Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton Athletic v Fleetwood Town

I am including the referee for marking, I shall do this for the next 4 league matches and if useful will incorporate it for the rest of the season. Please mark the ref as you would a player - by their performance over the whole match:

Referee:
Phillips:
Bauer:
Bielik:
Sarr:
Solly:
Marshall:
Aribo:
Pratley:
Page:
Taylor:
Grant:
Vetokele:

Lapslie: n/a

«1

Comments

  • I am including the referee for marking, I shall do this for the next 4 league matches and if useful will incorporate it for the rest of the season. Please mark the ref as you would a player - by their performance over the whole match:

    Referee: 4
    Phillips: 5.5 time for Steer
    Bauer: 8
    Bielik: 6.5
    Sarr: 6 sublime and crass , as usual
    Solly: 6
    Marshall: 2
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 5.5
    Page: 6.5
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 6
    Vetokele: 6

    Lapslie: 3

    Bowyer 3. Defensive system and the Aribo substitution was baffling

  • Referee: 7- One of the easiest match he will ever referee.
    Phillips: 6.5 One cracking save
    Bauer: 7- Class. Makes everything look easy.
    Bielik: 6- Time will tell. Not his biggest fan.
    Sarr: 6- Clean sheet, but is an accident waiting to happen.
    Solly: 6- Average.
    Marshall: 5.5- Hard worker who doesn’t have the quality.
    Aribo: 6- Not his best performance, playing too deep.
    Pratley: 6- Solid but cannot create anything.
    Page: 6- Marked down for giving the ball away in 93rd minute, which should have led to a Fleetwood goal.
    Taylor: 6- Unless he’s putting the ball away doesn’t offer much.
    Grant: 6.5- Lively and made some lovely runs.
    Vetokele: 6- Nowhere near match fit.

    Lapslie: 6- unlucky to not score at the end.
  • Referee: 6.5
    Phillips: 7
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 5.5
    Sarr: 5.5
    Solly:6
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 6
    Page: 6
    Taylor: 5
    Grant: 5.5
    Vetokele: 6
  • Referee: 6 idk he seemed ok
    Phillips: 7.5 made the big save when he had to
    Bauer: 6.5 a bit dicey at times
    Bielik: 7 looks good as a DM and quite skilful, overplayed it a couple of times
    Sarr: 7 plays a dangerous game sometimes but overall in credit for this showing and worked it wide really well. never a booking
    Solly: 7.5 very much back to his old self I'd say
    Marshall: 4 ugh no stop it. he's done as an attacking force
    Aribo: 6 great when he could get hold of it, which was rarer than it should have been
    Pratley: 6.5 for the shift he put in. not always so effective but he sure runs around a lot
    Page: 7 dreadful error at the end but until then played pretty well and was our biggest threat
    Taylor: 6 looked dangerous but couldn't quite get that clear opening (apart from in the first 30 seconds)
    Grant: 6 didn't quite make it happen
    Vetokele: 6 will ease into it

    Lapslie: n/a
  • Phillips: 8 - Made a couple of outstanding saves
    Bauer: 6.5 - Won most of his headers
    Bielik: 7 - I like him, think he could do a job in the Championship but not good enough for Arsenal
    Sarr: 7 - Having a good spell, I like him yet always makes your heart stop at times
    Solly: 8 (MOTM) - What a stop when it was him v about four Fleetwood players... No where near finished as a player!!
    Marshall: 4 - I've just got no words, I've given him a four out of generosity
    Aribo: 6 - Needs to shoot more, does well with the ball but a bit too hesitant
    Pratley: 7 - Surprised at how forward he played at times, did well in the middle
    Page; 6 - His error at the end almost proved costly but did well otherwise
    Taylor: 7 - Tried and is going to be a fan favourite
    Grant: 7 - Dangerous going forward, maybe needs to be aware a bit more (as per the offside goal)

    Vetokele: 6 - Looked lively and more importantly, looked interested
    Lapslie: 6 - Didnt realise it was his header off the line, disappointed Marshall started ahead of him
  • Referee:5
    Phillips:6
    Bauer:6
    Bielik:7
    Sarr:6
    Solly:6
    Marshall:5
    Aribo:6
    Pratley:6
    Page:6
    Taylor:6
    Grant:6
    Vetokele:6
    Lapslie:6
  • Referee 6
    Phillips 6.5
    Bauer 6.5
    Bielik 6
    Sarr 6
    Solly 6.5
    Marshall 5.5
    Aribo 6
    Pratley 6
    Page 6
    Taylor 6
    Grant 6

    Vetokele 6
    Lapslie n/a
  • I think the marks and commentary from @SDAddick above are absolutely spot on so to save writing out what I had to say can the administrator just go with those marks for me please.

