Players Marks: Charlton v Sheffield Utd (closes Sunday late luncheon)
Comments
-
KAMINSKI: 8
BREE: 4
RAMSAY: 5
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 6
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 7
KELMAN: 6.5
Referee: 7
Subs: CAREY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 6
DYKES: 6.5
0 -
-
KAMINSKI 9
BREE 6
RAMSAY 6
JONES 8
GILLESPHEY 7
CLARKE 7
ANDERSON 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO 7
KNIBBS 6
LEABURN 8
KELMAN 6
CAREY 6
CAMPBELL 7
DYKES 70 -
KAMINSKI: 8 MOM Best keeper argument over
BREE: 5.5
RAMSAY: 6 Rusty and surprisingly nervy
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 6
CLARKE: 7.5 Promising
ANDERSON: 4.5 found out
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 55 Very quiet
KNIBBS: 6 touch wood
LEABURN: 7 fighter
KELMAN: 4 surprisingly poor
Subs: CAREY: 7 gooooooal
CAMPBELL: 7 pleasing
DYKES: 6.5 Not bad at all
Ref 8
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8 mom
BREE: 4
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 7
CLARKE: 6
ANDERSON: 4
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 7
KELMAN: 4.5
Referee: 7
Subs: CAREY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6.5
DYKES: 6.5
GODDEN: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8.5
BREE: 4 (disaster out of position)
RAMSAY: 5.5 - not fit
JONES: 6.5 - stupid booking
GILLESPHEY: 5.5
CLARKE: 6.5
ANDERSON: 4
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
KNIBBS: 5
LEABURN: 6.5
KELMAN: 5
Referee:
Subs: CAREY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 6
DYKES: 6.5
GODDEN: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BREE: 5
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 6
CLARKE: 6
ANDERSON: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
KNIBBS: 5
LEABURN: 6
KELMAN: 5
Referee: 7
Subs: CAREY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6
DYKES: 6
0 -
KAMINSKI:8
BREE:6
RAMSAY:6
JONES:7
GILLESPHEY:6
CLARKE:7
ANDERSON:6
RANKIN-COSTELLO:6
KNIBBS:6
LEABURN:7
KELMAN:6
Referee:7
Subs: CAREY:7.5
CAMPBELL:6
DYKES:7
0 -
KAMINSKI:8
BREE:6
RAMSAY:6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY:6
CLARKE:7
ANDERSON:7
RANKIN-COSTELLO:6
KNIBBS:6
LEABURN:7
KELMAN:6
Subs: CAREY:7.5
CAMPBELL:7
DYKES: 6
GODDEN- he touched grass 🙌
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BREE: 5
RAMSAY: 6.5
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
CLARKE: 7.5
ANDERSON: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 7
KELMAN: 6
Referee: 7
Subs: CAREY: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
DYKES: 7
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BREE: 5
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 6
CLARKE: 6.5
ANDERSON: 5.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5.5
KNIBBS: 5.5
LEABURN: 6.5
KELMAN: 5
Referee: 8 obvious man of the match for not bottling the big decisions
Subs: CAREY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
DYKES: 6.5
1 -
At the game
KAMINSKI: 8.5 - 3 great saves kept us in the game
BREE:5
RAMSAY:4 poor on the ball, looked to be struggling with a knock or fitness
JONES:7
GILLESPHEY:6
CLARKE:6 will get better when more familiar with his team mates
ANDERSON: 5 tried hard but ineffective
RANKIN-COSTELLO:5.5
KNIBBS:6 hope the injury is not as bad as it looked
LEABURN:7 battled hard but should have scored
KELMAN:5 no service
Referee:8 spot on with the 2 reds
Subs: CAREY:7.5 good goal
CAMPBELL:6 looked dangerous but kept passing back
DYKES:7 Good debut with an assist- liked his no nonsense approach
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8.5BREE: 5RAMSAY: 6JONES: 6.5GILLESPHEY: 6CLARKE: 6.5ANDERSON: 5RANKIN-COSTELLO:5.5KNIBBS: 5.5LEABURN: 6KELMAN: 5.5Referee: 8Subs: CAREY: 6.5CAMPBELL: 6.5DYKES: 6.50
-
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BREE:6.5
RAMSAY:6
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN:7
KELMAN:6.5
Referee:8
Subs: CAREY:6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
DYKES:7.5
GODDEN: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7 MOTM best performance from him in a Charlton shirt (minus the distribution)
BREE: 3 worst I have seen him play, rightfully hooked at half time looked like he didn’t want to be there
RAMSAY: 4 almost worse than his performance vs QPR and Millwall earlier in the season. Not sure if he was playing through injury but he looked really poor
JONES: 6.5 Good again held his own
GILLESPHEY: 7 surprisingly good
CLARKE: 5 alright debut weren’t amazing but first 90 minutes in almost a year so will give the benefit of the doubt
ANDERSON: 4 not good enough but not as bad as some are making out
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5 didn’t impress me at all today hopefully a blip
