Sullivan - 6.5 Hardly had anything to do, but looks a hundred times more commanding then Robbie
Solly - 6.5 Decent overlapping, if he could cross as well as Francis we'd have a player on our hands
Doherty - 6.5 Done ok. Wish he try and be as dominant in offence as he is in defence
Fortune - 6.5 As above.
Bessone - 6 Nervous first half against their very good right winger. Grew as the game went on but still error prone.
Wagstaff - 6.5 Best game in a while, links up well with Solly and had a couple of decent chances
Semedo - 7 He is trying to be a box-to-box, could've had two more today
Stewart - 7 Took a while to get into the game but when he did he was good. Definitely worth a contract.
Racon - 6 Not his best, done ok but took an extra second on too many occasions and lost the ball
Wright Phillips - 6.5 Some moments of real class in terms of turns and layoffs, probably should've had a goal.
Benson - 6.5 Tireless and a good partner for BWP.
Sullivan 7 - Made some good decisions as to when to come out and when to stay back. His non stop talking to the back four impressed me. Solly 7 - His energy is excellent, his willingness to fight and get stuck in is clear. Doherty 8 - Not been a fan of his this season but he was excellent today Fortune 5 - Some bad touches in my opinion Bessone 6.5 - Looked out of sorts to me and was beaten by their winger almost all the time. Improved later in the game though. Wagstaff 7 - Best i have seen him work for a long time. Eager to get forward and put in a couple of good crosses. Works well with Solly Semedo 7 - Steady again, linked well with Stewart and got forward when Stewart stayed back and vice versa. Stewart 8 - Always talking to the team, encouraging them and giving direction. I can see why people could see him as a leader. Hope he stays, but i sadly doubt he will. Racon - 6.5 - Did nothing particularly wrong, but was a little annoymous in my opinion on the wing. But he has played a few very good games recently, so allowed one weak one. Wright Phillips 6.5 - Ran onto a few chances, i am still not convinced he was offside in the 2nd half. Hope he stays for next season. Benson 7 - This guy worked so hard today. Guy in front was criticising his committment. Not sure what game he was watching. Needs ball in the box to score goals though
n/a Reid 6 - If only he had taken the ball within him during that run at the end.
Powell 7 - Played the right tactics against a physical team. I would have changed Racon for Eccleston personally, but other than that i believe he played good football today.
OK some of my scores may be too high in some peoples eyes, but i think we played very well today, easily matched a team gunning for promotion and did not deserve to lose. So glad the crowd never booed at the end as that would have been appalling. They fought well, looked like a team, they just couldn't get the goal, but it wasn't through not trying.
Sullivan 6 - Didn't have much to do.
Solly 6.5 - Linked up well with Wagstaff
Doherty - 7.5 - Best game Ive seen him have. MOM
Fortune - 5 - He's half the player he used to be.
Bessone - 5 - Never looks assured. Not Convinced
Wagstaff - 7 - Much Better than recent weeks
Semedo - 7.5 - Had the best chance.Hope he signs a new contract.
Stewart - 6 - Parette is a better player
Racon - 5 . Poor today
Wright Phillips 6 - Was kept quite.
Benson - 7 - worked hard but has he got the quality?
Sullivan - 5 Should have organised his wall better for the free kick
Solly - 6 Worked hard and made a few good runs down the wing.
Doherty - 6 Ran his socks off
Fortune - 5 A vast improvement on previous performances
Bessone - 6 Solid defending, didn't do much wrong
Wagstaff - 6 Wasted a good chance to score. Still needs to improve his game.
Semedo - 7 Worked hard and was closing down huddersfield players constantly
Stewart - 6.5 Fluffed a couple of decent chances but has some nice touches and was composed on the ball
Racon - 6.5 Can be frustrating at times with some of his passing and flicks but worked hard
Wright Phillips - 6 Not much service up front again, but won plenty of headers against their lump of a defender
Benson - 7.5 Ran his socks off and had some nice touches. My MOM.
I give Reid a big fat Zero for having the temerity to wear orange boots and play like that. No wonder Racon took his time to walk off when subbed. Useless.
