Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
STATBANK: PORT VALE 3-3 CHARLTON

lancashire lad
Posts: 15,630
thanks to the 46 Lifers who gave marks




















6
Comments
-
Tough 5 games coming up…
Minor point - shouldn’t CBT be top of assists with all his being in the league?0 -
EveshamAddick said:Tough 5 games coming up…
Minor point - shouldn’t CBT be top of assists with all his being in the league?1 -
All very harsh on Edun imho. Thought he was our best player first half.1
-
Had enough of the Hector debate now, but the antis giving him 3s and 4s for a very solid performance seem to have skewed his mark.0
-
Dazzler21 said:JamesSeed said:Had enough of the Hector debate now, but the antis giving him 3s and 4s for a very solid performance seem to have skewed his mark.2
-
Overall, despite wondering if fan/critics are watching the same match, by the time Lancs lad puts the averages up they are mostly a fair reflection.
IF Charlton had held on for a 3-2 (3 time lead chucked away !) then the feel good factor would've pushed most players scores up a tad.
Just my opinion but the world seemed a better place (I must be on drugs) when Charlton win ( you need a good memory)
2 -
JamesSeed said:Dazzler21 said:JamesSeed said:Had enough of the Hector debate now, but the antis giving him 3s and 4s for a very solid performance seem to have skewed his mark.JamesSeed said:Dazzler21 said:JamesSeed said:Had enough of the Hector debate now, but the antis giving him 3s and 4s for a very solid performance seem to have skewed his mark.
IN the end it is a matter of people personal thought on how They think platers performed - so why call out people whio have a different opinion to how you think a player performed.............just because you like that player!!
3 -
Opps looks like splet check took over !! - PlatersBoPeepAddick said:JamesSeed said:Dazzler21 said:JamesSeed said:Had enough of the Hector debate now, but the antis giving him 3s and 4s for a very solid performance seem to have skewed his mark.JamesSeed said:Dazzler21 said:JamesSeed said:Had enough of the Hector debate now, but the antis giving him 3s and 4s for a very solid performance seem to have skewed his mark.
IN the end it is a matter of people personal thought on how They think platers performed - so why call out people whio have a different opinion to how you think a player performed.............just because you like that player!!
2 -
JamesSeed said:Dazzler21 said:JamesSeed said:Had enough of the Hector debate now, but the antis giving him 3s and 4s for a very solid performance seem to have skewed his mark.
IN the end it is a matter of people personal thought on how They think platers performed - so why call out people whio have a different opinion to how you think a player performed.............just because you like that player!!0 -
Sponsored links:
-
There were at least two occasions where the commentators called Hector out for being beaten far too easily. (I'll use their perspective otherwise I'll be accused of having an agenda). I think 'playing well' is a very subjective term, you have your view on what that means, other people have theirs, and everyone is entitled to their opinion.
A 6 seems like a very fair score on balance. Some people think he played well, others not so well, so he gets an average mark. I think you'd struggle to find any CB historically getting a 7 when the team has conceded 3 goals and drawn/lost.0 -
He's certainly capable of being beaten too easily, as he was for Oxford's first goal. Saying that doesn't mean I have an agenda. I also think he could be replaced by better. I also believe anyone giving a three on Saturday was being unfair - that's just my opinion of course, which I'm allowed. I'll also admit I can be wrong (quite often), but I do try to be fair Chunsey. 😊
PS I'm also aware that I'm banging on about Hector way too much. Apologies for that.1 -
I’m not a massive fan of Hector, but he was pretty decent against Port Vale. Very unusually Jones was a bigger issue.1