Your Charlton 11

paulie8290

Your best Charlton 11 that you have seen play only 1 player from each nation.

GK-Saša Ilić (Yugoslavia)

RB-Radostin Kishishev (Bulgaria)
CB-Patrick Bauer (Germany)
CB-Jorge Costa (Portugal)
LB-Chris Powell (England)

RM-Dennis Rommedahl (Denmark)
CM-Mark Kinsella (Ireland)
CM-Yoni Buyens (Belgium)
LM-John Robinson (Wales)

ATT-Lyle Taylor (Montserrat)
ATT-Shaun Bartlett (South Africa)

Probably forgetting a few but thats my 1st draft, obviously Sasa was born in Australia but he played for Yugoslavia

LenGlover

Dean Kiely Eire

Billy Bonds England

Jorge Costa Portugal

Talal El Karkouri Morocco

John Hewie Scotland

Allan Simonsen Denmark

Radostin Kishishev Bulgaria

Alou Diarra France

John Robinson Wales

Eddie Firmani Italy

Shaun Bartlett South Africa

Like you a first draft

paulie8290

Forgot Costa, think he will replace Naby

killerandflash

Ilic - Yugoslavia

Kishishev Bulgaria
Costa - Portugal
Fish - South Africa
HH - Iceland

Robinson - Wales
Parker - England
Kinsella - Ireland
Jensen - Denmark

JJ - Finland
Di Canio - Italy

The toughest choice was picking my English player, which meant discarding Rufus, Powell, Bolder, Lee, Bowyer, Bent, Mendonca, Hales, Flanagan etc

johnny73

GK-Saša Ilić (Yugoslavia)

RB- Luke Young (England)
CB- Jorge Costa (Portugal)
CB -Hermann Hreiðarsson (Iceland)
LB - Rhoys Wiggins (Wales)

RM- Colin Walsh ((Scotland)
CM-Mark Kinsella (Rep of Ireland)
CM- Claus Jenson (Denmark)
LM- Jasper Blomkquist (Sweden)

ATT- Paolo Di Canio (Italy)
ATT- Yann Kermorgant (France)

harveys_gardener

Would have Costa (Portugal) and Gomez (England) as CBs, Melrose (Scotland) and Firmani (Italy) upfront. Jensen over Rohmedal and alas Herman (Iceland) for Powell. Lloyd Sam (Ghana) for Buyens or even JJ (Finland) slightly out of position or 4-3-3.

Cafc43v3r

I haven't picked any UK or Ireland players

1 Myher Norway

2 Kisishev Bulgaria
5 Costa Portugal
6 Diawara Senegal
3 Heirdarsson Iceland

4 Smertin Russia
7 Diarra France
8 Jensen Denmark

9 Bartlett South Africa
10 Di Canio Italy
11 Barnes Jamica

Subs

Illic Yugoslavia
Tal Ben Hiam Israel
Suk-young S Korea
Zhi China
Robinson Zimbabwe
Bulot Gabon
Vetokele Angola
JJ Finland

harveys_gardener

Mentions for Zheng Zhi (China) El Kharkouri (Morocco) and Karim Bagheri (Iran).

Chizz

Cafc43v3r said:

I haven't picked any UK or Ireland players

1 Myher Norway

2 Kisishev Bulgaria
5 Costa Portugal
6 Diawara Senegal
3 Heirdarsson Iceland

4 Smertin Russia
7 Diarra France
8 Jensen Denmark

9 Bartlett South Africa
10 Di Canio Italy
11 Barnes Jamica

Subs

Illic Yugoslavia
Tal Ben Hiam Israel
Suk-young S Korea
Zhi China
Robinson Zimbabwe
Bulot Gabon
Vetokele Angola
JJ Finland

Is that John Barnes, who played 79 times for England, 3 times for Enand U-21s, 586 for English teams and never played for a team outside England? Is he the non-British person you mean?

Cafc43v3r

Yup qualifies for my team because he was born in Jamica, the same criteria I have used for Robinson, if Terry Butcher had played for charlton I would have picked him to on the same basis :-)

Igor was born in Belgium but I originally had another Belgium on the bench.

