Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Next manager - Ben Garner confirmed (p256)
Comments
-
From a journo in Swindon1
-
So TS has made some mistakes, let's hope if any of you lot make a few mistakes in your job, you aren't thought of like this, your probably get fired
1 -
paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.5 -
supaclive said:paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.9 -
OK fair enough - so for my benefit…
why was Roddy a mistake?Has Roddy’s son really impacted things?MS - people are now calling out some of the great signings made by Driesen, so maybe the data is key!Charlton Ladies - agreedRonnie - crap signing won’t be the last
I agree on the song but it’s not contributed to anything on the pitch.Fill the ground - I’m a ST holder and I got what he was trying to do, it didn’t work, but the right intentions were there.
Washington - that’s a matter of opinion, so many fans saying he wasn’t good enough.
Loan signings - I agree that was strange but again, who really knows the circumstances around those signings.
IMO when Skiverton joined JJ was going to be in charge this year but the end to last season was woeful.No current manager - he said we’d have a manager before pre-season
my point is the list above is not that bad. I’m not saying we shouldn’t criticise but a lot on here and Twitter and other sites are going way over-board!11 -
paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.
"Jackson has also continually emphasised the fact that when both Jayden Stockley and Conor Washington have started together, he has never lost."1 -
paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.
The fact that Martin was involved in that and is now more involved doesn't fill me with any confidence at all.
If you think Martin has the back ground and experience to play such a crucial role can you tell me why? Because I am not the only one.3 -
Rossman92 said:From a journo in Swindon14
-
supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.5 -
Read up.....
We're allowed to have concerns.
You're allowed to believe all will get better.
No swearing required.
Enjoy your long bank holiday weekend. Have a few beers. We'll all still be here Monday.5 - Sponsored links:
-
supaclive said:seth plum said:If people at the club have been taking the piss when TS is absent, and if he feels he has been somewhat ‘played’ on the football side (Watson may be an example), then to me it makes sense that he wants his son around to protect his interests.
The problem seems to be about Martin and Thomas’ eyes being bigger than their stomachs, job titles and autonomy being less than ideal.
It is much easier from a supporters point of view to look at the games and absorb the results, if we win consistently a lot of angst will dissipate.
I still maintain that 2000 fans were betrayed at Ipswich, and were I Thomas at that game I would contemplate how much of that betrayal was my fault, and how much was down to precious footballers and football management seeking to demonstrate how pissed off they were.
2000 fans were shown up at the wrong place at the wrong time.
What part of the last 18 months makes you think he is. Or that TS genuinely can make this work?
Thank fcuk he saved us but we're going nowhere fast under this structure.
Listen to @Airman Brown when he mentions ex pros in the game, club insiders and players at the club that have a questionable perception of TS.
Nobody wants TS to fail. Jesus I love his enthusiasm and his passion. But it isn't, from a results perspective, working.
If Garner is announced this week, TS is going to lose some credibility in the fact Cawley said 10+ days ago he had the job, he's left Swindon, he's "apparently" been to the training ground three times already and yet TS still says he's not hired anybody yet.....0 -
The Martin obsession continues..!
Anyway, sounds positive from the Swindon journo. Let’s hope he’s in charge from next week.
18 -
supaclive said:Read up.....
We're allowed to have concerns.
You're allowed to believe all will get better.
No swearing required.
Enjoy your long bank holiday weekend. Have a few beers. We'll all still be here Monday.3 -
thetomahawkkid said:supaclive said:seth plum said:If people at the club have been taking the piss when TS is absent, and if he feels he has been somewhat ‘played’ on the football side (Watson may be an example), then to me it makes sense that he wants his son around to protect his interests.
The problem seems to be about Martin and Thomas’ eyes being bigger than their stomachs, job titles and autonomy being less than ideal.
It is much easier from a supporters point of view to look at the games and absorb the results, if we win consistently a lot of angst will dissipate.
