PLAYERS MARKS: Championship: Bristol City v Charlton (closes Sunday teatime)

lancashire lad

marks 0.5 to 10.0

KAMINSKI: 
RAMSAY: 
BELL: 
JONES: 
EDWARDS: 
COVENTRY: 
KELMAN: 
CAMPBELL: 
DOCHERTY: 
CAREY: 
APTER: 
Referee: 
Subs: LEABURN: 
         OLAOFE: n/a
         KNIBBS: n/a
         GILLESPHEY: n/a
         ANDERSON: n/a

Bedsaddick

KAMINSKI: 6
RAMSAY: 9 MOM
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 5
CAMPBELL: 6
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5

Leaburn - 7

Steven81

KAMINSKI: 6.5
RAMSAY: 9 motm
BELL: 7.5
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 6.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 7
APTER: 8
Subs: LEABURN 7
Referee: 5.5

Pelling1993

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 7
CAMPBELL: 8
DOCHERTY: 7.5
CAREY: 7.5
APTER: 8
Referee: 4
Subs: LEABURN: 7
         OLAOFE: n/a
         KNIBBS: n/a
         GILLESPHEY: n/a
         ANDERSON: n/a

DONVANVLIET

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 6
APTER: 8
Referee: 
Subs: LEABURN: 6
         OLAOFE: 6
         KNIBBS:6
         GILLESPHEY: n/a
         ANDERSON: n/a

Pico

KAMINSKI:    7
RAMSAY:     9
BELL:          8
JONES:        8
EDWARDS:   7 
COVENTRY:  7 
KELMAN:    6
CAMPBELL  7: 
DOCHERTY:  7
CAREY:      7
APTER:   8.5
Referee: 
Subs: LEABURN:7

MattTeesHeader

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 7
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8 
Referee: 6
Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

Longtimeaddicted

KAMINSKI: 7 not a lot to do
RAMSAY: 10 outstanding 
BELL: 8
JONES: 9
EDWARDS: 8.5
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 5 really can’t lead a line being bossed by CBs 
CAMPBELL: 8 much improved did not waste the ball
DOCHERTY: 9.5 non stop graft, not pretty but very creditworthy 
CAREY: 9 as above 
APTER: 9
Referee: 4
Subs: LEABURN: 8 can’t be long until he starts 

Cloudworm

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5

BELL: 9

JONES: 9

EDWARDS: 7.5

COVENTRY: 5.5

KELMAN: 4.5 (I've seen enough. QPR get revenge for Bonne)

CAMPBELL: 7

DOCHERTY: 6

CAREY: 7

APTER: 8.5

Referee: 7.5

Subs: LEABURN: 8

RedChaser

KAMINSKI: 6.5
RAMSAY: 8.5
BELL: 7.5
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 5.5
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 7
APTER: 7.5
Referee: 4
Subs: LEABURN: 6.5

lordromford

I’m going to make a prediction that Ramsay’s score will be the highest ever for a game we didn’t win.
Apologies LL for interrupting your thread. ❤️

Danny Addick

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 8
BELL: 7
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 5 no service 
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7
APTER: 8

tangoflash

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 10
BELL: 8
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 8 
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 5
CAMPBELL: 6 
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7.5
APTER: 8
Referee: 5

MeerKat

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 9
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 5
Subs: LEABURN: 7

Valley11

KAMINSKI: 7 looked solid 
RAMSAY: 10 - never given a ten but that’s a complete performance. Outstanding. Once he kicked their two pacey wingers in the air they knew they were in a game. 
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 8.5
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 7
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7.5
APTER: 8
Referee: 
Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

vff

KAMINSKI: 7 - Not much to do, but saved what he had to, and clean sheet.
RAMSAY: 9 - Excellent -brilliant first half in particular
BELL: 7.5 -Assured. Looks as though, he may loose ball but generally doesn't. 
JONES: 8 - Strong as always
EDWARDS: 7 - Steady
COVENTRY: 7 - Steady
KELMAN: 6 - didn't really notice him in attacking third but helped team performance.
CAMPBELL: 6.5 - Ok, but lacking some end product, will happen at some point 
DOCHERTY: 7 - Steady 
CAREY: 7.5 - good energy and strength
APTER: 8 - some great crossing, drive and energy

Referee: 5 - poor referee with lots of non free kicks given

Subs: 

LEABURN: 7 - good energy and strength

OLAOFE: n/a - strong looks good

KNIBBS: n/a - 

GILLESPHEY: n/a

ANDERSON: n/a - good energy helps late on

JamesSeed

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5 MOM 
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 5.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5  Better than some are saying
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5 
Subs: LEABURN: 8 Made a difference, as did Tanto
ref: 6.5

CafcWest

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 7
CAMPBELL: 8
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 7.5
APTER: 8 
Referee: 6
Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

Pavoren007

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 10 FAUTLESS
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 7
Subs: LEABURN: 7
         OLAOFE: n/a
         KNIBBS: n/a
         GILLESPHEY: n/a
         ANDERSON: n/a 

EastSussexAddick

KAMINSKI: 8 - solid

RAMSAY: 10 - Best player on the pitch

BELL: 8 - solid 

JONES: 8.5 - commanding

EDWARDS: 7 - good defensively, but struggled in possession

COVENTRY: 7 - honest performance

KELMAN: 6 - needs to be playing off Leaburn

CAMPBELL: 5 - nowhere near good enough for this level. His processing speed isn’t there. 

