Attention: Please take a moment to consider our <a href="http://forum.charltonlife.com/home/termsofservice">terms and conditions</a> before posting.

Karlan Grant SIGNED - 2 year deal

1…5678911»

Comments

  • wmcf123
    wmcf123 Posts: 6,660
    I'm prepared to cut him some slack if he's been playing through injury but that of course then leads to the question that given how poor he has been, why the fuck has Jones kept starting him?
    He’s backup for Campbell now, for me . Once again, Jones has fortunately stumbled upon balance and it worked . 
  • wmcf123 said:
    I'm prepared to cut him some slack if he's been playing through injury but that of course then leads to the question that given how poor he has been, why the fuck has Jones kept starting him?
    He’s backup for Campbell now, for me . Once again, Jones has fortunately stumbled upon balance and it worked . 
    Can't argue with that, although i wouldn't be surprised to see Grant start at Wolves.

    Jamaica play in the early hours of Weds 18th away in Mexico. At the very earliest Campbell is going to arrive back in London at some point on the Thursday, and then we'll travel to Wolves on the Friday. 

    I would personally rather bench TC for that so he's fresh for Lincoln at home on the Tuesday night.
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 5,850
    What is his injury - bruised ego?
  • Chunes
    Chunes Posts: 19,279
    He's been awful so no idea why NJ insisted on playing him through an injury. I think Karlan has done him a favour yesterday by saying he can't play. 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 24,493
    wmcf123 said:
    I'm prepared to cut him some slack if he's been playing through injury but that of course then leads to the question that given how poor he has been, why the fuck has Jones kept starting him?
    He’s backup for Campbell now, for me . Once again, Jones has fortunately stumbled upon balance and it worked . 
    Always funny to me that when things are going badly it’s all on NJ and bad luck doesn’t matter and then when he does well he’s “stumbled” across the right thing to do, just like he did with Small. As if it was a total mistake 
  • Sword65pf
    Sword65pf Posts: 3,238
    We’ve been crowbarring him in the team which unbalances us, and he’s been shit, hopefully he took note of a team making a real effort yesterday and tries to do the same if he gets the opportunity, for me he should only be an option off the bench until he starts showing up.
  • wmcf123
    wmcf123 Posts: 6,660
    fenaddick said:
    wmcf123 said:
    I'm prepared to cut him some slack if he's been playing through injury but that of course then leads to the question that given how poor he has been, why the fuck has Jones kept starting him?
    He’s backup for Campbell now, for me . Once again, Jones has fortunately stumbled upon balance and it worked . 
    Always funny to me that when things are going badly it’s all on NJ and bad luck doesn’t matter and then when he does well he’s “stumbled” across the right thing to do, just like he did with Small. As if it was a total mistake 
    It’s true though, isn’t it ? He didn’t use Small on the right until injuries necessitated it.  
  • Redspace
    Redspace Posts: 16
    He was an underwhelming signing for me. Probably unnecessarily expensive wage bill for the return we will see. Hope he's binned off at the end of the season. 
  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 29,171
    I’m hoping his poor performances have been down to injury.
  • There's a chance NJ has pushed him to play beyond the pain barrier and that's why his performances, attitude and quality has dipped. Not sure as hard to tell.

  • Sponsored links:



  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 39,690
    edited November 9
    Biggest disappointment for me is that he never takes players on. He’s had some occasional good moments with the ball but I thought the idea of signing him was to add another player with pace who’d take players on.

    Not sure the energy has been there consistently enough either, but that’s been a problem with the team in general and they increase in tempo, aggression and intensity was what made a big difference on Saturday.
  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 3,076
    Probably would have ended up a decent signing if TC went and could play his best position week in week out , but just shoehorning him into the side for the sake of it similar when we were obsessed with TC at wingback or in a 2 striker formation 
  • ElfsborgAddick
    ElfsborgAddick Posts: 31,631
    Redspace said:
    He was an underwhelming signing for me. Probably unnecessarily expensive wage bill for the return we will see. Hope he's binned off at the end of the season. 
    Doubt it, he'll only have one more season and run it down for another free transfer.
  • fenaddick said:
    wmcf123 said:
    I'm prepared to cut him some slack if he's been playing through injury but that of course then leads to the question that given how poor he has been, why the fuck has Jones kept starting him?
    He’s backup for Campbell now, for me . Once again, Jones has fortunately stumbled upon balance and it worked . 
    Always funny to me that when things are going badly it’s all on NJ and bad luck doesn’t matter and then when he does well he’s “stumbled” across the right thing to do, just like he did with Small. As if it was a total mistake 
    We’ve won one in twelve game after losing four in a row with the team changing constantly. 

    He has stumbled across this. 

    There was no other way to look at the Shef u game other than the last roll of the dice. 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 24,493
    fenaddick said:
    wmcf123 said:
    I'm prepared to cut him some slack if he's been playing through injury but that of course then leads to the question that given how poor he has been, why the fuck has Jones kept starting him?
    He’s backup for Campbell now, for me . Once again, Jones has fortunately stumbled upon balance and it worked . 
    Always funny to me that when things are going badly it’s all on NJ and bad luck doesn’t matter and then when he does well he’s “stumbled” across the right thing to do, just like he did with Small. As if it was a total mistake 
    We’ve won one in twelve game after losing four in a row with the team changing constantly. 

    He has stumbled across this. 

    There was no other way to look at the Shef u game other than the last roll of the dice. 
    Or maybe the players finally did all the stuff he’s been talking about in the post match interviews for about 2 months. No doubt he’s been saying the same stuff at the training ground too. He’s been tinkering to find the right formula and he might have found it. I’m not sure trial and error is the most effective method but it is also isn’t “stumbling” onto something 
  • Chunes
    Chunes Posts: 19,279
    edited November 9
    Nathan criticised for having no Plan B. But he also gets criticised for not getting it right until he's on Plan X.
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,976
    wmcf123 said:
    fenaddick said:
    wmcf123 said:
    I'm prepared to cut him some slack if he's been playing through injury but that of course then leads to the question that given how poor he has been, why the fuck has Jones kept starting him?
    He’s backup for Campbell now, for me . Once again, Jones has fortunately stumbled upon balance and it worked . 
    Always funny to me that when things are going badly it’s all on NJ and bad luck doesn’t matter and then when he does well he’s “stumbled” across the right thing to do, just like he did with Small. As if it was a total mistake 
    It’s true though, isn’t it ? He didn’t use Small on the right until injuries necessitated it.  
    He had actually already tried it before Northampton, away at Huddersfield. But it didn’t really work that well that game (not helped by a Docherty red card)

    We also had REG fit who could play there so it wasn’t even last resort 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,976
    Scoham said:
    Biggest disappointment for me is that he never takes players on. He’s had some occasional good moments with the ball but I thought the idea of signing him was to add another player with pace who’d take players on.

    Not sure the energy has been there consistently enough either, but that’s been a problem with the team in general and they increase in tempo, aggression and intensity was what made a big difference on Saturday.
    I think if played on the left more we’d see more of that 1v1 ability. He’s too predictable on the right because the defender knows he’s not going to go inside 

    He might get his chance at Wolves, with TC away with Jamaica and getting back late in the week I think it’s likely Grant plays on the left at wolves and we save TC for Lincoln