Player Marks, Charlton Athletic v Bristol City, 10th October 2026 (closes Sunday 7pm)
A huge thank you to @lancashire lad, who has done an amazing job managing the Player Marks and Statbank over the years. To give you an idea of just how mammoth a task it is, Lancs’ workload will now be shared between myself, @Weegie Addick and @Jonniesta.
Hopefully, we can do justice to the work of a true Charlton Life legend and avoid going full Iain Dowie in the process!
The thread will close tomorrow night, and we’ll have the first iteration and results up by Tuesday.
Please stick to the format by copy and pasting the below. You know the drill:
0.5 to 10 please:
OKONWKO:
MCNAMARA:
JONES:
KOUMETIO:
EDWARDS:
GRANT:
SKIPP:
COVENTRY:
CAMPBELL:
MBICK:
LEABURN:
RAMSAY:
MESÍK:
KNIBBS:
KELMAN:
ALLI: N/A
Referee:
Comments
-
OKONWKO: 6.5
MCNAMARA: 6
JONES: 7 MoM
KOUMETIO: 6.5
EDWARDS: 6
GRANT:7
SKIPP: 6
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 5.5
RAMSAY: 6
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
0 -
The Red Robin said:
A huge thank you to @lancashire lad, who has done an amazing job managing the Player Marks and Statbank over the years. To give you an idea of just how mammoth a task it is, Lancs’ workload will now be shared between myself, @Weegie Addick and @Jonniesta.
Hopefully, we can do justice to the work of a true Charlton Life legend and avoid going full Iain Dowie in the process!
The thread will close tomorrow night, and we’ll have the first iteration and results up by Tuesday.
Please stick to the format by copy and pasting the below. You know the drill:
0.5 to 10 please:
OKONWKO: 7.5
MCNAMARA:6.5
JONES:6.5
KOUMETIO:6.5
EDWARDS:5.5
GRANT:6
SKIPP:6
COVENTRY:6
CAMPBELL:6
MBICK:5
LEABURN:7
RAMSAY:6.5
MESÍK:6.5
KNIBBS:6
KELMAN:6
ALLI: N/A
Referee:
0 -
OKONWKO: 6.5
MCNAMARA: 7
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 5 Clearly not fit
GRANT: 6
SKIPP: 6
COVENTRY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
MBICK: 5.5
LEABURN: 6.5
RAMSAY: 7
MESÍK: 6.5
KNIBBS: 5
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 5
0 -
Okonkwo 7 did ok
Mcnamara 6 ok
Jones 6.5 not his best
Koumetio 7.5 solid till he tired
Edwards 4 poor
Skipp 5 I really don't like him
Coventry 7 tried hard
Grant 5 poor but good goal
Campbell 6.5 ok but missed big chance
Leaburn 6.5 tried hard
Mbick 5 sniffed some half chances
Mesik 7 much better than Edwards
Ramsey 7 looked good
Knibbs 6 good free kick
Kelman 5 little time
Ref 5 ok1 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 5
JONES: 6.5
KOUMETIO: 6.5
EDWARDS: 6
GRANT: 5
SKIPP: 5
COVENTRY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 6.5
RAMSAY: 6.5
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN:6
0 -
OKONWKO: 7 One very good free kick save first half and solid throughout
MCNAMARA: 6 Stuck to his task
JONES: 6.5 Look more relaxed once the team went to back five
KOUMETIO: 8 Fully fit again and an outstanding purchase
EDWARDS: 4 Popular with the fans but is he really Championship standard?
GRANT: 5 Well taken goal but disappeared for the rest of the first half and did little in the second
SKIPP: 6 Hum, neat and tidy but we need to see more creativity from him
COVENTRY: 7 Maximum effort as always but he does resort too often to the hoof up the field
CAMPBELL: 6.5 Always a threat but really should have scored near the end
MBICK: 5 Don't think he should be starting in the first team, just not ready yet
LEABURN: 7.5 Gave their defenders a torrid time and nearly provided a winner before coming off
RAMSAY: 7 Look very assured
MESÍK: 7 The team looked better the moment he walked on the pitch. No way backing down against the big City forward at the end
KNIBBS: 6 He can take a fine free kick
KELMAN: 6 One good run and shot
ALLI: N/A
Referee:
0 -
Forgot to score the ref again.
