Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Players Marks: FACupR1 Replay: Cray Valley (PM) v Charlton Athletic (closes Friday brekkers)
Comments
-
Applescore: 7
WALKER: 4
ASIIMWE: 7
NESS: 6.5
JONES: 8
EDUN: 6
DOBSON: 8
McGRANDLES: 6.5
FRASER: 7
MAY: 9
LEABURN: 5
CBT:4
T.CAMPBELL: 6.5
Referee: 6
0 -
how can you give him a 4 if you didn't even notice him! lets remember we were playing a team of NON-LEAGUE players, 3 of them scaffolders who worked 7-3 for a firm. It's an absolute disgrace how poor he was, if this was Kirk, we'd be saying he should never wear the shirt again after a performance like that. Our fans are honestly so far up his arse it drives me mad. The bloke is a lazy c***, turns it on when he wants, when his good his good, when his bad, he wouldn't even play non league.thewolfboy said:Applescore: 8
WALKER: 5
ASIIMWE: 7.5 well played
NESS: 6
JONES: 7
EDUN: 6
DOBSON: 8
McGRANDLES: 7
FRASER: 5
MAY: 9 magnifique!
LEABURN: 6
CBT: 4 Didn't notice him!
T.CAMPBELL: 7 extra mark for his tidy goal
Referee: 6 We were lucky he didn't't send Walker off!3 -
WALKER: 3
ASIIMWE: 6.5
NESS: 5
JONES: 6
EDUN: 6
DOBSON: 7
McGRANDLES: 6
FRASER: 6.5
MAY: 7.5
LEABURN: 7
CBT: 3
T.CAMPBELL: 6.5
Referee: 3
0 -
Gary Manilow
-WALKER: 5 - Had one thing to do, didn't nail it.
totally agree -So hard to evaluate Goalkeepers in majority of games
0 -
Applescore: 7
WALKER: 5
ASIIMWE: 8
NESS: 7
JONES: 7
EDUN:7
DOBSON: 7.5
McGRANDLES: 7
FRASER: 7
MAY: 9
LEABURN: 6.5
CBT:5
T.CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 6
0 -
Applescore: 6.5
WALKER: 5
ASIIMWE: 8
NESS: 6
JONES: 6.5
EDUN: 6.5
DOBSON: 7.5
McGRANDLES: 6.5
FRASER: 7
MAY: 8.5
LEABURN: 6.5
CBT: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 6.5
Referee: 6
0 -
Applescore:
WALKER: 4 He's ploppers
ASIIMWE: 7 Much better 2nd half
NESS: 5.5 always looks a bit ponderous to me
JONES: 7 Good player assured on the ball too
EDUN: 6 lots of irritating fouls
DOBSON: 7.5 good goal. Do think he's slightly overdoing the long diagonal balls
McGRANDLES: 6.5 lovely assist for TC. Some good turns too.
FRASER: 6.5 similar to McG
MAY: 8.5 best player on the pitch by a mile. love the man
LEABURN: 6 didn't look interested. Decent header
CBT: 5.5 see Leaburn
T.CAMPBELL: 7 well taken goal. Looked way more up for it than CBT & Leaburn.
Referee: 6 - Got everything right except the penalty decision
0 -
Applescore: 7
WALKER: 5
ASIIMWE: 8
NESS: 7
JONES: 7
EDUN: 6
DOBSON: 7
McGRANDLES: 7
FRASER: 7
MAY: 9
LEABURN: 6
CBT: 4 - has this player agreed to play elsewhere? Really like him, but starting to go missing in games…
T.CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 7
T.WATSON: n/a
KEDWELL: n/a
MBICK: n/a
C.CAMPBELL: n/a
0 -
Applescore: 7
WALKER: 5
ASIIMWE: 7
NESS: 7
JONES: 7.5
EDUN: 7
DOBSON: 8
McGRANDLES: 7
FRASER: 7
MAY: 8.5
LEABURN: 7
CBT: 4
T.CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 5
0 -
Applescore: 7 - got the selection right and it was good to introduce the two young lads at the end and give them a taste
WALKER: 4.5 - he worries me
ASIIMWE: 8 - a powerful and athletic performance and a lovely cross for Leaburn's goal
NESS: 7 - a lovely pass for Alfie's opener and had two good efforts himself. Slow to track Lisbie's run prior to the penalty but generally very solid and so much better than in the first game
JONES: 7.5 - very authoritative throughout. He ducked under the through ball for their penalty, but it looked as if he had a call ?
