Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Wendies (closes Sunday lunchtime)

13»

Comments

  • Jonniesta
    Jonniesta Posts: 1,159
    At the game

    KAMINSKI: 6

    JONES: 6.5

    BURKE: 7 (inc + 1 for the goal)

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 7 (inc +1 for that cross)

    COVENTRY: 5.5

    CAREY: 8.5 MoM

    DOCHERTY: 5.5

    BELL: 5.5

    KELMAN: 5

    CAMPBELL: 5

    Referee: 3

    Subs: LEABURN: 6

    OLAOFE: 6.5

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a



  • KAMINSKI: 7 pretty steady 

    BURKE: 7.5 decent wnough extra mark for Well taken goal 

    JONES: 8 class as usual

    GILLESPHEY: 7.5 solid 

    BREE: 7 not great today but still gets another assist and put in some good deliveries 

    COVENTRY: 7 was slightly worried with early booking but broke up play well 

    CAREY: 8.5 motm Great performance. still can’t get over he was free and is currently out front runner for poty.

    DOCHERTY: 6.5 busy captains performance but quieter than of late 

    BELL: 8 a class composed strong skillful defender

    KELMAN: 7 was praying he was gonna stick that chance away first half but so great link up play 

    CAMPBELL: 6 not happening for him of late need to give Olafe a start and bring TC on last 25

    Referee: 3 shocking worse than some of the league one refs we had 

    Subs: LEABURN: 5.5 good in air today but offered little else 

    OLAOFE: 7 Looked a threat deserves a start 

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a

  • KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 7.5

    DOCHERTY: 6.5

    BELL: 7.5

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 5.5

    Referee: 4

    Subs: LEABURN: 5

    OLAOFE: 6

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a

  • Pavoren007
    Pavoren007 Posts: 2,529

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 6.5

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 5.5

    CAMPBELL: 5.5

    Referee: 2

    Subs: LEABURN: 6

    OLAOFE: 6

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a 

  • Hartleypete
    Hartleypete Posts: 4,702
    edited October 19

    KAMINSKI: 6

    JONES: 6

    BURKE: 6

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 5

    CAREY: 6

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 6

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL:6

    Referee: 

    Subs: LEABURN: 5

    OLAOFE:6


    Ref 0

  • roseandcrown
    roseandcrown Posts: 7,588
    edited October 19

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    BREE: 6.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8.5

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7.5

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL:6.5

    Referee: 2

    Subs: LEABURN: 7

    OLAOFE: 6.5

  • CafcWest
    CafcWest Posts: 6,173

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    Referee: 5

    Subs: LEABURN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7

  • Martinspringle
    Martinspringle Posts: 8
    edited October 19

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 7.5

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

    Referee: 4

    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a

  • JustFloydRoad
    JustFloydRoad Posts: 1,633

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 8

    BURKE: 7 

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 8 Assist king

    COVENTRY: 6 disappointing considering 

    CAREY: 8 Well taken goal

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 7 broke away  few times 

    CAMPBELL: 7 best performance since promotion 

    Referee: Very poor.

    Subs: LEABURN: 6 was brought on to waste time, won a few fouls 

    OLAOFE: 7

    Ramsay: Solid when came on

    Knibbs: Nothing much to note

    J.R-C: Came on as a fresh pair of legs. 


    JONES: Manic as ever 

  • Pedro45
    Pedro45 Posts: 5,828

    KAMINSKI: 7 - Solid game, bar one stupid throw out

    JONES: 8 - Excellent game and leadership

    BURKE: 7 - Did OK but exposed by pace

    GILLESPHEY: 7 - Did OK and got stuck in

    BREE: 6 - Quiet game overall, despite nice assist

    COVENTRY: 6 - Early booking quelled his desire slightly

    CAREY: 8.5 - Excellent and could have scored more

    DOCHERTY: 8 - Very good throughout

    BELL: 7.5 - Decent

    KELMAN: 4 - Offers little and blew his big chance (again)

    CAMPBELL: 5 - Another quiet game from TC; he really needs a rest!

    Referee: 7 - Good first half but why could he see the fouls against our subs strikers late in the game?

    Subs: LEABURN: 7 - Got stuck in and did well

    OLAOFE: 7 - Needs a start please Nathan!


