Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Next manager - Ben Garner confirmed (p256)
Comments
-
-
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
1 -
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.0 -
Didn't Luzon, Peters and Riga all bring back room staff with them? Slade did, Robinson did. It was only after KM left and RD gave up (chicken or egg?) that Bowyer didn't?Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
1 -
“I’m not actually bald”Amos on the wing said:
”Well that’s a hell-of-a partin’”2 -
.1
-
JJ desperately wanted the job so put pen to paper even though he had no say on recruitment & the contract was heavily weighted against him. Early reports said Garner & his two coaches were a team & were incoming, all the reports coming from the Swindon end said the coaches were coming but Charlton/sandgaard didn't want to pay the compensation. Same as Adkins, work with the coaches that are here.ricky_otto said:
You would assume if he wasn’t, he wouldn’t have put pen to paper.charltonbob said:
Is he ?Gribis hebo said:
Garner's obviously happy with how things are.FAVADDICK said:
They should be here now with Ben to be honest, why waitThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.0 -
As you know what TS is thinking and what contracts he's offering I hope you can you tell us all the signings we'll be making.Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
7 -
WOW!golfaddick said:
This for me.ShootersHillGuru said:One thing we can look forward to with Ben Garner is a manager that has spent a significant part of his career coaching all of kids, teens and adults. He’s going to be able to see what probably none of our recent managers have been able to see. Sounds like coaching is his passion and that’s got to be a massive positive. I expect signings of young players from league two and one that none of us have heard of but he will have tracked. I’m quite excited by the prospect of a Charlton style. Bring on the new season.
Was about to post the same thing. One thing is for sure, Garner has spent years coaching players- decent ones at that.It's not like he's just hung up his boots & taken his Pro licence (like some of our recent managers 😉).
I spy good times ahead. Buying our season tickets tomorrow.1 - Sponsored links:
-
My understanding was they were RD people, not Luzon, Peters or Riga's.Cafc43v3r said:
Didn't Luzon, Peters and Riga all bring back room staff with them? Slade did, Robinson did. It was only after KM left and RD gave up (chicken or egg?) that Bowyer didn't?Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
I fully expect the two guys to arrive, but suspect the delay/wrangling is over terms, and not the minor compensation to Swindon. They won't be getting straight 3 year deals! We are also yet to hear/understand (nor will we likely to) the terms of Garners, could it be like Jacksons and severance will be performance related?0 -
Are we buying any players?southamptonaddick said:
As you know what TS is thinking and what contracts he's offering I hope you can you tell us all the signings we'll be making.Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
The biggest shock for me today was Gallen saying we had over 100 applicants for the Managers role, clearly that's why it took so long, that's a lot of CV's to go through........0 -
If they were Roland people not Riga etc people why did they all change when the manager did? Barker and Nugent weren't RD people.Rob7Lee said:
My understanding was they were RD people, not Luzon, Peters or Riga's.Cafc43v3r said:
Didn't Luzon, Peters and Riga all bring back room staff with them? Slade did, Robinson did. It was only after KM left and RD gave up (chicken or egg?) that Bowyer didn't?Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
I fully expect the two guys to arrive, but suspect the delay/wrangling is over terms, and not the minor compensation to Swindon. They won't be getting straight 3 year deals! We are also yet to hear/understand (nor will we likely to) the terms of Garners, could it be like Jacksons and severance will be performance related?
The Jackson contract has no bearing on anything other than Thomas didn't really want Jackson and didn't like the football. Full stop. It was a tool to get a job done. No evidence at all it's been used again.
Your either putting 2 and 2 together and making 25 or still grieving.2 -
This interview of BG by Swindon supporters club (first 17 mins) may have already been posted, but in case not: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnfipIi61Is0
-
Interesting because TS said 40.Rob7Lee said:
Are we buying any players?southamptonaddick said:
As you know what TS is thinking and what contracts he's offering I hope you can you tell us all the signings we'll be making.Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
The biggest shock for me today was Gallen saying we had over 100 applicants for the Managers role, clearly that's why it took so long, that's a lot of CV's to go through........