EDUN: 6 - did ok. Not tested defensively. Good to get another 90 minutes under his belt
DOBSON: 8 - sprayed the ball around very well and scored a cracking goal (a bit like the one at Crawley)
McGRANDLES: 7 - went quietly and efficiently about his business. A nice assist for Campbell's goal
FRASER: 6.5 - a couple of excellent set pieces but, otherwise, a tepid first half. Picked up in the second as more space appeared
MAY: 9 - excellent throughout
LEABURN: 6 - a thumping header for his goal but generally subdued
CBT: 5 - very quiet - with a tight pitch and opponents sitting deep, he made no impact
T.CAMPBELL: 6.5 - looked lively and a nice finish
Referee: 6 - got the penalty decision wrong but was entitled to better support from his linesman. Like the first match at The Valley, the game was played in a good spirit, with no cloggers (non-league or otherwise) in evidence.
0 - Sponsored links:
-
Applescore: 6.5
WALKER: 4
ASIIMWE: 8
NESS: 3
JONES: 4
EDUN: 5
DOBSON: 8
McGRANDLES: 1.5
FRASER: 4
MAY: 9.5
LEABURN: 8
CBT:6.5
T.CAMPBELL: 8
Referee: 5
4 -
Applescore: 9
WALKER: 5
ASIIMWE: 8
NESS: 7
JONES: 8
EDUN: 6
DOBSON: 7
McGRANDLES: 6
FRASER: 5
MAY: 9
LEABURN: 5
CBT: 6
T.CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 7
0 -
Applescore: 7.5
WALKER: 6
ASIIMWE: 7.5
NESS: 6.5
JONES: 7
EDUN: 6.5
DOBSON: 8
McGRANDLES: 7
FRASER: 7
MAY: 8.5
LEABURN: 7
CBT: 5.5
T.CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 7
0 -
1
-
Applescore: 7.5WALKER: 5ASIIMWE: 8NESS: 7.5JONES: 7.5EDUN: 7DOBSON: 8McGRANDLES: 7.5FRASER:7MAY: 8.5LEABURN: 6.5CBT: 5.5T.CAMPBELL: 6Referee: 6.5
0 -
Applescore: 7.0
WALKER: 5.0
ASIIMWE: 8.0
NESS: 7.0
JONES: 7.0
EDUN: 6.0
DOBSON: 8.0
McGRANDLES: 7.5
FRASER: 7.5
MAY: 9.0
LEABURN: 7.0
CBT: 5.0
T.CAMPBELL: 8.0
Referee: 8.0
T.WATSON: n/a
KEDWELL: n/a
MBICK: n/a
C.CAMPBELL: n/a
0 -
Applescore: 8
WALKER: 5.0 so far two performances not had much to do yet still worried me
ASIIMWE: 7.5 very good attacking
NESS: 7.0 a threat going forward
JONES: 7.0 solid
EDUN: 6.0 he is either really poor one min really good the next nk inbetween
DOBSON: 8.5 captains performance and lovely goal
McGRANDLES: 7.5 solid liking what I see tidy got an assist too
FRASER: 6 gets 4 for 1st half 8 for second half
MAY: 9.0 motm class fast becoming my fave Charlton player in a long long time
LEABURN: 6 suprised with some high ratings scored but a L1 keeper is saving that unless it’s Walker and didn’t do much else or note
CBT: 2 ppl would be scoring 0 if that was Kirk. Seems unless he has space and confidence is high has full back on toast he just can’t be arsed
T.CAMPBELL: 7 tried and got a goal
Referee: 8.0 would of been higher if not for that first half error
T.WATSON: n/a fine
KEDWELL: n/a looks quality to me think he will be a player
MBICK: n/a happy for him to get a debut goal
C.CAMPBELL: n/a not enough time to make any real impact0 -
lancashire lad said:Applescore:
WALKER: 4
ASIIMWE: 7
NESS: 6
JONES: 6
EDUN: 6
DOBSON: 8
McGRANDLES: 6
FRASER: 6
MAY: 9
LEABURN: 6
CBT: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 6
Referee: 6
T.WATSON: n/a
KEDWELL: n/a
MBICK: n/a
C.CAMPBELL: n/a
0 -
Applescore: 8 did the job
WALKER: 4 poor hard to believe he is a real goalie
ASIIMWE: 8.5 - great game
NESS: 7 - mostly good
JONES: 8 calm and assured
EDUN: 8 - looks a good player
DOBSON: 9.5 MOM
McGRANDLES: 7 better in the second half playing deeper and good assist
FRASER: 7.5 - played well at times, grew into the game. Dead ball delivery was decent.
