Premature Evaluation Thread

Henry Irving

To help with the "humble pie/told you so" threads please give your views on today's transfers

A: Seabourne. Crap or Star

B: Eggert. Waste of space or Brill

C: Harris. Not good enough or prem player

Sullivan. Glad he's gone or should never have let him go.

E: Wagstaff. Should have left him at Orient or so glad he's back

GreenWithEnvy

what? where does it say Wagstaff back??

C.Walsh'sLoveChild

A. Who?
B. Who?
C. Who?
D. Good for him
E. Since when?

cafctom

Powell out.

Henry Irving

Sorry, ignore E: not on OS yet.

Uboat

Everyone is terrible.

I'm going for this strategy because it worked with Yann.

sralan

Oh sorry, thought this was a thread about "man problems".

killerandflash

A: All at sea
B: We'll have egg on our faces
C: Whoever signed him should be carpeted
Only Fools and Horses would have sent him out on loan
E: The tail is Wagging the dog

ValleyGary

am i allowed to put a ;-) at the end just to cover all bases?

soapy_jones

Yep it is a safe assumption that they are crap until they prove otherwise...

Mortimerician

I like to have seen a player for 5 minutes before I form an un-changeable opinion of them.

Macronate

A: will win the National
B: not the same after Mastermind
C: CP will need to tame his ego after so many years of success with his fist stuffed up that duck's arse
seems disinterested in the game & always arguing with the top brass after having the O' removed from his surname
E: Green is better

Oakster

A: Seabourne. Pah! Only good enough for Hellenic Football League Division One East

B: Eggert. Would look good in the Liverpool County Premier League Premier Division, thats his level

C: Harris. Would struggle in the Devon and Exeter Football League Division Three

Sullivan. Why did we let him go, he's at least Premier League standard

E: Wagstaff. Only a little bit more experience away from being a leading star in Serie A. - sort it out Powell

Davo55

On the basis of bugger all actual knowledge, as per usual....

A: Seabourne. Crap or Star? Neither, but ok enough.

B: Eggert. Waste of space or Brill? Don't know but would have been a headline writer's dream if he had joined at Easter.

C: Harris. Not good enough or prem player? Under 21/development player who'll be gone by the summer.

Sullivan. Glad he's gone or should never have let him go? Glad for him and hope he get's some games and an offer.

E: Wagstaff. Should have left him at Orient or so glad he's back. Glad if he actually gets a game, not just to warm the bench.

Southendaddick

a - Crap, All Jiminez fault
b - Crap, All Jiminez fault
c - Crap, All Jiminez fault
d - Crap, All Jiminez fault
e - Glad hes back I like him more than Green but should never have let him go, All Jiminez fault