MATCH THREAD : Charlton Athletic V Sheffield Wednesday : Saturday 18th October 2025 : KO 15:00

fenaddick

Here is the challenge that the ref was going to let go

https://x.com/modmag1905/status/1979578164624928998?s=46&t=MojDVxh_AjG5taAWPQn6Tw

ForeverAddickted

Zulu said:

Was the referee any good ?!

Yes he was very good... Put in a good display for Sheffield Wednesday

DDOUBLEE

Olaofe still the only striker to have scored in the league so far. But yeah, wins a win. Would have appreciated it being a bit more comfortable considering the opposition but oh well

closet_addick

Valley11 said:

Wtf is Bannan complaining about the red to the Lino?
dickhead 

Need someone to poke Friar Tuck in the eye. 

RoanRedNY

Awful. But it wouldn’t be Charlton without a crappy second half hanging on to a win against a bottom 3 side.  3 points.

Dave2l

I thought we were very decent in the last 15 minutes. 

You'd have thought the wendys would have done a lot more 

Stig

Thanks for the updates everyone. If what I've read here is accurate, we've made what should have been a easy win into something rather more tense - typical Charlton. Oh well, three points is three points. Up the Addicks!

blackpool72

Enjoy league one Bannon you prick 

Karma 

stonemuse

fenaddick said:

Here is the challenge that the ref was going to let go

https://x.com/modmag1905/status/1979578164624928998?s=46&t=MojDVxh_AjG5taAWPQn6Tw

Wtf!!! That’s gotta be a massive ban 

Briston_Addick

Wendy' no 10 beong serenaded by the Cupboard End:

Bannan, Bannan, you're a ***!

🤣🤣

eastterrace6168

Roll on Tuesday, and another three points up at Portman Road...

Briston_Addick

Today's tunnel jumps brought to you in association with Carey and Burke.

Sounds like a firm of undertakers ... or grave robbers ...

Redvalleyeast

ForeverAddickted said:

Laddick01 said:

Tbf Macca just had to put that anywhere other than into the wall. 

To be fair, he did put it anywhere other than into the wall

Think he hit someones wall in Floyd Road tbf

Callumcafc

Think it shows just how poor Blackburn were. Like today, they were behind but unlike today, they rolled over, letting us dominate the second half.

Leuth

I think that red's been given for handball tbh (which it was) 

IR94

Pleased with the 3 points but awful display, especially second half, kelman needs dropping too

ForeverAddickted

stonemuse said:

fenaddick said:

Here is the challenge that the ref was going to let go

https://x.com/modmag1905/status/1979578164624928998?s=46&t=MojDVxh_AjG5taAWPQn6Tw

Wtf!!! That’s gotta be a massive ban 

Dont think it can... Referee has "acknowledged it" by giving a Red Card so it'll be in his Match Report

Unless the rules have changed, the FA can only give retrospective bans, if the Referee doesn't mention it... Because thats where they can get involved and "assist" because by not mentioning it, he's admitting he hasn't seen it.

Exiled_Addick

I think Nathan Jones will be quite upset that it took conceding a goal to finally wake us up, but we did kill the game well in the final minutes.

Could and should have been more comfortable. Sheff Weds look relegation fodder but they also have some bright players with pace and power so will have their spells in games and will give some teams a few problems as they did to us today. A better side than Sheff W would’ve punished us, I think. 

One of our less convincing performances but got the job done which is all that ultimately matters. Hopefully some lessons being learned that we need to maintain our intensity for the full 90 every match other wise even weaker teams in this division have the capability to pick us off. 

Fortune 82nd Minute

ForeverAddickted said:

stonemuse said:

fenaddick said:

Here is the challenge that the ref was going to let go

https://x.com/modmag1905/status/1979578164624928998?s=46&t=MojDVxh_AjG5taAWPQn6Tw

Wtf!!! That’s gotta be a massive ban 

Dont think it can... Referee has "acknowledged it" by giving a Red Card so it'll be in his Match Report

Unless the rules have changed, the FA can only give retrospective bans, if the Referee doesn't mention it... Because thats where they can get involved and "assist" because by not mentioning it, he's admitting he hasn't seen it.

Didnt the Millwall keeper get an extra ban after nearly taking the head of the Palace forward off in the FA cup game  last year? 

Croydon

ForeverAddickted said:

Quite comfortable, and a professional display from us, especially at  2-1 as never really were in threat

Fell over the finish line though

I'm not sure many in the ground would agree with you!

ForeverAddickted

Croydon said:

ForeverAddickted said:

Quite comfortable, and a professional display from us, especially at  2-1 as never really were in threat

Fell over the finish line though

I'm not sure many in the ground would agree with you!

What chances did Sheff Wed really waste though at 2-1, Kaminski barely had a save to make

Teams that play pretty passes, and have nothing to show for it, don't overly scare me - Thank god our Defence don't shit themselves in similar fashion whenever the opposition get a goal back.

LoOkOuT

Thanks everyone, over to the post-match thread.