7 Very tight using his cards which benefitted us in the first half
1 -
OKONWKO: 8
MCNAMARA: 6.5
JONES: 6.5
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 6
GRANT:7
SKIPP: 5
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 5.5
RAMSAY: 6
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
0 -
OKONKWO: 5.5 decent enough on crosses, one weird punch, absolutely should have been sent off
MCNAMARA: 7 did well enough, was out of position second half too
JONES: 7 couple of missed headers, did the usual
KOUMETIO: 8.5 huge performance tbh
EDWARDS: 4 woeful, can't be first or second choice until he's fully up to speed
GRANT: 6.5 good goal but gave it away for fun thereafter
SKIPP: 6.5 had some decent moments but often behind the pace of play
COVENTRY: 6.5 penalty machine, liability, wibble. Did very well apart from that
CAMPBELL: 7 such good wingplay as ever, argh though
MBICK: 5 I'm not eating my words any time soon, just not ready, nor willing
LEABURN: 7.5 really great effort as usual
RAMSAY: 6 one good pass and a lot of very bad passes
MESÍK: 7 so obviously needs to start
KNIBBS: n/a but if I must, 6.5 that was a nice hit
KELMAN: n/a but if I must, 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 6.5 gave us a huge one first half
2 -
OKONWKO: 6.5
MCNAMARA: 7 Not a wingback tho
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 4 Not fit, but remember has never proved himself at this level
GRANT: 7 Great finish and worked hard
SKIPP: 6 Solid,some errors
COVENTRY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7 Shame about the miss at the end
MBICK: 4 Anonymous, another failure in the 10 position
LEABURN: 7 .5
RAMSAY: 7
MESÍK: 6.5
KNIBBS: 5.5 Great free kick
KELMAN: 5
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 7
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA:7
JONES:8
KOUMETIO:7
EDWARDS:6
GRANT:7
SKIPP:7
COVENTRY:7
CAMPBELL:7
MBICK:6
LEABURN:6
RAMSAY:7
MESÍK:6
KNIBBS:6
KELMAN:6
0 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 6
JONES: 6.5
KOUMETIO: 7
EDWARDS: 5 clearly not fit
GRANT: 6.5 top goal but not much after that
SKIPP: 5. not championship standard
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
MBICK: 6
LEABURN: 5.5
RAMSAY: 6 not on long enough
MESÍK: 6 ditto
KNIBBS: 6.5 ditto
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 7
0 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 7
JONES: 6
KOUMETIO: 8
EDWARDS: 5
GRANT: 6
SKIPP: 6
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY:6.5
MESÍK: 6.5
KNIBBS: 6
1 -
OKONWKO: 6.5
MCNAMARA: 6
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 2. I love Josh but he was terrible
GRANT: 6.5
SKIPP: 5
COVENTRY: 5.5
CAMPBELL: 6
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 6
RAMSAY: 7.5
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 5.5
KELMAN: 5
1 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 6
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7
EDWARDS: 5
GRANT: 7
SKIPP: 5
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 7
MESÍK: 7
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 6
0 -
OKONWKO: 6 poor communication today on more then one occasion
MCNAMARA: 7
JONES: 6 not his best today to many sloppy passes and little mistakes
KOUMETIO: 9 MOM
EDWARDS: 6 good to see him back but looked very rusty
GRANT: 6 well taken goal but lost the ball to many times todsy
SKIPP: 8 excellent
COVENTRY: 8 excellent
CAMPBELL: 6 drifted in and out started well but went missing should have scored the second goal
MBICK: 5 not ready
LEABURN: 7 worked hard
RAMSAY: 7 good to see him
Back
MESÍK: 7 don’t mess with this guy
KNIBBS: 6 so unlucky with the free kick had goal
Written all over it
KELMAN: 5 not enough time
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 4 strange performance
4 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 6.5
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 5
GRANT:7
SKIPP: 5
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 6.5
RAMSAY: 6
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
0 -
Edwards you forgot how long he been out ?? stupid commentDugdaleclass said:OKONWKO: 7 One very good free kick save first half and solid throughout
MCNAMARA: 6 Stuck to his task
JONES: 6.5 Look more relaxed once the team went to back five
KOUMETIO: 8 Fully fit again and an outstanding purchase
EDWARDS: 4 Popular with the fans but is he really Championship standard?
