Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: L1 Playoff Final: Charlton v Leyton Orient (closing Monday lunchtime)

aliwibble
aliwibble Posts: 27,158
edited May 26 in General Charlton
Your marks please
MANNION: 
RAMSAY: 
JONES: 
GILLESPHEY: 
EDWARDS: 
COVENTRY: 
DOCHERTY: 
SMALL: 
GILBERT: 
CAMPBELL: 
GODDEN:
WATSON:
ANDERSON:
Referee:
Other subs:
Aneke
Mbick
«134

Comments

  • SteveACS
    SteveACS Posts: 397
    MANNION: -10
    RAMSAY: - 10
    JONES: - 10
    GILLESPHEY: - 11
    EDWARDS: - 10
    COVENTRY: - 10
    DOCHERTY: - 10
    SMALL: - 10
    GILBERT: - 10
    CAMPBELL: - 10
    GODDEN:- 10
    WATSON:- 10
    ANDERSON:- 10
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 21,614
    I also echo the above, 10s for everyone, 11 for Macca
  • Holdkneebomb
    Holdkneebomb Posts: 1,271
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    GILLESPHEY: 9
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    DOCHERTY: 7
    SMALL: 7
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN: 8
    WATSON: 7
    ANDERSON: 8
    Referee: 6
    Other subs:
    Aneke 7
    Mbick 7
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,823
    SteveACS said:
    MANNION: -10
    RAMSAY: - 10
    JONES: - 10
    GILLESPHEY: - 11
    EDWARDS: - 10
    COVENTRY: - 10
    DOCHERTY: - 10
    SMALL: - 10
    GILBERT: - 10
    CAMPBELL: - 10
    GODDEN:- 10
    WATSON:- 10
    ANDERSON:- 10

    This
  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 51,569
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 7
    GILLESPHEY: 9
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    SMALL: 6
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    GODDEN: 7.5
    WATSON: 6
    ANDERSON: 7.5
    Referee: 6
    Other subs:
    Aneke
    Mbick
  • lancashire lad
    lancashire lad Posts: 15,708
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 9.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    DOCHERTY: 8
    SMALL: 8
    GILBERT: 8
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN: 9
    WATSON:7
    ANDERSON:7
    Referee:7
  • NornIrishAddick
    NornIrishAddick Posts: 9,632
    SteveACS said:
    MANNION: -10
    RAMSAY: - 10
    JONES: - 10
    GILLESPHEY: - 11
    EDWARDS: - 10
    COVENTRY: - 10
    DOCHERTY: - 10
    SMALL: - 10
    GILBERT: - 10
    CAMPBELL: - 10
    GODDEN:- 10
    WATSON:- 10
    ANDERSON:- 10

    I agree, provided these are not minus amounts.
  • Jonniesta
    Jonniesta Posts: 1,173

    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 10
    EDWARDS: 9
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 7.5
    SMALL: 7
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 8
    GODDEN: 8
    WATSON: 8
    ANDERSON: 8
    Referee: 7
    Other subs:
    Aneke
    Mbick
    First 10 mark of the season, but totally deserved. For Shirtliff, Mendonca and Bauer... now read Macca Gillesphey! 
  • Stuart_the_Red
    Stuart_the_Red Posts: 1,921
    MANNION: 10
    RAMSAY: 10
    JONES: 10
    GILLESPHEY: 10
    EDWARDS: 10
    COVENTRY: 10
    DOCHERTY: 10
    SMALL: 10
    GILBERT: 10
    CAMPBELL: 10
    GODDEN: 10
    WATSON:10
    ANDERSON: 10
    Referee: 7

    An all round excellent, fighting team performance!

  • Sponsored links:



  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,268
    edited May 25
    MANNION: 9 claimed every high ball in the area
    RAMSAY: 9 was struggling for fitness but class
    JONES: 9 rock 
    GILLESPHEY: 9.5 Macca you beautiful man.
    EDWARDS: 9 our Scottish battler
    COVENTRY: 9 hard game but gives 100% in the midfield battle
    DOCHERTY: 8.5 covered some distance keeping the Orient out.
    SMALL: 8  Stay with CAFC, Thierry.
    GILBERT: 8 The loanee did fine
    CAMPBELL: ,8 put in a shift without can't breaking free
    GODDEN:8.5 not Godden again but led the line with his normal high work rate.
    WATSON:8  did a job.
    ANDERSON:8.5 Got involved straight away.
    Referee: 8 Didn't give Lloyd the early card when it could have been a yellow.
    Other subs:
    Aneke first time shot nearly scored.
    Mbick looks very raw.

