Players Marks: Charlton v M.K.Dons

lancashire lad · April 2017

Your marks 0.5 to 10 please:

Rudd:
Solly:
Bauer:
Pearce:
DaSilva:
Jackson:
Forster-Caskey:
Aribo:
Holmes:
Maginnes:
Watt:
Byrne:

Botaka: n/a

Leuth · April 2017

Rudd: 6.5 did what he could
Solly: 4 awful in possession and in defence
Bauer: 5 not good
Pearce: 5 should have been sent off?
DaSilva: 8 too small! Also far, far, far too good for us
Jackson: 6 ineffectual but saved us a couple of times
Forster-Caskey: 5.5 surprisingly shit, saved us once
Aribo: 5 didn't seem to know where he was playing
Holmes: 6 no end product but looked like doing something
Magennis: 3 fuck me what's happened
Watt: 2 fuuuck me what's happened
Byrne: 6 did OK

At least we have a proper left-back for five more games

sam3110 · April 2017

Rudd: 4
Solly: 2.5
Bauer: 4
Pearce: 4
DaSilva: 6
Jackson: 4.5
Forster-Caskey: 3
Aribo: 4
Holmes: 4.5
Maginnes: 3
Watt: 2
Byrne: 5

Nicholas · April 2017

Rudd: 5
Solly: 3 off the pace
Bauer: 3
Pearce: 3 let's not only bring Solly back but let's bring Pearce who has been off for months too.
DaSilva: 4.5
Jackson: 1 should be no where near this team
Forster-Crappy 1 awful awful player
Aribo 2.5
Holmes: 3
Maginess 3
Watt: 1 since this twat has been back we have been bloody awful
Byrne: 3

Robinson 0 yet again. Useless shit scum of a manager

palarsehater · April 2017

Rudd: 5
Solly: 3
Bauer: 3.5
Pearce: 3
DaSilva: 6
Jackson: 4
Forster-Caskey: 3
Aribo: 4
Holmes: 5.5
Maginnes: 2
Watt: 2
Byrne: 4

EastTerrace · April 2017

All 2 apart from Holmes 3 as he is enthusiastic but still can't cross a ball

Rob7Lee · April 2017

Rudd: 5 Looked very nervous, should have claimed a couple of catches, couple of good saves.
Solly: 4 Moments of him old self but looked rusty
Bauer: 3 below average, even for this league
Pearce: 5 He needs someone else along side him,
DaSilva: 6 Did ok, even won some headers!
Jackson: 5 not his best, but his awareness saved us a couple of times
Forster-Caskey: 3 did we really pay money for him, poor
Aribo: 4 looked out of his depth
Holmes: 5 lots of running, zero end product, looks like he needs a rest
Magennis: 2 From hero to zero, what on earth, needs a stint at Swindon.
Watt: 2 Please never let him wear the shirt again, lost the ball that lead to both goals, did he chase back.. did he heck, I actually am starting to hate him and thats a first in 30 years.
Byrne: 6 he was 'ok'

EastTerrace · April 2017

EastTerrace said:
All 2 apart from Holmes 3 as he is enthusiastic but still can't cross a ball

And yes, Robinson 0. The player's marks wouldn't have been so low if they knew what they were doing.

AC · April 2017

This was my first game this season and first since we lost to Huddersfield at home last year.

The reason for my absence is partly Work/Family/Roland being a c*nt.

Rudd: 5 - good distribution, couldn't do much about the goals.

Solly: 3 - what happened??? He used to be f*ckin quality

Bauer: 4 - poor

Pearce: 4 - poor, should have been sent off!

DaSilva: 6 - ok

Jackson: 5 - Tried his best but loads of misplaced passes

Forster-Caskey: 5 - Bang Average

Aribo: 4 - can see he has potential but didn't look up for it tonight. Always looks like he's going to fall over when he runs!

Holmes: 4 - shocking although he did put himself about

Maginnes: 4 - thought he was better with the ball at his feet. why did we keep trying to punt to ball up to him when the first 100x didn't work!

Watt: 2 - that first touch!

Byrne: 3 - couldn't pass to a team mate if his life depended on it!