GRANT: 5 Well taken goal but disappeared for the rest of the first half and did little in the second
SKIPP: 6 Hum, neat and tidy but we need to see more creativity from him
COVENTRY: 7 Maximum effort as always but he does resort too often to the hoof up the field
CAMPBELL: 6.5 Always a threat but really should have scored near the end
MBICK: 5 Don't think he should be starting in the first team, just not ready yet
LEABURN: 7.5 Gave their defenders a torrid time and nearly provided a winner before coming off
RAMSAY: 7 Look very assured
MESÍK: 7 The team looked better the moment he walked on the pitch. No way backing down against the big City forward at the end
KNIBBS: 6 He can take a fine free kick
KELMAN: 6 One good run and shot
ALLI: N/A
Referee:
1 -
At the game
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 7
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 8
EDWARDS: 5
GRANT: 6
SKIPP: 6
COVENTRY: 7
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 7.5
RAMSAY:6.5
MESÍK: 6.5
KNIBBS: 6
0 -
OKONWKO: 6
MCNAMARA: 6.5
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 4
GRANT: 6
SKIPP: 5
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 4
LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 7
MESÍK: 6.5
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 6
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
OKONWKO: 6
MCNAMARA: 6.5
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 6
GRANT: 6.5
SKIPP: 5.5
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 6
LEABURN: 6.5
RAMSAY:5.5
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 7
0 -
OKONWKO:6
MCNAMARA:7
JONES:7.5
KOUMETIO:8
EDWARDS:4
GRANT:6
SKIPP:6
COVENTRY:6.5
CAMPBELL:6.5
MBICK:5.5
LEABURN:7
RAMSAY:6
MESÍK:7
KNIBBS:6
KELMAN:
ALLI: N/A
Referee:6
0 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 6.5
JONES: 7.5
KOUMETIO: 7
EDWARDS: 6
GRANT: 6.5
SKIPP: 5
COVENTRY: 5
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 6
LEABURN: 6.5
RAMSAY: 7
MESÍK: 7
KNIBBS: 6.5
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee 7
0 -
The Red Robin said:
A huge thank you to @lancashire lad, who has done an amazing job managing the Player Marks and Statbank over the years. To give you an idea of just how mammoth a task it is, Lancs’ workload will now be shared between myself, @Weegie Addick and @Jonniesta.
Hopefully, we can do justice to the work of a true Charlton Life legend and avoid going full Iain Dowie in the process!
The thread will close tomorrow night, and we’ll have the first iteration and results up by Tuesday.
Please stick to the format by copy and pasting the below. You know the drill:
0.5 to 10 please:
OKONWKO: 6
MCNAMARA: 6.5
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 6
GRANT: 6.5
SKIPP: 6
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 7
MBICK: 5
LEABURN: 5
RAMSAY: 5.5
MESÍK: 7
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee:
0 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 7
JONES: 7
KOUMETIO: 7
EDWARDS: 4
GRANT: 6.5
SKIPP: 6.5
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6.5
MBICK: 6
LEABURN: 7
RAMSAY: 5
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 5
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 7 Was kind to us!
0 -
OKONWKO: 6
MCNAMARA:6
JONES:6
KOUMETIO:6
EDWARDS:5
GRANT:6
SKIPP:6
COVENTRY:5
CAMPBELL:5
MBICK:5
LEABURN:6.5
RAMSAY: 5.5
MESÍK: 6
KNIBBS: 5
KELMAN: 4
0 -
OKONWKO:6.5 Lucky to be on the pitch but glad he was.
