Rate SCP's Signings

ShootersHillGuru

Astonished that Alonso was scored a 3 / 10 by one poster. Would love an explanation of on what grounds ?

JJ21

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes; 8/10
Cedric Evina; 3/10
Michael Morrison; 8/10
Matt Taylor; 8/10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 6/10
Paul Hayes; 6/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 7/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 8.5/10
Jason Euell; 4/10
Bradley Pritchard; 6/10
Danny Hollands; 9/10
Lee Cook; 6/10
Leon Cort; 7/10
Michael Smith; 5/10
Yann Kermorgant; 10/10
Darel Russell; 7/10
Dany N'Guessan; 7/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 3/10
Leon Clarke; 0/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 9.5/10

Its_Hamer_Time

Ben Hamer; 9/10 19 clean sheets!
Andy Hughes; 7/10
Cedric Evina; 6/10 Not seen too much of the lad unfortunately
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 8.5/10
Danny Green; 7/10
Dale Stephens; 7.5/10 Bit too inconsistent ATM, but sure he'll be good.
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 7/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 10/10
Jason Euell; 5/10
Bradley Pritchard; 8/10
Danny Hollands; 9/10
Lee Cook; 7.5/10
Leon Cort; 8.5/10
Michael Smith; 5/10 Not seen him play.
Yann Kermorgant; 9/10
Darel Russell; 6.5/10
Dany N'Guessan; 7.5/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10 Not seen him play.
Leon Clarke; 3/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 10/10

seriously_red

"Its_Hamer_Time">Ben Hamer; 9/10 19 clean sheets!
Andy Hughes; 7/10
Cedric Evina; 6/10 Not seen too much of the lad unfortunately
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 8.5/10
Danny Green; 7/10
Dale Stephens; 7.5/10 Bit too inconsistent ATM, but sure he'll be good.
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 7/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 10/10
Jason Euell; 5/10
Bradley Pritchard; 8/10
Danny Hollands; 9/10
Lee Cook; 7.5/10
Leon Cort; 8.5/10
Michael Smith; 5/10 Not seen him play.
Yann Kermorgant; 9/10
Darel Russell; 6.5/10
Dany N'Guessan; 7.5/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10 Not seen him play.
Leon Clarke; 3/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 10/10

Team for Derby... + Fuller, Wilson and Solly of course... maybe Hulse and Frimpong figure in the starting line up or on the bench...
When you look at it this way it seems clear that the massive influx of summer 2011 has had to make do for at least 18 months and maybe 24 depending on what happens in the window

SHoare93

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes; 6/10
Cedric Evina; 6/10
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 7/10
Danny Green; 7/10
Dale Stephens; 8/10
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 8/10
Danny Haynes; 8/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 6/10
Bradley Pritchard; 9/10 - Baring in mind the price!
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 6/10
Leon Cort; 8/10
Michael Smith; 6/10
Yann Kermorgant; 8/10
Darel Russell; 6/10
Dany N'Guessan; 6/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10
Leon Clarke; 3/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 7/10

Valley11

SHoare93 said:

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes; 6/10
Cedric Evina; 6/10
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 7/10
Danny Green; 7/10
Dale Stephens; 8/10
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 8/10
Danny Haynes; 8/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 6/10
Bradley Pritchard; 9/10 - Baring in mind the price!
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 6/10
Leon Cort; 8/10
Michael Smith; 6/10
Yann Kermorgant; 8/10
Darel Russell; 6/10
Dany N'Guessan; 6/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10
Leon Clarke; 3/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 7/10

So JohnSullivan (7 apps) was a better signing than Danny Hollands (56apps, 7 goals) and BWP (72 apps, 31 goals)?

