worst charlton eleven,,,,,,
Comments
-
Surely you can't have Rowett in this thread. It wasn't his fault. He was excellent until his unfortunate injury. Yes, expensive games to price ratio but I'm sure the club would have received a decent insurance payout.ads said:
He'll come good, he's banging em in in the Maltese first division so unlikely we'd be able to get him back to the valley.LenGlover said:Chris Dickson with his prolific goalscoring record must be a contender?
Sorondo, Llera, Bagheri, Gary Rowett, Jonathan Spencer, Ian Dowie.....money well spent2 -
All good calls there. Funnily enough I didn't mind Green, good player in there but so frustrating. Sam and Thomas I wasn't so keen on. All typical wide players I guess, no consistency and should have achieved more that the have done.SDAddick said:
Out wide you'd have plenty to choose from. Scott Wagstaff plus one from Lloyd Sam, Jerome Thomas, Darren Ambrose, Danny Green (did anyone rate him? I couldn't stand him).ricky_otto said:
That's it Stig - Kish was certainly the type of player i was looking for. He certainly divided opinion.Stig said:
I suspect a midfield pairing of Kish and Holland would probably be the best example.ricky_otto said:Was thinking about an XI that divided opinion as in not your worst player, not your best but somewhere in the middle - players such as Danny Murphy (probably not the best example)
0 -
I'd put forth a similar argument about Corey Gibbs. He was a very decent player, played at a World Cup, but had chronic knee problems when he joined us and never played.Bangkokaddick said:
Surely you can't have Rowett in this thread. It wasn't his fault. He was excellent until his unfortunate injury. Yes, expensive games to price ratio but I'm sure the club would have received a decent insurance payout.ads said:
He'll come good, he's banging em in in the Maltese first division so unlikely we'd be able to get him back to the valley.LenGlover said:Chris Dickson with his prolific goalscoring record must be a contender?
Sorondo, Llera, Bagheri, Gary Rowett, Jonathan Spencer, Ian Dowie.....money well spent0 -
Certainly can't include Rowett. Would have been an excellent signing if it wasn't for injury.Bangkokaddick said:
Surely you can't have Rowett in this thread. It wasn't his fault. He was excellent until his unfortunate injury. Yes, expensive games to price ratio but I'm sure the club would have received a decent insurance payout.ads said:
He'll come good, he's banging em in in the Maltese first division so unlikely we'd be able to get him back to the valley.LenGlover said:Chris Dickson with his prolific goalscoring record must be a contender?
Sorondo, Llera, Bagheri, Gary Rowett, Jonathan Spencer, Ian Dowie.....money well spent
3 -
Plus wasnt Cory Gibbs a Free Transfer...SDAddick said:
I'd put forth a similar argument about Corey Gibbs. He was a very decent player, played at a World Cup, but had chronic knee problems when he joined us and never played.Bangkokaddick said:
Surely you can't have Rowett in this thread. It wasn't his fault. He was excellent until his unfortunate injury. Yes, expensive games to price ratio but I'm sure the club would have received a decent insurance payout.ads said:
He'll come good, he's banging em in in the Maltese first division so unlikely we'd be able to get him back to the valley.LenGlover said:Chris Dickson with his prolific goalscoring record must be a contender?
Sorondo, Llera, Bagheri, Gary Rowett, Jonathan Spencer, Ian Dowie.....money well spent0 -
Signing from Crystal Palace.Charlton_Stu said:Remember the name, but that's about it, also Chris Jones from Spurs can't remember if he was on loan or a signing.
Scored a good volley to beat Man City at Maine Road (one of the best away wins I've been to). Didn't do much else apart from headers against Cardiff and Brentford.2 -
Consolation goals in 4-1 humiliations are not eligible for diplomatic immunity.1StevieG said:Naby Sarr scored against
Palace in the cup so he has some immunity.2 -
Would Brendan O'Connell be in with a shout? I was still quite young when he played for us and seem to remember thinking he wasn't very good but I can't really remember if he was shite or just a bit average.0
-
Shite.Exiled_Addick said:Would Brendan O'Connell be in with a shout? I was still quite young when he played for us and seem to remember thinking he wasn't very good but I can't really remember if he was shite or just a bit average.
1 -
Maybe in your book but he's got a free pass off my shit list.Exiled_Addick said:
Consolation goals in 4-1 humiliations are not eligible for diplomatic immunity.1StevieG said:Naby Sarr scored against
Palace in the cup so he has some immunity.0 -
Sponsored links:
-
That's what I thought, still probably better than Faye and McCormack though. At least the one's that played for Charlton.ricky_otto said:
Shite.Exiled_Addick said:Would Brendan O'Connell be in with a shout? I was still quite young when he played for us and seem to remember thinking he wasn't very good but I can't really remember if he was shite or just a bit average.
0 -
To a degree, it's all down to personal opinion. I remember standing on the East Terrace behind a guy who would shout "Aaarggh, Hales!!" every time Killer passed the ball. And I remember that John Dunn, Eamon Dunphy, Keith Peacock and even Paddy Powell had their detractors at the time. Dick Tydeman anyone?0
-
I'd have him over those 2 that's for sure.Exiled_Addick said:
That's what I thought, still probably better than Faye and McCormack though. At least the one's that played for Charlton.ricky_otto said:
Shite.Exiled_Addick said:Would Brendan O'Connell be in with a shout? I was still quite young when he played for us and seem to remember thinking he wasn't very good but I can't really remember if he was shite or just a bit average.
0 -
He does impressions that explains a lotunjpc49427 said:Reuben Agboola struggled to make an impression. Surprised he doesn't make the bench at least!
0 -
"Coach" Karel Fraeye
1 Yohann Thuram-Ulien
2 Loic Nego
3 Djimi Traore
4 El Hadji Ba
5 Rhys Williams
6 Roger Johnson
7 Ralph Milne RIP
8 Christope Lepoint
9 Piotr Parzyek
10 Leon Clarke
11 Jesper Blomquist
Subs
12 Naby Sarr
13 Mike Salmon
14 Brendan O'Connell
15 Alan McCormack
16 Kenny Achampong
17 Kim Grant (maybe exonerated due to the snow goals)
18 Tamer Tuna
I've been going since '88 so tried to keep to just players I've seen but it's really hard to get away from the Staypricks signings....0 -
Scored the winner in the 1-0 win at Maine Road in 1983-84 season. That made me oblivious to anything else he was good or bad at...Charlton_Stu said:Remember the name, but that's about it, also Chris Jones from Spurs can't remember if he was on loan or a signing.
0
