Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player marks: Charlton vs Walsall

2

Comments

  • Amos 7 good solid performance.
    Solly6 better 2nd half
    DaSilva7.5 little gem
    Lennon5 poor game, must improve his passing.
    Konsa 6.5 still learning.

    Aribo 7.5 flair and work rate
    Kashi6.5 does the hard yards for this team.

    Mavididi 8 cracking game MOM
    Reeves5.5 still struggling to make his mark.
    Marshall7 great cross for goal but bad miss in 2nd half.

    Magennis 5.5 all his best work is on the wing or outside the box. We need a striker who can do tap ins at this level.

    Subs

    Fosu 7.5 we have missed him so much.
    Jackson


  • Amos 7
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 6 ok defensively. Awful passing
    Konsa 7

    Aribo 7
    Kashi 6

    Mavididi 8 Lively. Very lively
    Reeves 4 poor man's Billy Clarke
    Marshall 4 refuses to take on his man and zero end product

    Magennis 7 worked hard. Needs a goal

    Subs

    Fosu 9. Looked so much more dangerous when he came on. Marshall take note
  • edited January 2018
    Amos 6.5

    Solly 6.5
    DaSilva 7.5
    Lennon 5.5
    Konsa 6.5

    Aribo 7
    Kashi 6.5

    Mavididi 7.5
    Reeves 5
    Marshall 6.5

    Magennis 6.5

    Subs

    Fosu 7.5
  • Amos - 7
    Solly - 6
    DaSilva - 7.5
    Lennon - 5 Sarr is a better player but both are prone to errors
    Konsa - 6
    Aribo - 7.5
    Kashi - 7
    Mavididi - 8
    Reeves - 5
    Marshall - 6
    Magennis - 6 Minus one for his awful miss but he actually played very well today.
    Fosu - 7.5 Wow!
  • Amos 7 Made a few decent saves
    Solly 6.5 Good to have him back, a decent first game back
    DaSilva 7.5 Class as usual
    Lennon 6 Okish, but made one absolute howler, that he got away with.
    Konsa 6.5 Mixed bag today of good, average and not so good
    Aribo 7.5 I like his positivity & took the goal well
    Kashi 7 Wasn't faffing around at the back like usual thank God
    Mavididi 8 Excellent, the boy oozes class
    Reeves 6 Ok, but I expect more than ok. He created very little.
    Marshall 7 Decent game possibly best yet and he's definitely improving
    Magennis 7 Played quite well, but missed his chances once again
    Subs
    Fosu 9 Absolutely superb. Magnificent performance & he totally changed the game.
    Jackson 6
  • Amos 7 couple of important saves at 1-1
    Solly 6 good to have a bit of experience back in the back four
    DaSilva 7 consistently good
    Lennon 5 defended ok but not sure he has the technique to play the Robinson way
    Konsa 7 thought he dealt with a pacy forward really well

    Aribo 7 has some quality about him
    Kashi 7 thought he played the holding role a bit further forward which relieved some of the pressure

    Mavididi 8 not everything came off for him but his pace and direct running were the difference today
    Reeves 5 largely ineffective, can we swap him for their little fella?
    Marshall 7 put in a right shift today

    Magennis 6 got to admire him for keeping going. Once he gets one more will follow

    Subs

    Fosu 7 so much more effective than Reeves
    Jackson 6 helped us keep our shape at the end.
  • Amos. 7. Dealt with what they could muster competently
    Solly. 6. Solid. Good to have him back if only for experience
    DaSilva 8.5. Excellent
    Lennon 6. Poor 10/15 mins either side of half time but got in some crucial blocks
    Konsa. 6.5. Few shaky moments
    Aribo 6.5.
    Kashi. 6.5
    Mavididi 8.5. Joy to watch
    Reeves. 5 hmmm
    Marshall 6.5. Great at tracking back but won't deliver an early cross
    Magennis 7. Was a good target man today

    Subs

    Fosu. 8. Like he hadn't been away
    Jackson


  • Amos 7.5
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 6
    Lennon 6
    Konsa 6

    Aribo 7.5
    Kashi 6

    Mavididi 8
    Reeves 5
    Marshall 5.5

    Magennis 5.5

    Subs

    Fosu 8

  • Amos 7 - Little to do. Nothing he could do about the header.
    Solly 5 - Not at his best - Walsall had a lot of joy down his side.
    DaSilva 8.5 - Great performance, as usual. So tricky.
    Lennon 6.5 - minus 0.5 for his howler. Actually did well first half and put some good balls into big mac.
    Konsa 6.5 - Good at attracting fouls which compensates for his lack of pace. He doesn't inspire confidence in me like Bauer and Pearce.
    Aribo 5 - Good goal but the bloke just hides when he's feeling tired. He's a very good footballer but the workrate isn't there for me.
    Kashi 7 - A few cracking challenges
    Mavididi 8.5 - Really dangerous going forward
    Reeves 6 - Great ball into Josh but a bit lightweight.
    Marshall 7.5 - Looks better with DaSilva helping him out. Can't fault workrate.
    Magennis 6.5 - it won't fall for him. Very unlucky with the header.
    Fosu 9 - What a superb substitute appearance. Some great improvisation, not at least for the third goal!
  • Amos 6.5
    Solly 5.5
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 5
    Konsa 5.5

