Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks: Charlton v Hull

24

Comments

  • Nicholas
    Nicholas Posts: 7,812
    Kaminski 6
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 7.5
    Gillesphey 7.5
    Clarke 6
    Docherty 8.5 brilliant end of season would def have him around for another year as a squad player 
    Coady 7
    Carey 5
    Fevrier 8 Pretty much identical to Thierry Small frustrating but can show quality. If we had signed a more defensive LWB instead of chambers think we would have seen a lot more of him. 
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 9
    Burke 6
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 6
  • Dugdaleclass
    Dugdaleclass Posts: 604

    Kaminski: 7 Bizarre delayed reaction to the shirt pull for their goal but was very good in all other aspects of his game. Held on well to shots and was excellent in taking difficult crosses 

    Sichenje: 5 Was a relief when he went off as he looked like red card material  

    Jones: 9 Commanding as always

    Gillesphey: 6.5 Got skinned once in the box in the first half but was solid enough throughout

    Clarke: 5 Other will remember this as a great afternoon's work. He won't


    Docherty: 9 Never stopped working and trying even when carrying a bad injury. A true leader

    Coady: 8 Has bought balance and calmness to the team. Great ball to Kelman for the first goal


    Carey: 5 Tried the head down and shoot ploy twice and failed. Looking a bit of busted flush


    Fevrier: 9.5 Works hard and has that little bit of stardust that makes things happen. Cracking goal. Get him signed up


    Knibbs: 8 Ran his socks off for the cause and never let their back line settle


    Kelman: 9 An all action performance topped off with a sumptuous goal. Message is clear - get the ball to his feet and things will happen


    Burke: 7 Lacks pace but did fine on the right hand side

    Chambers: 6 Had his hands full trying to deal with their very gifted number 10


    Campbell: 7 Immediately became an outlet for us and gave their number 2 (who was on a yellow) the run around 

    Dykes n/a Did well in covering for the struggling Doc


    Ref: 6 Missed the tug on Kaminski's  shorts but ok


    Special mention for the pitch: Back to its tip top appearance similar to a couple of years ago. Well done to the ground staff.

  • Stuart_the_Red
    Stuart_the_Red Posts: 2,003

    Kaminski: 7
    Sichenje: 6
    Jones: 7
    Gillesphey: 7
    Clarke: 6
    Docherty: 8
    Coady: 7
    Carey: 7
    Fevrier: 9
    Knibbs: 8
    Kelman: 9
    Burke - 7
    Chambers - 7
    Campbell - 7
    Dykes n/a

    Ref - 6

  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 1,954

    Kaminski 6
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 7
    Gillesphey 6 
    Clarke 4 
    Docherty 8 
    Coady 6 
    Carey 5
    Fevrier 9 
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 9
    Burke 7 
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 6
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 7

  • Eric_Dales
    Eric_Dales Posts: 436

    Kaminski: 6
    Sichenje: 6
    Jones: 7
    Gillesphey: 6
    Clarke: 6
    Docherty: 7
    Coady: 6
    Carey: 6
    Fevrier: 8
    Knibbs: 7
    Kelman: 8.5
    Burke: 6
    Chambers: 6
    Campbell: 6
    Dykes n/a

    Ref: 6



  • jose
    jose Posts: 1,240

    Kaminski 7.5
    Sichenje 7
    Jones 9
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 7
    Docherty 9
    Coady 7.5
    Carey 7
    Fevrier 9
    Knibbs 8
    Kelman 9.5
    Burke 7
    Chambers 7
    Campbell 7
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 7.5

  • kentred2
    kentred2 Posts: 2,431
    Kaminski 8
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey7
    Clarke 6
    Docherty 9
    Coady 9
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 8
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 8
    Burke 8
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 7
  • superdulvertonred
    superdulvertonred Posts: 1,225
    At the game 
    Kaminski 7
    Sichenje 7
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey7
    Clarke 6
    Docherty 9
    Coady 8
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 8.5
    Knibbs 7.5
    Kelman 9
    Burke 7
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 8