Sullivan - 6 -Not vocal enough. Kicking Chuff. Poor lining up of the wall for the goal. Solly - 6.5 - Steady. Doherty - 7 - Best game for ages. Fortune - 5 - Poor as ever. Bessone - 5 - Don't rate him. Wagstaff - 6.5 - Steady Semedo - 6.5 - Would have been 7 but he gave away the stupid freekick for their goal. Stewart - 7 - Like the look of him. Yes please for next year. Racon - 6 - Quiet. Wright Phillips - 6.5 - Few flashes. Benson - 6.5 - Worked hard but not the answer if we harbor ambitions of automatic promotion next year.
Sullivan 7 Tried to command his area which I like. No chance with the free kick although perhaps he could have lined the wall up better?
Solly 7 Worked well with Waggy and defended competently
Doherty 6.5 Wasn't exposed for pace today and was competent without being outstanding
Fortune 6.5 As Doc
Bessone 6.5 Struggled against Hunt in the first half but stuck to his task well
Wagstaff 8 MOM Works well with Solly and involved in most of our attacks. Covered every blade of grass and some. A John Robinson for the 21st Century.
Semedo 6.5 Did what he does. Unlucky with his header
Stewart 7 Made little impression (that I noticed) early on but grew into it and pulled the stings whwn we exerted pressure. Takes a decent corner. Only downside was the shanked shot from a decent position.
Racon 6.5 Back to the in and out player that frustrates so much.
Wright Phillips 6.5 Put himself about without too much service
Benson 7 Can't fault his workrate but little service
n/a Reid In the interests of diplomacy I'll heed the n/a!
Sullivan. 6.5. Competent
Solly. 6.5. Growing in stature if not height
Doherty. 7.0. Gives 100%
Fortune. 6.0 ok today but quite frankly he should piss this league.
Bessone. 5.5 not impressed overall.
Wagstaff. 7.0 good to see Waggy getting stuck in.
Semedo. 6.5. Not his best game but decent enough
Stewart. 7.0 Still finding his feet in a Charlton shirt but looks good to me.
Racon. 6.0 worst performanc by Theiry for a while and maybe he was due a stinker
Wright Phillips. 7.0 great turn in second half. Will always pose a danger.
Benson. 7.0. Worked hard for the team without really posing a threat.
Sullivan - 6 Caught two crosses and possibly didn't line his wall up properly. Cannot kick from the floor but still might be quite a good goalie....don't know. Solly - 7 He was ok at the back and got forward when he could Doherty - 8 Won countless tackles and his share of the headers. Made many interceptions and cleared the box well. Good defender who looks better for the few games rest. Fortune - 6 Can't have been that bad because HTFC didn't have a shot of note from open play but doesn't (and I don't think ever has) command in the air. Does stick tight to a man though. Bessone - 6 Would've been subbed if we had a spare left back because he was woeful 1st half but to his credit did well defensively 2nd half. Offered nothing offensively throughout. Wagstaff - 7.5 Had a pretty useful 2nd half but was starved of the ball 1st half. The sort of performance that needs to become his benchmark. Semedo - 7 Looked like he was given a bit more licence to go forward today. Plenty of effort and a useful header at the far post. Stewart - 6 Didn't get on the ball much and looked a tad weak but did join up well and looks like he could score a few. There were flashes of something but they were a bit sporadic. Gut feeling is that he'd be quite good for us. Racon - 6 For effort rather than attainment. Wright Phillips - 7 Probably the best he's looked in open play. showed for the ball, used it wisely and produced a superb turn when his shot was blocked. Other than that, he never looked like scoring....weird. Benson - 6.5 Stacks of effort and some signs that he and BWP are starting to work better together but he didn't look like scoring either against a good Huddersfield back line.
n/a Reid - Telling contribution. Barnet for you next season methinks.
n/a Reid - You tit, we would have got at least a point if you hadn't entered the game, I find it bemusing so many fans still clamber after you thinking you'll effect games for the better
Sullivan - 6 maybe was at fault was the goal and few bad kicks. Solly - 8.5 solid and created many chances. Doherty - 6.5 tried to create things but was beaten easily in the air. Fortune - 0.4561phahahahahahahahahah Bessone - 7 did struggle at first but eventually got the hang of things. Wagstaff - 7 was good and did make a few runs. Semedo - 7.5 solid same old, maybe could have had a few shots at times. Stewart - 7 did create things but stamina did go in the second half. Racon - 8 good game and crooses but did lose the ball a couple of times and was getting dragged in to the middle. Wright Phillips - 7 had a few chances but could've been involved more. Benson - 8.5 won a lot of headers and is starting to show some form.