  • cafcrocky87
    cafcrocky87 Posts: 422
    edited May 25
    MANNION: 9
    RAMSAY: 9.5
    JONES: 9.5
    GILLESPHEY: 10
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    DOCHERTY: 8
    SMALL: 7
    GILBERT: 8
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN: 7
    WATSON:7.5
    ANDERSON: 8
    Referee: 8
  • cafc4ever
    cafc4ever Posts: 571
    MANNION: 9
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    GILLESPHEY: 9.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 8.5
    DOCHERTY: 8
    SMALL: 8
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    GODDEN: 7.5
    WATSON: 7
    ANDERSON: 8
    Referee: 9

    Other subs:
    Aneke 7
    Mbick 5
  • kenhem
    kenhem Posts: 178
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8.5
    SMALL: 7
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN: 7
    WATSON: 6.5
    ANDERSON: 8
    Referee: 7
  • Danny Addick
    Danny Addick Posts: 3,952
    edited May 25
    MANNION: 9
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    GILLESPHEY: 8.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6,5
    SMALL: 6.5
    GILBERT: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    GODDEN: 6
    WATSON: 6

    ANDERSON: 7
  • Rossman92
    Rossman92 Posts: 3,687
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 8
    GILLESPHEY: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 8
    SMALL: 7.5
    GILBERT: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    GODDEN: 7
    WATSON: 6.5
    ANDERSON: 7.5
    Referee: 8
    Other subs:
    Aneke: 7.5
    Mbick: 6
  • newyorkaddick
    newyorkaddick Posts: 3,057
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 8
    GILLESPHEY: 8
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    SMALL: 6
    GILBERT: 4
    CAMPBELL: 5
    GODDEN: 5
    WATSON: 5
    ANDERSON: 6
    Referee: 7
  • gringo
    gringo Posts: 697

    MANNION:       9   very safe hands one excellent save.
    RAMSAY:         9    
    JONES:            9
    GILLESPHEY:  10
    EDWARDS:      8
    COVENTRY:     8
    DOCHERTY:     9
    SMALL:             8
    GILBERT:         7
    CAMPBELL:     7
    GODDEN:         7
    WATSON:         6
    ANDERSON:    6
    Referee:           6
    Other subs:
    Aneke
    Mbick

  • MattTeesHeader
    MattTeesHeader Posts: 634
    MANNION: 9
    RAMSAY: 9
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 9.5
    EDWARDS: 9
    COVENTRY: 8 
    DOCHERTY: 8
    SMALL: 7.5
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN:  7.5
    WATSON: 6
    ANDERSON: 6
    Referee:7
  • charente addick
    charente addick Posts: 3,850
    aliwibble said:
    Your marks please
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 10
    EDWARDS: 9
    COVENTRY: 8
    DOCHERTY: 8.5
    SMALL: 7.5
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN:8
    WATSON:7.5
    ANDERSON:8
    Referee:6.5
    Other subs:
    Aneke8
    Mbick7


  • Sponsored links:



  • Pavoren007
    Pavoren007 Posts: 2,552
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 10
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    DOCHERTY: 8
    SMALL: 7
    GILBERT: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN: 8
    WATSON:7
    ANDERSON: 8
    Referee: 7
    Other subs:
    Aneke
    Mbick 
  • JohnnyH2
    JohnnyH2 Posts: 5,383
    MANNION: 7
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    GILLESPHEY: 9
    EDWARDS: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    SMALL: 6
    GILBERT: 6
    CAMPBELL: 5
    GODDEN: 6
    WATSON: 6
    ANDERSON: 7
    Referee: 7
    Other subs:
    Aneke 6
    Mbick 5
  • thetomahawkkid
    thetomahawkkid Posts: 772

    MANNION: 8 Some good catches, and very assured all game.
    RAMSAY: 8.5 Very strong again and another good block when needed.
    JONES: 8.5 Another dominant display.
    GILLESPHEY: 9.5 Not only did he score the goal that won us promotion, but he was magnificent defensively.
    EDWARDS: 8 Another component of our rock-steady defence.
    COVENTRY: 7.5 Decent, but overrun at times.
    DOCHERTY: 7.5 Same as Coventry.
    SMALL: 7 He was handled well.
    GILBERT: 7.5 Some tidy passing and worked hard too.
    CAMPBELL: 7 Largely marked out of the game, but won the free kick  that produced the goal.
    GODDEN: 7 Worked hard, but only had crumbs to feed off.
    WATSON: 7 Slotted in fine.
    ANDERSON: 7 Usual great work rate.
    Referee: 7 Quite decent apart from his comms.
    Other subs:
    Aneke 7 Did okay. A couple of decent bits of skill. Bye bye Chuks.
    Mbick 6 Didn't really get into game.

