Charlton v Millwall post match views (2017, the Robinson era)
Comments
-
I thought it was a fighting performance today. If we'd have bottled it we would have lost that by a fair few goals. No one bottled any challenges and Solly was immense!20
-
Tex was terrible. Even excluding the red card i think he's hugely overrated. Bauer as well is very dodgy9
-
Charlton are covered in just 2 and a half lines.ForeverAddickted said:https://www.londonnewsonline.co.uk/15320/millwall-boss-neil-harris-created-better-chances-charlton-athletic/
Addicks boss Karl Robinson came into his post-match press conference and played the video of a disallowed goal for Patrick Bauer
the footage proving that Jordan Archer did not get challenged before the German hooked the ball home.
And the other 90% of the article is all about Millwall.
The South Lions Press lives on.
2 -
Maybe the Kent Messenger will be more balanced in the years to comeOggy Red said:
Charlton are covered in just 2 and a half lines.ForeverAddickted said:https://www.londonnewsonline.co.uk/15320/millwall-boss-neil-harris-created-better-chances-charlton-athletic/
Addicks boss Karl Robinson came into his post-match press conference and played the video of a disallowed goal for Patrick Bauer
the footage proving that Jordan Archer did not get challenged before the German hooked the ball home.
And the other 90% of the article is all about Millwall.
The South Lions Press lives on.
5 -
I'm literally 33 and greyForeverAddickted said:Would just like to say there are some Footballers who shouldn't have hair!! (Paul Konchesky is one of those for example)
Another one is Steve Morrison... He looks a proper prat and looks like he's pinched the wig from a mannequin in the Grandad section @ Marks and Spencer!!... Your 33, you shouldnt be bloody Grey!!
8 -
No one's disagreeing that the goal should have stood. There seems no reason why it wasnt and we all obviously wish it did.cafc_harry said:Some of the deliberate pessimism on here nowadays is embarrassing. Imagine arguing against a perfectly valid goal for your own team. Don't know why you bother going.
I'm just looking at the facts. That decision wasn't given, the game finished 0-0. They had 12 shots and we had 4....hence I don't think we deserved more than a point on the balance of good chances created (but if you think that gift Jordan Archer gave us means we put in a creative goalscoring performance today then fair play to you).3 -
I dont get it... I'm 33 and still have my luscious locksValleyGary said:
I'm literally 33 and greyForeverAddickted said:Would just like to say there are some Footballers who shouldn't have hair!! (Paul Konchesky is one of those for example)
Another one is Steve Morrison... He looks a proper prat and looks like he's pinched the wig from a mannequin in the Grandad section @ Marks and Spencer!!... Your 33, you shouldnt be bloody Grey!!0 -
Don't worry about the hair, the bloke is just a complete cxxx. See you next season you gormless txxx.ForeverAddickted said:Would just like to say there are some Footballers who shouldn't have hair!! (Paul Konchesky is one of those for example)
Another one is Steve Morrison... He looks a proper prat and looks like he's pinched the wig from a mannequin in the Grandad section @ Marks and Spencer!!... Your 33, you shouldnt be bloody Grey!!2 -
Thought we did OK and no doubt the players were up for it.
Thought spanners had the better chances although it seems we had a good goal disallowed.
Scum looked like a settled team who knew where to find a colleague but not brilliant. Tex and Bauer had a tough afternoon and their strikers got in behind a few times. Rudd is a good sweeper keeper.
No surprise that we looked disjointed with three debuts, Josh injured and Watt playing a role he's not suited for. Aribo and Konsa had a game to learn from.
Tex was stupid but he's apologised. Take note Roger Johnson.
Ref was all over the place. I thought the foul on Rudd was worth a red. He kicked out when the ball was in the keepers hand.
Another game without beating them but we didn't lose.
We still look a long way off a top six side but Watt, Holmes and Rudd back is positive. Losing Magennis is a blow. I like Novak and Umerah but not sure either brings the same to the side.
Like Desilva, not as impressed with Byrne but way too early to judge.6 -
Sponsored links:
-
Strange how fans see players differently... I really liked Byrne and his attitude to come in and play his socks off for usHenry Irving said:Thought we did OK and no doubt the players were up for it.
Thought spanners had the better chances although it seems we had a good goal disallowed.
Scum looked like a settled team who knew where to find a colleague but not brilliant. Tex and Bauer had a tough afternoon and their strikers got in behind a few times. Rudd is a good sweeper keeper.
No surprise that we looked disjointed with three debuts, Josh injured and Watt playing a role he's not suited for. Aribo and Konsa had a game to learn from.
