Players Marks: Charlton v Birmingham (closes Sunday lunchtime)
Comments
-
MANNION:8
RAMSAY: 8.5
JONES:9
BELL: 8
CLARKE:8
COVENTRY:7
CAREY:7
DOCHERTY:7
CHAMBERS:6
DYKES:7
CAMPBELL:7
Referee:7
SUBS: KELMAN: 8
RANKIN-COSTELLO:7
LEABURN: n/a
GILLESPHEY: n/a
COADEY: n/a
0 -
marks 0.5 to 10.0
MANNION: 6.5. Love how he commands the box. Other than that, didn’t have much to do, couple of dodgy kicks and one missed claim on a low cross.
RAMSAY: 8.5. Man of the match for me. Felt like he won so many battles - Gray did very little and he got to grips with Osman quickly too. Fantastic skill to keep the ball in and turn during the second half.
JONES: 8. Won everything barring a couple of early 50/50s on the ground with Stansfield. Read him like a book when he tried to play a cutback.
BELL: 7. Solid, composed self.
CLARKE: 7.5. He will score soon, he has to! Great energy and physicality.
COVENTRY: 7.5. Felt like a proper return to form today. Great energy, broke the game up well, used the ball nicely.
CAREY: 6.5. Quiet game, don’t remember him doing loads - snatched at two shots in quick succession first half.
DOCHERTY: 7. A quiet but solid game.
CHAMBERS: 6.5. Brought some balance back to the team and a few nice touches, but hasn’t kicked on yet.
DYKES: 6.5. Wasn’t his day today, but still put a shift in.
CAMPBELL: 6.5. Played well in parts but drifted in others. Such a threat when he’s on.
Referee: 6. Thought he did ok to be honest, couldn’t tell in the ground the Priske tackle was bad and an easy one to miss.
SUBS: KELMAN: 7.5. Proper Godden-esque finish and some diligent running in behind and strength to hold the ball up.
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6. Didn’t quite get up to speed with the game.
LEABURN: n/a
GILLESPHEY: n/a
COADEY: n/a
0 -
Enjoyed today massivelyMannion 7 commanding. Gives defenders confidence
Ramsay 8.5 he’s back and he’s pretty bloody brilliant
Jones 9 imperious
Bell 7.5 brings so much balance
Clarke 9 awesome. Probably First loaner I’ve fallen in love with since Cullen and Ajdarevic. MOM
Coventry 7.5 metronome. Keeps it ticking
Carey 7.5 busy. Available. Love his energy
Docherty 7.5 busy. Tidy. Not glamorous
Chambers 7 easy to overlook the significance of a proper lwb at lwb
Dykes 7 didn’t let up.
Campbell 7 scares defenders and gives us an outlet.
Ref 7 we’ve had many worse
Kelman 8 for the goal and the application
Rankin-costello 6.5 I’m not a fan but he didn’t let standards drop1 -
MANNION: 7 - no real saves to make but took 3 or 4 crosses very well. He's never let us down
RAMSAY: 8 - very good
JONES: 8.5 - got turned twice by Stansfield but otherwise a faultless display. As well as his aerial dominance, Lloyd's reading of the game is excellent
BELL: 7.5 - calm and assured as usual. He certainly helps us keep the ball better
CLARKE: 7 - another dynamic display. He gets into very good attacking positions and will surely open his account before the end of this season
COVENTRY: 7 - worked hard and kept things ticking over
CAREY: 6.5 - keeps trying to make things happen and put in a few dangerous crosses
DOCHERTY: 7 - good work and energy when we were out of possession, which was a fair amount of the time, albeit Birmingham were playing in front of us
CHAMBERS: 6 - looks a little lightweight at times
DYKES: 6.5 - put in his usual good shift and contributed yet another assist
CAMPBELL: 6.5 - not his best game but some good moments. Missed a good chance early in the second half
Referee: 5 - not particularly impressed and seemed to spend an inordinate amount of time talking to players. I suppose at least he wasn't card happy
SUBS: KELMAN: 7 - a really nice finish and worked the channels well after his introduction
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5 - a decent enough cameo. He can pass the ball but lacks some pace and athleticism
1 -
MANNION: 7.5
RAMSAY: 9
JONES: 9
BELL: 7.5
CLARKE: 8
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAREY: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 8
CHAMBERS: 7.5
DYKES: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 7
SUBS: KELMAN: 7.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7
LEABURN: n/a
GILLESPHEY: n/a
0 -
MANNION: 7.5
RAMSAY:8
JONES: 8.5
BELL:8
CLARKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS: 6.5
DYKES: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 3
SUBS: KELMAN:8
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7