Botaka: n/a

I see the problem now. I had come into the game thinking it was just the players under performing. I was wrong the quality just isn't there.

We have a shit team on paper and in real life!

What a waste of my evening.

ROLAND OUT

JoshrewCAFC · April 2017

Your marks 0.5 to 10 please:

Rudd: 6
Solly: 6
Bauer: 5
Pearce: 3
DaSilva: 4
Jackson: 2
Forster-Caskey: 2
Aribo: 6
Holmes: 10
Maginnes: 1
Watt: 0.5
Byrne: 5

Yes these marks are serious. Can't believe out of a team of waster fucks that one player still manages to get his act together and at least try to play and give respect for PC Keith Palmer and his family, for that Holmes gets 10.

seth plum · April 2017

Rudd: 5
Solly: 5.5
Bauer: 4
Pearce: 5
DaSilva: 5
Jackson: 4
Forster-Caskey: 3
Aribo: 5
Holmes: 6
Maginnes: 1
Watt: 1
Byrne: 5

PaddyP17 · April 2017

Lowest average marks I'll probably have ever given.

Rudd: 5.5
Solly: 5.5
Bauer: 3.5
Pearce: 5.5
DaSilva: 5
Jackson: 4
Forster-Caskey: 2.5
Aribo: 4
Holmes: 6 MOM (i.e. least worst)
Magennis: 1
Watt: 0, if that's allowed

Byrne: 5
Botaka: n/a

Swisdom · April 2017

Frankly can't be arsed

All get 3
Except Bauer who displayed toblerone feet to a Dan Seabourne level of shitness and gets 2

Da Silva with a 6 my mom - in a couple of years when he is playing regularly in the Premier League we will think "what the fuck ". Really like him

Buglehorn · April 2017

Rudd 5.5
Solly 4
Bauer 5
Pearce 5
Dasilva 7
Jackson 5.5
Forrester-caskey 4
Aribo 5
Holmes 7
Magennis 4
Watt 4

Byrne 4

andynelson · April 2017

lancashire lad said:
Your marks 0.5 to 10 please:

Rudd: 6
Solly: 5
Bauer:4
Pearce:5
DaSilva: 7
Jackson:4
Forster-C
Holmaskey: 3
Aribo: es: 4
Maginnes: 3
Watt: 1
Byrne: 2

Botaka: n/a

lancashire lad said:
Your marks 0.5 to 10 please:

Rudd: 6
Solly: 5
Bauer: 4
Pearce: 5
DaSilva: 7
Jackson: 4
Forster-Caskey: 3
Aribo: 4
Holmes: 6.5
Maginnes: 3
Watt: 1
Byrne: 2

Botaka: n/a

Dansk_Red · April 2017

Rudd: 5
Solly: 5.5
Bauer: 4
Pearce: 5
DaSilva: 6.5
Jackson: 5
Forster-Caskey: 4
Aribo: 5
Holmes: 5.5
Maginnes: 4
Watt: 3.5
Byrne: 4

Clem_Snide · April 2017

Rudd: 5
Solly: 4
Bauer: 2
Pearce: 3
DaSilva: 5
Jackson: 3
Forster-Caskey: 2
Aribo: 3
Holmes: 5
Maginnes: 2
Watt: 1
Byrne: 3

1StevieG · April 2017

Rudd: 5
Solly: 5
Bauer: 4
Pearce: 5
DaSilva: 5
Jackson: 4
Forster-Caskey: 3
Aribo: 5
Holmes: 5
Maginnes: 4
Watt: 2
Byrne: 5

Fumbluff · April 2017

Rudd: 6
Solly: 4
Bauer: 3
Pearce: 5
DaSilva: 6.5
Jackson: 5.5
Forster-Casket: 3
Aribo: 6
Holmes: 6.5
Magennis: 4
Watt: 0.5
Byrne: 3.5

Leuth · April 2017

JoshrewCAFC said:
Your marks 0.5 to 10 please:
DaSilva: 4

I know you're (rightfully) furious but...I mean, it's not like you gave him 4 and everyone else 1

se9addick · April 2017

Rudd: 6
Solly: 6
Bauer: 3
Pearce: 4
DaSilva: 5
Jackson: 2
Forster-Caskey: 2.5
Aribo: 6.5
Holmes: 6.5
Maginnes: 3
Watt: 1.5
Byrne: 3

