Rudd: 7 - Could do nothing about the goal, solid apart from that Solly: 9 - Different class MOTM Fox: 7 - Fantastic Defensively, poor going forward Konsa: 6.5 - Bit nervy but grew into the game Pearce: 7 - Solid Holmes: 7.5 - He made the difference when he moved to a more central position, started to boss the game in our 20 min spel Foley: 6 - Didn't notice him much Crofts: 6.5- Okay Jackson: 7- Was everywhere, so much passion and great goal Magennis: 8 - Strong, good in the air was better then expected, real hard worker ! Ajose: 5 - Better second half but needs the ball to his feet to make things happen Lookman: 6.5 - bags of ability, needs to start and sometimes look for the pass rarther then shoot
Rudd 6 Didn't have much to do. No chance with the goal. Solly 7 Mom Fox 6 DId ok Konza 6 Some good interceptions but the odd mistake which you would expect for his age Pearce 6 Not the dominant force we had been lead to believe. Hopefully will improve with Bauer along side Holmes 6 Looked lively but it's hard when you are the only creative player in the side Foley 5 Should only be used as cover for Solly Crofts 6 Got better as the game went on Jackson 6 took goal well and better when he moved inside Magennis 6 worked hard but never looked like scoring Ajose 6 Annonymous first half, 2 good shots on the turn second half and lovely pass for the goal Lookman 6 Looked dangerous but guilty of over running it and not looking up a couple of times.
Rudd: 7. He is good enough Solly: 7. Solid. Worked hard to press. Fox: 7. Defensively ok today. Konsa: 8. Kids a class act. Rufus like at times. Pearce: 8. A winner. Like him. Holmes: 7.5. Slow but creative. Foley: 7.5 Brave. Wants the ball when others don't. Crofts: 7.5 Sorry but I rate him. Jackson: 7. At fault for goal. No legs. Only option is to play him centrally. Magennis: 7. Physical. Worked hard. Ajose: 7.5 Better with back to goal. Superb touch. Lookman. 6. Premier league. Do me a favour.
Rudd: 6.5 didn't do too much wrong Solly: 7 busy Fox: 6.5 few over hit passes Konsa: 6.5 had his work cut out with Revell but did OK Pearce: 7 intercepted lots Holmes: 7.5 made some great runs with the ball Foley: 6.5 tidy performance Crofts: 6.5 busy Jackson: 7 extra point for goal Magennis: 7 put more effort into one game than Marcus Bent did in his Charlton career Ajose: 6.5 made three quick turn and shots, nearly scored Lookman 7.5 made some good runs
Rudd: 6: very competent, not much to do Solly: 7.5: a tigerish performance Fox: 6.5: did pretty well. Not much support on the left flank in the first half Konsa: 6.5: a couple of shaky moments early on but settled down and looked comfortable Pearce: 6: solid Holmes: 7.5: our main source of creative play Foley: 5: looked like what he is, namely, a full back slotting into midfield Crofts: 6: a very poor first half but much improved in the second; he played with much more energy and passed the ball forward, rather than sideways or hoofing it mindlessly up the middle Jackson: 6.5: poor in the first half when deployed out of position on the left; much better in the second and a fine finish for our equaliser Magennis: 6.5: a promising debut Ajose: 6.5: unsurprisingly, he barely touched the ball in the first half, when we played hoofball. Much better in the second half - a couple of good efforts on goal and he frequently came deep to link the play up intelligently Lookman: 7: really troubled Northampton. Defenders at this level will find him a real handful if we can hold onto him
Rudd: 6 - not at fault for goal and little else to do Solly: 8 - all action performance and point-saving block at the death Fox: 7 - looked unusually assured Konsa : 6 - a good prospect but premature to be a first choice when Bauer is fit Pearce: 6 - rarely noticed him which is usually good for a defender (but someone didn't pick up Revell for the goal) Holmes: 7 - encouraging but little end product - lacks pace Foley: 6 - perfectly solid defensive midfield cover until Diarra or Kashi retunrs Crofts: 7 - impressive physical presence but not one to unlock defences Jackson: 5 - great finish but anonymous otherwise - painfully slow Magennis : 6 - muscular and direct with great workrate Ajose: 6 - unlucky with one individual effort but great assist and will eventually score goals Lookman 6 - seems too casual despite obvious talent
Rudd: 7 - couldn't fault him on the goal and did everything else with confidence Solly: 8 MOM - solid Fox: 7 - his crossing let him down in the frst half in particular but very good otherwise Konsa: 6 - a real prospect but still raw at times, would still pick ahead of Relegator though Pearce: 7 - solid and think he'll improve as the team gels Holmes: 8 - was our only creative output, desperately need him to stay fit Foley: 5 - will be a decent squad addition but should not be relied upon Crofts: 6 - improved presence in the middle but another not to be relied upon Jackson: 6 - gets an extra mark for the goal, woeful 1st half made me think of the retirement thread on here but as ever is a threat in front of goal, can finish and you just knew he'd tuck that chance away Magennis: 7 - thought he was a presence up front which is more than many of our recent strikers can say Ajose: 6 - needs better service but did link up well with Magennis at times, another who will improve as the team gels Lookman: 7 - why was he on the bench? clearly too good for Northampton, start him on Tuesday!