MattD

Valley11 said:

SHoare93 said:

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes; 6/10
Cedric Evina; 6/10
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 7/10
Danny Green; 7/10
Dale Stephens; 8/10
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 8/10
Danny Haynes; 8/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 6/10
Bradley Pritchard; 9/10 - Baring in mind the price!
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 6/10
Leon Cort; 8/10
Michael Smith; 6/10
Yann Kermorgant; 8/10
Darel Russell; 6/10
Dany N'Guessan; 6/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10
Leon Clarke; 3/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 7/10

So JohnSullivan (7 apps) was a better signing than Danny Hollands (56apps, 7 goals) and BWP (72 apps, 31 goals)?

Without some of performances from Hollands and BWPs goals we would not have got promoted.
I would consider giving BWP a look in again now.

scabbyhorse

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes;5 /10
Cedric Evina; 6/10
Michael Morrison; 8/10
Matt Taylor; 8/10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 6/10
Paul Hayes; 6/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 6/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 4/10
Bradley Pritchard; 6/10
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 5/10
Leon Cort; 8/10
Michael Smith; 5/10
Yann Kermorgant; 6/10
Darel Russell; 5/10
Dany N'Guessan; 5/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10
Leon Clarke; 4/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8/10

Bedsaddick

Yan and Pritchard just 6 ? Are you sure

scabbyhorse

yes, yan is a good league one player but dont rate him at all at championship level. Pritchard works hard but no quality for me.

Bournemouth Addick

Quite what is the point of this thread?

Am I missing something or is it being used to illustrate that Chrissy's record is good or bad? Looking at some of those it seems there's a negative agenda underlying some of the scores.

AddickedAthletic

Ben Hamer; 9/10
Andy Hughes; 6/10
Cedric Evina; 5/10
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 8/10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 7/10
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 7/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 5/10
Bradley Pritchard; 8/10
Danny Hollands; 8/10
Lee Cook; 4/10
Leon Cort; 7/10
Michael Smith; 3/10
Yann Kermorgant; 9/10
Darel Russell; 4/10
Dany N'Guessan; 6/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 3/10
Leon Clarke; 1/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 9/10

Kap10

Added a few names

Ben Hamer; 7.5 /10
Andy Hughes; 4/10
Cedric Evina; 5 /10
Michael Morrison; 8/10
Matt Taylor; 7.5/10
Danny Green; 5/10
Dale Stephens; 6/10
Paul Hayes; 6/10
John Sullivan; 6/10
Danny Haynes; 8 /10
Rhoys Wiggins; 8.5 /10
Jason Euell; 4 /10
Bradley Pritchard; 7.5/10
Danny Hollands; 6.5/10
Lee Cook; 5 /10
Leon Cort; 8 /10
Michael Smith; 5/10
Yann Kermorgant; 8/10
Darel Russell; 6.5/10
Dany N'Guessan; 7 /10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10
Leon Clarke; 2 /10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 9/10
Ricardo Fuller 6.5/10
Abdul Raziz 3/10
Emanuelle Frimpong 5/10
Frank Nouble 1/10
Lawrie Wilson 8/10
Robert Hulse 7/10

Pedro45

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes; 5/10
Cedric Evina; 6/10
Michael Morrison; 7/10
Matt Taylor; 7/10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 8/10
Paul Hayes; 5/10
John Sullivan; 4/10
Danny Haynes; 5/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 8/10
Jason Euell; 4/10
Bradley Pritchard; 5/10
Danny Hollands; 6/10
Lee Cook; 1/10
Leon Cort; 9/10
Michael Smith; 2/10
Yann Kermorgant; 8/10
Darel Russell; 3/10
Dany N'Guessan; 4/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 2/10
Leon Clarke; 1/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8/10

Ranked in terms of contribution during the last two years (on and off the pitch) to date, and also value (ie can we make a profit on them).

Valley11

Bournemouth Addick said:

Quite what is the point of this thread?

What he said.