  • Scott
    Scott Posts: 258

    Kaminski 7.5
    Sichenje 5
    Jones 7
    Gillesphey 6.5
    Clarke 5
    Docherty 8.5
    Coady 7.5
    Carey 5
    Fevrier 8 
    Knibbs 7.5
    Kelman 9
    Burke 7 
    Chambers 5
    Campbell 7
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 7



  • swords_alive
    swords_alive Posts: 4,847

    Kaminski  7
    Sichenje   6.5
    Jones    7
    Gillesphey  6.5
    Clarke  6.5
    Docherty  7
    Coady  7
    Carey  6.5
    Fevrier  8
    Knibbs  7
    Kelman  8
    Burke   6.5
    Chambers  6.5
    Campbell  7
    Dykes n/a

    Ref  7


  • Sponsored links:



  • Redrobo
    Redrobo Posts: 11,402

    Kaminski - 7
    Sichenje - 6
    Jones - 7
    Gillesphey - 7
    Clarke - 6
    Docherty - 8
    Coady - 7.5
    Carey - 7
    Fevrier - 9 mom
    Knibbs - 8
    Kelman - 9
    Burke - 7
    Chambers - 7
    Campbell - 8
    Dykes n/a

    Ref - 7

  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,845
    edited April 26

    Kaminski 7.5  I didn't notice the shirt tug at first but he did take balls in the air which isn't normally a strength of his.
    Sichenje ,6 once he got the early booking as Clarke missed his grab ! It maybe was fortunate that he had a knock because he could've easily have pickup another card. A work in progress.
    Jones 8 Lloyd is always playing with injuries at the business end of the season. Our lion heart.
    Gillesphey 7 no cock up and good to see the Wembley hero enjoy a victory.
    Clarke 5 Harry has crazy moments and could've been book seconds before Sichenje but missed ! At fault for giving away the corner goal and he is erratic but he does give 100%.
    Docherty 8.5 The Doch has been outstanding at the business end of the season. "Popped" his groin but stayed on as we couldn't make any more subs. Great engine 
    Coady 7.5 his legs have gone but he has been  good for this squad on the field and at Sparrows lane. Can't see him coming permanently because of family and the drop in wages from Wrexham.
    Carey 6 Sonny has fallen from his shagging status of earlier in the season but the 8 goals helped to keep Cafc in the championship. Hopefully he can get his mojo back.
    Fevrier8.5 +1 for his magic feet goal which sealed the deal. He is similar to Small other that he ripped the net instead of striking a fan in the covered end. Would have been a 9 but that first corner ! He has flair and at 23 would be a good addition to Charlton as other leave.

    Knibbs 7.5 The jury is still out but hopefully he has a good pre season and he can prove that the hype that some of our fans said when he joined was justified. 

    Kelman 9 +1 for sublime goal. This was the complete Charlie that we had waited for all season and I felt as soon as he left the full back for dead early doors it was going to be a special day for our Essex/American boy.

    Subs:

    Burke 7 did fine

    Chambers 7 still learning but could turn into a Championship player but needs to progress more and come out his shell.could he be a back up to Josh Edwards or would he want to be ?

    Campbell  good cameo.
    Dykes n/a nearly scored.

    Ref ,7.5 Don't blame him for missing the pull of the shirt on Kaminski as there is always so much wrestling going on.