Rudd: 7 - solid Solly: 8 - never lets us down Fox: 6 Konsa: 7.5 - thought he was brilliant second half Pearce: 7 Holmes: 8 MOM - lost momentum when he went off and looked better CM; tried too hard though Foley: 6 Crofts: 6.5 - better second half Jackson: 6.5 Magennis: 6.5 - honest, worked hard, good hold up player; we only started to play well when we stopped hoofing it to him though Ajose: 6.5 - I don't think he received a single pass first half - feed him, he knows where the goal is
Lookman: 6.5 - good to see him back but poor decision making and greedy Botaka - hopefully will improve when fit?? Novak - didn't notice him
Rudd: 6 Solly: 6 Fox: 6 Konsa: 6 Pearce: 6 Holmes: 7 Foley: 3 Crofts: 10 extra 2 for some of the silly marks on here , could some of you please try to watch the game without blindfolds on? Jackson: 3 will live on that goal for another 10 games Magennis: 6 Big , powerfull and pony , hope he proves me wrong Ajose: Their is a good striker in there , just needs sone decent service Lookman: Why the fuck did he not start only russ will know
Rudd: 6 - Had little to do but pick the ball out of the back of the net. Solly: 7 - Solid performance Fox: 7 - Some fantastic tackles in the 2nd half. Unlike Solly, no help, so having to be far more circumspect. Konsa: 6 - A few wobbles early on, but a solid debut. Pearce: 6 - Probably not heard during the game, but in the pre match drills very vocal. Solid, if unspectacular. Holmes: 7.5 - MOTM. Maybe you could say he tried too hard, but the emphasis should be on TRIED. No prisoners from the Cobblers, which means I bet he has some new bruises this morning. Genuinely always wants the ball. The tempo of our game disappeared when he was substituted. Yes, he made some mistakes, but if he didn't, we couldn't afford him! Foley: 6 - Decent, I thought. Always available, and moves the ball quickly. Crofts: 6.5 - Best of the midfield. Moved well, and looks as fit as a butcher's dog. Jackson: 6.5 - Legs have gone. The Jacko of old would have got on the end of that sweeping, incisive move, and buried that chance. Hang on a minute... Magennis: 7 - Where are those people who said he was sh*t? They were right. He did nothing but make intelligent runs, win headers, hold the ball up, and pass to team mates. I dread to think how rubbish he will be when he knows all his team mates names, and doesn't have to shout "Oi!"... Ajose: 6.5 - Poor first half, but dropped deeper to get more involved in the second. Then involved in most of the good link up play when we were battering them. A couple of outstanding turns and shots which showed how good he can be in this league, when everybody has settled in. Lookman: 6 - First touch usually excellent. Second usually pants. We all no how good Ade is, but worryingly picking up the TW habit of never passing. Settle down, Ade, and make it impossible for Slade to drop you...
Can we have somewhere to comment on marks rather than getting flagged please?
I only flag someone if their remarks are extreme and offensive, which is rare. Marks are very individual and no mark is wrong although the occasional one does raise the eyebrow. For this reason I see no need to comment on someones marks but if you want to then start your own thread.
Rudd: 6 Not much to do. What he did he did competently without being particularly good or bad
Solly: 7 One of the few to turn up for 90 minutes as ever. 'Proper' Charlton. MOM
Fox: 6.5 Always puts in a shift. Encouraging to see him up at corners and trying to get forward more.
Konsa: 6.5 Horrible shank in the first minute or two but grew into it and didn't look out of place at all.
Pearce: 6 My instinctive reaction was that he was at fault for the goal hence .5 less than Fox and Konsa. Jury out.
Holmes: 6.5 Tough making his home debut against his old club. Mixed bag but hope for the future.
Foley: 6 Hardly noticed him which might mean he was working solidly off the ball which is a good thing but I cannot really mark him up or down from my par of 6 based on that performance.