Sullivan 7 - Del Boy would be proud Solly - 7 - is he big enough? Doherty 8 - blimey, rolled back the years Fortune 6 - I've looked everywhere!! Bessone 6 - Jury still out, but tough opponent Wagstaff 8 - blimey, didn't see that coming. Semedo 8 - another top drawer performance Stewart 6 - mmmmm, no better than the bench warmers Racon 7 - remains the best player on the pitch at this level Wright Phillips 6 - class in patches Benson 9 - best game yet for Charlton MOM
Sullivan 6.5 little to do to judge him on Solly 8 excellent and should be inked in for next year Doc 7.5 rose to the responsibility Fortune 6 - tried hard but looks past it Bessone 6 - looks like they targeted him as our weak point. Wagstaff 7.5 - undestanding with solly helps Semedo 7 - solid and getting forward a bit more Stewart 6.5 - promising - definately worth another look Racon 5.5 - poor game Wright Phillips 6.5 - Benson 7.5
Sullivan- 6.5 gonna fit right in with the dodgy kicking, should have lined up the wall better but impressed overall. Solly- 7.5 Doherty- 7 Fortune- 6.5 Bessone- 6 said in the programme his positioning is his weakness. which was very apparant but generally made up for any slips. Wagstaff- 7.5 better 3nd half, unlucky not to score. Semedo- 7 could have scored again, better all round performance. Stewart- 7.5 guy looks very decent, worth keeping. Got a bit of class about him and some good leadership qualities. Racon-6 Wright Phillips- 6.5 Benson- 8 worked tirelessly and MOM.
Sullivan 6
Solly 6.5
Doherty 6
Fortune 5 (Oh dear)
Bessone 6 (A worry but Racon was nowhere to be seen to help him out)
Wagstaff 6 (good effort as usual but too lightweight and poor first touch)
Semedo 7
Stewart 6.5
Racon 4.5 (v poor)
Wright Phillips 7 (if anyone bothered to pass to him on the floor we would not need a defence)
Benson 7.5 (this guy has silenced his critics (me)- well done Benno)
Comments
Solly - 6.5
Doherty - 7.5
Fortune - 6
Bessone - 6
Wagstaff - 6.5
Semedo - 6.5
Stewart -7
Racon -6
Wright Phillips -5.5
Benson - 7
Solly - 6.5 Decent overlapping, if he could cross as well as Francis we'd have a player on our hands
Doherty - 6.5 Done ok. Wish he try and be as dominant in offence as he is in defence
Fortune - 6.5 As above.
Bessone - 6 Nervous first half against their very good right winger. Grew as the game went on but still error prone.
Wagstaff - 6.5 Best game in a while, links up well with Solly and had a couple of decent chances
Semedo - 7 He is trying to be a box-to-box, could've had two more today
Stewart - 7 Took a while to get into the game but when he did he was good. Definitely worth a contract.
Racon - 6 Not his best, done ok but took an extra second on too many occasions and lost the ball
Wright Phillips - 6.5 Some moments of real class in terms of turns and layoffs, probably should've had a goal.
Benson - 6.5 Tireless and a good partner for BWP.
