Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: CHARLTON v PORTSMOUTH (closes Wednesday teatime)

13»

Comments

  • Eric_Dales
    Eric_Dales Posts: 429

    KAMINSKI: 3

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 5

    BELL; 5

    CLARKE: 5

    COADY: 5

    DOCHERTY: 6

    CAREY: 5

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 5

    DYKES: 5

    Referee: 4

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5

    FEVRIER: 6.5

    COVENTRY: 6

    Berry: 5

    Kelman: 5



  • KAMINSKI: 5

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 6.5

    BELL; 6

    CLARKE: 4.5 got in good position, should have scored, silly booking

    COADY: 4 didn't do much

    DOCHERTY: 5.5 

    CAREY: 6

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 5

    DYKES: 6 kept going 

    Referee: 4.5 penalty decision awful, think he could have given them a penalty too

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5

    FEVRIER: 5.5

    COVENTRY: 6 improvement on Coady

  • cafcsinger
    cafcsinger Posts: 5,664

    KAMINSKI: 2

    RAMSAY: 4

    JONES: 5

    BELL; 3

    CLARKE: 4

    COADY: 5

    DOCHERTY: 5

    CAREY: 5.5

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 5

    DYKES: 4

    Referee: 1

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 6

    FEVRIER: 7

    COVENTRY: 5

    Berry: 

    Kelman:

  • timken
    timken Posts: 1,077
    Kaminski 4
    Ramsey 7
    Jones6
    Bell6
    Clarke3
    Docherty 3
    Chambers 3
    Dykes 3
    Leaburn 3 
    Carey 4
    Codey3
    Campbell 5 
    Coventry 5
    Fevrier 6
  • BertieB
    BertieB Posts: 903

    KAMINSKI: 2

    RAMSAY: 5

    JONES: 6

    BELL: 6

    CLARKE: 3

    COADY: 3

    DOCHERTY: 5

    CAREY: 4

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 4

    DYKES: 4

    Referee: 4

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 3

    FEVRIER: 6

    COVENTRY: 5

  • KAMINSKI:3

    RAMSAY: 4

    JONES: 4

    BELL; 4

    CLARKE: 4.5

    COADY: 5

    DOCHERTY: 3

    CAREY: 4

    CHAMBERS: 4

    LEABURN: 3

    DYKES: 5

    Referee: 0.5...embarrassment to the profession

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 4.5

    FEVRIER: 5.5

    COVENTRY: 4.5

    Berry: 3

    Kelman: 4


  • KAMINSKI: 3 - Tommy butterfingers

    RAMSAY: 6 - Best player - low bar

    JONES: 5 - Can't blame him if he's had enough

    BELL; 4 - Unlucky pen.

    CLARKE: 4 - Silly booking. Silly ref.

    COADY: 2 - Found out. Neutralised

    DOCHERTY: 4 - Run rabbit run rabbit run run run

    CAREY: 4 - My wife's given up on you

    CHAMBERS: 4 - Scared to cross - halfway line and ball

    LEABURN: 5 - Trying

    DYKES: 4 - Very trying

    Referee: 1 - Men in white coats

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 6 - Soup

    FEVRIER: 7 - nifty goal

    COVENTRY: Not Coady

    Berry: Never again

    Kelman: Never say never

  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,362

    KAMINSKI: 1

    RAMSAY: 5

    JONES: 5

    BELL; 6

    CLARKE: 4

    COADY: 3

    DOCHERTY: 5

    CAREY: 4

    CHAMBERS: 4.5

    LEABURN: 3

    DYKES: 4

    Referee: 3

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 3

    FEVRIER: 4

    COVENTRY: 5

    Berry: 2

    Kelman: 2


  • KAMINSKI:    3   Earns £20k/week    wtf!

    RAMSAY:       6

    JONES:           6

    BELL;               5.5

    CLARKE:          5    BIG miss 1st minute 

    COADY:            4

    DOCHERTY:     5.5

    CAREY:              5

    CHAMBERS:     4  ineffective crossing

    LEABURN:         5

    DYKES:               5

    Referee:   2.  Abysmal 

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 6

    FEVRIER:                  6.5

    COVENTRY:              6

    Berry:                         5

    Kelman:                     5


  • At the game

    KAMINSKI: 4

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 6

    BELL; 6

    CLARKE: 4

    COADY: 3

    DOCHERTY: 5

    CAREY: 4

    CHAMBERS: 4.5

    LEABURN: 5

    DYKES: 6

    Referee: 3

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 4

    FEVRIER: 7

    COVENTRY: 6

    Berry: 5

    Kelman: 5



  • Sponsored links:



