Players Marks: Reading v Charlton (closure later, and stats by Friday)

MANNION: 4
A.MITCHELL: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 6
RAMSAY: 6
BERRY: 6
COVENTRY: 6.5 MOM
DOCHERTY: 5
SMALL: 5
AHADME: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 6
ANDERSON: 6

MANNION: 3 - Very poor game from him
A.MITCHELL: 5
JONES: 3 - Amateurish mistake for their 2nd, very poor
GILLESPHEY: 4
RAMSAY: 6 (MOTM)
BERRY: 4
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY: 5
SMALL: 3 - Hurry back Josh
AHADME: 2
T.CAMPBELL: 2
ANDERSON: 3 
Referee: 

ANEKE:  n/a
GODDEN: n/a
KANU: n/a

MANNION: 4
A.MITCHELL: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 6
RAMSAY: 6.5
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 6
SMALL: 5
AHADME: 4
T.CAMPBELL: 6
ANDERSON:  5
Referee: 4

Mannion: 4
A.Mitchell: 6
Jones: 5
Gillesphey: 6
Ramsay: 6
Berry: 5
Coventry: 6
Docherty: 6
Small: 5
Adahme: 5
T.Campbell: 6
Anderson: 5

Referee: 6

MANNION: 4
A.MITCHELL: 5
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY: 5
RAMSAY: 6
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 6
SMALL: 4
AHADME: 3
T.CAMPBELL: 5.5
ANDERSON: 5
Referee: 4

MANNION: 5, Couldn't do anything about the goals but his dribble out summed up the side today.
A.MITCHELL: 6, Didn't do much wrong.
JONES: 5, He was right about the keeper getting a touch but standing there moaning caused the goal
GILLESPHEY: 5, Not at it today 
RAMSAY: 7, One of the better ones 
BERRY: 5, Unlucky with the one chance but got the wrong side of his man for the booking that got him subbed. 
COVENTRY: 7, One of the few who could pass, but those deadball kicks, really poor. 
DOCHERTY: 8, MOM, worked hard but there were too many others who didn't 
SMALL: 4, For whatever reason, and I have my theory, this is not the same player as last season.
AHADME: 4, Awful clumsy display. 
T.CAMPBELL: 4, When you are under the cosh you need your forwards to keep the ball, he doesn't know how to do it and got found out today. 
ANDERSON, 4, Came on and showed the part of his game that seriously needs work, passing !  
Referee:5, Bored with having to mark these clowns  

MANNION: 4
A.MITCHELL: 4
JONES: 4
GILLESPHEY: 5
RAMSAY: 6
BERRY: 4
COVENTRY: 7
DOCHERTY: 4
SMALL: 5
AHADME: 3
T.CAMPBELL: 6
ANDERSON: 3
Referee: 5

MANNION: 5
A.MITCHELL: 5.5
JONES: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 6
RAMSAY: 6
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 6.5
DOCHERTY: 6.5
SMALL: 5
AHADME: 4.5
T.CAMPBELL: 5.5
ANDERSON: 5
Referee: 6

MANNION:       6
A.MITCHELL:   5.5 
JONES:              5.5 
GILLESPHEY:   5.5 
RAMSAY:           5.5
BERRY:               5
COVENTRY:       6
DOCHERTY:       6
SMALL:              5.5
AHADME:           4
T.CAMPBELL:    6
ANDERSON:       5.5
Referee:               6

ANEKE:  n/a
GODDEN: n/a
KANU: n/a

MANNION: 5
A.MITCHELL: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 7
RAMSAY: 6
BERRY: 4
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 6
SMALL: 5
AHADME: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
ANDERSON: 5.5

MANNION 4 Scary
A.MITCHELL 5 ok
JONES 4 needs to be aware
GILLESPHEY 4 can’t tackle
RAMSEY 5 ok
BERRY 5 great save from his shot 
COVENTRY 4 poor
DOCHERTY 5 Not in the game 
SMALL 5 Lost
AHADME 4 lost in this system 
T.CAMPBELL 4 lazy player needs to do more needs a loan. 
ANDERSON 3 crap

MANNION - 5 - feels like he got a bit caught out for the first goal, and what was he doing getting caught on the ball?!
A.MITCHELL - 6 - we actually looked fairly solid for large parts of the game, and Mitchell looks to be the one who is organising a lot of it.
JONES - 5 - as with Mitchell above but loses a point for the schoolboy error of giving them the ball straight back.
GILLESPHEY - 4.5 - thought most of their play came down that side. Wasn’t helped by Small but struggled today.
RAMSAY - 6.5 - probably as good as anyone but didn’t really impact the game.
BERRY - 4.5 - was the scapegoat of an awful first half for the entire midfield, probably taken off because he was on a card.
COVENTRY - 5.5 - not great, but not terrible. His set pieces are far too floaty to cause any real problems.
DOCHERTY - 6 - love his passion and effort but didn’t really show enough quality today.
SMALL - 4 - this is why we signed Edwards, in a game where you are defending more than attacking, Small gets shown up a little.
AHADME - 6 - absolutely our best player in the first half, but looked like he was knackered coming out for the second half. Needs a goal to build his confidence.
T.CAMPBELL - 5 - awful first half, offered precisely zero. Doesn’t anticipate anything, he just tries to react. Ironically, just started to look threatening when he came off. Probably time for someone else to have a go.
ANDERSON - 3.5 - I knew we were in trouble when he was our game changer. He proved me right by consistently failing to make simple passes. Hopefully with Allan Campbell now in, we don’t see Anderson again for some time.
Referee - 2 - he was absolutely not the reason we lost the game, but he was atrocious.

Awful performance today, but we all would have taken 9 points from the first 4 games. Hopefully we get a response from that performance next game.

MANNION: 5
A.MITCHELL: 6
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY: 5
RAMSAY: 5 
BERRY: 2
COVENTRY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
SMALL: 6
AHADME:3 
T.CAMPBELL: 5
ANDERSON: 4
Referee: 7

MANNION: 4 
A.MITCHELL: 5
JONES: 4 thick as shit letting that go out. Second goal all his fault 
GILLESPHEY: 3 bring in Potts this bloke Looks awful 
RAMSAY: 5 
BERRY: 5
COVENTRY: 5
DOCHERTY:6
SMALL: 5
AHADME: 4 donkeyish 
T.CAMPBELL: 5
ANDERSON: 4

MANNION: 5
A.MITCHELL: 6
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY: 6
RAMSAY: 5
BERRY: 4
COVENTRY: 6
DOCHERTY: 6
SMALL: 5
AHADME: 5
T.CAMPBELL: 5
ANDERSON: 6
Referee: 7