clear there are people not in support of TS, naturally there will always be, They’re agenda would be to not have him owning the club I’m guessing,which really unless we start creating a  new dossier, he will be around for a while.but I’m pretty sure I didn’t really to explain that to you. We don’t need cryptic clues just facts is my point really. 
  • Meanwhile the people at that Charlton Athletic Museum, who must be in the know, posted this.

    A nod's as good as wink to a blind horse


    Ive wanted Beale all along and given the big delay I still think that would tie in with him wanting to end the season with Villa, 6/1 still available on him too
  • shirty5 said:
    I would ask around and then get all the advice/conversations I needed and then decide from there. 
    It's the only sensible thing to do.
  • edited May 2022
    It's like a switch has been flicked. Sandgaard good. Sandgaard good. SANDGAARD BAD! BOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
  •  I'm sorry. But I can't keep giving these people the benefit of the doubt. I can only react to what I'm seeing and hearing. The blind faith part of my brain was scorched some years ago.

    We are by far in a worse position now than we were 12 months ago. 
    And I say that in terms of building a successful side and pushing forward.
    You'll remember that Adkins was appointed after a diligent interviewing stage and he at least had the luxury of a few months before the pivotal summer period to get established and decide what he wanted and didn't want. He was then subsequently let down badly during that period for reasons only known by this ownership.

    Now fast forward 12 months. A team of people who on the whole still know very little about football are tasked with trying to find a manager.
    When they've managed to do that, they will then be faced with the equally monumental task of finding players to fit into the new managers ethos. ( If he or she are allowed to have their own one?)

    So to wrap up, the stage was set much fairer last summer than it is this. Quite why anyone would think the outcome will be rosier is beyond me?
    Carly Burn you have summed this up perfectly. We should judge on what we’ve seen evidence wise. Maybe we will find the next Eddie Howe but from the evidence so far it’s not to be expected. Neither depressed or anxious by this just being realistic.
  • Please tell me it could not happen.Martin Sandgaard Mananger Jason Euell Head Coach ?
  • edited May 2022
    Leuth said:
    This cast-iron delineation between 'good owners' and 'bad owners' is the sort of bullshit that our fans have gone insane swallowing. We've ended up in the situation where the only 'acceptable' owner has limitless cash, limitless patience, gives the manager limitless control, and probably does limitless damage in their day-job of human-rights-abusing oil potentate. Football is fucked and we don't know we're born. Sandgaard is fine. He cares. He'll very easily do. 
    Not if we continue to drop down the leagues he won't. Or even fail to get promoted.

    He doesn't have oligarch unlimited funds and no way would he hang around throwing £8m a year of his families' finite inheritance into the bottomless money pit of league one perpetually and no one could expect him to.

    Particularly when the fanbase expects us to be challenging to play at a higher level.

    If we were AFC Wimbledon or Burton then plodding along in yhis league with low expectations and mirrored lower expenditure I think it would be sustainable.

    But we're not and both fans and owner know that and will want to get to the championship asap where both fans and owner would likely be far more comfortable in staying in that league for the foreseeable.


  • Sponsored links:


  • My god this place is both tedious and depressing at times.

    Literally nobody knows what terms have been offered to any prospective manager (if any have), what restraints will be placed on that manager, what structure they'll work within.

    Yet the hand wringing and incessant bleating is endless, "nobody will come in under this system", "why haven't we got anybody in yet", and on and on and on.

    It's like you're all desperate for the worst possible outcome just so you can justify your self flagellation.

    RedRobin said:
    So no news then? The club is a joke, takes us weeks to get anything done. Last summer we went about a month without signing anyone during the window, and we wonder why we failed last season. 
    If anyone who has got a lot of posts to catch up on, please just read the above then get on with your day. 
  • Not if we continue to drop down the leagues he won't. Or even fail to get promoted.

    He doesn't have oligarch unlimited funds and no way would he hang around throwing £8m a year of his families finite inheritance into the bottomless money pit of league one perpetually and no one could expect him to.

    Particularly when the fanbase expects us to be challenging to play at a higher level.

    If we were AFC Wimbledon or Burton then plodding along in yhis league with low expectations and mirrored lower expenditure I think it would be sustainable.

