STATBANK: Scunthorpe United 5-3 Charlton Athletic

lancashire lad

many thanks to the 23 Lifers who gave their marks:

RedChaser

Had it not been for one errant pass from Taylor he would have been MOM scoring over 8. Cheers Lancs, good stuff as always.

killerandflash

Interesting spread of marks, unusual to get 2 players well over 7 at the same time as 2 players getting less than 5...

redman

I note in Steer's 5 games he has once scored a higher mark than Phillips average; and that was at Luton where he was ok was certainly not mind blowing.

CafcWest

redman said:

I note in Steer's 5 games he has once scored a higher mark than Phillips average; and that was at Luton where he was ok was certainly not mind blowing.

Think Phillips should definitely be given another chance. Only real issue I can see is that there might be a clause in Steer's loan agreement that he plays when fit or for xx games in a season.

CafcWest

cafc-west said:

redman said:

I note in Steer's 5 games he has once scored a higher mark than Phillips average; and that was at Luton where he was ok was certainly not mind blowing.

Think Phillips should definitely be given another chance. Only real issue I can see is that there might be a clause in Steer's loan agreement that he plays when fit or for xx games in a season.

Think Phillips should definitely be given another chance. Only real issue I can see is that there might be a clause in Steer's loan agreement that he plays when fit or for xx games in a season.

Blucher

I suspect that we pay Villa a higher percentage of his wages if he doesn’t play