10 interviews for Gallen and 12 from TS
minor inconsistencies.
tS did sound slightly peeved about the leak!1 -
And the build up to Bauer’s goal was crazy. But they were isolated moments of excellence in an otherwise solid performance.Todds_right_hook said:
And Wembley. The build up to purrington a goalJamesSeed said:
The 45 minutes v Forest at The Valley?CAFCsayer said:
No we didn’t. We had players breaking forward quickly and scored a lot of goals on the counter. At no point under bowyer were we playing patient, intricate footballThe Red Robin said:
We played a similar style under Bowyer at times, especially in our promotion season.Swisdom said:Right. So it's now official and he's come out and said how he wants to play. I don't think there's many fans who don't want to see us play in a more attractive manner. To see us play with players who are confident of having the ball. Players who actually want the ball.
All we, as fans, need to remember is there will be times it doesn't work. There will be times we concede goals from "fucking about with it" and times where we won't just "knock it forwards" but as BG himself has said, we want to change the ethos of the club and to play like this throughout the ages groups. The U18's particularly play nice and neat football and take the occasional risks and anyone who has seen them in the last couple of seasons has said how refreshing they are to watch. Won't it be nice if the first team can replicate that!
I particularly like the way he says we will have a style of play that is the same both home and away. It's now going to be up to the opposition to nullify us whereas we have been far too predictable previously. I look forward to seeing us playing it around the opponents and watching them get knackered and watching players like JFC and Fraser pulling the strings. I also wonder if BG will be able to harness Albie Morgan and get the best value out of him
Obviously there will need to be a number of new bodies and a change in the way the existing ones train and play but if it improves them, and us, I'm all for it.
I'm mildly excited and hope he gets a bit of time and patience, from fans and TS alike, to deliverMost of you have been watching Charlton much longer, and more regularly than me, but the best I’ve seen Charlton play was probably the 1-1 v Arsenal with the Dicanio penalty, when Parker ran the show. I think we were second in the Prem with Arsenal top, from memory? Well it shut my Arsenal mate up at least.1 -
Ben Garner, eh? Didn't see that coming.3
-
Bowyer was backroom staff himself (effectively) when appointed manager so had no staff to bring.Cafc43v3r said:
Didn't Luzon, Peters and Riga all bring back room staff with them? Slade did, Robinson did. It was only after KM left and RD gave up (chicken or egg?) that Bowyer didn't?Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.4 -
I think sandgaards comment that "realistically most of our signings will be made later in the window" suggest that he has learnt very little from last seasons poor window.paulfox said:There’s a bit of flip flopping of the narrative going on, all the interviews are put to us in a positive tense, throughout there is an acceptance of mistakes and how they are going to try to put things right, everything people have been moaning about has been addressed within the interviews and explained how they intend to learn lessons. I think it really is time we as fans collectively do what we do best and get behind our club and help get out of this shit league, I think some attractive signings will really give us hope we can push on with.13 -
50 of them were from here though.Rob7Lee said:
Are we buying any players?southamptonaddick said:
As you know what TS is thinking and what contracts he's offering I hope you can you tell us all the signings we'll be making.Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
The biggest shock for me today was Gallen saying we had over 100 applicants for the Managers role, clearly that's why it took so long, that's a lot of CV's to go through........1 - Sponsored links:
-
The 4-2 at home to Chelsea as well.JamesSeed said:
And the build up to Bauer’s goal was crazy. But they were isolated moments of excellence in an otherwise solid performance.Todds_right_hook said:
And Wembley. The build up to purrington a goalJamesSeed said:
The 45 minutes v Forest at The Valley?CAFCsayer said:
No we didn’t. We had players breaking forward quickly and scored a lot of goals on the counter. At no point under bowyer were we playing patient, intricate footballThe Red Robin said:
We played a similar style under Bowyer at times, especially in our promotion season.Swisdom said:Right. So it's now official and he's come out and said how he wants to play. I don't think there's many fans who don't want to see us play in a more attractive manner. To see us play with players who are confident of having the ball. Players who actually want the ball.