    Only difference is I would give the ref an 8 as he really didn’t annoy me at all which is a miracle in this league. Got in the way a couple of times and his early booking meant he had to give out a few more in a game that really was too anaemic to swerve them. For this level I thought he had a great game.
  • Referee: 4
    Phillips: 5
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 6.5
    Sarr: 5.5
    Solly: 5.5
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 7.5
    Page: 6
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 7
    Vetokele: 6

    Lapslie: 5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Referee: 5
    Phillips: 7
    Bauer: 7
    Bielik: 6.5
    Sarr: 7
    Solly: 6
    Marshall: 5.5
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 5.5
    Page: 7
    Taylor: 5
    Grant: 5
    Vetokele: 6

    Lapslie: 6
  • Referee: 7
    Phillips:6.5 A couple of good saves but distribution needs to be worked on.
    Bauer: 7.5 Solid
    Bielik: 8 Another excellent performance
    Sarr: 6.5 Some sublime skill, then heart in the mouth mistakes. Could easily had a second yellow with persistent fouling.
    Solly: 7 Worked hard
    Marshall: 4 Is this the same man who played for Bradford? Ran around a lot but was on the periphery
    Aribo: 6 Struggled at times today
    Pratley: 6.5 A real grafter, needs some creativity to play alongside him
    Page: 6 Steady, lost a mark for almost costing a goal towards the end.
    Taylor: 6 Must be a right pain to play against, puts in a shift.
    Grant: 5.5 Worked hard but didn't quite come off for him today
    Vetokele: 6 For a first game after injury he did well. Once match fit he will be a handful alongside Taylor

    Lapslie 6.5: Unlucky with the header off the line. I thought he did the block on their 4 man breakaway?

  • Referee: 7
    Phillips: 7
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 6
    Sarr: 7
    Solly:7
    Marshall: 6
    Aribo:6
    Pratley: 8
    Page:6
    Taylor: 6
    Grant:6
    Vetokele:6

    Lapslie:6
  • (ifollow)

    Referee: 6,5 - big improvement from Tuesdays ref
    Phillips: 7 - not assuring all the time, but a couple of great saves
    Bauer: 7 - commanded well
    Bielik: 6,5 - looks promising, some bad decisions
    Sarr: 6,5 - mainly good passes. strong and calm, sometimes too calm
    Solly: 7,5 - great spirit
    Marshall: 5 - invisible, not played in his best position but have to do more
    Aribo: 6 - not the best defensively, and fail to take responsibility on the attack
    Pratley: 8 - failed as a creator, but covered a lot of grass and for me he was our best player
    Page: 7 - good attacking intentions, not a lot of luck
    Taylor: 6 - not able to create much on his own
    Grant: 6 - another quiet game, surprised he got 90 minutes again
    Vetokele: 6 - hoped for more impact, will be a nice option

    Lapslie: 5,5 - gave the ball away too easy a few times, before he got closest to scoring
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 7
    Bauer: 7
    Bielik: 6
    Sarr: 6
    Solly: 6
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo: 5.5
    Pratley: 6
    Page: 7
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 6
    Vetokele: 6
  • Referee: 6.5
    Phillips: 6 mixed performance one great save from Evans, but he is too slow and predictable with his distribution.
    Bauer: 7
    Bielik: 6.5
    Sarr: 7
    Solly: 6.5
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley:5.5
    Page:7
    Taylor:5.5 looks disinterested, but also not getting referees protection
    Grant:5.5
    Vetokele:6

    Lapslie: n/a

    V

    I
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 7
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 6
    Sarr: 6
    Solly:6
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 7
    Page: 6.5
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 6
    Vetokele: 6
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 7
    Bauer: 6.5
    Bielik: 6
    Sarr: 6
    Solly:5
    Marshall: 4
    Aribo: 5
    Pratley: 6
    Page: 6
    Taylor: 5
    Grant: 5
    Vetokele: 5
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 6
    Bauer: 7
    Bielik: 7
    Sarr: 7
    Solly: 6.5
    Marshall: 4
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 6
    Page: 7.5
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 5.5
    Vetokele: 6
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 6.5 couple of good saves but missed a couple of crosses
    Bauer: 7 had Evans in his pocket
    Bielik: 7 mom looked class, would like to see him further forward
    Sarr: 6 good passing
    Solly: 6 good piece of defending near the end
    Marshall: 6 worked back well but little going forward
    Aribo: 6 ineffective
    Pratley: 6 ineffective
    Page: 6 none of his crosses led to a goal
    Taylor: 5 think Magennis was better
    Grant: 6 didn’t come off for him today
    Vetokele; 6 looked lively

    Lapslie: n/a 6 thought he should have started, would have given us more energy
  • Sponsored links:



  • Phillips: 6.5
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 7
    Sarr: 5
    Solly: 6
    Marshall: 4.5
    Aribo:5.5
    Pratley:6
    Page:6.5
    Taylor:6
    Grant:6
    Vetokele:6
  • edited August 2018
    Referee: 7 - let quite a bit of shirt pulling and holding go, about par - no big mistakes. Bookings were fair.