I still maintain that 2000 fans were betrayed at Ipswich, and were I Thomas at that game I would contemplate how much of that betrayal was my fault, and how much was down to precious footballers and football management seeking to demonstrate how pissed off they were.
2000 fans were shown up at the wrong place at the wrong time.
What part of the last 18 months makes you think he is. Or that TS genuinely can make this work?
Thank fcuk he saved us but we're going nowhere fast under this structure.
Listen to @Airman Brown when he mentions ex pros in the game, club insiders and players at the club that have a questionable perception of TS.
Nobody wants TS to fail. Jesus I love his enthusiasm and his passion. But it isn't, from a results perspective, working.
If Garner is announced this week, TS is going to lose some credibility in the fact Cawley said 10+ days ago he had the job, he's left Swindon, he's "apparently" been to the training ground three times already and yet TS still says he's not hired anybody yet.....
No PR spin required. Most of us understand these things don’t happen overnight.14 -
Hey, general discussions thread:
That latest Stranger Things season huh? Thoughts?0 -
So BEN GARNER is our new man…makes sense for all the delays #UpTheAddicks0
-
ValleyGary said:thetomahawkkid said:supaclive said:seth plum said:If people at the club have been taking the piss when TS is absent, and if he feels he has been somewhat ‘played’ on the football side (Watson may be an example), then to me it makes sense that he wants his son around to protect his interests.
The problem seems to be about Martin and Thomas’ eyes being bigger than their stomachs, job titles and autonomy being less than ideal.
It is much easier from a supporters point of view to look at the games and absorb the results, if we win consistently a lot of angst will dissipate.
I still maintain that 2000 fans were betrayed at Ipswich, and were I Thomas at that game I would contemplate how much of that betrayal was my fault, and how much was down to precious footballers and football management seeking to demonstrate how pissed off they were.
2000 fans were shown up at the wrong place at the wrong time.
What part of the last 18 months makes you think he is. Or that TS genuinely can make this work?
Thank fcuk he saved us but we're going nowhere fast under this structure.
Listen to @Airman Brown when he mentions ex pros in the game, club insiders and players at the club that have a questionable perception of TS.
Nobody wants TS to fail. Jesus I love his enthusiasm and his passion. But it isn't, from a results perspective, working.
If Garner is announced this week, TS is going to lose some credibility in the fact Cawley said 10+ days ago he had the job, he's left Swindon, he's "apparently" been to the training ground three times already and yet TS still says he's not hired anybody yet.....
No PR spin required. Most of us understand these things don’t happen overnight.
including any discussions involving his coaching team and possible DoF coming aswell who knows how much negotiating has been going on3 -
thetomahawkkid said:supaclive said:seth plum said:If people at the club have been taking the piss when TS is absent, and if he feels he has been somewhat ‘played’ on the football side (Watson may be an example), then to me it makes sense that he wants his son around to protect his interests.
The problem seems to be about Martin and Thomas’ eyes being bigger than their stomachs, job titles and autonomy being less than ideal.
It is much easier from a supporters point of view to look at the games and absorb the results, if we win consistently a lot of angst will dissipate.
I still maintain that 2000 fans were betrayed at Ipswich, and were I Thomas at that game I would contemplate how much of that betrayal was my fault, and how much was down to precious footballers and football management seeking to demonstrate how pissed off they were.
2000 fans were shown up at the wrong place at the wrong time.
What part of the last 18 months makes you think he is. Or that TS genuinely can make this work?
Thank fcuk he saved us but we're going nowhere fast under this structure.
Listen to @Airman Brown when he mentions ex pros in the game, club insiders and players at the club that have a questionable perception of TS.
Nobody wants TS to fail. Jesus I love his enthusiasm and his passion. But it isn't, from a results perspective, working.
If Garner is announced this week, TS is going to lose some credibility in the fact Cawley said 10+ days ago he had the job, he's left Swindon, he's "apparently" been to the training ground three times already and yet TS still says he's not hired anybody yet.....
