Two different players played two different games a few months apart and got similar scores?
Okay to keep it simple.
Steer keeps a clean sheet though not his greatest game in terms of distribution. Yet his performance average is less than Phillips at Sunderland where he did okay to be fair but concedes a soft goal which blows the lead and we go on to lose the game.
I don't see how the Phillips performance at Sunderland was any better than Steer on Saturday but that's what the ratings say.
.02 difference is hardly better. Anyway to compare a score against Sunderland who were pressing with a poor Gillingham side who caused little threat is not relevant. You can only judge on what they had to do. Steer had little to do but what he did wasn't at his best and below average imo. He has been playing well but Saturday was below par.
Steer getting less than 6 because he shanked a couple of kicks and got fouled trying to catch a cross is a weird one
I mean, I rate him on what he had to do. Didn't have really any tough saves to make so therefore all I saw was his poor distribution. What else was there to rate him on?
Steer getting less than 6 because he shanked a couple of kicks and got fouled trying to catch a cross is a weird one
I mean, I rate him on what he had to do. Didn't have really any tough saves to make so therefore all I saw was his poor distribution. What else was there to rate him on?
The fact that apart from his kicking and his fumble of the cross early on, (although he was elbowed in the ribs and the ref should have given a foul), he didn't make a mistake and kept a clean sheet.
There were times last season when Ben Amos only got as an average of 6.5 and yet he was perfect in the few things he did in a match. I tend to give a keeper 7 on a quiet game unless like Steer on Saturday he was below par. (He got hit with 2 challenges TBF) Having said that Jed has been eccellent this season and his performances so far has emulated Amos.
He kept a clean sheet against the travellers so no harm done.
Comments
Phillips gets 5.87 vs Sunderland
Does anyone need me to elaborate on this?
Two different players played two different games a few months apart and got similar scores?
Steer keeps a clean sheet though not his greatest game in terms of distribution. Yet his performance average is less than Phillips at Sunderland where he did okay to be fair but concedes a soft goal which blows the lead and we go on to lose the game.
I don't see how the Phillips performance at Sunderland was any better than Steer on Saturday but that's what the ratings say.
I'm continuing to be impressed by Bielik.
Why not mark a player based on all the things he did right?
A decent display and worth an average 6 surely ?
Having said that Jed has been eccellent this season and his performances so far has emulated Amos.
He kept a clean sheet against the travellers so no harm done.