STATBANK: Play Offs Semi Final 1st Leg: Charlton Athletic 0-1 Shrewsbury Town

lancashire lad

many thanks to 83 Lifers who gave marks:

Redrobo

Blimey, that was quick.

cantersaddick

Didn't get round to giving my marks for this but I really didn't think Mavididi had a bad game. Thought Kashi was a long way worse than him.

Dazzler21

cantersaddick said:

Didn't get round to giving my marks for this but I really didn't think Mavididi had a bad game. Thought Kashi was a long way worse than him.

Nah Kashi broke up so many attacks. Mav lost the ball so many times.

Reeves was pretty bad from 50 minutes onwards, but got a good shot off.

Think JFC has got off lightly tbh.

cafcsinger

Thought Kashi was superb first half and poor second. 5.40 seems harsh IMO. Da Silva easily man of the match

Covered End

Dazzler21 said:

cantersaddick said:

Didn't get round to giving my marks for this but I really didn't think Mavididi had a bad game. Thought Kashi was a long way worse than him.

Nah Kashi broke up so many attacks. Mav lost the ball so many times.

Reeves was pretty bad from 50 minutes onwards, but got a good shot off.

Think JFC has got off lightly tbh.

Reeves was also pretty bad from 1-49 minutes.

JamesSeed

cafcsinger said:

Thought Kashi was superb first half and poor second. 5.40 seems harsh IMO. Da Silva easily man of the match

Dasilva gave the ball away a couple of times in dangerous positions - could have led to a goal for the Shrews. I love watching his forward runs, but he is a defender first and foremost, and I'm not sure his runs have led any goals this season. Stand to be corrected of course.

killerandflash

Personally, I thought Dasilva was overmarked by many, a couple of terrible cross field passes, that miskick in the first half that luckily ended up in Amos's gloves, that aerial misjudgement in the second half

Dazzler21

killerandflash said:

Personally, I thought Dasilva was overmarked by many, a couple of terrible cross field passes, that miskick in the first half that luckily ended up in Amos's gloves, that aerial misjudgement in the second half

True.

seriously_red

One stat that might be of interest is the team marks under KR then Bow... and perhaps individual player marks? Zyro started very well under Bow but there are many questions now.