Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Players Marks: Shrewsbury v Charlton

Roll up, roll up the brave few on the Welsh borders, your marks 0.5 to 10.0 please:

Rudd:
Byrne:
Jackson:
Teixeira:
Konsa:
Holmes:
Crofts:
Aribo:
Botaka:
Novak:
Magennis:

Ahearne-Grant n/a
Watt n/a
DaSilva n/a

PLEASE KEEP THIS THREAD FOR MARKS NOT REMARKS FROM THOSE WHO WERE NOT AT THE MATCH

Comments

  • Options
    Wasn't there so can't comment really, but Holmes deserve a 10 to soften the blow of a hatrick and still losing.
  • Options
    Sanogo got a high 9 in similar circumstances
  • Options
    Roll up, roll up the brave few on the Welsh borders, your marks 0.5 to 10.0 please:

    Rudd: 7
    Byrne: 6
    Jackson: 4
    Tex: 5
    Konsa : 5
    Holmes: 9
    Crofts: 6
    Aribo: 5
    Botaka: 5.5
    Novak: 6
    Magennis: 6

    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Watt n/a
    DaSilva n/a
  • Options
    Rudd: 6.5
    Byrne: 4.5
    Jackson: 3.5
    Teixeira: 3
    Konsa: 3.5
    Holmes: 9
    Crofts: 4
    Aribo: 4.5
    Botaka: 4.5
    Novak: 5
    Magennis: 5
  • Options

    Rudd: 9
    Byrne: 6.5
    Jackson: 4
    Teixeira: 3
    Konsa: 3
    Holmes: 9
    Crofts: 2
    Aribo: 3
    Botaka: 4
    Novak: 4
    Magennis: 3
  • Options
    Rudd: 5
    Byrne: 3
    Jackson: 4
    Teixeira: 4
    Konsa: 4
    Holmes: 9
    Crofts: 5
    Aribo: 4
    Botaka: 3
    Novak: 4
    Magennis: 3
  • Options
    Rudd: 9
    Byrne: 5
    Jackson: 4
    Teixeira: 4
    Konsa: 4
    Holmes: 9
    Crofts: 4
    Aribo: 4
    Botaka: 2
    Novak: 6
    Magennis: 4

    Ahearne-Grant n/a
    Watt n/a
    DaSilva n/a
  • Options
    Poor old Jacko. Dropped in the deep end there.
  • Options
    Rudd: 5 - Thought he could have done better with some of the goals.
    Byrne: 4 - Didnt offer anything going backwards of forwards
    Jackson: 3 - At fauilt for at least two of the goals.
    Tex: 5 - Shadow of previous games.
    Konsa : 5 _ Needs to have a break would have preferred him at right back.
    Holmes: 9 - Felt sorry for him all his goals were superb
    Crofts: 6 - Cant win everything in midfield on his own had no support from the other midfielders.
    Aribo: 5 - Quite game hardly new he was playing.
    Botaka: 5 - A couple of tricky runs but didnt pose much threat
    Novak: 4 - How this guy doesnt get more stick is beyond me...ten times worse than Makienok.
    Magennis: 5 - Not the same player pre MIllwall...lost pocession that lead to their second goal.

    Watt 4 - Senseless booking when he came on for kicking ball away
  • Options
    Rudd: 7 - one save in particular was top class - no chance with the goals IMO
    Byrne: 4 - hardly noticed him
    Jackson: 5 - not one of his best games
    Teixeira: 4 - I think he is part of our current problem
    Konsa: - 5 had too many games and it shows
    Holmes: - 9 MOM what a class act this guy is.
    Crofts: - 5 invisible
    Aribo: - 4 had too many games and it shows
    Botaka: - 3 he is all trickery and no delivery
    Novak: - 3 not good enough
    Magennis: - 3 don't know what has gone wrong with him

    Ahearne-Grant n/a - no point in playing this guy
    Watt n/a - 2 minutes of action, then nothing.
    DaSilva n/a - looks like a matchday mascot, will get bullied out of games
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Rudd: 7. One excellent save, two good saves, two goals I felt he could have done better with.

    Byrne: 4. Anonymous

    Jackson: 5. Got involved. Needs a stronger player in fron of him if he's playing left back.

    Teixeira: 1. Spent more time 'injured' after getting beaten by an opposition player. Two marks removed from what I've subsequently heard.

    Konsa: 4. Played out of position. Not helped at all by his senior partner.

    Holmes: 10. Kinsella type performance. Was everywhere. Still running about chasing the game in injury time. We all dream of a team of Ricky Homes.

    Crofts: 4. Anonymous

    Aribo: 4. Expected a lot more after all I'd read about him.

    Botaka: 3. Just another 'winger' we've had over the past three years, who is no better and no worse than the previous dross we've seen. All of them make Callum Harriet look world class.

    Novak: 6. Put in a shift. Always available. Unlucky or ineffective - not sure.

    Magennis: 3. Not the same player I saw earlier in the season. Didn't win a single ball in the air and seemed disinterested throughout.
  • Options
    Rudd: 6
    Byrne: 4 but what do we expect playing a winger as a full back?
    Jackson: 4 Lots of effort but he is not the answer at left back
    Teixeira: 4 Not sure what has happened here
    Konsa: 4 Whole defence looked all over the place. Konsa included.
    Holmes: 10 We all dream of a team of Ricky Holmes'
    Crofts: 3 Can he not find a pass?
    Aribo: 5 Not his best night
    Botaka: 4 Fine going forward but very poor tracking back/ tackling
    Novak: 6 Felt he was a little unlucky. No lack of effort
    Magennis: 3 What has happened to him? Never looked like scoring and totally at fault for their second goal.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!