  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 35,771
    AFKABartram said:

    Hoping Lanc Lad is all ok, but in his absence please post your marks below

    Kaminski   7
    Sichenje    7
    Jones    8
    Gillesphey   7
    Clarke    6
    Docherty   8
    Coady    8
    Carey    7
    Fevrier   8
    Knibbs   7
    Kelman   8
    Burke   7
    Chambers   7
    Campbell   6
    Dykes n/a

    Ref


  • MattTeesHeader
    MattTeesHeader Posts: 658

    Kaminski 7
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 6
    Clarke 5
    Docherty 8
    Coady 7
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 8
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 9
    Burke 6
    Chambers 5
    Campbell 6
    Dykes n/a

    Ref

  • Addictedoldgit
    Addictedoldgit Posts: 1,887

    Kaminski.     7
    Sichenje.      6.5
    Jones.          7.5
    Gillesphey.   6
    Clarke.         6
    Docherty.      8 real captains performance, need an upgrade next season though.
    Coady.          7
    Carey.           6.5
    Fevrier.         8.5
    Knibbs.         6
    Kelman.        8     Goal of the season
    Burke.           7
    Chambers     6.5
    Campbell      7
    Dykes n/a

    Ref


  • crookester
    crookester Posts: 1,526
    edited April 26
    Kaminski 6
    Sichenje 5
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 5
    Docherty 9
    Coady 7
    Carey 5
    Fevrier 8
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 8
    Burke 6
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 6
    Dykes n/a
  • Blucher
    Blucher Posts: 4,316
    Kaminski: 6 - dealt uncharacteristically well with a few crosses, save for one flap following a long throw in the second half. I don’t understand how the shirt pull made him fall to the ground a second or two later unless it was an attempt to draw the ref’s attention to it. Play to the whistle
    Sichenje: 6 - a rash challenge in the second minute would have limited his effectiveness 
    Jones: 7.5 - dealt very well with McBurnie
    Gillesphey: 6 - got skinned once by Geldhardt but a generally solid game
    Clarke: 5 - erratic and made a few errors (including conceding the corner leading to Hull’s goal, although his long throws are a useful weapon
    Docherty: 7.5 - another really good performance from The Doc. Covers the ground and reads the game well
    Coady: 7 - shielded the defence effectively and used the ball well. A really good pass to Kelman for the first goal
    Carey: 6 - ok
    Fevrier: 9: MoTM - played well in both positions he was asked to fill. In addition to the winning goal, he produced one magical dribble where we got past 3 men when hemmed in
    Knibbs: 7 - one of his better games for us. Played well, effective aerially and has good physicality 
    Kelman: 8.5 - by far his best game for us and produced a wonderful strike for the opener. I was worried that the ball wouldn’t stick but we changed our approach and he gave Hull real problems, especially in the first half. 
    Burke: 6.5 - he looked shaky when he first came on but settled down and had a good second half, with Hull running out of ideas and resorting to long, high balls into the box, which were meat and drink for our back 3
    Chambers: 6 - did ok
    Campbell: 6.5 - looked lively and gave Hull another problem
  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 14,335

    Kaminski - 7 - Did a dafty going down for the goal but otherwise performed brilliantly with his catching
    Sichenje - 6 - Uh-oh levels of injured already
    Jones - 8 - Unbeatable
    Gillesphey - 7 - Solid
    Clarke - 4 - So bad. I don't think he did anything right, cost us a goal and did his level best to cost us more
    Docherty - 8 - Dominant, aggressive, quick(!) and decent on the ball
    Coady - 7.5 - Clever passer of the ball, especially long and keeps the middle contained
    Carey - 6.5 - One of his better games recently
    Fevrier - 8 MOTM - Tracked well, drove on the ball well and got the winner. Should really have had a second but the time he wasted driving the ball up the pitch the way he did was enough
    Knibbs - 7 - Aggressive, strong and very physical, his best performance by far
    Kelman - 7.5 - Incredible finish and caused chaos with his physical play. More of that please
    Burke - 7.5 - Mobile, strong, fast, intelligent with his passing, felt like the player we were told we were getting outside the injuries
    Chambers - 6.5 - Fine
    Campbell - 7 - Scared them immediately
    Dykes 6.5 - That new look is a bit American History X but carved out a good chance he nearly scored from