    But we're not and both fans and owner know that and will want to get to the championship asap where both fans and owner would likely be far more comfortable in staying in that league for the foreseeable.


    But don't you see how your logic, which is sound, would surely mean he cares a LOT that we get promoted? And that would square with my own observations. Nothing he's done indicates contentment with League One
  • Neil Lennon odds have shortened, Matt Taylor has drifted but still favourite, Beale has drifted out too.
  • Is it to much to expect the club to give us a statement ?
  • Please tell me it could not happen.Martin Sandgaard Mananger Jason Euell Head Coach ?
    It can't happen

    MS doesn't have any coaching badges which are now a requirement for managerial roles in the EFL and EPL.
  • It can't happen

    MS doesn't have any coaching badges which are now a requirement for managerial roles in the EFL and EPL.
    It could of sorts, he could create a new position.. So you could have first team coaches that do the training field stuff... Then Director of Selection, who would pick the team..

    Let's hope TS doesn't read this forum... ha-ha
  • It thought a new manager had two years to get coaching badges
  • Meanwhile the people at that Charlton Athletic Museum, who must be in the know, posted this.

    A nod's as good as wink to a blind horse


    I’m wondering if he’s the only person, player or supporter to have ever done that button up. It’s a no from on that basis.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Good to hear from @ExeterDave.

    I liked Taylor as a player, and admire what he's done at Exeter.

    I think he'd be absolutely nuts to apply for the Charlton job under this ownership.
  • Oh yes I wholly agree with that sentiment mate. Where my concern stems from is whether he has the nous and experience, or has it in his management team, to achieve our wholly mutual objectives.

    I still think our objectives are aligned between fan and owner in a way not seen under prior owners eg football success.

    Concern is that it appears it requires really well executed strategies, shit ton of money, right managerial and playing appointments and a slice of fortune in today's game even in our increasingly daunting league one.

    Concern is thar TS is still in the "figuring it out" stage and that his proclamations of top 2 etc seem wildly optimistic/ naive if he truly believes them. Also worry he would lose interest/ be understandably terrified of doing a serious amount of his wealth year after year especially when there is no adulation and potential for the opposite with each season that failed to get near stated expectations.

    I don't question his heart or intentions but his understanding and experience of what is required beyond admirable positivity and can do attitude and the money he's gratefully pumping in to keep us going.
    All completely fair, and I wish this were the tenor of all the criticism - reasonable, balanced, understanding, constructive. 

    We're an abused, sick, desperate fanbase though, so I suppose it's inevitable that it isn't. 
  • i hope TS gets Curbs in
    I would like to see him involved in ‘some way or another’ on the team/playing side of things.
    Not sure how that could be accomplished though, first off an agreement with the new manager would need to be made in order that he would agree to the idea.
    Of course……..would Curbs himself be interested?
  • It can't happen

    MS doesn't have any coaching badges which are now a requirement for managerial roles in the EFL and EPL.
    Which rather begs the question as to why BetVic have him as a 12/1 shot - what happened to the old betting adage "if you can't win, you can't lose"?
  • I still believe that TS is in it for the right reasons, i.e building success for the fun times to roll. If financial gain comes in the deal, mores the pleasure. He wants it to come good as much as us, and has 8,000,000 reasons a season (if figures are as suggested).

    I like most fans just want to see success and good football. It makes me feel good on a Saturday and Sunday morning the Mrs reaps the benefit.

    Not all owners or managers can get the recipe right, as only 3 clubs gain promotion, which is generally the yardstick of a successful season.

    Our collective distain is set to remain until TS gets the recipe right. Success is crucial to TS winning favour with the fans. Shiny seats, a good U18, U23, women's team are very much appreciated, but the 1st team is what the majority including myself, use to measure football happiness.

    Get it right TS or trouble will be brewing. 
  • edited May 2022
    I’m not sure who the people “who have an agenda” against TS are or what their “agenda” is, But I do recognise this as the way any criticism of the spivs, Duchatelet and ESI was dismissed. Until it wasn’t. 
    I know who they are but they are on another forum……thankfully.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!