  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,605
    edited February 18
    KAMINSKI: 3 Thomas had a nightmare of a match.
    RAMSAY:6.5 Kayne had a strong 2nd half and got forward and back with skill and tenacity.
    JONES:,6 Difficult evening but he battled away while trying not too get a 2nd card.
    BELL:5 One of his poorest performances but he is still in credit. 
    CLARKE:4 missed the great chance in the 1st minute and then got a stupid 7th booking which meant he was then ineffective and struggled with the wide man. Harry's in credit but that was a night to forget.
    COADY:4 The first half he just couldn't get into the game and was rightly hooked.
    DOCHERTY:5 Always gives 100% but his lack of skill on the ball was plain for all to see. 
    CAREY:6 At least he kept going but all his attempts were blocked but I like his positive way he runs forward and personally I would still like to see his partnership with Apter ! 
    CHAMBERS:5 Difficult game as like Clarke he received the early card which inhibited his performance.
    LEABURN:5:The ref had it in for Miles from the start and just couldn't get any partnership going with Dykes.
    DYKES:5 Like Bell that was his poorest game in a Charlton shirt but he gives his all every game.

    Referee: 3 Gave out 7 cards like confetti to cafc but let off the Peruvian guy's foul on Docherty.
    Subs: CAMPBELL: 4.5 couldn't make a difference this time.
    FEVRIER:7 he made had a good cameo with two shots with one being the goal.
    COVENTRY:6.5 Conor got on the ball and tried to pass the ball on the ground.
    Berry:4 no impact.
    Kelman:4 no impact.
  • Arry Addick
    Arry Addick Posts: 1,181
    edited February 18

    KAMINSKI:  3

    RAMSAY:  6

    JONES:  6

    BELL;  5.5

    CLARKE:  5

    COADY:  5

    DOCHERTY:  5.5

    CAREY:  5

    CHAMBERS:  4

    LEABURN:  5

    DYKES:  5

    Referee: 1

    Subs: CAMPBELL:  4

    FEVRIER:  6

    COVENTRY:  5.5

    Berry:  4

    Kelman:  4

  • ross1
    ross1 Posts: 51,326

    KAMINSKI: 4

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 6

    BELL; 6

    CLARKE: 4

    COADY:  4

    DOCHERTY: 4

    CAREY: 4

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 4

    DYKES: 5

    Referee: 1

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5

    FEVRIER: 6

    COVENTRY: 5

    Berry: 5

    Kelman: 5


  • msomerton
    msomerton Posts: 3,329

    KAMINSKI: 4

    RAMSAY: 5

    JONES: 6

    BELL; 6

    CLARKE: 4

    COADY:  4

    DOCHERTY: 4

    CAREY: 4

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 4

    DYKES: 5

    Referee: 1

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5

    FEVRIER: 7

    COVENTRY: 6

    Berry: 4

    Kelman: 4


  • KAMINSKI: 4

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 6.5

    BELL; 5

    CLARKE: 4

    COADY: 4

    DOCHERTY: 5

    CAREY: 5

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 5

    DYKES: 6

    Referee: 

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5

    FEVRIER: 6

    COVENTRY:6

  • Killarahales
    Killarahales Posts: 1,124

    KAMINSKI: 4

    RAMSAY: 5

    JONES: 5

    BELL; 4

    CLARKE: 5

    COADY: 4

    DOCHERTY: 4

    CAREY: 5

    CHAMBERS: 5

    LEABURN: 4

    DYKES: 6

    Referee: 1

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5

    FEVRIER: 5

    COVENTRY: 4

    Berry: 4

    Kelman: 4

  • Blucher
    Blucher Posts: 4,269

    KAMINSKI: 3 - a ridiculous error for the first goal

    RAMSAY: 6.5 - the best of a poor bunch. Our only real ball carrier on the night

    JONES: 6 - a bit out of sorts. Some poor distribution

    BELL; 5 - below par

    CLARKE: 4 - a bad first minute miss and struggled a bit defensively

    COADY: 4 - the game passed him by, as Pompey bossed the midfield. I'm baffled as to how they found so much space

    DOCHERTY: 4 - ran around to no good effect. His passing was, as usual, generally poor 

    CAREY: 4 - a bit of a nothing game

    CHAMBERS: 4.5 - looked a bit shaky on occasions

    LEABURN: 4 - couldn't make any impact

    DYKES: 5.5 - worked hard as usual and got another assist

    Referee: 2 - an absolute clown. He fell hook, line and sinker for the Pompey players' dramatics. 7 bookings in a game where there was barely a bad tackle.