Nicholas

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes; 6/10
Cedric Evina; 5/10
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 7/10
Danny Green; 5/10
Dale Stephens; 4/10
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 5/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 2/10
Bradley Pritchard; 7/10
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 2/10
Leon Cort; 8/10
Michael Smith; 2/10
Yann Kermorgant; 8/10
Darel Russell; 2/10
Dany N'Guessan; 2/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 3/10
Leon Clarke; 1/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8/10
Ricardo Fuller 6/10
Emanuelle Frimpong 5/10
Frank Nouble 1/10
Lawrie Wilson 8/10
Robert Hulse 8/10

Dazzler21

Ben Hamer; 9/10
Andy Hughes; 5/10
Cedric Evina; 6/10
Michael Morrison; 7 /10
Matt Taylor; 7 /10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 6/10
Paul Hayes; 6/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 6/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 7/10
Jason Euell; 3/10
Bradley Pritchard; 8/10
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 3/10
Leon Cort; 7/10
Michael Smith; 6/10
Yann Kermorgant; 7/10
Darel Russell; 2/10
Dany N'Guessan; 5/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10
Leon Clarke; 1/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8/10

johnnybev1987

Ben Hamer; 8/10
Andy Hughes; 6/10
Cedric Evina; 5/10
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 8/10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 7/10
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 6/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 2/10
Bradley Pritchard; 7/10
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 2/10
Leon Cort; 8/10
Michael Smith; 2/10
Yann Kermorgant; 8/10
Darel Russell; 2/10
Dany N'Guessan; 4/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 3/10
Leon Clarke; 1/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8/10
Ricardo Fuller 7/10
Abdul Raziz 2/10
Emanuelle Frimpong 5/10
Frank Nouble - unknown didnt even realised we have/had him tbh
Lawrie Wilson 7/10
Robert Hulse 7/10

rikofold

You can't judge Powell's first signings in terms of how they're performing now. One Aim, and the signings he made achieved it. I doubt very much he imagined he'd have nothing to spend in the summer - and the only money he did spend, well Wilson's been a cracking signing.

cafcinperth

Ben Hamer;6/10
Andy Hughes; 6/10
Cedric Evina;4/10
Michael Morrison; 8/10
Matt Taylor; 7.5/10
Danny Green; 8/10
Dale Stephens; 7/10
Paul Hayes; 7/10
John Sullivan; 6/10
Danny Haynes;7 /10
Rhoys Wiggins;9/10
Jason Euell;6 /10
Bradley Pritchard; 6/10
Danny Hollands; 8.5/10
Lee Cook;6 /10
Leon Cort;7 /10
Michael Smith;
Yann Kermorgant; 7/10
Darel Russell; 4/10
Dany N'Guessan;5.5/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo;
Leon Clarke;6/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8.5/10

thewolfboy

Ben Hamer; 10/10
Andy Hughes; 5/10
Cedric Evina; 5/10
Michael Morrison; 10/10
Matt Taylor; 8/10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 7/10
Paul Hayes; 6/10
John Sullivan; 5/10
Danny Haynes; 7/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 10/10
Jason Euell; 4/10
Bradley Pritchard; 10/10
Danny Hollands; 7/10
Lee Cook; 4/10
Leon Cort; 10/10
Michael Smith; 5/10
Yann Kermorgant; 10/10
Darel Russell; 5/10
Dany N'Guessan; 5/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 4/10
Leon Clarke; 4/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8/10
Ricardo Fuller 7/10 Our most talented player.
Abdul Raziz 4/10
Emanuelle Frimpong 6/10
Frank Nouble - 4/10
Lawrie Wilson 8/10 I think he will soon be a 10/10 signing for me.
Robert Hulse 7/10

Note: I have given high scores for our promotion heros.