All we, as fans, need to remember is there will be times it doesn't work. There will be times we concede goals from "fucking about with it" and times where we won't just "knock it forwards" but as BG himself has said, we want to change the ethos of the club and to play like this throughout the ages groups. The U18's particularly play nice and neat football and take the occasional risks and anyone who has seen them in the last couple of seasons has said how refreshing they are to watch. Won't it be nice if the first team can replicate that!
I particularly like the way he says we will have a style of play that is the same both home and away. It's now going to be up to the opposition to nullify us whereas we have been far too predictable previously. I look forward to seeing us playing it around the opponents and watching them get knackered and watching players like JFC and Fraser pulling the strings. I also wonder if BG will be able to harness Albie Morgan and get the best value out of him
Obviously there will need to be a number of new bodies and a change in the way the existing ones train and play but if it improves them, and us, I'm all for it.
I'm mildly excited and hope he gets a bit of time and patience, from fans and TS alike, to deliverMost of you have been watching Charlton much longer, and more regularly than me, but the best I’ve seen Charlton play was probably the 1-1 v Arsenal with the Dicanio penalty, when Parker ran the show. I think we were second in the Prem with Arsenal top, from memory? Well it shut my Arsenal mate up at least.2 -
Genuinely nice to see you express your happiness and so much so that you’re committing to a season ticket from it. Let’s hope for more positive times ahead, with the football they’re promising, I can see you taking a lot less stick.golfaddick said:
This for me.ShootersHillGuru said:One thing we can look forward to with Ben Garner is a manager that has spent a significant part of his career coaching all of kids, teens and adults. He’s going to be able to see what probably none of our recent managers have been able to see. Sounds like coaching is his passion and that’s got to be a massive positive. I expect signings of young players from league two and one that none of us have heard of but he will have tracked. I’m quite excited by the prospect of a Charlton style. Bring on the new season.
Was about to post the same thing. One thing is for sure, Garner has spent years coaching players- decent ones at that.It's not like he's just hung up his boots & taken his Pro licence (like some of our recent managers 😉).
I spy good times ahead. Buying our season tickets tomorrow.1 -
It says to me that he is in it for the long term and he would far rather get the right people in than rush the wrong ones. He has said he wasn’t happy with how it was done last summer and it will be different this time round, but realistically, the way football is because of transfer windows the best players sometimes only become available towards the end of the window.charltonbob said:
I think sandgaards comment that "realistically most of our signings will be made later in the window" suggest that he has learnt very little from last seasons poor window.paulfox said:There’s a bit of flip flopping of the narrative going on, all the interviews are put to us in a positive tense, throughout there is an acceptance of mistakes and how they are going to try to put things right, everything people have been moaning about has been addressed within the interviews and explained how they intend to learn lessons. I think it really is time we as fans collectively do what we do best and get behind our club and help get out of this shit league, I think some attractive signings will really give us hope we can push on with.2 -
Barker and Nugent were when RD had an about turn of actually employing experience in English leagues Managers.Cafc43v3r said:
If they were Roland people not Riga etc people why did they all change when the manager did? Barker and Nugent weren't RD people.Rob7Lee said:
My understanding was they were RD people, not Luzon, Peters or Riga's.Cafc43v3r said:
Didn't Luzon, Peters and Riga all bring back room staff with them? Slade did, Robinson did. It was only after KM left and RD gave up (chicken or egg?) that Bowyer didn't?Rob7Lee said:
Much like RD TS doesn't like employing managers who want to bring their own backroom, as it's double bubble when he sacks them. I suspect it's more to do with the restrictive contracts he's offering.SoundAsa£ said:
I think TS realises that and is just playing crafty.shirty5 said:
These should be his first 2 signings before anything else is doneThe Red Robin said:https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/are-swindon-town-coaches-set-to-join-ben-garner-at-charlton-athletic-addicks-owner-thomas-sandgaard-responds/Sandgaard on Garner’s coaches joining.
I fully expect the two guys to arrive, but suspect the delay/wrangling is over terms, and not the minor compensation to Swindon. They won't be getting straight 3 year deals! We are also yet to hear/understand (nor will we likely to) the terms of Garners, could it be like Jacksons and severance will be performance related?