    Aribo 6.5
    Kashi 7

    Mavididi 7
    Reeves 4.5
    Marshall 6

    Magennis 6

    Subs

    Fosu 7
    Jackson N/A
  • Sponsored links:


  • Amos 6
    Solly 6.5
    DaSilva 6.5
    Lennon 6
    Konsa 6

    Aribo 8
    Kashi 6.5

    Mavididi 7.5
    Reeves 4
    Marshall 6

    Magennis 6.5

    Subs

    Fosu 7
    Jackson N/A

  • edited January 2018

    Amos - 7 - alongside DaSilva easily our most consistent player. several good saves kept us in the game
    Solly - 6.5 - was up against their best player in Roberts - did decently considering time out injured and the yellow card he picked up early doors
    DaSilva - 7 - dependable, linked well with Fosu/Mavididi
    Lennon - 5 - poor showing, lost count of the amount of times he hoofed it straight out of play and almost handed them a goal were it not for the crossbar
    Konsa - 6.5 - whilst better than Lennon still allowed Bakayoko and their attackers too much freedom in the second half
    Aribo - 7 - as usual good use of the ball, arguably a bit lightweight in the tackle but does still put himself about
    Kashi - 6.5 - patchy performance as we come to expect
    Mavididi - 8 - superb energy all game, constant threat,
    Reeves - 6 - some flashes of class but generally ineffective
    Marshall - 6 - was at least taking people on but final ball was poor and finishing awful, very erratic player
    Magennis - 6 - arguably had his best game in a long while but as a striker it's criminal not to take chances like that - straight at the keeper...
    Fosu - 8 - looked twice the side with him on the pitch - assist for Stephy's second was absolute class
    Jackson - n/a

    Lennon did hand them a goal - his shocking crossfield pass went straight to their player seconds later the ball was in the Charlton net.
    The boy is decent in the air but his ground play is League 2, at best.
  • edited January 2018
    At the Valley

    Amos 7 - Little to do. Nothing he could do about the header.
    Solly 5 - Not at his best - Needs a few games.
    DaSilva 7.5 - Good player.
    Lennon 5.5 - What was he thinking?. Woeful distribution but did well after his big mistake imo.
    Konsa 6.5 - Solid.
    Aribo 7 - Took goal well.
    Kashi 7 - always intercepting and predicting-i dont know about this going to collect ball from keeper business.
    Mavididi 8.5 - Very good player.
    Reeves 6 - lightweight.
    Marshall 5.5 - Hmmm, cross the fecking ball, and learn how to shoot straight..
    Magennis 5.5 - Better. Should have scored with 1 on 1 , bt nlucky with header..
    Fosu 7 - another good player- mayve its a good thing that he-s been injured else he could well be another one out the door.
  • Watched on ifollow.

    Amos 6
    Solly 5.5
    DaSilva 7.5
    Lennon 5
    Konsa 5.5

    Aribo 6.5
    Kashi 6.5

    Mavididi 8 mom
    Reeves 5
    Marshall 6

    Magennis 6

    Subs

    Fosu 7
    Jackson N/A
  • Amos 7
    Solly 4
    DaSilva 6
    Lennon 5
    Konsa 7

    Aribo 8
    Kashi 8

    Mavididi 8
    Reeves 5
    Marshall 6

    Magennis 5

    Subs

    Fosu 8
  • edited January 2018
    Amos- 7 didn’t have much to do but did well with what he did.
    Solly- 6 did well to deal with Roberts up the wing but a bit iffy at times.
    DaSilva- 7.5 another class game. would’ve been MOTM on another day.
    Lennon- 4 please put him out of his misery and get someone else to play there, he wasn’t nearly good enough before his injury and is even worse now. Nearly threw away the game all on his own.
    Konsa- 7 did really well sweeping in behind Lennon when needed.

    Aribo- 7.5 really good going forward and made a few really good sliding tackles.
    Kashi- 7.5 the Kashi of old if you like. Really good performance.

