Players Marks: Charlton v Barnsley

lancashire lad

for those at the Valley tonight your marks out of 10 please:

Hamer
Solly
Dervite
Wood
Wiggins
Harriott
Poyet
Cousins
Jackson
Sordell
Obika
Reza

Wilson n/a
Ajdarevic n/a

Bedsaddick

Utter shite. End off. . Nothing more to be said .

Hamer - 5
Solly - 6
Dervite - 5
Wood -5
Wiggins -5
Harriott -4
Poyet - 6
Cousins - 7 MOM
Jackson - 5
Sordell - 3
Obika - 2

Reza

Wilson n/a
Ajdarevic n/a

Laddick01

Hamer -4 - Slow off his line , No idea what he was doing for the second , watched it
Solly -7- Battled hard
Dervite -6- Flashes of good and bad
Wood - 5- Morrison ?
Wiggins -7- see solly
Harriott -2- If he doesn't play for us again it wouldn't bother me
Poyet -7- Once again the heart of the midfield , overplayed slightly at times
Cousins -6.5
Jackson -6
Sordell -6
Obika -6

Reza -5.5- Alright at times , Too weak though

Nicholas

Hamer 2 how the hell did the 2nd goal go in. That's 3 games on the bounce he has fucked up. Just changed his mark to a 2 from a 3 after seeing there goal on the telly. He ducked ffs.
Solly 5
Dervite 6
Wood 5 too slow mental to drop Morrison for him
Wiggins 5
Harriott 3. Not a right midfielder the one minute he played on the left he made 2 good chances then subbed. Well done Riga for probably fucking his confidence up for the rest of the season.
Poyet 6. Best player but was subbed. Nice one gaffer
Cousins 5
Jackson 4. Ref was shite today and games like this you need you captain to get in his face. Jacko was quiet as mouse as usual. Also his not good enough to play a full game. Very concerning everyone else gets dropped or subbed bar him.
Sordell 4. No service but is too weak.
Obika 2 how the hell did he play the whole match.
Reza 4 wanted to be the hero but looked crap.

Riga 0. Thought we was going to get away from the weird selections when Powell went but no. Rigas fault today 100%

Pico

Hamer 5
Solly 6
Dervite 5.5 (should have scored)
Wood 6
Wiggins 6
Harriott 3
Poyet 6.5
Cousins 7
Jackson 5
Sordell 6
Obika 4.5
Reza 5

Heisenberg

Hamer 5 - couldn't prevent first but wtf happened with second? Good distribution however
Solly 6 - looked like he hadn't been away
Dervite 5 - anonymous tonight
Wood 5 - mistake to rest Morro
Wiggins 6 - looks out for season now
Harriott 3 - just awful
Poyet 6 - MOM
Cousins 5.5 - first half awful but improved
Jackson 5.5 - worked tirelessly
Sordell 4 - it's already been said over and over
Obika 4 - disappeared after 20 minutes
Reza 5 - flattered to deceive

Heisenberg

Duplicate post

MSE7

Same old charlton fooking useless

Danny Addick

Hamer 5.5
Solly 6
Dervite 7
Wood 6
Wiggins 7
Harriott 3
Poyet 6
Cousins 8.5 carried the team
Jackson 6
Sordell 6.5 tried!
Obika 4
Reza 6.5

Buglehorn

Hamer 5.5
Solly 6
Wood 6
Devite 6
Wiggins 6
Harriott 4
Poyet 6.5
Cousins 7
Jackson 6
Obika 6
Sordell 5.5

Reza 5
Wilson 5

Lazy_eye_metaphor

Hamer 6
Solly 6
Dervite 6
Wood 5
Wiggins 6
Harriott 4
Poyet 7 MOM
Cousins 6
Jackson 6
Sordell 5
Obika 5
Reza 6

Lower_Westsider

Harriot -1 useless waste of space

RedChaser

Hamer 5
Solly 6.5
Dervite 6
Wood 5
Wiggins 6
Harriott 3
Poyet 7.5
Cousins 7
Jackson 6
Sordell 6
Obika 6
Reza 6

Cafckinsella

Hamer 5.5
Solly 6
Dervite 7
Wood 6
Wiggins 7

Harriott 3- his confidence is a real issue, makes a mistake and then tries to rectify it by doing trickery when a simple ball is on. Must learn to play simple football

Poyet 7 him and cousins are too good to be playing league 1 football

Cousins 8 best player on the pitch

Jackson 6

Sordell 6.5 good hold up play, anything he does wrong he gets abused for no wonder his confidence is shattered

Obika 4- He really isn't that good

Reza 5 tried but nothing came from him

floydroadfaithfull

And this bunch want me to renew my s/t dream on rd

C_A_F_C

Hamer 5
Solly 7
Dervite 7
Wood 6
Wiggins 6
Harriott 5
Poyet 6
Cousins 7
Jackson 6
Sordell 5
Obika 5
Reza 6

boggzy

Hamer 6
Solly 6
Dervite 6
Wood 5.5
Wiggins 5.5
Harriott 4
Poyet 7.5
Cousins 8 MOM as above - him and Poyet too good for this dross
Jackson 6
Sordell 5
Obika 4.5
Reza 6.5

Manager 3

Ref 3 (but not an excuse for the loss)

sirjohnhumphrey

for those at the Valley tonight your marks out of 10 please:

Hamer 5. Distribution good and caught well, but that second goal?
Solly 6. Solid enough but done a couple if times
Dervite 7. A decent game.
Wood 6. A little uncertain at times
Wiggins 7.5. Good game. Another injury is a big blow
Harriott 4. Poor.
Poyet 7. Assured again and some good runs.
Cousins 8. Was everywhere and is getting forward more. Didn't allow Dawson to bully him.
Jackson 7. Steady and some good link up play.
Sordell 4.5. Not disinterested but seems unable to stay on his feet under pressure.
Obika 4.5. Had plenty of opportunities to play in others but failed to do so.
Reza 5.5. Buzzed around but looked in no way a threat.