  • Sponsored links:



  • bristoladdick
    bristoladdick Posts: 1,148

    KAMINSKI: 6

    BURKE:7

    JONES:7

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    BREE: 6

    COVENTRY: 6.5

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 7

    LEABURN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7

    Referee: 3



  • mendonca
    mendonca Posts: 9,412
    edited October 19

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 9

    BURKE: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 6

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 6

    Referee: 5

    Subs: LEABURN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7

  • cafc4ever
    cafc4ever Posts: 566

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 8

    BURKE: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 7.5

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 2

    Subs: LEABURN: 6

    OLAOFE: 7

  • KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 7.5

    JONES: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 2

    Subs: LEABURN: 6

    OLAOFE: 7

  • AFKABartram
    AFKABartram Posts: 57,840

    marks 0.5 to 10.0 please:

    sorry it seems to be a double spacing which I can't change

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    BURKE: 7

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 6

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 6.5

    BELL: 7.5

    KELMAN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 6

    Referee: 3

    Subs: LEABURN: 6.5

    OLAOFE: 6.5

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a


  • SteveACS
    SteveACS Posts: 377

    KAMINSKI: - 7 Solid. Unlucky with rhe goal.

    BURKE: - 7 Powerful in the air, and a goal, but scares me. So slow, and the turning circle of an Isle of Wight ferry. When he decides to go forward, if we lose possession,  there's no way he'll get back. Absolutely the right decision to replace him with Ramsay.

    JONES: - 8 Is there a centre back anywhere mor dominant in the air than Lloydy? Imperious. Again.

    GILLESPHEY: - 6.5 We've lost some pace in central defence with the injury to Edwards. Burke and Macca don't give us the flexibility that Ramsay and Bell do. But, he's a calming presence, and doesn't scare me as much as Burke.

    BREE: - 6 After the recent heady heights, this was back to earth with a bump. Still good delivery from set pieces, including an assist, but late on I was clamouring for Apter to come on...

    COVENTRY: - 6 Possibly his worst game this season. He was probably affected by the early booking, but didn't dominate like he usually does. Some poor passing, too.

    CAREY: - 8 MotM Worked so hard in the first half. Leading the press, and starting and finishing the first goal. Visibly tired in the 2nd half. Irreplaceable at the moment.

    DOCHERTY: - 6 Again, not as physically dominant as in recent weeks. Still got around the pitch well, but always seemed to get there a bit late. He's allowed an average game, after some of the barnstormers he's had recently.

    BELL: - 8 We know why Jones didn't look for another left back back. Quick, and a decent level of distribution. Very calm defensively. With Carey, one of the signings of the summer.

    KELMAN: - 7.5 Really very good. Pulled the centre backs all over the park, and some lovely touches. Needs a bit of luck, really. Made a chance for himself in the first half, but his shot was blocked by a defender running back to to cover, do we don't know whether he was working the 'keeper or not. And, his body language is excellent. No moaning, just get's on with his job.

    CAMPBELL: - 6 Curate's egg of a performance. Scared them with his pace, but there was an instant in the 1st half, where his touch was pub league standard. Presses well from the front.

    Referee: I dont mark referees, and I'm not going to start with that pratt.

    Subs: LEABURN: - 5.5 Won lots of headers, but other parts of his game have disappeared. 

    OLAOFE: - 6.5 A real trier, and would probably have another goal to his name, but for a criminal assault by the 'keeper...


  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,286

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES:7

    BURKE:7

    JONES:

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY:7.5

    DOCHERTY:7

    BELL:7

    KELMAN:7

    CAMPBELL:6.5

    Referee:6.5

    Subs: LEABURN: 6.5

    OLAOFE:7

  • KAMINSKI: 6

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 7

    JONES: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL:7

    Referee: 2 Useless

    Subs: LEABURN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7


  • Bangkokaddick
    Bangkokaddick Posts: 4,299

    KAMINSKI: 7 Solid, no errors

    JONES: 7.5 So good in the air

    BURKE: 7 A couple of scary moments but scored the goal

    GILLESPHEY: 7 Remember him chasing down an attacker after an error with pace I didn't know he had!

    BREE: 7 Not as good as usual but it is great to have a quality dead ball deliverer

    COVENTRY: 6.5 OK first half but quiet second

    CAREY: 8 Doesn't stop running and chasing. No wonder he looks knackered in the final quarter. And a goal.

    DOCHERTY: 6.5 Not as dominant today as he has been this season

    BELL: 7.5 Must be the most laid-back defender we've had 

    KELMAN: 7 Played well, really should have had a goal

    CAMPBELL: 6.5 Looked tired today. Probably shouldn't have started

    Referee: 5 I thought he got most things right...until the last ten minutes!