I'm as desperate as the next person for signs of progress that we can work out a way to escape this current malaise but appointing a manager during his holiday (which I think he probably needs more than a curtailed break for his own wellbeing and capacity to do a good job next season) doesn't allow much more time to impact anything than doing so almost immediately upon his return. For all we know they may have already discussed detail behind the plan for the next month remotely while the final points in the deal are being resolved. Garner isn't going to want to cut off his nose to spite his face (particularly if he's going to potentially suffer under a performance-related severance term) if he has chosen us as his next move and thinks it's more likely than not it will go through.1 - Sponsored links:
-
Cafc43v3r said:paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.
The fact that Martin was involved in that and is now more involved doesn't fill me with any confidence at all.
If you think Martin has the back ground and experience to play such a crucial role can you tell me why? Because I am not the only one.7 -
.0
-
https://twitter.com/ryan_walker14/status/1533050056483524608?s=21&t=8EirlmO5etMOyQtD3B6BOwSeems a low salary for a manager for us? Or is football just that bonkers with money now I see 90k per year a low wage0
-
paulfox said:Cafc43v3r said:paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.
The fact that Martin was involved in that and is now more involved doesn't fill me with any confidence at all.
If you think Martin has the back ground and experience to play such a crucial role can you tell me why? Because I am not the only one.
The common theme is who makes the football decisions and whose advice is sought and taken. If you listen to what Thomas says it's quite clear that Martin has more influence than any "football" people. It's a symptom of a wider issue.6 -
Cafc43v3r said:paulfox said:Cafc43v3r said:paulfox said:thenewbie said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:supaclive said:paulfox said:Phil said:I don’t think Sandgaard has played a blinder. Appointing his son and giving him authority in a position where he lacks expertise and experience is already looking a poor decision. The CW incident alone is clear evidence of that. It’s widely believed that Junior and perceived interference has cost us a couple of candidates.
His record in hiring and firing at the club is atrocious. This ongoing saga does little to change that.
We all want him to do well and thereby, the club in turn. However, he doesn’t appear ready and willing to learn from mistakes. That doesn’t bode well.
He is PART of the system that has failed. So while it's not fair to say he is the whole and entire reason for a poor season he very much is PART of the reason.
The fact that Martin was involved in that and is now more involved doesn't fill me with any confidence at all.
If you think Martin has the back ground and experience to play such a crucial role can you tell me why? Because I am not the only one.
The common theme is who makes the football decisions and whose advice is sought and taken. If you listen to what Thomas says it's quite clear that Martin has more influence than any "football" people. It's a symptom of a wider issue.0 -
charltonbob said:grumpyaddick said:I would like to see TS with his shirt off striking a large gong to announce the new manager.0
-
TheAddicks4Ever said:So BEN GARNER is our new man…makes sense for all the delays #UpTheAddicks1
-
RedRobin said:TheAddicks4Ever said:So BEN GARNER is our new man…makes sense for all the delays #UpTheAddicks1
-
So much effort to achieve such mediocrity.7
-
DamoNorthStand said:Themightyath2 said:I think everyone needs to cut TS some slack.
We have a club to support thanks to him, no one else. Forget Barclay, he didn’t want to get involved without the assets, so TS was the only option and we all owe him a massive thanks.Has he over promised, has he made mistakes - yes, but who hasn’t.For the last 15 years, this club has been poorly run, so we need to forget the “that’s not the way we do things at Charlton mindset”.
He genuinely wants to build something here, so let’s get behind him, ride out the good with the bad, and be grateful that we’ll have a competitive club to support come the start of the season.
Just because we were mixing it in the premier league once, does not mean we have a right to do so again. Look at Oldham!
Honestly I can’t deal with this anymore. He saved the club doesn’t mean he (or anyone else) is immune to criticism. It’s beyond parody.
8