Tex was stupid but he's apologised. Take note Roger Johnson.
Ref was all over the place. I thought the foul on Rudd was worth a red. He kicked out when the ball was in the keepers hand.
Another game without beating them but we didn't lose.
We still look a long way off a top six side but Watt, Holmes and Rudd back is positive. Losing Magennis is a blow. I like Novak and Umerah but not sure either brings the same to the side.
Like Desilva, not as impressed with Byrne but way too early to judge.
Jay Dasilva am sure will be a better player for us this season but feel he'll be better against the Shrewsburys and Burys of the League13 -
Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.0 -
Oh shut up you absolute whelk.Hartleypete said:Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.
15 -
Byrne was probably not match fit, he started off very well then faded, but still did well.
DaSilva showed glimpse of talent, but a hard game to make your debut in, Tony Watt
looked good, faded out when going deep then had good spells, bit more match fitness
and who knows.
The ref, what a useless prick.
2 -
Not sure how we got away with that. They missed so many chances it was ridiculous.
Far too an inexperienced side for a derby game and fielding a team of shortarses didn't help either.
Never seen Tex and Bauer look so poor. Far too many straight balls allowed over the top of them for their carthorses to run on to.
Thought that Aribo and Konsa looked lost and showed their lack of experience.
Not been a huge fan previously but thought that Crofts was our best player, by a mile. We needed his knowhow and would have been overrun without him.
Not a win but at least we didn't lose. No. Chance of promotion with the squad that we have. Time to get your chequebook out Roland - if you are serious about wanting promotion. Somehow, I doubt if that is the case.2 -
[Formerly jdmotion]
I've waited 50 years for my second Charlton v. Millwall match, and it was another 0-0.
Considering we had a revamped team, and there were further disruption because of the injuries, I think we battled very well. Millwall played a settled team, and got away with murder on the pitch, and off the ball. Had Josh not been injured it might have been a different story.
I can't believe we've developed such an inferiority complex against Millwall. If we're in the same division as them next year, I can see their spell over us being broken. They huff and puff, but haven't much class. If we can match them for desire I think we can turn them over next season, referee not withstanding.
Unless Roland's sold our best players of course.
3 -
MillwallFan said:
Oh shut up you absolute whelk.Hartleypete said:Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.
Be careful what you wish on other people Pete. The last time you wished misfortune on us (to get relegated) you soon followed us.Hartleypete said:Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.
Wish us to be f***ed over by the council I guarantee you'll be the next club to follow. Karma is a proven fact.
7 -
http://www.skysports.com/football/live-blog/12309/10727616/watch-league-one-goals-now
Highlights are a little way down... Sky didnt even bother to cover our actual disallowed goal yet instead concentrated on the first (which fair enough was a push)0 -
Forgot to give a mention to the ref. Clueless twat. He broke up more of our attacks than the Millwall players!
Never seen a ref get in the way so much.5 -
You lot can all knock Morison but how many of you would want him in your team!?
And I thought the goal was not given due to offside NOT a foul against Archer?0 -
Sponsored links:
-
You cant guarantee anything in life, except perhaps you lot coming on a Charlton website, sad twats.MillwallFan said:MillwallFan said:
Oh shut up you absolute whelk.Hartleypete said:Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.
Be careful what you wish on other people Pete. The last time you wished misfortune on us (to get relegated) you soon followed us.Hartleypete said:Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.
Wish us to be f***ed over by the council I guarantee you'll be the next club to follow. Karma is a proven fact.6 -
Didnt Greenwich do that to us back in the 80s prior to the Valley Party being setup?MillwallFan said:MillwallFan said:
Oh shut up you absolute whelk.Hartleypete said:Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.
Be careful what you wish on other people Pete. The last time you wished misfortune on us (to get relegated) you soon followed us.Hartleypete said:Byrne had a good first half but average second.
Tex was diabolical today, he did make a goaline clearance but otherwise embarrassing, miss kicked several times and bottled a number of headers. Not really sure he would ever be up for a fight.
Baur not great but did an average job.
Solly and Rudd were great today.
The rest fairly average.
Everything about Millwall is scummy, fans, players and ground. I really hope they get kicked out the den.
That ref is surely nicking a living he was an absolute disgrace.
Wish us to be f***ed over by the council I guarantee you'll be the next club to follow. Karma is a proven fact.3 -
And us not beating them2
-
The Lino did put his flag up, but that was well after the ball was in the net. Not sure who could have been offside.JMP said:You lot can all knock Morison but how many of you would want him in your team!?