Solly - 7
Doherty - 6.5
Fortune - 6
Bessone - 6
Wagstaff - 6.5
Semedo - 6
Stewart -6.5
Racon -5
Wright Phillips - 6
Benson - 6.5
Solly - 7
Doherty - 8
Fortune - 6
Bessone - 6
Wagstaff - 7
Semedo - 7
Stewart -6.5
Racon - 5
Wright Phillips -6.5
Benson - 6.5
Solly 6.5
Doherty 7
Fortune 6
Bessone 6
Wagstaff 6.5
Semedo 7
Stewart 6
Racon 6
Wright Phillips 6.5
Benson 7
Solly 6.5
Doherty 6.5
Fortune 5
Bessone 5
Wagstaff 6.5
Semedo 7
Stewart 6.5
Racon 6
Wright Phillips 6
Benson 6
Solly 7
Doherty 6
Fortune 5
Bessone 6.5
Wagstaff 6.5
Semedo 6.5
Stewart 8
Racon 6.5
Wright Phillips 6.5
Benson 7
n/a Reid[/quote]
Solly - 7
Doherty - 6
Fortune - 5
Bessone - 6
Wagstaff - 7.5
Semedo - 6
Stewart - 6
Racon - 5
Wright Phillips - 6.5
Benson - 7
Reid - Twat
Solly 7 - His energy is excellent, his willingness to fight and get stuck in is clear.
Doherty 8 - Not been a fan of his this season but he was excellent today
Fortune 5 - Some bad touches in my opinion
Bessone 6.5 - Looked out of sorts to me and was beaten by their winger almost all the time. Improved later in the game though.
Wagstaff 7 - Best i have seen him work for a long time. Eager to get forward and put in a couple of good crosses. Works well with Solly
Semedo 7 - Steady again, linked well with Stewart and got forward when Stewart stayed back and vice versa.
Stewart 8 - Always talking to the team, encouraging them and giving direction. I can see why people could see him as a leader. Hope he stays, but i sadly doubt he will.
Racon - 6.5 - Did nothing particularly wrong, but was a little annoymous in my opinion on the wing. But he has played a few very good games recently, so allowed one weak one.
Wright Phillips 6.5 - Ran onto a few chances, i am still not convinced he was offside in the 2nd half. Hope he stays for next season.
Benson 7 - This guy worked so hard today. Guy in front was criticising his committment. Not sure what game he was watching. Needs ball in the box to score goals though
n/a Reid 6 - If only he had taken the ball within him during that run at the end.
Powell 7 - Played the right tactics against a physical team. I would have changed Racon for Eccleston personally, but other than that i believe he played good football today.
OK some of my scores may be too high in some peoples eyes, but i think we played very well today, easily matched a team gunning for promotion and did not deserve to lose. So glad the crowd never booed at the end as that would have been appalling. They fought well, looked like a team, they just couldn't get the goal, but it wasn't through not trying.
COME ON YOU REDS
Sullivan 6 - Didn't have much to do.
Solly 6.5 - Linked up well with Wagstaff
Doherty - 7.5 - Best game Ive seen him have. MOM
Fortune - 5 - He's half the player he used to be.
Bessone - 5 - Never looks assured. Not Convinced
Wagstaff - 7 - Much Better than recent weeks
Semedo - 7.5 - Had the best chance.Hope he signs a new contract.
Stewart - 6 - Parette is a better player
Racon - 5 . Poor today
Wright Phillips 6 - Was kept quite.
Benson - 7 - worked hard but has he got the quality?
Solly - 6 Worked hard and made a few good runs down the wing.
Doherty - 6 Ran his socks off
Fortune - 5 A vast improvement on previous performances
Bessone - 6 Solid defending, didn't do much wrong
Wagstaff - 6 Wasted a good chance to score. Still needs to improve his game.
Semedo - 7 Worked hard and was closing down huddersfield players constantly
Stewart - 6.5 Fluffed a couple of decent chances but has some nice touches and was composed on the ball
Racon - 6.5 Can be frustrating at times with some of his passing and flicks but worked hard
Wright Phillips - 6 Not much service up front again, but won plenty of headers against their lump of a defender
Benson - 7.5 Ran his socks off and had some nice touches. My MOM.
I give Reid a big fat Zero for having the temerity to wear orange boots and play like that. No wonder Racon took his time to walk off when subbed. Useless.
Solly - 6.5 - Steady.
Doherty - 7 - Best game for ages.
Fortune - 5 - Poor as ever.
Bessone - 5 - Don't rate him.