KNIBBS: 5 didn’t look great today pre injury but did get us playing 10 men. Looks like a bad injury hopefully recovers soon
LEABURN: 7 this Leaburn redemption arc is incredible
KELMAN: 4 arguably Kelmans worst game this season and I like Kelman
Referee: 10 breathtaking performance
Subs: CAREY: 4 scored the winner but was poor apart from that
CAMPBELL: 7 really good off the bench did look a bit tired in the last 20ish minutes
DYKES: 6 good debut put himself about got the assist for the winner
GODDEN: again ole ole
Nathan Jones: 6/10 not amazing or awful tactics today got 3 points which is all that matters
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BREE: 2
RAMSAY: 2.5
JONES: 5
GILLESPHEY: 3
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5.5
KNIBBS: 4
LEABURN: 6
KELMAN: 4
Referee: 3
Subs: CAREY: 1.5 +1 for the goal
CAMPBELL: 6.5
DYKES: 6 no service
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8.5 have to give him MOTM for the 1st half saves to keep us in the game. Distribution very slow though.
BREE:7
RAMSAY:6 not his usual self, looked a bit out of it in the first half, better in the second
JONES:7 worked hard
GILLESPHEY:7 better performance today
CLARKE:7 like the look of him
ANDERSON:7 better 2nd half
RANKIN-COSTELLO:6 looked knackered in the 2nd half
KNIBBS:n/a. Hope he gets well soon
LEABURN:7.5 good work rate, should have scored
KELMAN:6 not very effective but then none of our outfield players were in the 1st half either.
Referee:7
Subs: CAREY: 7 thank goodness that somebody was on target
CAMPBELL:8 game changer
DYKES:7.5looks very handy, just missed out on a goal and got an assist
GODDEN.n/a but great to see him back and to hear his song ringing out at the Valley!!
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8:MoTM - his first half performance kept us in the game
BREE: 4.5 - struggled playing out of position
RAMSAY: 6 - a bit rusty but I thought he did ok in his first game back
JONES: 7 - good
GILLESPHEY: 6.5 - reasonably solid
CLARKE: 7 - did very well for a guy who hasn't played a single first team game this season. Surprised he lasted the full game. I expected Apter to get a run out in the last 15 or 20 minutes
ANDERSON: 5 - good energy and a few decent tackles but his passing is poor
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5.5 - poor in the first half; better in the second when we had the numerical advantage
KNIBBS: 5 - was struggling to make an impact before he was assaulted. Let's hope the injury isn't a season ending one
LEABURN: 7 - worked hard and was the only player who gave the opposition anything to think about in the first half
KELMAN: 4.5 - ineffective and lacks any real physicality
Referee: 7 - got the big decisions right
Subs: CAREY: 5.5 - a fine strike for the winning goal but otherwise unimpressive
CAMPBELL: 7.5 - skinned his full-back on a number of occasions and forced United to double up on him. The only player we have with the ability to go past opponents and take them out of the game
DYKES: 6.5 - an improvement on Kelman
0 -
KAMINSKI: 9
BREE: 6.5
RAMSAY: 6.5
JONES: 7.5
GILLESPHEY: 8
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 8
KELMAN: 7
Referee: 8
Subs: CAREY: 7
CAMPBELL: 8.5
DYKES: 8
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8. Good saves that kept us in it.BREE: 5 poor end to the loan spell.RAMSAY: 5.5 looked shaky but could have been due to return from InjuryJONES: 7 won so many headers! SolidGILLESPHEY: 6 didnt have to do much defending but passing was shiteCLARKE: 7 good debut. Some of his crossing was different to wjat we have before. Early and whipped!ANDERSON: 5.5 energy levels are unmatched but passing let's him down.RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5 poor game after recent showingsKNIBBS:LEABURN: 6.5 played well but should have scored.KELMAN: 5.5 unfortunate to be taken off really.Referee: 8 got both reds correct.Subs
CAREY: 7 good finish.CAMPBELL: 7.5 menace but was the only attacking outlet.DYKES: 6.5 as predicted won good headers and got an assist0 -
Sponsored links:
-
KAMINSKI: 8.5
BREE: 4.5
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 6
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
KNIBBS: 5
LEABURN: 6.5
KELMAN: 5.5
Referee: 9
Subs: CAREY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6.5
DYKES: 6.5
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BREE:6.5
RAMSAY 6.5:
JONES:7.5
GILLESPHEY: 7
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 7
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 7
KELMAN: 6.5
Referee: 8
Subs: CAREY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
DYKES: 7.5
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5 - Two great saves kept us in it; distribution shocking!