Johnnysummers5

Chizz said:

Cafc43v3r said:

I haven't picked any UK or Ireland players

1 Myher Norway

2 Kisishev Bulgaria
5 Costa Portugal
6 Diawara Senegal
3 Heirdarsson Iceland

4 Smertin Russia
7 Diarra France
8 Jensen Denmark

9 Bartlett South Africa
10 Di Canio Italy
11 Barnes Jamica

Subs

Illic Yugoslavia
Tal Ben Hiam Israel
Suk-young S Korea
Zhi China
Robinson Zimbabwe
Bulot Gabon
Vetokele Angola
JJ Finland

Is that John Barnes, who played 79 times for England, 3 times for Enand U-21s, 586 for English teams and never played for a team outside England? Is he the non-British person you mean?

Cafc43v3r said:

I haven't picked any UK or Ireland players

1 Myher Norway

2 Kisishev Bulgaria
5 Costa Portugal
6 Diawara Senegal
3 Heirdarsson Iceland

4 Smertin Russia
7 Diarra France
8 Jensen Denmark

9 Bartlett South Africa
10 Di Canio Italy
11 Barnes Jamica

Subs

Illic Yugoslavia
Tal Ben Hiam Israel
Suk-young S Korea
Zhi China
Robinson Zimbabwe
Bulot Gabon
Vetokele Angola
JJ Finland

I am surprised you think John Barnes was a better player for Charlton, than John Robinson or JJ

Cafc43v3r

Johnnysummers5 said:

I am surprised you think John Barnes was a better player for Charlton, than John Robinson or JJ

I think he was a better footballer, who played for Charlton ;-)

Almost put Jseper Blomqvist in as well :-)

paulie8290

Cafc43v3r said:

Yup qualifies for my team because he was born in Jamica, the same criteria I have used for Robinson, if Terry Butcher had played for charlton I would have picked him to on the same basis :-)

Igor was born in Belgium but I originally had another Belgium on the bench.

That makes no sense tho.

Barnes was born in Jamaica so you have him as jamaican despite playing for England

Vetokele was born in Belgium but you have him as Angola because he plays for them.

Cafc43v3r

Sorry I thought this was in fun, jokes and captions not an attempt to redefine any defination of nationality.

Did John Barnes stop being Jamaican when he put on an England shirt? If so you better go and tell him, he identifies as Jamaican British.

You realise you can be British Jamaican, Belgian Angolan British Indian etc?

Addick Addict

In a 4-3-2-1 formation:

Charlie Wright (Hong Kong)

Madjid Bougherra (Algeria)
Talal El Karkouri (Morocco)
Jorge Costa (Portugal)
Hermann Hreiðarsson (Iceland)

Alan Campbell (Scotland)
Graham Moore (Wales)
Scott Parker (England)

Allan Simonsen (Denmark)
Paolo Di Canio (Italy)

Eddie Firmani (South Africa)

The Red Robin

Dean Kiely (Ireland)

Mark Fish (South Africa)
Jorge Costa (Portugal)
Stuart Balmer (Scotland)

Claus Jensen (Denmark)
Alexi Smertin (Russia)
Alex Song (Cameroon)
John Robinson (Wales)

Di Canio (Italy)

Clive Mendonca (England)
Yann Kermorgant (France)

RedChaser

4-2-3-1

Dean Kiely (Eire)

Radistan Kishishev (Bulgaria) Jorge Costa (Portugal) Marvin Hinton (England) John Hewie (Scotland)

Alexi Smertin (Russia) Graham Moore (Wales)

Alan Simonsen (Denmark) Stuart Leary (South Africa) Paulo Di Canio (Italy)


Yann Kermorgant (France)

RedChaser

Point of order for @paulie8290 to arbitrate on re Eddie Firmani, he was South African but actually played for Italy

Rock Spectacle

Ditto Yann, played for Breton. Bit young to have seen Hans Jeppson play but he seemed quite good. Our all time top Premier League scorer played for Jamaica however.