Wagstaff - 6.5 - Steady
Semedo - 6.5 - Would have been 7 but he gave away the stupid freekick for their goal.
Stewart - 7 - Like the look of him. Yes please for next year.
Racon - 6 - Quiet.
Wright Phillips - 6.5 - Few flashes.
Benson - 6.5 - Worked hard but not the answer if we harbor ambitions of automatic promotion next year.
n/a Reid - 3 - Might as well pay him off now.
Solly 7 Worked well with Waggy and defended competently
Doherty 6.5 Wasn't exposed for pace today and was competent without being outstanding
Fortune 6.5 As Doc
Bessone 6.5 Struggled against Hunt in the first half but stuck to his task well
Wagstaff 8 MOM Works well with Solly and involved in most of our attacks. Covered every blade of grass and some. A John Robinson for the 21st Century.
Semedo 6.5 Did what he does. Unlucky with his header
Stewart 7 Made little impression (that I noticed) early on but grew into it and pulled the stings whwn we exerted pressure. Takes a decent corner. Only downside was the shanked shot from a decent position.
Racon 6.5 Back to the in and out player that frustrates so much.
Wright Phillips 6.5 Put himself about without too much service
Benson 7 Can't fault his workrate but little service
n/a Reid In the interests of diplomacy I'll heed the n/a!
Solly - 7
Doherty - 6
Fortune - 5
Bessone - 6
Wagstaff - 7
Semedo - 7
Stewart - 6
Racon - 5
Wright Phillips - 6.5
Benson - 7
Solly 6.5
Doherty 6
Fortune 5.5
Bessone 6
Wagstaff 6.5
Semedo 7
Stewart 7 MOM
Racon 6
Wright Phillips 6.5
Benson 6.5
n/a Reid 5
Solly. 6.5. Growing in stature if not height
Doherty. 7.0. Gives 100%
Fortune. 6.0 ok today but quite frankly he should piss this league.
Bessone. 5.5 not impressed overall.
Wagstaff. 7.0 good to see Waggy getting stuck in.
Semedo. 6.5. Not his best game but decent enough
Stewart. 7.0 Still finding his feet in a Charlton shirt but looks good to me.
Racon. 6.0 worst performanc by Theiry for a while and maybe he was due a stinker
Wright Phillips. 7.0 great turn in second half. Will always pose a danger.
Benson. 7.0. Worked hard for the team without really posing a threat.
Solly - 7
Doherty - 7
Fortune - 6
Bessone - 4
Wagstaff - 7.5
Semedo - 6
Stewart - 7
Racon - 6
Wright Phillips - 7
Benson - 7
Solly - 7
Doherty - 7 MOM
Fortune - 6
Bessone - 5 Need a new left back next year
Wagstaff - 7
Semedo - 7
Stewart - 7
Racon - 6
Wright Phillips - 7
Benson - 7
Solly-7
Doherty-7.5 MOM
Fortune-5
Bessone-5
Wagstaff-7.5
Semedo-6
Stewart-7
Racon-5
Wright Phillips-6
Benson-6
Solly - 7 He was ok at the back and got forward when he could
Doherty - 8 Won countless tackles and his share of the headers. Made many interceptions and cleared the box well. Good defender who looks better for the few games rest.
Fortune - 6 Can't have been that bad because HTFC didn't have a shot of note from open play but doesn't (and I don't think ever has) command in the air. Does stick tight to a man though.
Bessone - 6 Would've been subbed if we had a spare left back because he was woeful 1st half but to his credit did well defensively 2nd half. Offered nothing offensively throughout.
Wagstaff - 7.5 Had a pretty useful 2nd half but was starved of the ball 1st half. The sort of performance that needs to become his benchmark.
Semedo - 7 Looked like he was given a bit more licence to go forward today. Plenty of effort and a useful header at the far post.
Stewart - 6 Didn't get on the ball much and looked a tad weak but did join up well and looks like he could score a few. There were flashes of something but they were a bit sporadic. Gut feeling is that he'd be quite good for us.
Racon - 6 For effort rather than attainment.