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5 - couldn't really impact the game

    FEVRIER: 5.5 - a nice finish and one other nice bending shot just past the far post 

    COVENTRY: 5 - got on the ball more as Pompey sat back but his passing was fairly basic

    Berry: 4 - the game was over by the time he came on but I don't recall him touching the ball. I'd much prefer to see Fullah on the bench

    Kelman: 3 - I'm pretty sure he didn't touch the ball. I fear that he lacks the necessary physicality and athleticism required at this level. Godden's hamstring strain is bad news.

  • Peter_G
    Peter_G Posts: 880
    KAMINSKI: 4
    RAMSAY: 6
    JONES: 6
    BELL; 6
    CLARKE: 5
    COADY: 3
    DOCHERTY: 6
    CAREY: 5
    CHAMBERS: 5
    LEABURN: 3
    DYKES: 5

    Referee: 3

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 4
    FEVRIER: 6
    COVENTRY: 4
    BERRY: 3
    KELMAN: 4
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 71,254
    KAMINSKI: 4
    RAMSAY: 6
    JONES: 6
    BELL; 5
    CLARKE: 4
    COADY: 4.5
    DOCHERTY: 5
    CAREY: 5
    CHAMBERS: 4
    LEABURN: 5
    DYKES: 6
    Referee: 3
    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5
    FEVRIER: 6
    COVENTRY: 5
    Berry: 5
    Kelman: 5
  • KAMINSKI: 5

    RAMSAY: 7

    JONES: 6

    BELL: 5

    CLARKE: 5

    COADY: 4

    DOCHERTY: 6

    CAREY: 5

    CHAMBERS: 4

    LEABURN: 5

    DYKES: 6

    Referee: 0

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 4

    FEVRIER: 5

    COVENTRY: 5


  • Sponsored links:



  • Billy_Mix
    Billy_Mix Posts: 2,811

    KAMINSKI: 2

    RAMSAY: 5

    JONES: 5

    BELL; 5

    CLARKE: 4

    COADY: 3

    DOCHERTY: 5

    CAREY: 1

    CHAMBERS: 1.5

    LEABURN: 4

    DYKES: 5

    Referee: 0

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 2

    FEVRIER: 5

    COVENTRY: 5

    Berry: 0.5

    Kelman: 0.5

  • ossie64
    ossie64 Posts: 24
    Kaminski     3  very poor on the first goal, ridiculous booking
    Ramsey       5 
    Jones          5  not his best
    Bell             4  poor game for him
    Clarke         4  should have scored early doors, ridiculous booking
    Doc            5
    Carey         5  will he ever learn to pass
    Chambers  4  lightweight
    Coady        3  completely overran
    Leaburn     3  
    Dykes        5  the effort was there as always

    Ref            2 card happy and inconsistent, the poorest example

    Campbell  4 early promise but again looked disinterested, poor miss at the end
    Coventry   5 at least he tried, upgrade on Coady last night
    Fevrier      5 good goal plus a decent effort

    Berry       n/a 
    Kelman   n/a
  • KAMINSKI: 3

    RAMSAY: 6

    JONES: 6

    BELL: 6

    CLARKE: 5

    COADY: 5

    DOCHERTY: 5.5

    CAREY: 6

    CHAMBERS: 5.5

    LEABURN: 5

    DYKES: 6.5

    Referee: 2

    Subs: CAMPBELL: 5.5

    FEVRIER: 6

    COVENTRY: 5.5

    Berry: 5

    Kelman: 5

  • SaySomething
    SaySomething Posts: 2,599

    KAMINSKI:4

    RAMSAY:5.5

    JONES:6

    BELL;5.5

    CLARKE:4.5 Silly booking

    COADY:4 

    DOCHERTY:5.5

    CAREY:5 Needs to learn to pass to others in better positions and stop trying to be Frank Lampard (jnr)

    CHAMBERS:5

    LEABURN:4

    DYKES:5.5

    Referee:4

    Subs: CAMPBELL:5

    FEVRIER:5.5

    COVENTRY:6

    Berry:5

    Kelman:5