    Phillips: 7 couple of very good saves from header and free kick
    Bauer: 6.5 looked untroubled
    Bielik: 7 got the ball moving, great in the air, physically great
    Sarr: 6.5 played the ball out nicely at times, needs to cut errors. A different referee might have sent him off.
    Solly: 6.5 was getting forward more
    Marshall: 5 contributed very little, runs about but without much of a brain as to where
    Aribo: 6 not too bad but missed our best chance and distribution is too predictable (out wide)
    Pratley: 6.5 worked hard but not incisive
    Page: 6.5 got into attacking positions and put good crosses into the box, but dind't produce anything
    Taylor: 6.5 worked hard and worked it into good positions, another frustrating game for him though as he got fouled a lot
    Grant: 5.5 made good runs but didn't get on anything
    Vetokele: 5.5 looked rusty but fairly fit

    Lapslie: 6 got stuck in but no on long enough to make any impact
  • Referee: 6
    Phillips: 7.5
    Bauer: 7.5
    Bielik: 7
    Sarr: 5.5
    Solly: 7
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo: 6.5
    Pratley: 7
    Page: 7.5
    Taylor: 8
    Grant: 7
    Vetokele: 6
  • Referee: 7
    Phillips: 8
    Bauer: 7
    Bielik: 6.5
    Sarr: 8.5
    Solly: 7.5
    Marshall: 6
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 7
    Page: 7.5
    Taylor: 7
    Grant: 7
    Vetokele: 5
  • Referee: 6.5 some wierd decisions, but not as bas as a lot of the refs we get
    Phillips: 7 kept us in it a couple of times
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 6 looks promising
    Sarr: 6
    Solly: 7
    Marshall: 4 there's something wrong here . He was anonymous, it was also obvious that Solly still doesn't like passing to him
    Aribo: 6.5
    Pratley: 6.5
    Page: 6.5
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 6
    Vetokele: 6.5 good to see him back but like all the forwards didn't get any service
  • Referee: 5
    Phillips:7
    Bauer: 7
    Bielik: 6.5
    Sarr: 6
    Solly:7
    Marshall: 4
    Aribo: 6
    Pratley: 6.5
    Page: 6.5
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 6
    Vetokele: 5
  • Ref 6.5
    Phillips: 7.5
    Bauer: 6.5
    Bielik: 7
    Sarr: 5.5
    Solly: 6.6
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo:5.5
    Pratley:6
    Page:6.5
    Taylor:6
    Grant:6.5
    Vetokele:6

  • Referee: 3
    Phillips: 7.5
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 7
    Sarr: 6.5
    Solly: 6
    Marshall: 5
    Aribo: 6.5
    Pratley: 6.5
    Page: 7
    Taylor: 6.5
    Grant: 6
    Vetokele: 5.5

    Lapslie: n/a
  • Referee: 7
    Phillips: 7
    Bauer: 6
    Bielik: 7
    Sarr: 7
    Solly: 6
    Marshall: 4
    Aribo: 5
    Pratley: 6
    Page: 6
    Taylor: 6
    Grant: 7
    Vetokele: 5

    Lapslie: n/a
  • Referee: 8 thought he helped close down our midfield really well a few times;Fleetwoods best player by far.
    Phillips:7 great save to save us at least a gargantuan point
    Bauer:6.5 pretty solid
    Bielik :6.5 not bad
    Sarr: 6.5 like how he passes and drives forward at times;at other times my heart is in my mouth
    Solly:6.5 showing some signs of the old Solly in defence ,not quite as effective going forward as he used to be
    Marshall: 4 dont know why he started ,was not missed when he went off
    Aribo:5.5 not at his best today but love this player
    Pratley:6.5 worked hard but not the creative midfielder we so desparately need
    Page:6 solid enough but error at the end nearly done us
    Taylor:6 good long range shot in the first half,gets pushed about a lot but needs to keep battling rather than moaning
    Grant:6 worked hard but final decision lets him down at times,absolutely leathered a ball to Narnia when needed to compose more
    Vetokele:6 good to see him back,didnt get a lot of service but worked hard

    Lapslie: 5.5 not bad but maybe would have kept Aribo on instead.
    Bowyer:5 said on website that "we're getting better every game", Really???? Didnt agree with him selecting Marshall to start or taking Aribo off.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out!