Wright Phillips - 7 Probably the best he's looked in open play. showed for the ball, used it wisely and produced a superb turn when his shot was blocked. Other than that, he never looked like scoring....weird.
Benson - 6.5 Stacks of effort and some signs that he and BWP are starting to work better together but he didn't look like scoring either against a good Huddersfield back line.
n/a Reid - Telling contribution. Barnet for you next season methinks.
Solly - 7
Doherty - 6
Fortune - 5.5
Bessone - 4
Wagstaff - 7
Semedo - 6.5
Stewart - 7
Racon - 6
Wright Phillips - 6
Benson - 7
n/a Reid - You tit, we would have got at least a point if you hadn't entered the game, I find it bemusing so many fans still clamber after you thinking you'll effect games for the better
Solly - 8.5 solid and created many chances.
Doherty - 6.5 tried to create things but was beaten easily in the air.
Fortune - 0.4561phahahahahahahahahah
Bessone - 7 did struggle at first but eventually got the hang of things.
Wagstaff - 7 was good and did make a few runs.
Semedo - 7.5 solid same old, maybe could have had a few shots at times.
Stewart - 7 did create things but stamina did go in the second half.
Racon - 8 good game and crooses but did lose the ball a couple of times and was getting dragged in to the middle.
Wright Phillips - 7 had a few chances but could've been involved more.
Benson - 8.5 won a lot of headers and is starting to show some form.
Solly - 7 - is he big enough?
Doherty 8 - blimey, rolled back the years
Fortune 6 - I've looked everywhere!!
Bessone 6 - Jury still out, but tough opponent
Wagstaff 8 - blimey, didn't see that coming.
Semedo 8 - another top drawer performance
Stewart 6 - mmmmm, no better than the bench warmers
Racon 7 - remains the best player on the pitch at this level
Wright Phillips 6 - class in patches
Benson 9 - best game yet for Charlton MOM
Solly 7
Doc 7
Fortune 5.5
Bessone 6.5
Waggy 7.5
Semedo 7
Stewart 6-5
Racon 6.5
Wright Phillips 7
Benson 8
Solly 7.5
Doc 7.5
Fortune 5
Bessone 6
Wagstaff 8
Semedo 7
Stewart 6
Racon 5.5
Wright Phillips 7
Benson 8
Solly 8 excellent and should be inked in for next year
Doc 7.5 rose to the responsibility
Fortune 6 - tried hard but looks past it
Bessone 6 - looks like they targeted him as our weak point.
Wagstaff 7.5 - undestanding with solly helps
Semedo 7 - solid and getting forward a bit more
Stewart 6.5 - promising - definately worth another look
Racon 5.5 - poor game
Wright Phillips 6.5 -
Benson 7.5
Reid - Oh dear!
Solly - 6
Doherty - 7
Fortune - 6
Bessone - 5
Wagstaff - 6
Semedo - 6
Stewart - 6
Racon - 6
Wright Phillips - 6
Benson - 6
Solly- 7.5
Doherty- 7
Fortune- 6.5
Bessone- 6 said in the programme his positioning is his weakness. which was very apparant but generally made up for any slips.
Wagstaff- 7.5 better 3nd half, unlucky not to score.
Semedo- 7 could have scored again, better all round performance.
Stewart- 7.5 guy looks very decent, worth keeping. Got a bit of class about him and some good leadership qualities.
Racon-6
Wright Phillips- 6.5
Benson- 8 worked tirelessly and MOM.
Solly 6.5
Doherty 6
Fortune 5 (Oh dear)
Bessone 6 (A worry but Racon was nowhere to be seen to help him out)
Wagstaff 6 (good effort as usual but too lightweight and poor first touch)
Semedo 7
Stewart 6.5
Racon 4.5 (v poor)
Wright Phillips 7 (if anyone bothered to pass to him on the floor we would not need a defence)
Benson 7.5 (this guy has silenced his critics (me)- well done Benno)
n/a Reid
Solly - 6.5
Doherty - 6
Fortune - 5
Bessone - 5
Wagstaff - 8
Semedo - 7
Stewart - 7
Racon - 5
Wright Phillips - 6.5
Benson - 6