    Mavididi- 9 magic. It’ll go down as an OG of course but I’m gonna give him credit for both goals.
    Reeves- 6 I don’t think he was too bad but just doesn’t have much to offer. Somehow doesn’t seem to work in KRs system.
    Marshall- 6.5 puts a shift in but tends to run down alleyways and struggle to get the ball over.

    Magennis- 7 missed the key chance obviously but other than that dominated their 24 in the air.

    Subs

    Fosu- 8.5 brilliant touch for Mavididi’s goal and was always threatening.
    Jackson N/A

  • Amos 7.5
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 5.5
    Konsa 7

    Aribo 7
    Kashi 6.5

    Mavididi 8
    Reeves 6.5
    Marshall 7

    Magennis 6.5

    Subs

    Fosu 8
  • Amos 7 - some excellent saves, he really has improved over time
    Solly 7 - makes such a difference to our side and helped Marshall too
    DaSilva 8 - unreal player, hope we go up and manage to get him back, he’s going to be fantastic
    Lennon 6 - passing awful and made a big mistake but there was no communication but he made a vital block when Bakayako was in
    Konsa 7 - very assured, reads the game well

    Aribo 8 - getting forward well now, scored the opener and really good in tight situations
    Kashi 7 - worked hard to cover the defence and looks so much better when he is 15 yards higher as he should be all the time

    Mavididi 9 - changed the game, was unlucky with the second as he deserved to be credited with it, hit the bar first half, scored the third, aggressive, power, pace, skill, strength... boy he is going to be good
    Reeves 6 - worked hard first half and done well I thought, but the change was obvious and he just can’t do what Fosu brings us
    Marshall 7.5 - thought he was very good yesterday, worked hard, supported Solly defensively and set up Aribo’s goal, well done

    Magennis 7 - forget the missed chances, he is low on confidence and just needs something to come off his back side and go in. He works exceptionally hard, was unlucky not to score and allows the 3 behind him to do what they do

    Subs

    Fosu 8 - gave us that extra impetus and the whole team lifted as soon as he came on. Terrified their defence which helped us pin them in at times
    Jackson - was nice for him to come on and sure things up. Every time I see him play it makes me feel proud, going to be a very sad day when he plays his last ever game
  • Amos 6
    Solly 6.5
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 6
    Konsa 6

    Aribo 7.5
    Kashi 6.5

    Mavididi 8
    Reeves 5
    Marshall 6

    Magennis 4

    Subs 

    Fosu 7
    Jackson 6
  • Amos 7 one very good save
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 7.5
    Lennon 6 As Sir Alf said to Jack Charlton “win the ball and give it to your brother”. i.e someone who can play football. After causing the first goal he started to play the ball long down the channel when under pressure. Keep doing that!
    Konsa 7.5

    Aribo 7.5 class.
    Kashi 7

    Mavididi 8.5 great game. Good goal and forced the own goal. Superb
    Reeves 6
    Marshall 7.5 switched to the left side 1st half and put ina load of good crosses. Should have taken a touch with his chance as no one near him.

    Magennis 6.5 worked hard but had two very good chances and should have scored

    Subs 

    Fosu 8 so glad to have him back.


  • Sponsored links:


  • edited January 2018
    Amos 7
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 6
    Konsa 7

    Aribo 7 Lovely goal and paired up well with Kashi.
    Kashi 7 Some great tackles and Passing.

    Mavididi 9 Hit the bar, one assist and one goal.
    Reeves 6
    Marshall 7

    Magennis 6 Unlucky to hit the post, can’t buy a goal at the moment.
    Fosu 8 Changed the game and was almost my MOM.
  • Amos 6.5 Tidy.
    Solly 6.
    Da Silva 7 Could be POTY.
    Lennon 6. Terrible mistake could've cost us match.
    Konsa 7 Good,classy.
    Aribo 7 Really pleased for him
    Kashi 7 Very good holding midfielder .
    Mavididi 8.5 Arsenal pedigree.
    Reeves 6 Just average.
    Marshall 6.5 Tries very hard ,but can go down blind alleys.
    Magennis 6 More of a rugby player. That 1 in 1 miss was shocking.
    Fosu 8 Changed the match.
  • Amos - 7
    Solly - 5
    Da Silva - 7
    Lennon - 4.5 (awful)
    Konsa - 6.5
    Aribo - 7
    Kashi - 7
    Mavididi - 7.5
    Reeves - 5.5
    Marshall - 6.5
    Magennis - 6

    Fosu - 7.5
  • 1StevieG said:

    Amos 7
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 6
    Konsa 7

    Aribo 7 Lovely goal and paired up well with Kashi.
    Kashi 7 Some great tackles and Passing.

    Mavididi 9 Hit the bar, one assist and one goal.
    Reeves 6
    Marshall 7

    Magennis 6 Unlucky to hit the post, can’t buy a goal at the moment.

