Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks - Charlton 3-1 Leyton Orient

124»

Comments

  • reedy_7
    reedy_7 Posts: 11
    @ Covered End - I do in some parts agree with you, I wouldn't necessarily say Reid hasn't performed. I think there's a combination of many things in regards to why Reid doesn't play as well as he could do, and I would still today say that Reid on a poor day offers much more of a threat that Racon on a good day, as I believe his direct running and 'sometimes' early crossing is a danger for teams in this league, and many defences are slow and/or do not close down wingers quick enough at this level, therefore Reid should be able to exploit this. I don't believe has played that bad at all, just because he doesn't beat his man every time doesn't mean he is a bad player e.g.Nani (yes, I know Nani is a Premier League player but it's just an example.) Therefore with more playing time, he may improve his consistency levels or not, and then I may be proved wrong. I don't want to argue with you, but thought a different approach/opinion may be something to think about.

    Lastly, I don't think Reid is amazing, just better that Racon. I also believe that Jackson should be playing CM when fit. leaving with a Bessone - Reid - Left sided combination.

    @masicat - why do I deserve to get banned when I give him a 5 and backed it up with logical reasoning, although you clearly disagree, there is no need for me being banned, maybe you should be?
  • lancashire lad
    lancashire lad Posts: 15,699
    That's it I am now compiling the stats so no more marks thank you.
  • masicat
    masicat Posts: 5,017
    TONGUE

    CHEEK

    IN
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,240
    [cite]Posted By: reedy_7[/cite]@ Covered End - I do in some parts agree with you, I wouldn't necessarily say Reid hasn't performed. I think there's a combination of many things in regards to why Reid doesn't play as well as he could do, and I would still today say that Reid on a poor day offers much more of a threat that Racon on a good day, as I believe his direct running and 'sometimes' early crossing is a danger for teams in this league, and many defences are slow and/or do not close down wingers quick enough at this level, therefore Reid should be able to exploit this. I don't believe has played that bad at all, just because he doesn't beat his man every time doesn't mean he is a bad player e.g.Nani (yes, I know Nani is a Premier League player but it's just an example.) Therefore with more playing time, he may improve his consistency levels or not, and then I may be proved wrong. I don't want to argue with you, but thought a different approach/opinion may be something to think about.

    Lastly, I don't think Reid is amazing, just better that Racon. I also believe that Jackson should be playing CM when fit. leaving with a Bessone - Reid - Left sided combination.

    @masicat - why do I deserve to get banned when I give him a 5 and backed it up with logical reasoning, although you clearly disagree, there is no need for me being banned, maybe you should be?

    I agree with you reedy, the issue is, he just hasn't done it & as he doesn't defend as well as others, so he is a liability if he's not on his game.

Categories

“Marketplace”