Botaka: n/a

ozaddick · April 2017

Rudd: 4, distribution was dire
Solly: 5 could tell he was rusty, couple of good blocks put in.
Bauer: 3.5 I thought he was a championship quality defender???
Pearce: 4 like solly, he was rusty, wasted possession a lot.
DaSilva: 6 the lad grew into the game, MK targeted him a fair bit.
Jackson: 4 not the usual composure I'd expect of the skipper
Forster- Caskey: 2.5. Not one fuck given by him, horrible to witness that performance
Aribo: 4 the lad was out of his depth.
Holmes: 7 the best by a mile tonight, but that's not that difficult considering.
Maginnes: 4 won a few flicked headers, that was about it.
Watt: 3 basic skills deserted him tonight. Didn't link up with big josh at all.
Byrne: 5 thought he looked ok, added a little zip when he came on,

Overall, if you lot have been watching that shower for quite a while, I really feel for you. It really was a terrible performance. I didn't see any urgency or commitment at all. What the fuck is KR doing all week with this squad?

BartramBlitz · April 2017

Rudd 5. Not at fault
Solly 5 tried but pace has gone
Bauer 3 doesn't want to be here anymore and it shows
Pearce 3 should have been sent off for late tackles totally off the pace
Da Silva 7. shaky start but did well 2nd half when others hid
Jackson 5 Does his best
Fster Crap 1 Robinson's man and it shows inept poser hopeless
Aribo. 2 completely adrift
Holmes. 8 Showed he cared when others couldn't give a toss
Maginnes 2. What has happened. Looked a Sunday league player
Watt. 0. Get rid. Tried to get sent off so he could have weekend off
Byrne 4. No impact
Botaka. na. A headless chicken of aplayer

WestStandNutters · April 2017

Rudd: 6
Solly: 5.5
Bauer: 5
Pearce: 6.5
DaSilva: 6.5
Jackson: 6
Forster-Caskey: 4.5
Aribo: 5.5
Holmes: 6.5
Maginnes: 6
Watt: 5.5
Byrne: 6

Robinson: 1 he's worse than Fraeye!

Taxi_Lad · April 2017

Rudd: 4
Solly: 4
Bauer: 4
Pearce: 4
DaSilva: 6.5
Jackson: 4
Forster-Caskey: 3
Aribo: 6
Holmes: 6
Maginnes: 3
Watt: 5
Byrne: 3

Botaka: n/a

ValleyGary · April 2017

Rudd: 3 - Poppadom hands
Solly: 5
Bauer: 4
Pearce: 5
DaSilva: 5 - shit but no protection at all
Jackson: 4
Forster-Caskey: 4
Aribo: 3 - didn't know his arsehole from his elbow
Holmes: 7
Maginnes: 2 lazy
Watt: 2 very lazy
Byrne: 4

Botaka: n/a

vff · April 2017

Rudd 5.5
Solly 5
Bauer 4 - lots of errors & misplaced passes
Pearce- 4 I was trying to reassure myself that defence would improve when he returns, then I realised he was on the pitch. Lucky not to be sent off.
Da Silva 6 - Had a good second half, particularly after second goal went in. Went past his man on a number of occasions
Jackson 5 - Tried but misplaced passes.
Foster-Caskey 3 - lightweight, unfit & off the pace.
Aribo - 5 flashes of quality, & will be a good player one day but today looked a little out of depth. MK midfield never gave him a breath
Holmes - 6 - tried but it never came off.
Magennis - 4 - shadow of the player he was early season
Watt - 3.5 very very poor, lost ball, that led to break that resulted in mk goal.
Byrne - 5.5 made a few good passes.
Botaka - did nothing

Robinson -15. What do they do in training ? Failed to build a coherent style of play. The defence is terrible. No way should he rebuild the team. Not a good manager & it would be fine if he got fired tomorrow. With his misplaced gobshite chatter, he has completely mismanaged the squad. Team looks like relegation material under him.