    Ref - 7 - Decent



  • Buglehorn
    Buglehorn Posts: 1,054
    Kaminski 7.5 
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 7
    Docherty 8
    Coady 7
    Carey 6.5 
    Fevrier 7.5
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 8.5
    Burke 7
    Chambers 6.5 
    Campbell 7
    Ref 6
  • Amos on the wing
    Amos on the wing Posts: 1,834
    edited April 26

    Kaminski 6.5
    Sichenje 5
    Jones  7
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 5
    Docherty 8
    Coady 7
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 7.5
    Knibbs 6
    Kelman 7.5
    Burke 7
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 6
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 7



  • Sponsored links:



  • Coveredendchoir
    Coveredendchoir Posts: 311

    Kaminski 6 
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 8.5
    Gillesphey 7 
    Clarke 6.5
    Docherty 9.5
    Coady 9
    Carey 7.5
    Fevrier 9.5 
    Knibbs 8.5
    Kelman 9
    Burke 7
    Chambers 7
    Campbell 7.5
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 8

  • thai malaysia addick
    thai malaysia addick Posts: 18,921

    Kaminski 7
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 7
    Gillesphey 6.5
    Clarke 6
    Docherty 9
    Coady 8
    Carey 6.5
    Fevrier 8
    Knibbs 8
    Kelman 9
    Burke 6.5
    Chambers 6.5
    Campbell 6.5
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 7

  • ateamofcorygibbs
    ateamofcorygibbs Posts: 1,273
    Kaminski 6.5
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 6.5
    Clarke 4.5
    Docherty 8
    Coady 7.5
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 8.5
    Knibbs 6.5
    Kelman 8.5 MOM
    Burke 6
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 7
    Dykes n/a
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,761
    edited April 26
    Kaminski 7 Gave away the first by throwing himself to the ground, leaving a wide open goal. Made some decent saves 2nd half. I’ll never rate him.
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 7
    Gillesphey 6.5
    Clarke 7
    Docherty 8
    Coady 7 
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 9
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 7.5
    Burke 6
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 7
    Ref 8

  • clive
    clive Posts: 20,326

    Kaminski 7
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 7
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 6.5
    Docherty 7
    Coady 7
    Carey 6.5
    Fevrier 8
    Knibbs 6.5
    Kelman 7.5
    Burke 6.5
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 6.5
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 6.5

  • Peter_G
    Peter_G Posts: 937

    Kaminski 7
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 5
    Docherty 8
    Coady 7
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 8
    Knibbs 6
    Kelman 9


    Burke 6
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 6

    Ref 6

  • Bangkokaddick
    Bangkokaddick Posts: 4,392

    Kaminski 7
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 7.5
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 5
    Docherty 8
    Coady 7.5
    Carey 5.5
    Fevrier 8.5
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 8
    Burke 7
    Chambers 6.5
    Campbell 7
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 7.5

  • wolfgang
    wolfgang Posts: 736

    Kaminski 7.5
    Sichenje 4
    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 6.5
    Clarke 5.5
    Docherty 7.5
    Coady 7
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 7.5
    Knibbs 6
    Kelman 8
    Burke 5
    Chambers 4.5
    Campbell 5
    Dykes n/a

    Ref 7.5

  • _uptheaddicks
    _uptheaddicks Posts: 344
    Kaminski 6
    Sichenje 6
    Jones 9
    Gillesphey 7
    Clarke 3
    Docherty 9
    Coady 8
    Carey 6
    Fevrier 9
    Knibbs 6
    Kelman 9
    Burke 6
    Chambers 6
    Campbell 6
  • AddicksAddict
    AddicksAddict Posts: 16,298
    Kaminski 8
    Sichenje 7

    Jones 8
    Gillesphey 7.5
    Clarke 5
    Docherty 7
    Coady 7.5
    Carey 6.5
    Fevrier 8.5
    Knibbs 7
    Kelman 8
    Burke 7
    Chambers 6.5
    Campbell 7

    Ref 9 one of the better ones this season  


Categories

“Marketplace”