    Subs: LEABURN: 6 Something not quite right with Myles this season

    OLAOFE: 7 Works hard and looks dangerous. Time for a start?

  • SaySomething
    SaySomething Posts: 2,530
    edited October 19
    KAMINSKI:7
    JONES:7.5
    BURKE:7
    GILLESPHEY:7
    BREE:7
    COVENTRY:6.5
    CAREY:7.5
    DOCHERTY:6
    BELL:7
    KELMAN:6.5
    CAMPBELL:6
    Referee:3 shocking missed decisions at the end - good job the linesman was awake and spotted the Wendies keeper's Harold Schumacher-esque 'challenge' on Olaofe!
    Subs: LEABURN:6
    OLAOFE:6.5

  • Sponsored links:



  • Davo55
    Davo55 Posts: 7,838

    KAMINSKI: 6.5

    JONES: 7

    BURKE: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 6.5

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 6.5

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 6.5

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    Referee: 

    Subs: LEABURN: 6

    OLAOFE: 6.5

  • crookester
    crookester Posts: 1,335
    KAMINSKI: 7

    BURKE: 7

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 6

    BREE: 6.5

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 7.5

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    Referee: 4

    Subs: LEABURN: 7

    OLAOFE: 6.5
  • Killarahales
    Killarahales Posts: 1,058

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 7.5

    BURKE: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7

    KELMAN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 2

    Subs: LEABURN: 7

    OLAOFE 7

  • Arry Addick
    Arry Addick Posts: 1,170

    KAMINSKI:  6.5 - I thought he was a bit slow to react to the shot for their goal.

    BURKE:  7

    JONES:  7.5 - Dominant in air as per.

    GILLESPHEY:  7

    BREE:  7.5 - We need to get a perm deal agreed with Southampton ASAP.

    COVENTRY:  7

    CAREY:  8 - Brilliant first half. How a no.10 should play.

    DOCHERTY:  7.5

    BELL:  7

    KELMAN:  7 - I really believe he's getting more in tune with the team/system. Just needs that 1st goal.

    CAMPBELL:  6 - Bottled a challenge (again) with their keeper in 2nd half. He's not a striker/forward...he's a winger.

    Referee: 1 - Had the right kit....apart from that, should never ref again.

    Subs: LEABURN:  6.5

    OLAOFE:  7

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a

  • rananegra
    rananegra Posts: 3,694

    KAMINSKI: 7

    JONES: 7.5

    BURKE: 7

    GILLESPHEY: 7

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 6.5

    CAREY:8

    DOCHERTY:8

    BELL:7

    KELMAN:7

    CAMPBELL:7.5  we seem to concede whenever he is taken off 

    Referee: 1 not just biased incompetent
    Subs: LEABURN: 6

    OLAOFE: 7

  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,081

    KAMINSKI: 7 decent. Unlucky with the goal. No chance with original shot and then the rebound, the player was there

    JONES: 7 solid again. Won everything in the air. If I was being extra critical, could’ve reacted quicker for their goal, and played the man onside.

    BURKE: 7.5 extra .5 for goal. Solid, but when they got on top, got done for pace

    GILLESPHEY: 7 solid again

    BREE: 7.5 extra .5 for assist. Tired second half

    COVENTRY: 7.5 controlled the midfield. Early booking didn’t phase him

    CAREY: 8 very very good first half. Involved in every threat.

    DOCHERTY: 8 gets better and better. The man to always give 100%. Love how he kept the crowd pumped up after the Tanto challenge before the ref got told how to do his job by one of the assistants.

    BELL: 7 So calm on the ball again

    KELMAN: 7.5 worked his socks off. Really improved his hold up play. Game changed when he went off

    CAMPBELL: 7 his pace is frightening. Just doesn’t use it enough. Game changed when he went off

    Referee: 2 abysmal. The fact he went to give the foul on Knibbs on the edge of the box, then changed his mind… and to top it off, didn’t give the foul on Tanto and got helped out by his officials who were miles away. Gave them everything on the day. Extra .5 for listening to his officials. Says it all 

    Subs: LEABURN: 6.5 done okay, but not the change that we needed at that time

    OLAOFE: 6.5 same as Leaburn

    Ramsay: n/a

    Knibbs: n/a

    J.R-C: n/a good to see him get minutes