Addick Addict

RedChaser said:

Point of order for @paulie8290 to arbitrate on re Eddie Firmani, he was South African but actually played for Italy

If I can't have Firmani I will gladly take Yann instead.

SoundAsa£

harveys_gardener said:

Would have Costa (Portugal) and Gomez (England) as CBs, Melrose (Scotland) and Firmani (Italy) upfront. Jensen over Rohmedal and alas Herman (Iceland) for Powell. Lloyd Sam (Ghana) for Buyens or even JJ (Finland) slightly out of position or 4-3-3.

.

Chizz

Cafc43v3r said:

Sorry I thought this was in fun, jokes and captions not an attempt to redefine any defination of nationality.

Did John Barnes stop being Jamaican when he put on an England shirt? If so you better go and tell him, he identifies as Jamaican British.

You realise you can be British Jamaican, Belgian Angolan British Indian etc?

I knew you could be British Jamaican. But I hadn't heard of a Belgian Angolan British Indian before.

Chizz

Cafc43v3r said:

Yup qualifies for my team because he was born in Jamica, the same criteria I have used for Robinson, if Terry Butcher had played for charlton I would have picked him to on the same basis :-)

Igor was born in Belgium but I originally had another Belgium on the bench.

John Robinson was born in Jamaica?

Chizz

Cafc43v3r said:

Yup qualifies for my team because he was born in Jamica, the same criteria I have used for Robinson, if Terry Butcher had played for charlton I would have picked him to on the same basis :-)

Igor was born in Belgium but I originally had another Belgium on the bench.

You'd have picked Terry Butcher, because John Robinson was born in Jamaica? Blimey, this game's a lot more complicated than it first seemed.

Fumbluff

I think I’ve come up with a squad that’ll take some beating(s)....

1. Yolan Thuram Ulien (Guadeloupe)
2. Federico Bessone (Argentina)
3. Yun Suk Young (South Korea)
4. Anil Koc (Turkey)
5. Gonzalo Sorondo (Uruguay)
6. Abdul Razak (Ivory Coast)
7. Christophe Lepoint (Belgium) -captain-
8. Kenny Achampong (Ghana)
9. George Tugyourself (Romania)
10. Piotr Parsley (Poland)
11. Ralph Milne (Sweatland)

12. Rhys Williams (Wales)
13. Neil Etheridge (Philippines)
14, Loic Nego (France)
15. David Petrucci (Italy)
16, Sullay Kaikai (Sierra Leone)
17. Reza Goochannejhad (Iran)

Manager (interim) Karel Fraeye (Laundry)

Cafc43v3r

Chizz said:

Cafc43v3r said:

Sorry I thought this was in fun, jokes and captions not an attempt to redefine any defination of nationality.

Did John Barnes stop being Jamaican when he put on an England shirt? If so you better go and tell him, he identifies as Jamaican British.

You realise you can be British Jamaican, Belgian Angolan British Indian etc?

I knew you could be British Jamaican. But I hadn't heard of a Belgian Angolan British Indian before.

Need to get out more then......

killerandflash

Fumbluff said:

I think I’ve come up with a squad that’ll take some beating(s)....

1. Yolan Thuram Ulien (Guadeloupe)
2. Federico Bessone (Argentina)
3. Yun Suk Young (South Korea)
4. Anil Koc (Turkey)
5. Gonzalo Sorondo (Uruguay)
6. Abdul Razak (Ivory Coast)
7. Christophe Lepoint (Belgium) -captain-
8. Kenny Achampong (Ghana)
9. George Tugyourself (Romania)
10. Piotr Parsley (Poland)
11. Ralph Milne (Sweatland)

12. Rhys Williams (Wales)
13. Neil Etheridge (Philippines)
14, Loic Nego (France)
15. David Petrucci (Italy)
16, Sullay Kaikai (Sierra Leone)
17. Reza Goochannejhad (Iran)

Manager (interim) Karel Fraeye (Laundry)

One more place on the bench can go to Tom Hovi (Norway)!