And I thought the goal was not given due to offside NOT a foul against Archer?
0 -
It still baffles me how we can all watch the same match and see it completely differently, although I think we all agree the ref was watching an entirely different game to us!!
Good to have Rudd back, thought Page looked decent till he went off.
Watt was blowing before before half time but he still went going, there were definitely 2 or 3 times when he passed (wrongly) where before he would have taken his man on, so maybe he will be more of a team player this time around?.
Gutted to lose Josh and it was always going to be a struggle without him.
Byrne started well but faded, thought Dasilva showed some good pace and skill and will only get better.
Konsa and Aribo had a tough game today and will learn from it but I thought their "rawness" showed today
Personally thought Solly was MOM although the "lounges" voted Konsa.
8 points from 12 is still a decent return and a win Saturday will see us putting together a decent run.2 -
Hopefully you dont have Morrison's noncey smile as well?ValleyGary said:
I'm literally 33 and greyForeverAddickted said:Would just like to say there are some Footballers who shouldn't have hair!! (Paul Konchesky is one of those for example)
Another one is Steve Morrison... He looks a proper prat and looks like he's pinched the wig from a mannequin in the Grandad section @ Marks and Spencer!!... Your 33, you shouldnt be bloody Grey!!2 -
Doesnt it have to be two players (or Goalkeeper and one player) between the opposing player and the goal for it to be onside?JMP said:You lot can all knock Morison but how many of you would want him in your team!?
And I thought the goal was not given due to offside NOT a foul against Archer?
I guess for the 'keeper to drop the ball, our guy who hit the ball must have had Archer and another Millwall player closer to the goal at least?0 -
Not when the keeper had the ball, it doesn't matter.ForeverAddickted said:
Doesnt it have to be two players (or Goalkeeper and one player) between the opposing player and the goal for it to be onside?JMP said:You lot can all knock Morison but how many of you would want him in your team!?
And I thought the goal was not given due to offside NOT a foul against Archer?
I guess for the 'keeper to drop the ball, our guy who hit the ball must have had Archer and another Millwall player closer to the goal at least?0 -
alan dugdale said:
It's not 21 consecutive years though is it ? The clubs were in different divisions for the majority of that time. It's a lot of matches though !MillwallFan said:My inebriated match report...
Sh*t game, two poor teams. No one deserved to win. Freezing f-**ing cold. Poor atmosphere from us. Ok From you lot but can never justify a drum. We've been on a great run but just ran out of steam today I think. The fans too.
Plus side, bumped in to some old mates who I haven't seen for years. Currently warming up in a mates motor getting a lift home with a couple of beers. Boy enjoyed it. Oh, and 21 years and counting. "You'll never beat Millwall..."
Seriously don't mind you lot. Proper south London club. Good traditional ground. You'll come good again off the pitch. Oh and the plastic stripey c***s lost again and look in serious trouble. Zero respect for those pricks. Can't stand them. Will stop now as the Stella's starting to talk. Enjoy your evening folks. Miiil
Who said it was 21 consecutive years? You last beat us 22 years ago. End of.alan dugdale said:
It's not 21 consecutive years though is it ? The clubs were in different divisions for the majority of that time. It's a lot of matches though !MillwallFan said:My inebriated match report...
Sh*t game, two poor teams. No one deserved to win. Freezing f-**ing cold. Poor atmosphere from us. Ok From you lot but can never justify a drum. We've been on a great run but just ran out of steam today I think. The fans too.
Plus side, bumped in to some old mates who I haven't seen for years. Currently warming up in a mates motor getting a lift home with a couple of beers. Boy enjoyed it. Oh, and 21 years and counting. "You'll never beat Millwall..."
Seriously don't mind you lot. Proper south London club. Good traditional ground. You'll come good again off the pitch. Oh and the plastic stripey c***s lost again and look in serious trouble. Zero respect for those pricks. Can't stand them. Will stop now as the Stella's starting to talk. Enjoy your evening folks. Miiil
1 -
What about when he dropped it?guinnessaddick said:
Not when the keeper had the ball, it doesn't matter.ForeverAddickted said:
Doesnt it have to be two players (or Goalkeeper and one player) between the opposing player and the goal for it to be onside?JMP said:You lot can all knock Morison but how many of you would want him in your team!?
And I thought the goal was not given due to offside NOT a foul against Archer?
I guess for the 'keeper to drop the ball, our guy who hit the ball must have had Archer and another Millwall player closer to the goal at least?1