MCNAMARA:7 Good first half, not quite so good in the second
JONES:7 Some uncharacteristic errors but still a decent performance
KOUMETIO:8 We've missed him. MOM
EDWARDS:4 Shouldn't really have started but he needs minutes
GRANT:6.5 Looked up for it in the first 15 minutes, good goal, but disappointing after City scored
SKIPP: 5 Is he an upgrade on Doc? Supposedly better on the ball but too many mistakes
COVENTRY:6.5 Solid game
CAMPBELL:6.5 Didn't have his usual affect. Maybe tired from travelling
MBICK:5 Was surprised to see him starting. Wasn't surprised to see him subbed
LEABURN:7 Worked very hard. Let's hope he gets a goal soon?
RAMSAY:6 A bit rusty but grew into it
MESÍK: 6.5 Gave us a lot more impetus
KNIBBS:6 Great save from his excellent free kick
KELMAN: 5.5 Not really in the game
ALLI: N/A
Referee:6 A few errors, including a big one which benefitted us.
0 -
OKONWKO: 7 mainly sound
MCNAMARA: 6 usual endeavour offered little in moving the ball forwards though
JONES: 6 did ok
KOUMETIO 6.5 best of the starting defenders and comfortable on the ball
EDWARDS: 5 understandably struggled and nearly cost us with a weak header
GRANT: 6.5 extra point for the goal
SKIPP: 5.5 very poor 1st half better 2nd
COVENTRY: 6 minus a point for conceding the pen otherwise ok
CAMPBELL: 6.5 extra 0.5 for assist should’ve scored with those 2 bites of the cherry
MBICK: 5 Still waiting to see what he brings
LEABURN: 6 better 2nd half
RAMSAY: 6.5 Good to see him back also comfortable on the ball playing out
MESÍK: 6 got involved in more ways than one
KNIBBS: 6 unlucky not to convert free kick
KELMAN: 6 couple of decent runs off the shoulder
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 5 missed a lot of fouls, fortunately in our favour
0 -
OKONWKO: 7
MCNAMARA: 6
JONES: 6
KOUMETIO: 7.5
EDWARDS: 4
GRANT: 5
SKIPP: 5.5
COVENTRY: 6
CAMPBELL: 6
MBICK: 4
LEABURN: 6
RAMSAY: 6
MESÍK: 6.5
KNIBBS: 6
KELMAN: 6
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 5
0 -
OKONWKO: 6.5 - Not a lot to do, kicking isn't great but made the save from Twine that he needed to
MCNAMARA: 7 - Solid
JONES: 7.5 - Did his Lloyd Jones thing without being spectacular
KOUMETIO: 7 - Couple of moments where he looked a bit off it but otherwise quite good.
EDWARDS: 5.5 - First start in a year and it showed. There will be a lot more to come from him this season. This was like a first or second pre-season match for him.
GRANT: 7 - Good goal then largely went quiet.
SKIPP: 6.5 - His second touch is too often a tackle.
COVENTRY: 5.5 - I don't love him quiet as much as Leuth does, but I still love him loads. And he looked leggy and and just didn't have his best game. I do think it's hard for him and Skipp without a more natural 10 in front of them.
CAMPBELL: 7 - Good assist that Grant made look very good. Still looks our most dangerous outlet. Unfortunate miss in a crowded area. Brownie talking about him just laying it off is fanciful, there's no way he can see that at pace.
MBICK: 5.5 - Just didn't get in the game
LEABURN: 6.5 - Battled but wasn't quite as effective as in recent weeks. Still put in a good ball that Tickle dropped and nearly led to a winner.
RAMSAY: 6.5 - Looked solid again
MESÍK: 6 - Solid but didn't do a whole lot
KNIBBS: 6.5 - Extra .5 for a brilliant free kick that he was unlucky not to score
KELMAN: 6 - Made some good runs but nothing came off
ALLI: N/A
Referee: 4 - Thankfully for us he missed a lot.
0