0 -
@stop_shouting you fatfingered Chambers and Dykes marks. Did you mean 7 for both of them, 6 for one, 8 for the other or something else?0
-
MANNION: 7RAMSAY: 8.5JONES: 8BELL: 8CLARKE: 7.5COVENTRY: 7.5CAREY: 7DOCHERTY: 7CHAMBERS: 6.5DYKES: 7CAMPBELL: 7Referee: 5.5SUBS: KELMAN: 8RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.50
-
MANNION: 8RAMSAY: 8JONES: 9BELL: 8CLARKE: 8COVENTRY: 8CAREY: 7DOCHERTY: 78CHAMBERS: 7DYKES: 8CAMPBELL: 7
Ref. 7KELLMAN : 8RANKIN-COSTELLO : 71 -
MANNION: 7 - Commanded his area well
RAMSAY: 7.5 - Under pressure but did well
JONES: 9 (MoM) - Immense performance
BELL: 6.5 - Got caught out a few times
CLARKE: 7.5 - Probably his best game for us
COVENTRY: 7.5 - Covered lots of ground in a tight midfield
CAREY: 6.5 - Struggled to find any space
DOCHERTY: 7 - Put in a good shift
CHAMBERS: 6 - Seemed off the pace
DYKES: 7 - Excellent shift leading the line
CAMPBELL: 6.5 - Did OK but fluffed his best chances
Referee: 6 - Bottled any big calls but didn't make any howlers
SUBS: KELMAN: 7 - Took his goal well and chased everything
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7 - Slotted in well
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
MANNION: 8
RAMSAY: 8
JONES: 9
BELL: 8
CLARKE: 8
COVENTRY: 7
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS:7
DYKES: 8
CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 5
SUBS: KELMAN: 9
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7
0 -
MANNION:7.5
RAMSAY:8.5
JONES:8.5
BELL:8
CLARKE:8
COVENTRY:7.5
CAREY:7
DOCHERTY:7
CHAMBERS:7
DYKES:8
CAMPBELL:7
Referee:6.5
SUBS: KELMAN:7.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO:6.5
0 -
MANNION 7 Good
RAMSAY 8 Good
JONES 8 Excellent
BELL 7 Good
CLARKE 7 His best game so far
COVENTRY 6 Goes sideways too much, try forward for a change
CAREY 7 Lots of energy great throw for the goal
DOC 7 Done well
CHAMBERS 6 Got beaten a lot today
DYKES 8 Excellent again
CAMPBELL 6 Better today but body language terrible. More worried about his headwear. Thinks he’s doing us a favour by playing for us. Attitude problems.KELMAN 7 A goal says it all
RC 6 Ok
REF 7 Did ok0 -
MANNION: 8 A commanding presence in the box. Must instill great confidence in his defence knowing he's brave enough to come out and catch amidst flying elbows and heads
RAMSAY: 8 Back to his Bristol City best. Best one-on-one defender I've ever seen. Confidence returned after his Millwall red card.
JONES: 9 Make no bones about it, the best player on the park. By a mile, but...
BELL: 7.5 Poise, balance and pace. So effective. It's incredible how much better we are when he's in the team.
CLARKE: 9 (PotM) Wins man on the match on energy. Possibly one of the best loan signings we've ever had. Strong as an ox, and gets up and down the pitch for the full 90+ minutes.
COVENTRY: 8 Really very good. Willing to receive the ball everywhere. His energy is phenomenal. One of the reasons I prefer him to Coady is his ability to help out on the flanks as well as through the middle.
CAREY: 7 Seems to be playing a little deeper. Still very good, but does reduce ho goal threat. Has got fitter as the season hs gone on.
DOCHERTY: 7 For doing Doc things. Such a force of nature off the ball, and an excellent captain. We're better with him in the side, at present.
CHAMBERS: 6 Not as good as the rest of the back 5. Bailed out a few times by the excellent Bell. Tired badly.
DYKES: 6.5 Not everything worked for him, but, boy! He leaves nothing on the pitch! Won a really good flick on in the first half, only to find TC was 40 yards away from him. You could see him gesturing to TC to "get closer"..
CAMPBELL: 5.5 Distinctly average. I'm not going to criticise his attitude, but my biggest criticism of TC is his lack of anticipation. He reacts, rather than acts. Sometimes you have to just hope that the no. 9 will win a header, and act accordingly. TC never does, which means he's often on his heels, rather than his toes...
Referee:
SUBS: KELMAN: 7 An excellent cameo. A good goal, and showed strength and determination to chase down the channels. Showed great strength on the ball, too. I'd love to see him start with Dykes.
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6 Probably the best vision for a pass of anybody at the club. Unfortunately, his lack of pace and fitness means he's often chasing shadows, rather than influencing the game.