Crofts: 6.5 He's not Jordan Cousins that's for sure but more mobile than I thought he'd be and showed definite glimpses of having played at a higher level. Decent shot off target in the first half.
Jackson: 6.5 Struggles on the left but cometh the hour cometh the man with his goal
Magennis: 7 Hardworking and a useful long throw. Occasionally looks like Akpo in a kilt but overall a positive first impression
Ajose: 6.5 Totally anonymous first half showed encouraging glimpses in the second that with a service he could be useful.
Lookman: 7 Changed the game in our favour when he arrived. We need to see more of him even if he cannot do the full 90.
Comments
Solly: 9 - Different class MOTM
Fox: 7 - Fantastic Defensively, poor going forward
Konsa: 6.5 - Bit nervy but grew into the game
Pearce: 7 - Solid
Holmes: 7.5 - He made the difference when he moved to a more central position, started to boss the game in our 20 min spel
Foley: 6 - Didn't notice him much
Crofts: 6.5- Okay
Jackson: 7- Was everywhere, so much passion and great goal
Magennis: 8 - Strong, good in the air was better then expected, real hard worker !
Ajose: 5 - Better second half but needs the ball to his feet to make things happen
Lookman: 6.5 - bags of ability, needs to start and sometimes look for the pass rarther then shoot
Solly: 8
Fox: 6
konsa : 6
Pearce: 6
Holmes: 8
Foley: 5
Crofts: 6.5
Jackson: 6.5
Magennis : 6.5
Ajose: 7.5
Lookman : 7
Solly 7 Mom
Fox 6 DId ok
Konza 6 Some good interceptions but the odd mistake which you would expect for his age
Pearce 6 Not the dominant force we had been lead to believe. Hopefully will improve with Bauer along side
Holmes 6 Looked lively but it's hard when you are the only creative player in the side
Foley 5 Should only be used as cover for Solly
Crofts 6 Got better as the game went on
Jackson 6 took goal well and better when he moved inside
Magennis 6 worked hard but never looked like scoring
Ajose 6 Annonymous first half, 2 good shots on the turn second half and lovely pass for the goal
Lookman 6 Looked dangerous but guilty of over running it and not looking up a couple of times.
Solly: 8
Fox: 6
Cons 6.5:
Pearce: 6.5
Holmes: 7
Foley: 5.5
Crofts: 6
Jackson: 7.5
Magennis: 7
Ajose: 7
Lookman: 6.5
Solly: 8
Fox: 7
Konsa: 6
Pearce: 6
Holmes: 8
Foley: 5
Crofts: 5
Jackson: 6.5
Magennis: 7.5
Ajose: 7 unlucky with a quick shot. Needs a goal to settle.
Lookman: 6
Novak: I was quite impressed. Think he is a better footballer than Mag the magnificent.
Solly: 7.5
Fox: 6.5
Konsa: 6.5
Pearce: 7
Holmes: 8
Foley: 6
Crofts: 7
Jackson: 6
Magennis: 6
Ajose: 6.5
Lookman: 7
Rudd: 7. He is good enough
Solly: 7. Solid. Worked hard to press.
Fox: 7. Defensively ok today.
Konsa: 8. Kids a class act. Rufus like at times.
Pearce: 8. A winner. Like him.
Holmes: 7.5. Slow but creative.
Foley: 7.5 Brave. Wants the ball when others don't.
Crofts: 7.5 Sorry but I rate him.
Jackson: 7. At fault for goal. No legs. Only option is to play him centrally.
Magennis: 7. Physical. Worked hard.
Ajose: 7.5 Better with back to goal. Superb touch.
Lookman. 6. Premier league. Do me a favour.