    Fosu @1StevieG ?
  • Amos - 7. Couple of vital saves

    Solly - 6.5 not fit but was solid

    DaSilva - 7.5 customary quality performance

    Lennon - 4.5. Some solid defending but woeful distribution and one absolute howler that could have cost the game.

    Konsa - 6.5 good game I thought.

    Aribo - 7.5 great goal and some quality moments

    Kashi - 6. Poor first half. Better second.

    Mavididi - 9. Some real pace and quality. Ricky who?

    Reeves - 4. Waste of space despite the odd moment of skill. Lightweight. Needs to be made to watch the match video and watch oztzumer. That’s what we bought you to do matey!!

    Marshall - 6.5. Horrible miss after being set up by Fosu but his most productive home game.

    Magennis - 6. Tried ever so hard and won more Balls in the air than normal but he just has to score that one on one.

    Fosu - 9.5. Completely changed the game when he came on. A goal and I’d have given him 10. Please stay fit. And please don’t go! Hurry up February.

    This for me sums it up perfectly.
  • edited January 2018
    Amos - 7 - Good saves and nearly saved the goal which would have been a worldy - Very happy with him
    Solly - 6.5 - Did OK, not so much offensively but was solid defensively
    DaSilva - 7 - Very good offensively and defensively, great pass for the second
    Lennon - 6- Is at his level and still getting into the groove, but a useful squad player
    Konsa - 6.5 - Ok
    Aribo - 7.5 - Very good, was our best player in the first half by a mile
    Kashi - 6.5 - Improved
    Mavididi - 8 - They don't like it up em captain
    Reeves - 5.5 - One great piece of skill then stupid shot! Not rheally a threat otherwise
    Marshall - 6 - Great cross for first goal but a bit quiet
    Magennis - 7 - Lacking confidence in front of goal but dominated their defenders.
    Fosu -7.5 - They couldn't cope with both him and Mavididi - promising partnership going forwards
    Jackson - n/a
  • Amos - 7: not much to do but one very good save in the second. A very reliable keeper

    Solly - 5.5: a bit off the pace. Will hopefully get back in the grove

    DaSilva - 7.5: another stellar performance from this outstanding and outstandingly consistent young player

    Lennon - 5.5: his distribution was erratic (especially for a player who can actually pass the ball) and a horrendous error nearly gifted Walsall the lead. Got in some very good blocks thereafter

    Konsa - 7: a polished performance and Iooked well in control

    Aribo - 7.5: a very skilful player, as illustrated by his goal, his set up for Malvididi to strike the bar and the sublime pass down the line to Marshall with the outside of his left foot in the second half. Has a tendency to fade out of the game for periods but I think we do have a player on our hands

    Kashi - 6.5: pretty good and kept things nicely ticking over

    Mavididi - 8.5: a gifted package of pace, skill and power. Fully deserved his standing ovation

    Reeves - 6: some skilful moments in the first half but pretty lightweight and, as something of a 'luxury' player, he needs to influence the game more to justify his inclusion. I still think he'll come good but it needs to be soon

    Marshall - 7: a much better performance. Worked hard and put some nice crosses in, although I wish he'd sometimes opt for an early ball in rather than taking on his man every time

    Magennis - 6.5: much better from Josh, who won a lot in the air and benefitted by having much more movement around and close to him. One poor miss but unlucky not to score. He desperately needs that monkey off his back

    Fosu - 9: a virtuoso performance and one that turned the game decisively in our favour
  • edited January 2018
    iFollow
    Will come back and do a write up in a bit.


    Amos 7
    Solly 6.5
    DaSilva 8
    Lennon 6
    Konsa 8.5

    Aribo 8
    Kashi 7.5

    Mavididi 9
    Reeves 6.5
    Marshall 6.5

    Magennis 7

    Subs

    Fosu 8
    Jackson
  • JamesSeed said:

    1StevieG said:

    Amos 7
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 6
    Konsa 7

    Aribo 7 Lovely goal and paired up well with Kashi.
    Kashi 7 Some great tackles and Passing.

    Mavididi 9 Hit the bar, one assist and one goal.
    Reeves 6
    Marshall 7

    Magennis 6 Unlucky to hit the post, can’t buy a goal at the moment.

    Fosu @1StevieG ?
    Fixed. Thanks. How could forget to mark that performance!

  • Amos 6
    Solly 6
    DaSilva 7
    Lennon 5
    Konsa 7

    Aribo 7
    Kashi 7

    Mavididi 8
    Reeves 6
    Marshall 6

    Magennis 6

    Subs

    Fosu 7.5
    Jackson

Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!