MAY: 9 loving watching him, a real proper striker
LEABURN: 7.5 nice goal, cheer up Miles!
CBT: 5 not his day
T.CAMPBELL: 7.5 - played well, nice goal
Referee: 7 mostly ok, not sure about the pen
T.WATSON: n/a
KEDWELL: n/a
MBICK: n/a great debut goal!!
C.CAMPBELL: n/a
0 -
Applescore 7
WALKER 4 A liability he is like Dracula he hates crosses
ASIIMWE 8 great game
NESS 6 Better as a striker
JONES 8 Looks a good buy
EDUN 7 Did good
DOBSON 8 Hope he stays
McGRANDLES 6 looks better
FRASER 6 Still looses control easy
MAY 9 Looks different class
LEABURN 6 Looks a grumpy player
CBT 2 He’s running Kirk for the worst player. Not interested at all just like Saturday he goes missing too much. Rightly hooked at half time. Needs dropping.T CAMPBELL 7 makes CBT look what he is very poor.T. WATSON n/a
KEDWELL n/a
MBICK n/a
C. CAMPBELL n/a
REF 7 Not a penalty but was def a red card. Lucky Boy.0 - Sponsored links:
-
WALKER: 0
ASIIMWE: 8
NESS: 5
JONES: 7
EDUN: 5
DOBSON:7.5
McGRANDLES: 5
FRASER: 6
MAY: 9
LEABURN: 7.5
CBT: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 7
1 -
Applescore: 7.5
WALKER: 4
ASIIMWE: 7
NESS: 6.5
JONES: 6
EDUN: 5
DOBSON: 7
McGRANDLES: 6
FRASER: 6
MAY: 8
LEABURN: 7
CBT:5
T.CAMPBELL: 6
Referee: 7
0 -
Applescore: 7WALKER: 4
ASIIMWE: 7
NESS: 6
JONES: 7
EDUN: 7
DOBSON: 7.5
McGRANDLES: 6.5
FRASER: 5
MAY: 8
LEABURN:6.5
CBT: 4
T.CAMPBELL: 6.5
Referee: 40 -
He never did at HT in fact he was pleased with the way we had playedRossman92 said:Applescore: 8-Put a rocket up their asses at halftime and never let off the gas, what you want to see
WALKER: 6-Not a lot to do, minus 1 for his brain dead foul
ASIIMWE: 8.5-would be mom if Alfie May didn’t exist
NESS: 6-still not comfortable with him starting, was happy to see him coming forward
JONES: 7-Solid, same as Ness, glad he started coming forward
EDUN: 7.5 Exciting talent
DOBSON: 8-Dobbo being Dobbo, rocket of a goal
McGRANDLES: 7-Solid, don’t really see what he did wrong
FRASER: 7-first half he was well off it, was running the show second half, think his set pieces were great today
MAY: 10-Lock him in the training ground so he can never leave
LEABURN: 6.5-Plus .5 for the well taken goal, not his most energetic performance to date
CBT: 4-Rightfully subbed, worryingly lack of heart today
T.CAMPBELL: 7 mustard
Referee: 7 knew what he was doing giving the pen, didn’t wanna send someone off. Probably grateful for that call0 -
Applescore: 7.5
WALKER: 4.5
ASIIMWE: 7
NESS: 6.5 both CBs looked authoritative but somehow managed to let in another soft goal
JONES: 6.5
EDUN: 6
DOBSON: 7
McGRANDLES:7
FRASER: 6.5
MAY: 8
LEABURN: 6.5
CBT: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 6
T.WATSON: n/a
KEDWELL: n/a
MBICK: n/a
C.CAMPBELL: n/a
0 -
FFS @RonnieMoore how many times? If you want to discuss people's marks don't quote them on the player marks thread, do it on the post match
1