Solly 7
Fox 6.5
Konsa 6
Pearce 6
Holmes 6.5
Foley 5.5
Crofts 6.5
Jackson 6.5
Magennis 6
Ajose 6
Lookman 6
Botaka 5
Novak 6
Solly: 8
Fox: 7
Konsa: 7
Pearce: 7
Holmes: 7
Foley: 6
Crofts: 6
Jackson: 7
Magennis: 6
Ajose: 6
Lookman: 6
Solly: 7.5
Fox: 7
Konsa: 7
Pearce: 7
Holmes: 7
Foley: 6.5
Crofts: 7
Jackson: 7
Magennis: 7.5
Ajose: 6.5
Lookman: 6.5
Solly: 7 busy
Fox: 6.5 few over hit passes
Konsa: 6.5 had his work cut out with Revell but did OK
Pearce: 7 intercepted lots
Holmes: 7.5 made some great runs with the ball
Foley: 6.5 tidy performance
Crofts: 6.5 busy
Jackson: 7 extra point for goal
Magennis: 7 put more effort into one game than Marcus Bent did in his Charlton career
Ajose: 6.5 made three quick turn and shots, nearly scored
Lookman 7.5 made some good runs
Solly: 7.5: a tigerish performance
Fox: 6.5: did pretty well. Not much support on the left flank in the first half
Konsa: 6.5: a couple of shaky moments early on but settled down and looked comfortable
Pearce: 6: solid
Holmes: 7.5: our main source of creative play
Foley: 5: looked like what he is, namely, a full back slotting into midfield
Crofts: 6: a very poor first half but much improved in the second; he played with much more energy and passed the ball forward, rather than sideways or hoofing it mindlessly up the middle
Jackson: 6.5: poor in the first half when deployed out of position on the left; much better in the second and a fine finish for our equaliser
Magennis: 6.5: a promising debut
Ajose: 6.5: unsurprisingly, he barely touched the ball in the first half, when we played hoofball. Much better in the second half - a couple of good efforts on goal and he frequently came deep to link the play up intelligently
Lookman: 7: really troubled Northampton. Defenders at this level will find him a real handful if we can hold onto him
Solly: 8 - all action performance and point-saving block at the death
Fox: 7 - looked unusually assured
Konsa : 6 - a good prospect but premature to be a first choice when Bauer is fit
Pearce: 6 - rarely noticed him which is usually good for a defender (but someone didn't pick up Revell for the goal)
Holmes: 7 - encouraging but little end product - lacks pace
Foley: 6 - perfectly solid defensive midfield cover until Diarra or Kashi retunrs
Crofts: 7 - impressive physical presence but not one to unlock defences
Jackson: 5 - great finish but anonymous otherwise - painfully slow
Magennis : 6 - muscular and direct with great workrate
Ajose: 6 - unlucky with one individual effort but great assist and will eventually score goals
Lookman 6 - seems too casual despite obvious talent
Solly 5.5
Fox 5
Konsa: 7
Pearce: 6
Holmes: 5
Foley: 5
Crofts: 6
Jackson: 7
Magennis: 4.5
Ajose: 6.5
Lookman: 6
Solly: 8 MOM - solid
Fox: 7 - his crossing let him down in the frst half in particular but very good otherwise
Konsa: 6 - a real prospect but still raw at times, would still pick ahead of Relegator though
Pearce: 7 - solid and think he'll improve as the team gels
Holmes: 8 - was our only creative output, desperately need him to stay fit
Foley: 5 - will be a decent squad addition but should not be relied upon
Crofts: 6 - improved presence in the middle but another not to be relied upon
Jackson: 6 - gets an extra mark for the goal, woeful 1st half made me think of the retirement thread on here but as ever is a threat in front of goal, can finish and you just knew he'd tuck that chance away
Magennis: 7 - thought he was a presence up front which is more than many of our recent strikers can say
Ajose: 6 - needs better service but did link up well with Magennis at times, another who will improve as the team gels
Lookman: 7 - why was he on the bench? clearly too good for Northampton, start him on Tuesday!
Solly: 8
Fox: 7
konsa : 7
Pearce: 6
Holmes: 8
Foley: 6
Crofts: 7
Jackson: 7.5
Magennis : 7
Ajose: 7.5
Lookman : 7
Solly: 7.5
Fox: 6.5
Konsa: 5
Pearce: 5.5
Holmes: 7
Foley: 5
Crofts: 5.5
Jackson: 6.5
Magennis: 5.5
Ajose: 6.5
Lookman: 6
Rudd: 7
Solly: 8
Fox: 7
Konsa: 6.5
Pearce: 6.5
Holmes: 7.5
Foley: 5
Crofts: 6
Jackson: 7
Magennis: 7.5
Ajose: 7
Lookman: 6.5
Solly: 8 - never lets us down
Fox: 6
Konsa: 7.5 - thought he was brilliant second half
Pearce: 7
Holmes: 8 MOM - lost momentum when he went off and looked better CM; tried too hard though
Foley: 6
Crofts: 6.5 - better second half
Jackson: 6.5
Magennis: 6.5 - honest, worked hard, good hold up player; we only started to play well when we stopped hoofing it to him though
Ajose: 6.5 - I don't think he received a single pass first half - feed him, he knows where the goal is
Lookman: 6.5 - good to see him back but poor decision making and greedy
Botaka - hopefully will improve when fit??