DOCHERTY: 5.5 - He is going to cost us a game soon. Offers nothing in possession, and not quick enough. Works hard, but not good enough for the championship.

CAREY: 6.5 - some bright moments

APTER: 7 - very dangerous on the ball, a constant threat. 

Referee: 6 - getter than some of the league one dross, but still gave some head scratchers. 

Subs: LEABURN: 7 - looked very lively. Would love to see him up top with Kelman

RonnieMoore

KAMINSKI: 7 very little to do 
RAMSAY: 9 best game for Charlton 
BELL: 8 
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 6 worked hard with no service but keep him on 
CAMPBELL: 6 worked hard but should have been replaced instead of Kelman 
DOCHERTY: 8 one of his best games for the club 
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8
Referee: 5 poor for both sides 
Subs: LEABURN: 6 
         OLAOFE: should have been on at HT for Campbell 
         KNIBBS: n/a
         GILLESPHEY: n/a
         ANDERSON 

jose

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 8.5
BELL: 7
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 6.5
KELMAN: 5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CAREY:7 
APTER: 7.5
Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

Referee: 6

CAFCsayer

KAMINSKI: 7

RAMSAY: 9

BELL: 7.5

JONES: 8

EDWARDS: 7.5

COVENTRY: 7.5

KELMAN: 6

CAMPBELL: 6.5

DOCHERTY: 7.5

CAREY: 8

APTER: 8.5

TellyTubby

KAMINSKI:  7

RAMSAY: 9

BELL: 8

JONES: 10

EDWARDS: 7

COVENTRY: 7.5

KELMAN: 6

CAMPBELL: 7

DOCHERTY: 6

CAREY: 7

APTER: 8

Referee: 

Subs: LEABURN: 9

         OLAOFE: n/a

         KNIBBS: n/a

         GILLESPHEY: n/a

         ANDERSON: n/a

DoctorCharlton

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 7.5
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7
COVENTRY: 7
KELMAN: 5
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 6
CAREY: 7.5
APTER: 8
Referee: 5
Subs: LEABURN: 6.5

Karim_myBagheri

KAMINSKI: 6.5 not a huge amount to do. 

RAMSAY: 9 - if he carries on like this I think my crush on him might lead to love. 

BELL: 7.5

JONES: 8.5 reads the game so well. 

EDWARDS: 7.5

COVENTRY: 7 like all midfield and defence dealt with tricky situations at the back which nullified most of their possession/attacks. 

KELMAN: 5 struggles as a hold up centre forward. 

CAMPBELL: 7 felt he was better this week. 

DOCHERTY: 7

CAREY: 7.5

APTER: 8 

Referee: 6 

Subs: LEABURN: 7 makes a difference 

Chris_from_Sidcup

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9 MOTM
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 6
CAMPBELL: 6
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5

Stuart_the_Red

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 9
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 8
COVENTRY: 8
KELMAN: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8
Referee: 4
Subs: LEABURN: 7

DamoNorthStand

KAMINSKI: 7 - Not a lot to keep him busy, but did what he had to well enough. Kicking looks a bit spongefoot-esque.
RAMSAY: 9.5 - No words adequately describe how good he is.
BELL: 7.5 - Better on the ball than MG, who is a good option for me when we need the added height. But I like him overall.
JONES: 8.5 - Another player who looks at home in the Champ.
EDWARDS: 7.5 - Solid, but that knee injury worries me.
COVENTRY: 7.5 - Still think he is a better overall player than Dobbo. He looks at home at this level
KELMAN: 6.5 - No support but seeing glimpses of some nice touches coming in and we know he can finish. Will be just fine.
CAMPBELL: 7.5 - Our best outlet in the first half and ran himself in to the ground. 
DOCHERTY: 7 - Steady and looks better in the championship than league 1 so far. 
CAREY: 7.5 - Not quite as good as last week, but still very strong performance. Reminds me of Graham Stuart so much.
APTER: 8.5 - Another Rolls Royce of a player and the stand out new signing.

Referee: 5 - poor referee... agree with Brownies POV.

Subs: 

LEABURN: 7.5 - Caused chaos in the air. He is gonna be a big player this season.

OLAOFE: n/a - Another great new signing. Pace, power, and troubled them as soon as he came on.

KNIBBS: n/a - Looked sharp and instantly got involved. Nearly scored.

GILLESPHEY: n/a

ANDERSON: n/a - I was gonna say I would start him in the harder away games, then realised this was one of the harder away games.

BoPeepAddick

KAMINSKI: 7
RAMSAY: 8
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
EDWARDS: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
KELMAN: 7
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7.5
CAREY: 8
APTER: 8.5
Referee: 6.5
Subs: LEABURN: 7

Jonniesta

KAMINSKI: 6.5 bored
RAMSAY: 9.5 MoM inspired
BELL: 7.5 effective
JONES: 8.5 typical Jones
EDWARDS: 6.5 improved as it went on
COVENTRY: 8 covered brilliantly
KELMAN: 6 not his kind of game
CAMPBELL: 7 threatened
DOCHERTY: 6 not stepped up a level yet
CAREY: 7.5 impactful and links up well with Apter
APTER: 8 looks absolute class
Referee: 
Subs: LEABURN: 7
         OLAOFE: n/a made a difference
         KNIBBS: n/a
         GILLESPHEY: n/a
         ANDERSON: n/a