  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,977
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    GILLESPHEY: 8
    EDWARDS: 8
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 7.5
    SMALL: 7
    GILBERT: 7.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    GODDEN: 6.5
    WATSON: 6.5
    ANDERSON: 7

  • mattwils
    mattwils Posts: 219
    MANNION: 7
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 8
    GILLESPHEY: 8
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 7
    SMALL: 7.5
    GILBERT: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    GODDEN: 7
    WATSON:6.5
    ANDERSON:7
    Referee: 7
    Other subs:
    Aneke 6
    Mbick 5
  • Bridgeboy
    Bridgeboy Posts: 134
    MANNION: 8
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 9.5
    GILLESPHEY: 9.5
    EDWARDS: 9
    COVENTRY: 8
    DOCHERTY: 8
    SMALL: 7.5
    GILBERT: 8
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    GODDEN: 8
    WATSON: 7.5
    ANDERSON: 8.5
    Referee: 7
  • Orpingtony
    Orpingtony Posts: 303

    MANNION: 9
    RAMSAY: 10
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 10
    EDWARDS: 9
    COVENTRY: 10
    DOCHERTY: 9
    SMALL: 9
    GILBERT: 9
    CAMPBELL: 10
    GODDEN:9
    WATSON:9
    ANDERSON:10
    Referee:8
    Other subs:
    Aneke 9
    Mbick9

  • vff
    vff Posts: 6,915
    edited May 25
    MANNION: 8 - Caught everything in the air, barely a shot to save
    RAMSAY: 8 - another great block
    JONES: 9 - Immense, leader & brilliant block from Kelman
    GILLESPHEY: 9.5 - Excellent free kick, with a bit of curl and very good defensively
    EDWARDS: 8  - Integral to rock solid defence
    COVENTRY: 8 - worked hard
    DOCHERTY: 7 - kept going, took a couple of knocks to the head
    SMALL: 7 - couple of good runs
    GILBERT: 7 -  good as cover for Berry
    CAMPBELL: 7 - Won free kick with run, that led to goal
    GODDEN: 7.5 - Worked hard, and excellent covering tackle near end of first half.
    WATSON: 7  - Good cover
    ANDERSON: 7 - Good energy 
    Referee: 7 - good referee - didn't throw the cards around, tec fail but that's not his fault
    Other subs:
    Aneke - Contributed as sub, held the ball up
    Mbick - Good experience to be in play off final


  • JamesSeed
    JamesSeed Posts: 17,416
    edited May 25
    Why not:
    MANNION: 10
    RAMSAY: 10
    JONES: 10
    GILLESPHEY: 10* MotM
    EDWARDS: 10
    COVENTRY: 10
    DOCHERTY: 10
    SMALL: 10
    GILBERT: 10
    CAMPBELL: 10
    GODDEN: 10
    WATSON:10
    ANDERSON: 10
    Referee: 10 (and extra three points for not ballsing it up). 
  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 13,438
    MANNION: 10 - Seems ridiculous but he did what he had to which wasn't much other that covering shots going wide until the 11 minutes of injury time, when crosses were coming in. He caught everything and was the only player on our team capable of killing Orient's momentum. He made 3 or 4 huge catches to stop them building anything and that's him doing 100% of what he had to do today perfectly. What could he have done better?
    RAMSAY: 8 - A bit lax chasing back at times and bailed out by his pace but he doesn't even let Mannion do any work as he gets his foot out to block every shot
    JONES: 8 - Won everything in the air and honestly felt like our biggest attacking threat when the ball fell to his feet in advanced positions towards the end
    GILLESPHEY: 9 - Along with Edwards controlled Agyei and got the winner. Beaut
    EDWARDS: 8 - Forced Agyei to do nothing but send left foot crosses out of play and didn't let them stretch us at all
    COVENTRY: 8 - Dominant defensively, did was he needed to
    DOCHERTY: 8 - Ran everywhere, didn't let anyone get away from him and made them play sideways. Absolutely incredible performance off the ball and the only way they could run at us was from the right back cutting in
    SMALL: 7 - Just doesn't get the ball enough. Had their full back on toast on the inside but wasted the best opening with a pass for Godden that was too heavy. We need to invovle him more
    GILBERT: 6.5 - Worked but visibly tired and if that Kelman shot hadn't hit the bar after he didn't bring his man down running through he would have been flensed.
    CAMPBELL: 7 - Didn't offer enough on the ball but turned Beckles into a comedy show as the game went on. Had his panicking, slipping everywhere and even beat him for a header. Took their most charismatic and inspiring player and made him look a bit silly
    GODDEN: 8 - Won a ridiculous number of headers, chased down crosses and even sprinted back to nick the ball of an Orient player well inside our half as they started to build up some steam. Such a clever player
    WATSON: 7 - Did his job, didn't let anyone past him
    ANDERSON: 8 - Was his usual self but with a bit of added calm in the final third. Teed Doc up nicely and should have got an assist to kill the game but for Mbick being his option on the break
    Referee: 5 - Obviously wanted to let things flow but didn't give TC enough protection and how Beckles didn't get a card I will never know. Gave us the free kick when it mattered (not that he couldn't) though and didn't book Mannion despite him treating the last ten like a nap so I'll take it
    Other subs:
    Aneke 7 - Targeted the space Beckles had been in previously and they couldn't get round him.
    Mbick 5 - Was on a hiding to nothing coming on in a game of that significance but I'm yet to see anything. Threw away the chance to either wind the clock down or kill the game and was lucky it didn't cost us. Not really his fault though, I think Jones has put him in a tough spot there.


This discussion has been closed.

Categories

“Marketplace”