BREE: 4.5 - Poor on his last appearance
RAMSAY: 5.5 - Off speed and doesn't look fit
JONES: 7 - Very good, albeit desperate at times
GILLESPHEY: 5.5 - Rushed into mistakes, but kept going
CLARKE: 6.5 - Solid enough and put in a couple of good low crosses
ANDERSON: 5.5 - Tried hard but lacked quality at this level
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6 - Worked well with TC 2nd half
KNIBBS: 5 - Should have been booked, hardly got a kick of the ball, then got done. Hope he 's OK
LEABURN: 7 - Worked hard but missed his good chance
KELMAN: 4.5 - Hardly got involved and rightly pulled at h/t
Referee: 2 - Wanted to make it all about him - not giving the penalty, showing two reds desperately, getting an escort off the pitch, etc etc
Subs: CAREY: 5.5 - Took his goal well but still off the boil generally
CAMPBELL: 7 - Took huge chunks of time out of the game strolling down the wing, which was exactly what we need once in front!
DYKES: 6.5 - Got stuck in and showed he can work with Leaburn
1 -
At the game
Kaminski : 8
BREE: 6
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 6
CLARKE: 6.5
ANDERSON: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 6
KELMAN: 5
Referee:
Subs: CAREY: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
DYKES: 6.5
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8 Kept us in it during that period before the two red cards
BREE: 5
RAMSAY: 6.5 A little off the pace at times but good to see him back
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 7
CLARKE: 6.5 ok
ANDERSON: 5 Much as I admire his commitment, does not have the football skills for the championship
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6 Pretty quiet
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 7 has started to show more desire to get involved over the past few games
KELMAN: 5.5 Couldn’t get involved as we were largely pinned back in the first half
Referee: 7
Subs: CAREY: 7 Well taken goal
CAMPBELL: 6.5 Frightens tiring defences but someone needs to show him how to get his crosses past the first defender
DYKES: 7 Could be a useful addition
GODDEN: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 9
BREE: 5
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 8
GILLESPHEY: 7
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 4
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 7.5
KELMAN: 5
Referee:
Subs: CAREY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 8
DYKES: 7
0 -
Impressed that in lancashire you have Luncheon LL2
-
Kaminski 9 kept us in it
Clarke. 7 Looked,fit aggressive and up for it
Ramsey 6 not his best game
Jones 7
Gilly 6
Bree 5
Anderson 5 ..that's not his position
Rc 6
Knibbs 5 was anonymous prior to the injury
Kellman 5
Leaburn 6
Subs
Campbell 7
Dykes 7
Carey 6
Godden n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BREE: 4
RAMSAY: 5
JONES: 7
GILLESPHEY: 4
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 5
KNIBBS: 5
LEABURN: 7
KELMAN: 4
Referee:
Subs: CAREY: 6
CAMPBELL: 5
DYKES: 6.5
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BREE: 5
RAMSAY: 6
JONES: 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
CLARKE: 7
ANDERSON: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
KNIBBS: 6
LEABURN: 7
KELMAN: 6
REF: 7
Subs: CAREY: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
DYKES: 7
0