0 -
MANNION: 7.0
RAMSAY: 8.0
JONES: 8.0
BELL: 8.0
CLARKE: 7.0
COVENTRY: 8.0
CAREY: 7.0
DOCHERTY: 8.0
CHAMBERS: 7.0
DYKES: 8.0
CAMPBELL: 8.0
Referee:
SUBS: KELMAN: 7.0
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7.0
LEABURN: 7.0
GILLESPHEY:
COADEY:
0 -
MANNION: 8
RAMSAY: 8.5
JONES: 9
BELL: 8
CLARKE: 8.5
COVENTRY: 8
CAREY: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7.5
CHAMBERS: 7.5
DYKES: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
Referee: 8
SUBS: KELMAN: 8.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7.5
0 -
MANNION: 8
RAMSAY: 9
JONES: 9
BELL: 8
CLARKE: 8
COVENTRY: 7
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 8
CHAMBERS:7
DYKES: 8
CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 7
SUBS: KELMAN: 9
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7
0 -
MANNION: 7.5
RAMSAY: 7.5
JONES: 8
BELL: 7.5
CLARKE: 8 had a good game
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS: 6.5
DYKES: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7.
Referee: 6.5 better than most recently.
SUBS: KELMAN:7.5 did the crucial thing
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5
0 -
MANNION: 7
RAMSAY:7
JONES: 7.5
BELL: 7.5
CLARKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS:6.5
DYKES: 7
CAMPBELL:6.5
Referee:6
SUBS: KELMAN:7.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO:6.5
0 -
-
Sponsored links:
-
MANNION: 7.5
RAMSAY: 8
JONES: 8.5
BELL: 8
CLARKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
CAREY:7.5
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS: 6
DYKES: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 6.5
Referee: 6
SUBS: KELMAN: 7.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5
0 -
MANNION: 7
RAMSAY: 8
JONES: 8.5
BELL: 7.5
CLARKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 6.5
CHAMBERS: 6.5
DYKES: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 6
Referee: 6.5
SUBS: KELMAN: 7
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5
0 -
MANNION: 7.5 - My preferred No.1
RAMSAY: 8 - Back to his best
JONES: 8.5 - Immense....as usual!
BELL: 7.5 - So calm under pressure
CLARKE: 8.5 - My M.o.t.M. Hope we can sign him permanently in the summer.
COVENTRY: 7.5 - Keen to impress and done well.
CAREY: 7 - A relatively quiet game for the GG.
DOCHERTY: 7 - Done his job well, however we will need a more dynamic & creative player in this role.
CHAMBERS: 6.5 - Done ok, but looked a bit nervy at times.
DYKES: 7 - Lead the line well, but he needs a proper strike partner.
CAMPBELL: 6.5 - Frustrates me. Clearly has talent, but decision making is poor and he lacks bottle.
Referee: 3 - He was crap, but we've seen worse!
SUBS: KELMAN: 8 - Needs a run in the team alongside Dykes. He will score goals.
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7 - I like his style. Think he could be effective in the middle alongside Coventry.
LEABURN: n/a
GILLESPHEY: n/a
COADEY: n/a
0 -
MANNION: 7 Yes he comes for crosses which is great. But he also fumbled one on the ground and his kicking still isn't greatRAMSAY: 9 Really strong. Gray and Osman are good wingers and he helped shut them down.JONES: 9 MOTM Just won everything.BELL: 8.5 - He does the mopping up a lot and he does it so well. So strong on the ball.CLARKE: 7.5 - Helped keep Osman and Gray quietCOVENTRY: 7.5 - Back to his old selfCAREY: 7 - Put in a shift and a couple of good crossesDOCHERTY: 7.5 - Put in an absolute shift yet again. Got into passing lanes and broke up play wellCHAMBERS: 7 - Solid if unspectacular. Vicente is very good and he kept him largely quiet.DYKES: 7.5 Put in an absolute shift. Closes everything down. Maybe another assist for the goal, I think Ramsay got a touch in there but either way he was involved in the build up.CAMPBELL: 6.5 - Blew hot and cold but did a good job at LWBReferee:SUBS: KELMAN: 7.5 What an instinctual finishRANKIN-COSTELLO: 6.5 worked hard and tidy on the ballLEABURN: n/aGILLESPHEY: n/aCOADEY: n/a0
-
MANNION: 7.5
RAMSAY: 8
JONES: 9
BELL: 7
CLARKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS: 7
DYKES: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7
Referee: 3.5
SUBS: KELMAN: 7.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 6
0 -
MANNION: 7
RAMSAY: 9
JONES: 8
BELL: 7
CLARKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7
CAREY: 7.5
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS: 7
DYKES: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 6
Referee: 6
SUBS: KELMAN: 8
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7
0 -
MANNION: 7 He took every cross cleanly and for the first time this season I wasn't afraid of the keeper making an error. Please keep him in and give him a chance. If he fails then fair enough.
RAMSAY: 8 Best game for a long time.
JONES: 8 Magnificent as always.
BELL: 7 Very good.
CLARKE: 7.5 Very good.
COVENTRY: 7 Decent, but still just boots the ball anywhere too often.
CAREY: 7
DOCHERTY: 7
CHAMBERS: 6 Looks a little weak, I think it's the amount he's playing.
DYKES: 7.5 A colossus.
CAMPBELL: 6 So frustating.
Referee: 7 I thought he did well.
SUBS: KELMAN: 7
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7
0