Wilson n/a
Ajdarevic n/a

DeeBee

Hamer 5
Solly 6
Dervite 6
Wood 4
Wiggins 6
Harriott 2
Poyet 6.5
Cousins 7
Jackson 5.5
Sordell 5
Obika 4
Reza 6

Sir Chrissy

Hamer - 5 - would like to see 2nd again to see what the hell went on?

Solly - 6.5 - not fit but 100% as always

Dervite - 6.5 - ok

Wood - 5.5 - not Morrison

Wiggins - 6 - will miss him now

Harriott - 3.5 - makes mistake after mistake. Tries too hard to make up for it. Confidence shot.

Poyet - 7.5 - unbelievable player. Head and shoulders above everyone, alongside cousins, on the pitch. Why oh why take him off when we need a goal I have no idea.

Cousins - 7.5 - doesn't stop grafting. Very good future. Just not here which is a shame.

Jackson - 7.5 - wish he was 5 years younger. Doesn't stop working.

Sordell - 4 - send him back to Bolton.

Obika - 5 - no service.

Reza - 5 - nothing of note.

falconwood_1

Hamer 4
Solly 6
Dervite 5
Wood 4
Wiggins 5
Harriott 4
Poyet 8 mon
Cousins 7
Jackson 4 Giving him a two year deal was nothing short of bizarre.
Sordell 4
Obika 4
Reza 4

Bar Mike Small and Akpo Sodje, I can't think of worse forwards than we have had than the two up front tonight.

Bloody rubbish.

1StevieG

Hamer - 6
Solly - 7
Dervite - 7
Wood - 7
Wiggins - 7
Harriott - 3 Only going to bother commenting one one player and ran out of expletives all the way back home describing how poor he was. Couldn't believe it when I heard he was starting. Way out of his league. Don't want to see him in a red shirt again.
Poyet - 7.5
Cousins - 7
Jackson - 6
Sordell - 5
Obika - 5
Reza - 6

cafcrocky87

Hamer 7 - great distribution, nothing could do for first, perhaps suspect for second.
Solly 8 - so composed, solid and offers an option forward
Dervite 6 - ok
Wood 6 - ok
Wiggins 6 - not too many positives or negatives
Harriott 2 - not usually one to give low marks, but boy was he poor.
Poyet 8 - so composed, creative and only hindered by those in front
Cousins 7 - not quite Poyet, but tries hard
Jackson 5 - creativity lacking, slow
Sordell 4 - can't believe how long he took when clean through
Obika 5 - runs, but lacks ability
Reza 5 - one shot way way off target was the highlight

Holdkneebomb

Hamer 4
Solly 5
Dervite 6
Wood 6
Wiggins 7
Harriott 4
Poyet 6
Cousins 6
Jackson 7 mom
Sordell 4
Obika 6
Reza 6

Unknown

This content has been removed.

kimbo

Hamer 5.5
Solly 6.5
Dervite 7
Wood 6
Wiggins 6
Harriott 4
Poyet 6.5
Cousins 7.5
Jackson 7
Sordell 6
Obika 6.5
Reza 6

seth plum

Hamer 6
Solly 7
Dervite 7
Wood 7
Wiggins 7
Harriott 4
Poyet 7.5
Cousins 8
Jackson 7.5
Sordell 5
Obika 5.5
Reza 4.5

mid_life_crisis

Hamer - 4
Solly - 6
Dervite - 6
Wood - 5
Wiggins - 6
Harriott - 4
Poyet - 6
Cousins - 7
Jackson - 6
Sordell - 4
Obika - 5
Reza - 6

stackitsteve

Hamer - 5
Solly - 6
Dervite - 6
Wood - 6
Wiggins - 6
Harriott - 4
Poyet - 6
Cousins - 8
Jackson - 6
Sordell - 5
Obika - 5
Reza - 5

masicat

Hamer - 4
Solly - 6.5
Dervite - 6
Wood - 5
Wiggins - 6.5
Harriott - 1
Poyet - 8
Cousins - 7.5
Jackson - 5.5
Sordell - 5
Obika - 5
Reza - 6

Riga 1 ( petticoat is showing )

paulsturgess

Hamer 5
Solly 5
Dervite 5
Wood 5
Wiggins 6.5
Harriott 2
Poyet 6
Cousins 7
Jackson 6.5
Sordell 5.5
Obika 5
Reza 4

Harriott was shambolic. Playing him on the right was the direct opposite of a masterstroke. Obika started well but was dire second half. Actually thought contrary to many others that Sordell had one of his better games for us, far more appetite than he showed on Saturday and managed to come away with the ball and hold it up in some difficult positions. Far better than Church. However, he is still utter dog turd and couldn't hit a cow's arse with a banjo.

WHY HAS NOT A SINGLE **** INVOLVED WITH RUNNING THE CLUB THIS SEASON AT LEAST ATTEMPTED TO GIVE ONE OF THE POOR BASTARDS CHARGED WITH MANAGING THE TEAM A FOOTBALL PLAYER WHO CAN AT LEAST ATTEMPT A SHOT AT THE GOAL.