The Jackson contract has no bearing on anything other than Thomas didn't really want Jackson and didn't like the football. Full stop. It was a tool to get a job done. No evidence at all it's been used again.
Your either putting 2 and 2 together and making 25 or still grieving.
I agree TS had doubts about Jackson, but he does about everyone. He has a very clear vision as to what he wants and how to achieve that, which in many respects is great, if it works. Two years in and so far it's been a categoric failure and I don't see much change between simply repeating the same mistakes time after time. Anyone notice TS saying signings will likely be towards the end of the window? Has he learnt nothing from last year? Or does he believe players will be more desperate, and therefore cheaper, as the window draws to a close?
I really really hope I'm wrong and Garner becomes a massive success with us, but he'll be another manager (coach) working with an arm tied behind his back, make no mistake. We'll have a very small squad thats fit and up to speed by the 1st game, remember we're starting at the end of July this year! The window closes 1st September.....
FWIW I believe from speaking to people in the game Garner is a very respected coach, but then one of the most respected in the game was Les Read - management didn't exactly work out for him and he didn't work for an owner who wanted to dictate the style of play (AFAIK!).
As I say, I truly hope he'll be a massive success, and maybe he will and take us back to the premiership only leaving to take over from Southgate....... but the current set up and based on the last two years, he's set up to fail IMHO.1 -
So much said and written about this appointment that I doubt I have anything original to say, plus I’ve never knowingly watched a Ben Garner team play, so I’ll just say… Welcome Ben and good luck.4
-
A positive golfie post!!!! He must have gone to the pub tonight and left his phone on the table when he went to the toiletgolfaddick said:
This for me.ShootersHillGuru said:One thing we can look forward to with Ben Garner is a manager that has spent a significant part of his career coaching all of kids, teens and adults. He’s going to be able to see what probably none of our recent managers have been able to see. Sounds like coaching is his passion and that’s got to be a massive positive. I expect signings of young players from league two and one that none of us have heard of but he will have tracked. I’m quite excited by the prospect of a Charlton style. Bring on the new season.
Was about to post the same thing. One thing is for sure, Garner has spent years coaching players- decent ones at that.It's not like he's just hung up his boots & taken his Pro licence (like some of our recent managers 😉).
I spy good times ahead. Buying our season tickets tomorrow.
seriously....good post and i agree3 -
Talks about the importance of the two Scotts.KHA said:This interview of BG by Swindon supporters club (first 17 mins) may have already been posted, but in case not: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnfipIi61IsAgain, TS needs to get the full team.5 -
It’s a huge relief! Now the attention can be turned to the Swanley game!1
-
Golfie I’m probably normally one of the first to get aggy with you when you have opinions which are counter to my normally more ‘positive’ ones.golfaddick said:
This for me.ShootersHillGuru said:One thing we can look forward to with Ben Garner is a manager that has spent a significant part of his career coaching all of kids, teens and adults. He’s going to be able to see what probably none of our recent managers have been able to see. Sounds like coaching is his passion and that’s got to be a massive positive. I expect signings of young players from league two and one that none of us have heard of but he will have tracked. I’m quite excited by the prospect of a Charlton style. Bring on the new season.
Was about to post the same thing. One thing is for sure, Garner has spent years coaching players- decent ones at that.It's not like he's just hung up his boots & taken his Pro licence (like some of our recent managers 😉).
I spy good times ahead. Buying our season tickets tomorrow.But have to respect you for a reasonable balanced comment here, and think it’s very important that people understand, as you mentioned, that Garner is just not some complete random pulled out of nowhere because he is ‘cheap’.
As you mention he is first and foremost a coach that has seen it all, and coached at the highest level. If you listen to any of his interviews his desire to reflect upon what he has done and continue to improve sounds like a massive strength.I’m so excited to finally have someone in, again as Sage has mentioned, who wants to implement an identity and style of play that certainly is in line with what I want to see.
Football is a funny old game, but I’m not buzzing for next season already.0 -
This feels very much little a massive roll of the dice in so much, it could go spectacularly well or bad either way1