Nicholas

Who is Abdul Raziz and when and where did we get him from?

dickplumb

Ben Hamer; 9/10
Andy Hughes; 5/10
Cedric Evina; 5/10
Michael Morrison; 9/10
Matt Taylor; 8/10
Danny Green; 6/10
Dale Stephens; 7/10
Paul Hayes; 5/10
John Sullivan; 4/10
Danny Haynes; 7/10
Rhoys Wiggins; 9/10
Jason Euell; 4/10
Bradley Pritchard; 10/10
Danny Hollands; 8/10
Lee Cook; 4/10
Leon Cort; 9/10
Michael Smith; 5/10
Yann Kermorgant; 9/10
Darel Russell; 5/10
Dany N'Guessan; 5/10
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 4/10
Leon Clarke; 2/10
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 8/10
Ricardo Fuller 7/10 Our most talented player.
Abdul Razak 4/10
Emanuelle Frimpong 6/10
Frank Nouble - 1/10
Lawrie Wilson 8/10 I think he will soon be a 10/10 signing for me.
Robert Hulse 7/10

Nicholas

Nicholas said:

Who is Abdul Raziz and when and where did we get him from?

Ok should be Rasak

addick16

we must not forget about ol' eggert jonsson ...

seriously_red

Valley11 said:

Bournemouth Addick said:

Quite what is the point of this thread?

What he said.

The point of digging up this (and the other) thread from the end of last season is to illustrate that this squad is almost 100% CP and that it was playing good footy with great results all the way up to the latest 3 or 4 games... even without big money signings over the summer...

In this league there are no easy games and so looking for that next win needs good management, good support and maybe some luck too.

With the state of Championship club finances I'm not convinced that spending big money is the answer... and if CP were to go this would be very expensive since any replacement would want money for five signings so why not give CP some cash now to get us through.

Kap10

Nicholas said:

Nicholas said:

Who is Abdul Raziz and when and where did we get him from?

Ok should be Rasak

Sorry I think Raziz is a cricketer. Rasak was such fleeting visitor

Red7Oak

Ben Hamer;10/10 Good up and coming keeper attracting interest higher up
Andy Hughes; 5/10 Never more than utility player
Cedric Evina; 7/10 Need to be given a chance
Michael Morrison; 10/10 Done an excellent job.
Matt Taylor; 8/10 Did well last season.
Danny Green; 5/10 Though he was supposed to be a good crosser of the ball?
Dale Stephens; 6/10 Can be good can be very wasteful, hopefully we can cash in.
Paul Hayes; 5/10 Was ok never set the world alight.
John Sullivan; 5/10 Ok cover
Danny Haynes; 10/10 Think Danny when fit is our best striker at this level
Rhoys Wiggins; 10/10 Excellent
Jason Euell; 4/10 Not sure why he was bought back
Bradley Pritchard; 9/10 A gem
Danny Hollands; 6/10 Good L1 signing
Lee Cook; 5/10 One for the future?
Leon Cort; 10/10 Has done well
Michael Smith; 5/10 Unkown - one for the future?
Yann Kermorgant; 9/10 Good last season and a good signing for L1
Darel Russell; 7/10 provided a bit of backbone at L1 level ok
Dany N'Guessan; 7/10 made an impact whether he ever more than a squad player?
Ruben Bover Izquierdo; 5/10 still an unknown
Leon Clarke; 5/10 never given a real chance
Bradley Wright-Phillips; 6/10 time to move him on. Good for L1

seriously_red

rikofold said:

You can't judge Powell's first signings in terms of how they're performing now. One Aim, and the signings he made achieved it. I doubt very much he imagined he'd have nothing to spend in the summer - and the only money he did spend, well Wilson's been a cracking signing.

I think you can because the gap between top of League 1 and the Championship is not that big as Brighton, Norwich, Millwall and Southampton have shown.
Most of the signings have shown real character and it is noticeable that there were no loan players in the team today! Today's first XI and performance supports my view that we are building a decent squad. It is unfortunate that we didn't bring in 3 x £1M+ players over the summer - equally we have had at least four or five players starting at left back! But we are here now and every player who got the club promoted has had their chance to stake a claim in the team / squad and for a new contract! It will take longer this way but maybe in 12 months time we will be looking a bit closer to top 6 ???

happyvalley

Is Kerkar so bad that nobody wants to mention him?