Novak - didn't notice him
Solly 8.5
Fox 6.5
Konsa. 7
Pearce. 7
Holmes 8.5
Foley. 6.5
Crofts. 6.5
Jackson. 7
Magennis. 7
Ajose 6.5
Lookman. 7
Solly: 6
Fox: 6
Konsa: 6
Pearce: 6
Holmes: 7
Foley: 3
Crofts: 10 extra 2 for some of the silly marks on here , could some of you please try to watch the game without blindfolds on?
Jackson: 3 will live on that goal for another 10 games
Magennis: 6 Big , powerfull and pony , hope he proves me wrong
Ajose: Their is a good striker in there , just needs sone decent service
Lookman: Why the fuck did he not start only russ will know
Solly: 7 - Solid performance
Fox: 7 - Some fantastic tackles in the 2nd half. Unlike Solly, no help, so having to be far more circumspect.
Konsa: 6 - A few wobbles early on, but a solid debut.
Pearce: 6 - Probably not heard during the game, but in the pre match drills very vocal. Solid, if unspectacular.
Holmes: 7.5 - MOTM. Maybe you could say he tried too hard, but the emphasis should be on TRIED. No prisoners from the Cobblers, which means I bet he has some new bruises this morning. Genuinely always wants the ball. The tempo of our game disappeared when he was substituted. Yes, he made some mistakes, but if he didn't, we couldn't afford him!
Foley: 6 - Decent, I thought. Always available, and moves the ball quickly.
Crofts: 6.5 - Best of the midfield. Moved well, and looks as fit as a butcher's dog.
Jackson: 6.5 - Legs have gone. The Jacko of old would have got on the end of that sweeping, incisive move, and buried that chance. Hang on a minute...
Magennis: 7 - Where are those people who said he was sh*t? They were right. He did nothing but make intelligent runs, win headers, hold the ball up, and pass to team mates. I dread to think how rubbish he will be when he knows all his team mates names, and doesn't have to shout "Oi!"...
Ajose: 6.5 - Poor first half, but dropped deeper to get more involved in the second. Then involved in most of the good link up play when we were battering them. A couple of outstanding turns and shots which showed how good he can be in this league, when everybody has settled in.
Lookman: 6 - First touch usually excellent. Second usually pants. We all no how good Ade is, but worryingly picking up the TW habit of never passing. Settle down, Ade, and make it impossible for Slade to drop you...
Solly 8
Fox 7
Konsa 7
Pearce 7.5
Holmes 7.5
Foley 5
Crofts 6
Jackson 7
Magennis 7
Ajose 6.5
Lookman 7
Rudd: 7
Solly: 7
Fox: 6.5
Konsa 7
Pearce: 6.5
Holmes: 7
Foley: 6
Crofts: 6.5
Jackson: 6.5
Magennis 6.5
Ajose 6.5
Lookman 7
Botaka: n/a
Novak: n/a
Solly: 7.5
Fox: 7
Konsa: 6.5
Pearce: 6
Holmes: 7.5
Foley: 6
Crofts: 6
Jackson: 6
Magennis: 7.5
Ajose: 6.5
Lookman: 6.5
Solly: 7 One of the few to turn up for 90 minutes as ever. 'Proper' Charlton. MOM
Fox: 6.5 Always puts in a shift. Encouraging to see him up at corners and trying to get forward more.
Konsa: 6.5 Horrible shank in the first minute or two but grew into it and didn't look out of place at all.
Pearce: 6 My instinctive reaction was that he was at fault for the goal hence .5 less than Fox and Konsa. Jury out.
Holmes: 6.5 Tough making his home debut against his old club. Mixed bag but hope for the future.
Foley: 6 Hardly noticed him which might mean he was working solidly off the ball which is a good thing but I cannot really mark him up or down from my par of 6 based on that performance.
Crofts: 6.5 He's not Jordan Cousins that's for sure but more mobile than I thought he'd be and showed definite glimpses of having played at a higher level. Decent shot off target in the first half.
Jackson: 6.5 Struggles on the left but cometh the hour cometh the man with his goal
Magennis: 7 Hardworking and a useful long throw. Occasionally looks like Akpo in a kilt but overall a positive first impression
Ajose: 6.5 Totally anonymous first half showed encouraging glimpses in the second that with a service he could be useful.
Lookman: 7 Changed the game in our favour when he arrived. We need to see more of him even if he cannot do the full 90.
Botaka: n/a Jury out!
Novak: n/a
Solly: 7
Fox: 7
Konsa: 6.5
Pearce: 6.5
Holmes: 7.5
Foley: 6.5
Crofts: -7
Jackson: 7
Magennis: 7
Ajose: 7
Lookman: 6.5